Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a small farmer who owns two parcels of land in Panamarathupatti Village, Salem Taluk, Salem District (0.09.0 hectare in S.No.284/1-C and 1.14.0 hectare in S.No.284/2-C). A Gazette Notification by the first respondent in R.O.C.No.89488/96(D8), dated 12.1.1997, was published in the Salem District Gazette Extraordinary (Issue No.3) dated 20.2.1997, indicating a decision to acquire the petitioner's lands under the Tamil Nadu Acquisition of Lands for Harijan Welfare Scheme Act, 1978 ("the Act").

The petitioner learned of acquisition proceedings when the second respondent visited the lands on 23.3.1997. He was directed to the second respondent's office and was served on 24.3.1997 with a notice in Form III in R.O.C.No.914/96-A calling an award enquiry on 26.3.1997. The petitioner submitted an objection dated 25.3.1997 but was informed a decision to acquire had already been taken and objections could not be considered.

The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking certiorari to call for and quash the records relating to the Gazette Notification and the subsequent Form III notice insofar as they affected him, alleging non-compliance with the Act and the Rules (in particular, that he was not served with the Form I show-cause notice under Section 4(2) and that the District Gazette notification was not in conformity with Section 4(1)).

In response, the counter-plea stated that a Section 4(2) notice had been issued for an enquiry scheduled on 4.11.1996 but, allegedly, the petitioner refused to receive that notice and the notice was affixed to the survey stones of the lands on 17.10.1996. The Special Tahsildar reportedly sent a report and recommendation to the District Collector on 19.11.1996; the Collector approved the Section 4(1) notification and it was published on 20.2.1997. A Form III notice was served on the petitioner on 24.3.1997 for an award enquiry on 26.3.1997; the petitioner did not appear but filed objections through counsel. An award was passed on 26.3.1997 (15/96-97) and the award amount was deposited in the Principal Sub Court, Salem. The present writ petition was filed after these acquisition proceedings became final.

On 12.4.1997, notice of motion was ordered and the Government Advocate was directed to secure records. The court was presented with records which did not contain the actual Form I show-cause notice; the Special Tahsildar's file recorded an attempted service and alleged refusal but lacked endorsement or evidence of refusal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statutory service requirements under Section 4(2) of the Tamil Nadu Acquisition of Lands for Harijan Welfare Scheme Act, 1978 and Rule 3(1) of the Harijan Welfare Scheme Rules, 1979 (i.e., service of the Form I show-cause notice) were complied with in respect of the petitioner's lands.
  2. Whether the mode of service relied upon by the respondents (including affixture of the notice on survey stones and an assertion of refusal to accept notice) sufficed to render the acquisition proceedings valid.
  3. Whether any procedural irregularity in service or in publication under Section 4(1) vitiates the acquisition proceedings and warrants quashing of those proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted that he was not served with the Form I notice under Section 4(2) of the Act and that this omission violated the Act and the Rules, vitiating the proceedings.
  • The petitioner contended the District Gazette notification was not in conformity with Section 4(1) of the Act.
  • He alleged that insufficient time was given for the award enquiry (Form III notice called the enquiry on short notice), preventing him from obtaining legal advice and submitting a valid objection.

Respondents' (Government) Arguments

  • The counter-statement asserted that a Section 4(2) notice was issued for an enquiry on 4.11.1996, but the petitioner refused to receive the notice; the notice was therefore affixed on the survey stones of the property on 17.10.1996.
  • The Special Tahsildar reported that the landowners did not appear for the Section 4(1) enquiry and did not file objections, and on 19.11.1996 the Tahsildar sent a report and recommendation to the Collector, which led to the Section 4(1) notification being approved and published on 20.2.1997.
  • The respondents also pointed out that the petitioner later received Form III notice on 24.3.1997, did not appear at the award enquiry on 26.3.1997 but filed objections through counsel, and that an award was passed and the amount deposited in court—facts which they suggested completed the acquisition process before the writ petition was filed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Muthu v. The Government of Tamil Nadu, etc., 1986 Writ L.R. 391 Service of statutory notices must follow the procedures prescribed by the Land Acquisition Act (Section 45) — personal delivery/tendering must be first attempted; only if that is not feasible should other modes such as service on an adult male family member, affixture on house/office, affixture on the land, or registered post be resorted to. The court relied on this precedent to hold that service under the Harijan Welfare Scheme Act must conform to the principles set out in Section 45 of the Land Acquisition Act. The court concluded that the record did not show proper attempts at personal service and that affixture on the survey stones alone was not sufficient.
Church of South India Trust Association v. The Government of Tamil Nadu, 95 L.W. 87 (S.N.) Statutory prescriptions for service of notices must be strictly followed; service cannot be carried out casually without adhering to statutory rigour. The court cited this authority to reinforce the requirement of strict compliance with statutory modes of service, supporting the view that the mode of service employed in the present case was inadequate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the record and proceeded step-by-step as follows:

