AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 35 of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules.14. A close examination of Rule 8
  • rule 35 of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules.15.
  • Section 15; Rule 6 of the said Rules provides:6. Training.(a)
  • provisions of Rule 6 of the Madras Forest Service Rules.
  • Rule 2(a) of the Special Rules of the Madras Forest
  • Rule 8 of the Madras Forest Service Rules
  • rule 10(a)(iv), 10(d), 16, 39(d) or 44(d),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 35 of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules.14. A close examination of Rule 8
  • rule 35 of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules.15.
  • Section 15; Rule 6 of the said Rules provides:6. Training.(a)
  • provisions of Rule 6 of the Madras Forest Service Rules.
  • Rule 2(a) of the Special Rules of the Madras Forest
  • Rule 8 of the Madras Forest Service Rules
  • rule 10(a)(iv), 10(d), 16, 39(d) or 44(d),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners were recruited as Assistant Conservators of Forests in the Madras Forest Service and, following the States' reorganisation in 1956, were allotted to the State of Mysore. They contested their rankings in the Final Inter-State Seniority List of Gazetted Officers in the Forest Department published by the State of Mysore (Notification dated 9th May, 1969). The two principal petitioners discussed are S. Shyam Sunder (recruited 21 March 1953; joined duty 31 March 1953; began drawing pay after training from 5 April 1955; Mysore declared probation completed 31 May 1958 by notification dated 25 June 1958) and K. Rama Gowda (appointed 7 March 1951; joined duty after training on 10 April 1953; Mysore declared completion of probation effective 11 July 1956 by notification dated 2 July 1960).

The State of Mysore prepared several inter-State seniority lists (provisional list dated 26 March 1957; final list dated 24 February 1966; another final list published 2 May 1964). In various lists the petitioners were placed at different serial numbers and categories; respondents 13–17 were ranked below them in earlier lists but in the impugned final list dated 9 May 1969 the petitioners were ranked below respondents 13–17. The petitioners had earlier challenged related lists by writ petitions in this Court which were disposed of together in an order in G.M Shankaraiah v. Union of India; that order directed opportunity to make representations with assistance of an Advisory Committee. The Supreme Court (in appeals by Union of India) upheld and limited that direction to the petitioners before the High Court and allowed further time to make representations. Pursuant to that, the petitioners made representations, and the Government of India communicated its decision on 25 April 1969 (rejecting the requested equation of posts but indicating that the petitioners could be shown in the seniority list with reference to continuous length of service in the equated grade provided they were enjoying the scale of pay and drawing increments).

The State of Mysore issued the impugned final Inter-State Seniority List dated 9 May 1969 which placed Rama Gowda at Sl. No. 39 in Category IV (counting continuous length of service from 11 July 1956) and placed Shyam Sunder as a probationer below all persons in Category IV (although continuous length of service was counted from 31 March 1953). The petitioners challenged the 9 May 1969 list by these writ petitions under Article 226.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the preparation of the impugned final Inter-State Seniority List (9 May 1969) was in accordance with the decision of the Government of India.
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to count their seniority from the dates on which they first joined duties as Assistant Conservators of Forests (i.e., whether probationary service and training periods should be included).
  3. Whether the equation of the petitioners' posts (as made by the State of Mysore) with particular Mysore posts was correct — specifically, whether the petitioners' posts should have been equated with Deputy Conservators of Forests from Bombay and Hyderabad rather than with Assistant Conservators/Sub-Assistant Conservators of Forests of Mysore.
  4. Whether Rama Gowda was denied an opportunity to be heard before adverse ranking.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The impugned seniority list was not prepared in conformity with the decision of the Government of India.
  • The petitioners were entitled to count for seniority the period commencing from the dates on which they first joined duties as Assistant Conservators of Forests (i.e., the period including training/joining dates should affect seniority).
  • The equation of their posts by the State of Mysore was incorrect; their posts should have been equated with the Deputy Conservators from Bombay and Hyderabad rather than with lower grades of Mysore.
  • Specifically for Rama Gowda: he was downgraded in the impugned seniority list without being afforded an opportunity to be heard.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioners were allotted as probationers and were not permanent members of the cadre at the relevant times; they did not draw pay of their posts during probation and training.
  • The Government of India had taken a decision that probationary period of allottees should not be counted for seniority while integrating services, and the impugned list was prepared pursuant to that decision.
  • The State and Central authorities followed the applicable rules and decisions in preparing the seniority list and in the equation of posts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
G.M. Shankaraiah v. Union of India (High Court) Directed that the Central Government's impugned decision was effectively provisional; affected persons must be given opportunity to make representations and the Central Government should consider them with the assistance of an Advisory Committee before arriving at a final decision. The High Court's order was relied on as the procedural foundation requiring representations and advisory committee consideration; the present petitions arose in the context of that process.
Union of India v. G.M. Shankariah (Supreme Court) Upholding the High Court's direction but limiting the obligation to those petitioners who were before the High Court; gave further time to such petitioners to make representations to the Government of India. The Court noted the Supreme Court's limitation and that the petitioners in the present matters had been among those given further time to represent; this governed how the Government of India proceeded and what representations were considered.
D. Maheswarappa & Others v. Union of India & Others Considered and upheld the validity of the same order of equation (i.e., posts of certain Assistant Conservators were equated as done by Government) — rejecting claims that those posts should be equated with higher grades (Deputy Conservators) from Bombay/Hyderabad. The Court treated that decision as binding authority against the petitioners' contention that their posts should have been equated with Deputy Conservators from Bombay and Hyderabad, and on that basis rejected their challenge to the equation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined (A) the decision of the Government of India; (B) the manner in which the Government of Mysore implemented that decision in the impugned list; and (C) the applicable rules governing recruitment, training and seniority for the Madras Forest Service.