  1. Identification of the relevant statutory framework: the court set out Section 4(1) and Section 4(2) of the Tamil Nadu Acquisition of Lands for Harijan Welfare Scheme Act, 1978 and the relevant Rules under the Harijan Welfare Scheme Rules, 1979 (notably Rule 3(1), Rule 3(2) and Rule 5). The court explained the sequence: Rule 3(1) requires a Form I show-cause notice under Section 4(2) to be individually served on the owner or persons interested; only after completion of steps under Section 4(2) and (3) and where acquisition is considered necessary should a notice under Form II be published in the District Gazette; Form III comes into play later for the award enquiry and procedure for determining amount (per Rule 5).
  2. Inspection of the records revealed that the Form I show-cause notice was not present in the file. The court characterized this as an apparent procedural error by the authorities.
  3. The Special Tahsildar's report recorded that the landowners "refused to receive the notice" and that the notice was affixed to the survey stones. The court noted the absence of the actual Form I notice and absence of any endorsement or evidence demonstrating refusal. There was no documentation showing who refused or in what circumstances.
  4. The court considered the applicability of principles in Section 45 of the Land Acquisition Act (Act I of 1894) regarding methods of service. While Section 20 of the Harijan Welfare Act prohibits invoking provisions of the central Land Acquisition Act for the purpose of acquisition under Section 4(1), the court observed that Section 20 does not preclude importing the service-procedure principles contained in Section 45 of the Land Acquisition Act for the purpose of determining what constitutes proper service under the state Act. In the court's view, those principles are relevant when the State exercises eminent domain and natural justice requires proper notice.
  5. The court analyzed the question whether a presumed "refusal" by the addressee could be taken to amount to valid service. It observed that Section 27 of the General Clauses Act creates a presumption of service where registered post endorsement shows refusal; however, there was no such endorsement or other reliable evidence in the file indicating refusal. The mere entry in the Special Tahsildar's report that the petitioner refused was held insufficient as proof of refusal.
  6. Applying the principles in the cited precedents (Muthu and Church of South India Trust Association), the court held that service must conform to the statutory norms and cannot be casually bypassed. Affixing the notice on the survey stones without adequate proof of prior attempts at personal service or without other steps corresponding to Section 45 of the Land Acquisition Act was not proper service.
  7. On these bases the court concluded there was non-compliance with Rule 3(1) and Section 4(2) in respect of service of the Form I notice; this procedural lapse vitiated the acquisition proceedings in respect of the petitioner's lands.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the writ petition and held that the petitioner was entitled to succeed on the point relating to non-service of the Form I show-cause notice as required by Rule 3(1) under Section 4(2) of the Act. As a result, the court quashed the land acquisition proceedings in respect of the petitioner's lands.

The court specifically ordered that:

  • The writ petition is allowed;
  • The land acquisition proceedings stand quashed;
  • There will be no order as to costs;
  • The miscellaneous petitions W.M.P.No.8564 of 1997 and W.M.P.No.26632 of 1999 are closed.

Implications: The direct effect is that the acquisition proceedings concerning the petitioner's parcels are nullified and the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. The opinion reaffirms the requirement that statutory modes of service (as interpreted with reference to Section 45 of the Land Acquisition Act and existing judicial authority) must be followed; however, the court did not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying and reiterating existing authorities. No broader change in precedent was announced by the court beyond the application of these established principles to the facts of this case.

    P.Rajendran v. The District Collector, Salem And Another

    The prayer is for a certiorari to call for the records of the respondents relating to the Gazette Notification of the first respondent in R.O.C.No.89488/96(D8), dated 12.1.1997 published at page 2 of Salem District Gazette Extraordinary Issue No.3, dated 20.2.1997 and the notice of the second respondent in R.O.C.No.914/96-A, dated 24.3.1997 in Form-III and quash the same insofar as they relate to the petitioner herein on the following allegations:

    The petitioner owns 0.09.0 hectare in S.No.284/1-C and 1.14.0 hectare in S.No.284/2-C both the lands being situated in Panamarathupatti Village, Salem Taluk, Salem District. He is a small farmer and he is depending on the yield from the said lands for his livelihood. On 23.3.1997 the second respondent came to the lands made enquiries and only then the petitioner came to know that proceedings had been initiated for acquiring his lands. The petitioner was asked to meet the second respondent in his office on 25.3.1997. When he went there he was served with a notice in Form No.III in ROC.No.914/96-A, dated 24.3.1997 informing him that the award enquiry would be conducted on the very next day, viz., 26.3.1997 at 11 a.m. Immediately on receipt of award enquiry notice in Form No.III, he submitted his objection dated 25.3.1997 to the second respondent. He was informed by the second respondent that a decision had already been taken to acquire his lands and therefore the second respondent would not be in position to consider the petitioner's objections.