A. Government of India decision: The Government of India had rejected the petitioners' request to equate their posts with Deputy Conservators of Forests from Bombay and Hyderabad. On seniority, the Government of India observed that the petitioners were probationers on 31 October 1956 but indicated there was no objection to them being shown in the seniority list with reference to their continuous length of service in the equated grade provided they were enjoying the scale of pay of Assistant Conservators and drawing increments. The Court interpreted this as meaning that seniority in the equated grade should be counted from the date when the petitioners enjoyed the pay of Assistant Conservators (i.e., when they began to draw the pay of the post) — and that this decision was binding on the State of Mysore.

B. Compliance by State of Mysore: The Court compared admitted facts (Rama Gowda began drawing pay from 10 April 1953; Shyam Sunder from 5 April 1955) with the impugned list. The Court held that, if the Government of India decision required seniority to be from the date the scale of pay was enjoyed, the petitioners should have been ranked in Category IV with reference to those dates. The impugned list did not follow that approach: Rama Gowda's continuous service in the equated grade was counted from 11 July 1956 and Shyam Sunder was shown as a probationer (despite other dates). Consequently the impugned list was, on its face, contrary to the Government of India decision.

C. Rules analysis (Madras rules vs. Madras Forest Service Rules): The Court noted that general Madras State and Subordinate Services Rule 35 provided seniority ordinarily from the date of first appointment unless portions do not count towards probation; that rule could support the petitioners if applicable. But the Court found that special rules for the Madras Forest Service govern and displace the general rule for this service. It examined Rule 6 (training provisions) and Rule 8 (seniority) of the Madras Forest Service Rules. Rule 6 provides that probationary appointees do not draw pay during training and begin to draw pay only when they join duty after successful completion of the college course. Rule 8 expressly states that the seniority of directly recruited Assistant Conservators shall be determined by the date of passing the Forest College examination (and, where the date is the same, by rank in the pass list).

The Court rejected the petitioners' reliance on the general Rule 35 as displacing the specific Rule 8 applicable to directly recruited Assistant Conservators. The Court interpreted Rule 8 as determining initial seniority (not merely inter-se seniority) because the rule specifies seniority by the date of passing the college examination. Given that the petitioners began drawing pay on the admitted dates (Rama Gowda 10 April 1953; Shyam Sunder 5 April 1955), the Court concluded the Government of India decision (count seniority from date of enjoying pay) aligned with Rule 8 and did not derogate from it.

Finally, on the equation of posts, the Court considered the earlier decision in D. Maheswarappa & Others v. Union of India & Others and found that that decision had already rejected the contention that such posts should be equated with Deputy Conservators from Bombay and Hyderabad. The Court treated that decision as binding and therefore rejected the petitioners' challenge to the equation.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petitions were allowed in part: the Court quashed the rankings assigned to the petitioners in the impugned final Inter-State Seniority List dated 9th May, 1969, and directed respondents 1 and 2 to refix their seniority taking 5th April, 1955 as the commencement date of continuous length of service in the equated grade for S. Shyam Sunder and 10th April, 1953 for K. Rama Gowda, after giving opportunities to officials likely to be affected by such refixation.

Direct consequences and directions:

  • The impugned seniority rankings were quashed as contrary to the Government of India decision and applicable Madras Forest Service Rules.
  • Respondents 1 and 2 are directed to refix the petitioners' seniority using the specified dates of commencement of continuous service in the equated grade and to give opportunities to affected officials before altering seniority positions.
  • Time for compliance was fixed at four months.
  • Petitioners were awarded costs against Respondent 2: advocate fee Rs. 100 in each petition.

Broader implications: The Court applied existing administrative decisions and service rules (including a binding prior High Court decision upheld and limited by the Supreme Court, and a prior decision upholding the equation of posts). The opinion resolves the parties' rights under those decisions and the Madras Forest Service Rules as applied to the facts; it does not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond the application of those authorities to these facts.

    S. Shyam Sunder And Anothers Petitioners v. The Union Of India And Others

    Jagannatha Shetty, J.:— This is the second time, the petitioners are approaching this Court for relief under Article 226.

    2. The petitioners originally entered Madras Forest Service as Assistant Conservators of Forests. Consequent on the reorganisation of States in 1956, they were allotted to the State of Mysore. Eversince then, they have been agitating for a proper equation of their posts and determination of their seniority in the Inter-State Seniority List. They are now aggrieved by the rankings given to them in the Final Inter-State Seniority List of the Gazetted Officers in the Forest Department published in the Notification dated 9th May, 1969 (published in the Mysore Gazette, dated May 9, 1969).

    3. To understand the problem presented, we have to state the facts in a little more detail. S. Shyam Sunder, the petitioner in W.P 4102/69 was selected by the Madras Public Service Commission as Assistant Conservator of Forests. He was recruited on 21st March, 1953 under Rule 2(a) of the Special Rules of the Madras Forest Service. The said post carried the pay scale of Rs. 300 to 700. He joined duty on 31st March, 1953. He was sent for training at the Indian Forest College, Dehra Dun. During the period of training, he was paid a stipend of Rs. 110 and, not the pay of this post. After the training he joined duty on 5th April, 1955 from which date alone, he began to enjoy the pay of his post. He was allotted to the State of Mysore as a probationer. The Government of Mysore by their notification dated 25th June, 1958 declared that he Completed satisfactorily his probationary period on 31st May, 1958.

    4. K. Rama Gowda, the petitioner in W.P No. 766/71, was also a direct recruit as a probationary Assistant Conservator of Forests in the Madras Forest Service. On 7th March, 1951, he was appointed by the erstwhile State of Madras. He was thereafter deputed for training at the Dehra Dun Forest College. After the training he joined duty on 10th April, 1953. Like Shyam Sunder, he was also paid stipend during the period of training and he bagan to enjoy the minimum pay of his post, with effect from 10th April, 1953. Consequent on the reorganisation of States, he was allotted to the State of Mysore, as a District Forest Officer of Kollegal Forest Division. His parent State did not pass any order declaring the completion of his probationary period. It was only by the notification dated 2nd July, 1960 issued by the State of Mysore, the said declaration was made as on 11th July, 1956.

    5. For the purpose of integration of posts allotted from different States, the State of Mysore equated the posts of Assistant Conservator of Forests of Madras with those of the Senior Assistant Conservator and Assistant Conservator of Forests of Mysore. The provisional Inter-State Seniority List dated 26th March, 1957 was prepared by the State of Mysore, in which Rama Gowda was placed at Serial Number 38, among the Class I (Divisional Forest Officers) and, Shyam Sunder was ranked at Sl. No. 6 among the Class II (Sub Divisional Forest Officers) of the Officers of the Forest Department. This was followed by the preparation of what was termed as the Final Inter-State Seniority List published by the notification dated 24th February, 1966. Therein both Rama Gowda and Shyam Sunder were placed at Serial Numbers 2 and 7 respectively in the cadre of the Assistant Conservators of Forests. By the said equation, the petitioners were very much aggrieved. While challenging the same, Rama Gowda filed W.P No. 2316/1963 and Shyam Sunder W.P No. 2574/1963, in this Court. During the pendency of the said writ petitions, the State of Mysore, as per the decision of the Government of India, published another final Inter-State Seniority List, dated 2nd May, 1964. In that list, the petitioners were included in Category IV at Sl. Nos. 24 and 30 respectively. They were given seniority from the respective dates on which they first joined duty as Assistant Conservators of Forests. But the equation remained the same.