    2. It would appear that a Notification under Sec.4(1) of the Tamil Nadu Acquisition of Lands for Harijan Welfare Scheme Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) was published by the first respondent in the Salem District Gazette under Notification No.3, dated 20.2.1997. From the notification thus issued it would be seen that the decision was taken to acquire the petitioner's lands in R.O.C.No.89488/96(D8), dated 12.1.1997. The petitioner was not served with any notice on him or any other person on his behalf under Sec.4(2) of the Act and this is in violation of the provisions of the Act and the Rules and therefore it would vitiate the entire proceedings. The notification published in the District Gazette is also not in conformity with the provisions of Sec.4(1) of the Act. Even for the award enquiry reasonable time had not been given. The petitioner did not have any time to get legal opinion and submit valid objection. It is under these circumstances, the present writ petition has been filed.

    3. On 12.4.1997 notice of motion was ordered by Jayasimha Babu, J. and while

    ordering such notice, the learned Judge passed the following order:

    Government Advocate is directed to take notice and secure records in two weeks. Petitioner claims that notice was not served before the notification was issued. If this averment is found to be incorrect. the petitioner will be liable to costs in a sum of Rs.3,000. If the petitioner is still in possession, dispossession not to be effected in the meantime .

    4. In the counter filed in the writ petition it is stated that notice under Sec.4(2) was issued to the petitioner to appear for enquiry which was scheduled to be held on 4.11.1996 at the office of the Special Tahsildar (A.D.W.), Salem, and as the petitioner refused to receive the 4(2) notice, the same had been affixed in the Survey stones of the petitioner's lands on 17.10.1996. The petitioner did not appear for enquiry on 4.11.1996 and file any objections to the proposed acquisition. In the result, the Special Tahsildar sent a report to the District Collector on 19.11.1996 along with his recommendation and the District Collector based on that report, had approved the 4(1) notification and published the same in the District Gazette on 20.2.1997. Thereafter the notice in Form No.III for award enquiry scheduled to be held on 26.3.1997 was received by the petitioner and the petitioner did not appear for the award enquiry on the said day, but had sent an objection petition through his counsel. After considering the objections, the award came to be passed on 26.3.1997 in 15/96-97 and the award amount had been deposited in the Principal Sub Court, Salem. Only after the entire acquisition proceedings had become final, the present writ petition has been filed. It is unnecessary to refer to the other allegations in the counter.

    5. Records have been produced. It is seen from the records that the petitioner had indeed received the notice in the forms framed as per Rule 5 of the Harijan Welfare Scheme Rules, 1979 on 24.3.1997 through his wife for enquiry under Sec.4(1) of the Act on 26.3.1997. Sec.4(2) of the Act requires that before publishing a notice in Sub-sec.(1) the District Collector or any officer authorised by the District Collector in this regard shall call upon the owner or any other person, who in the opinion of the District Collector or the officer so authorised may be interested in such land, to show cause why it should not be acquired. Rule 3(1) of the Rules requires the District Collector or the officer authorised by him in this regard to serve a show cause notice in Form No.I under Sub-sec.(2) of Sec.4 individually on the owner or on all persons interested in the land to be acquired and when the owner or any other person interested in the lands resides elsewhere where the lands are situated. The show cause notice shall be sent by registered post (acknowledgment due) to the last known address or any other person interested. Rule 3(2) of the Rules enjoins the Collector that after passing such orders as required by Sun-secs.(2) and (3) of Sec.4, if he is satisfied that it is necessary to acquire the land, notice in Form No.II to that effect shall be published in the District Gazette. Rule 4 relates to determination of market value of the land and this rule is as per Sec.7 of the Act. Rule 5 provides for procedure for determining the amount. Only at that stage Form.III framed under th Rules will come into operation and notice in Form III is required to be issued. In the records the Form-I notice is not found. Apparently, there is an error in the procedure adopted by the authorities.

    6. In the report from the Special Tahsildar to the Collector dated 19.11.1996 in page 83 under the heading objections at page 89 it is stated that the landowners refused to receive the notice and hence the notice has been affixed on the survey stones in the property. The landowners did not appear for the 4(1) enquiry and did not file any objection petition. Copy of the notice attempted to be served on the landowners in Form No.1 is not to be seen in the file made available. The actual endorsement made in such a notice has been kept away. Under the Act no particular method is prescribed for service on the landowners. No doubt, in Sec.20 of the Act it is specifically stated that the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 ceased to apply to any land which is required for the purpose of Sub-sec.(1) of Sec.4 and such land shall be acquired by the Government only in accordance with the provisions of this Act. Sec.4(2) of the Act has already been referred to. It empowers the District Collector to call upon the owner or any other person, who in the opinion of the Collector, may be interested in such land to show cause why it should not be acquired. Rule 3 requires the Collector or the officer authorised the Collector or the officer authorised to serve a show cause notice in Form-I under Sub-sec.(2) of Sec.2 individually on the owner or on all persons interested in the land to be acquired. the form is also given. There is a form prescribed against Form No.I.