    In all the above stated lists, the respondents 13 to 17 were ranked below the petitioners, as their juniors.

    The final Inter-State Seniority List, dated 2nd May, 1964 was the subject of many writ petitions filed in this Court. All those petitions together with the said petitions filed by Shyam Sunder and Rama Gowda came up for consideration and were disposed off by a common order dated 26th March, 1955 in G.M Shankaraiah v. Union of India(1). During the argument in the said cases, learned Attorney General who appeared for the Government of India said that the impugned decision of the Government of India was only a provisional one, and before coming to a final decision, the Government of India have to examine the representations of the petitioners with the assistance of an advisory committee. Accepting the said contention, Hegde, J. (as he than was) said:

    “For these reasons, we accept the contentions of the learned Attorney General that the impugned decision of the Central Government though purports to be a final decision is really a provisional decision. The affected persons have a right to make representations against it. The representations made by them will have to be considered by the Central Government with the assistance of the Advisory Committee and thereafter the Central Government should arrive at a final decision.”

    The learned Judge in the concluding para of the order further said:

    “For the reasons mentioned above, though we refuse to grant the reliefs prayed for in these petitions, at the same time, we direct the Central Government to give the petitioners an opportunity to make representations against the equation of posts proposed, consider their objections with the aid of the Advisory Committee and thereafter arrive at a final decision as regards the integration in dispute.”

    6. Against the said decision of this Court, the Union of India preferred appeals to the Supreme Court, in Union of India v. G.M Shankariah(2). The Supreme Court upheld the decision of this Court and dismissed the appeals with an observation that the direction given by this Court that the Government of India should give an opportunity to make representations and that it should consider them with the aid of the Advisory Committee and thereafter arrive at its final decision must be limited to the petitioners then before the High Court, whose writ petitions were heard and disposed off. It may be relevant to state that in all ten writ petitions including that of the present petitioners, were heard and disposed off by this Court. The Supreme Court gave further time for the said petitioners to make their representations to Government of India. Pursuant thereto, Rama Gowda and Shyam Sunder filed their representations inter alia contending that the posts of Assistant Conservators from Madras should be equated with that of the Deputy Conservators from Hyderabad and Bombay.

    7. Interrupting the naration, we have to state one other fact, which was the beginning of another trouble to the petitioners. The Government of Mysore, by their notification dated 17-18th April, 1969 called upon Shyam Sunder and one other, to show cause why they should not be included in a separate category below Categorty IV, under the head “Probationers”. It appears that the said notification was issued at the instance of the Government of India. They were asked to file their objections to the Secretary to the Government of India, within one month from the date of the receipt of the notification. On 8th May, 1969 Shyam Sunder submitted a detailed representations opposing the said proposal. Before the receipt of the said representation, the Government of India took a decision on the earlier representations of the petitioners and communicated the same to them by their letter dated 25th April, 1969 stating thus:

    “16. Shri K. Rama Gowda (17) Shri S. Shyam Sunder—

    Their representations for equation of post of Assistant Conservator of Forests from Madras with the posts of Deputy Conservators of Forests from Bombay and Hyderabad may be rejected.

    These two officers, who were probationers on 31st October, 1956 were presumably enjoying the scale of pay of Assistant Conservators and drawing increments in that scale; there need, therefore, be no objection to their being shown in the seniority list with reference to their continuous length of service in the equated grade.”

    8. Finally, the Government of Mysore published the impugned final Inter-State Seniority List dated 9th May, 1969 placing Rama Gowda at Sl. No. 39 in Category IV. His continuous length of service in the equated grade was counted from 11th July, 1956; the date on which he completed his probationary period. Shyam Sunder was placed immediately below all the persons in Category IV. He was shown as a probationer apparently with no benefit of his continuous length of service, though counted from 31st March, 1953.

    The respondents 13 to 17 were ranked above the petitioners.

    9. The first contention for the petitioners was that the preparation of the impugned list was not according to the decision of the Government of India. The second contention was that the petitioners are entitled to count for their seniority the period commencing from the dates on which they first joined duties as Assistant Conservators of Forests. The third and the last contention was regarding the correctness of the equation of posts held by the petitioners. One other contention urged on behalf of Rama Gowda was that he was kicked down in the impugned seniority list without affording him any opportunity.

    For the respondents, it was urged that the petitioners were allotted as probationers and, they were not permanent members in the cadre. They did not draw the pay of their posts during their probationary period and that the Government of India have taken a decision not to count probationary period for the seniority of the allottees while preparing the Inter-State Seniority list. As per that decision, the impugned list was said to have been prepared.

    10. We have perused the relevant records, which were placed before us by Sri Puttaswami, learned Government Advocate. It is not correct to state that the State Government, without authority of the Government of India, issued the notification dated 17-18th April, 1969 calling upon Shyam Sunder and one other to show cause why they should not be included in a separate category under the heading “Probationers”.

    11. We pass then to the first contention for the petitioners. For this we should refer to the decision of the Government of India. On the question of equation of the posts of Assistant Conservator of Forests from, Madras with the posts of the Deputy Conservator of Forests from Bombay and Hyderabad, the Government of India did not agree. On the question of seniority, they said that the petitioners were probationers on 31st October, 1956. They further said that they have no objection for the petitioners being shown in the seniority list with reference to their continuous length of service in the equated grade provided they were enjoying the scale of pay of Assistant Conservators and drawing increments in that scale. The Government of India never said that the petitioners should get their seniority from the date on which they first joined the posts of Assistant Conservators of Forests. The Government of India also never said that the entire probationary period should not count for the petitioners' seniority. The decision of the Government of India, as it appears to us, is that the petitioners should be given seniority in the equated grade from the date on which they enjoyed the pay of the posts of Assistant Conservators of Forests. That decision was binding upon the Government of Mysore.

    With that, we examine whether the Government of Mysore followed the said decision in preparing the impugned list. From the facts above narrated, it is seen that Rama Gowda began to enjoy the pay in the scale of his post (i.e, Rs. 300 to 700) with effect from 10th April, 1953, whereas Shyam Sunder began to do so from 5th April, 1953. These facts are admitted before us by counsel on both sides. If that be the admitted position, the petitioners should have been ranked in appropriate places in Category IV of the impugned list, with reference to the said dates as the dates of commencement of their service in the equated grade. But we find it was not done. The impugned list is, therefore, ex-facie contrary to the said decision of the Government of India.

    12. We turn from that, to the second contention, whether the petitioners have a right to count for their seniority the period commencing from the date when they first joined duties as Assistant Conservators of Forests. For the respondents, it was urged that the petitioner were probationers and the Government of India have taken a uniform decision to exclude the probationery period of the allottees while integrating their services. We do not think that the question before us could be decided on the basis of an alleged uniform decision of the Government of India. It cannot also be determined on the allegations and counter-allegations of the parties. In our view, it has got to be resolved with reference to the rules regulating the petitioners' recruitment and their conditions of service.

    (a) Conscious of the limitations of judicial review, in cases of this nature, we proceed to examine the relevant rules. Mr. T. Krishna Rao, learned counsel for Shyam Sunder referred to us the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules, and in particular Rule 35 therein. The said rule provides:

    “35. Seniority.—(a) The seniority of a person in a service, class, category or grade shall, unless he has been reduced to a lower rank as a punishment, be determined by the date of his first appointment to such service, class, category or grade. If any portion of the service of such person does not count towards probation under rule 10(a)(iv), 10(d), 16, 39(d) or 44(d), his seniority shall be determined by the date of commencement of his service which counts towards probation.”

    The said rule, if it is applicable to the case of the petitioners, does support them. But they are general rules applicable to all subordinate services in the erstwhile Madras State, if there is nothing to the contrary in the special rules of recruitment to any particular post or grade. The petitioners belonged to the Madras Forest Service. There were separate rules governing the said service (See Madras Services Manual—Vol. II, page 72). Under Section 15; Rule 6 of the said Rules provides:

    “6. Training.—(a) A probationary Assistant Conservator appointed by direct recruitment other than a candidate appointed on the successful completion of the Second Year Course of the Superior Forest Service Course shall, in the first instance, undergo practical training for a period of one year under a District Forest Officer. On the satisfactory completion of such training he shall undergo a special course of study for a period of two years at the Forest College at Dehra Dun or Coimbatore, as the case may be. If any probationer is prevented by sickness or any other adequate cause from appearing at the final examination at Dehra Dun or Coimbatore, as the case may be, at end of the course, the State Government may allow him to appear at the next final examination in which case the period of his probation specified in rule 5 shall be deemed to be extended by a period equivalent to the interval between the examinations aforesaid.