    7. In Sec.45 of Act I of 1984 the procedure to be followed is specifically provided. In my view, when the State exercises powers of eminent domain basic principles of natural justice have to be followed. The person whose lands are sought to be acquired ought to have proper notice of the proceedings initiated in respect of his lands.

    8. The question as to what is proper service has been dealt with by Nainar Sundaram, J., as the learned Judge then was) In Muthu v. The Government of Tamil Nadu, etc. Muthu v. The Government of Tamil Nadu, etc. Muthu v. The Government of Tamil Nadu, etc. , 1986 Writ L.R. 391. The learned Judge has held as follows:

    The service of any notice under the Land Acquisition Act in the manner provided therein is a mandate of law and the due procedure and modalities having been evolved, there cannot be a by-passing of the same by the officials and if they do so, they will be opening the gates for challenge of the proceedings as an illegality, It is not up to the officials to choose modes of service as suit them, if they do not conform to the statutory norms. As contemplated in Sub-secs.(1) and (2) of Sec.45, service on the person concerned by delivering or tendering a copy of the notice shall be first attempted, only when such service is not feasible, on the ground that such person cannot be found, the other modes of service as contemplated in Sub-sec.(3) of Sec.45 should be resorted to. If the person cannot be found, service on adult male member of the family should be attempted, and if no such adult male member can be found, then only service by affixture on the outer door of the house in which the person therein named ordinarily dwells or carries on business or by affixing a copy thereof in some conspicuous place in the office of the officer who signed the notice or in Collector's office or in the court house should be done. In such a case, in addition to the above modes, affixture of the copy of the notice in some conspicuous part of the land to be acquired should also be done. The proviso to Sub-sec.(3) says that the notice may, if the Collector or the Judge so directs, be sent by registered post in a letter addressed to the person named therein at his last known residence, address or place of business.

    The learned Judge further observed as follows:

    Enquiry under Sec.5-A of the Act is not an empty formality and notice for such enquiry has got to be served strictly in accordance with the mandates of Sec.45 of the Act. While discountenancing the service of notice in a casual manner without adhering to the rigour of the provisions of the Act, I have opined in Church of South India Trust Association v. The Government of Tamil Nadu , 95 L.W. 87 (S.N.) that the prescriptions of the statute in the matter of service of notices under it should be strictly followed and carried out.

    It must be satisfied followed and carried out. It must be satisfied that the person concerned could not be found after reasonable and diligent enquiries within the meaning of the Act.

    9. What is stated in the instant case is that the petitioner refused to receive notice. sec.45 of act i of 1894 also has not envisaged a situation where the addressee refuses to receive the notice. Indeed, in cases where letters are sent by registered post and the postman makes an endorsement that the addressee refused it , presumption as to proper service of notice under Sec.27 of the General Clauses Act should be drawn.

    10. The question now is whether the same principle can be invoked here. There is no endorsement of refusal available on file. There is nothing to show as to who refused to receive, in which case. In my view there is not enough evidence to raise the promotion requisite to hold that the petitioner had refused to receive the notice and therefore he must be deemed to have knowledge of the contents of the notice. The mere recording by the Special Tahsildar that the petitioner had refused to receive notice, in my view, is not sufficient compliance of requirements regarding service of notice. There should have been a further attempt in a manner corresponding to sec.45 of act i of 1894 for service of notice on the petitioner. As already noticed, Sec.20 of the Act only prohibits invoking the provisions of the central act for the purpose specified in Sub-sec.(1) of Sec.4 with regard to acquisition of land under the Act and not with regard to service of notice. The requirements set out in Sec.45, the court view, can be imported for the purpose of service of notice on the owners of lands sought to be acquired under the Act. It is also to be further noticed that affixing a copy of the notice on the survey stones cannot also be said to be proper service.

    11. In these circumstances, the petitioner is entitled to succeed on the point relating to non-service of notice in Form I framed as per Rule 3 (1) of the Rules. The writ petition will stand allowed. The land acquisition proceedings will therefore stand quashed. There will be no order as to costs. Consequently, the miscellaneous petitions W.M.P.No.8564 of 1997 and W.M.P.No.26632 of 1999 are closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P.Rajendran v. The District Collector, Salem And Another
    (Apr 12, 2000)