    (b) He shall, during the period of his training under a District Forest Officer, be paid a fixed travelling allowance of Rs. 25 a month. He shall not be entitled to any pay while undergoing the training and the course of study prescribed in this rule. He shall, however, be paid a stipend at such rate as the State Government may, from time to time, sanction during the course of study at the Forest College at Dehra Dun or Coimbatore, as the case may be. He shall begin to draw pay from the date he joins his appointment in the State after successfully completing the said course of study. He shall be granted in respect of the journeys performed by him while undergoing the course of study prescribed in this rule, actual expenses as authorized by the rules relating to the said course of study, and also travelling allowance for joining his appointment to this State after successfully completing the course, limited to a single second class railway fare and in addition a single mileage for any journey by road.”

    “Rule 8 Seniority.—The seniority of a directly recruited Assistant Conservator shall be determined by the date of his passing the examination held by the Forest College, Dehra Dun or Coimbatore, as the case may be. Where such date is the same in the case of two or more such members, their seniority inter-se shall be determined by their rank in the pass list issued by the college.”

    13. Mr. Krishna Rao contended that the said Rule 8 provides the procedure for fixing the inter-se seniority amongst the directly recruited Assistant Conservators of Forests and, it does not provide for the determination of their initial seniority. He said that the initial seniority should be determined only as per rule 35 of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules.

    14. A close examination of Rule 8 does not support the contention. It specifically states that the seniority of directly recruited Assistant Conservator of Forests shall be determined by the date of his passing the examination held by the Forest College at Dehra Dun or Coimbatore. It further states that when such date is the same in the case of two or more such members, their seniority inter-se shall be determined by their rank in the pass list issued by the College. The said Rule, as it appears to us, not only determines the initial seniority of the directly recruited Assistant Conservators of Forests, but also their inter-se seniority when the date of passing the examination becomes the same. To confine the operation of the rule only to determine the Inter-se seniority of the direct recruits, is to completely overloon the first part of the rule. In our view, this rule alone determines the initial seniority of the directly recruited Assistant Conservators of Forests like the petitioners and, not rule 35 of the Madras State and Subordinate Services Rules.

    15. Our view finds confirmation from the provisions of Rule 6 of the Madras Forest Service Rules. During the period of probation in the Forest College at Dehra Dun, the petitioners were not allowed to draw the pay of their posts. They began to draw the minimum pay in the pay scale only when they joined duty after their training at Dehra Dun College. Shyam Sundar so joined on 5th April, 1955 and Rama Gowda on 10th April, 1953. It is perhaps for this reason that the Government of India also stated that the petitioners though probationers on 31st October, 1956 should be given seniority with reference to their continuous length of service in the equated grade provided they were enjoying the scale of pay of Assistant Conservators. This decision was in accordance with the said Rule 8 of the Madras Forest Service Rules and not in derogation of it. We, therefore, reject the second contention for the petitioners.

    16. The third and the last contention was regarding the validity of the equation of posts. The posts of the petitioners were equated with the Assistant Conservators and Sub-Assistant Conservators of Forests from old Mysore. The petitioners contended that their posts should have been equated with the Deputy Conservators of Forests from Bombay and Hyderabad areas. This point, in our opinion, is concluded against the petitioners by the decision of this Court in D. Maheswarappa & Others… v. Union Of India & Others…(3). In that case, the validity of the same order of equation came up for consideration. The Assistant Conservators of Forests of the old Mysore who stood allotted to the new State of Mysore challenged the said order of equation. Their case, was that their posts should have been equated with those of Deputy Conservator of Forests of the erstwhile State of Bombay and Hyderabad and not with the Sub-Assistant Conservators. This Court rejected their contention upholding the said order of equation. That decision is binding on us and following the same, we reject the third contention also.

    17. In the result, we allow these petitions, quash the rankings assigned to the petitioners, with a direction to respondents 1 and 2 to refix their seniority taking into consideration the date 5th April, 1955 for Shyam Sundar and, 10th April, 1953 for Rama Gowda as the date of their commencement of continuous length of service in the equated grade, after giving opportunities to the officials who are likely to be affected by such refixation.

    18. Time for compliance 4 months.

    19. Petitioners are entitled to their costs from Respondent 2. Advocate fee Rs. 100 in each.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Shyam Sunder And Anothers Petitioners v. The Union Of India And Others
    (Feb 2, 1973)