AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed two suits (O.S. No. 90 of 1992 and O.S. No. 89 of 1992) in the Sub-Court, Erode, seeking injunctions restraining the respondent from interfering with their peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property, alleging tenancy under the respondent pursuant to an oral lease. Pending the suits, the petitioners filed applications (I.A. No. 220/92 and I.A. No. 302/92) for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. The lower Court dismissed those applications, and the present revision was filed against that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appointment of an Advocate Commissioner was necessary to note the existing physical features of the suit land and to establish that the respondent had not raised any seasonal crops.
  2. Whether the appointment of a Commissioner is appropriate where alternative evidence (such as Adangal entries, village cultivation accounts, or oral evidence) may be available and where the Commissioner can only record positive, not negative, facts.
  3. Whether, in the circumstances (including the absence of interim injunction and the age of the suits), relief by way of appointing a Commissioner should be refused and the lower court directed to dispose of the suits on priority.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to record the existing physical features of the land and to show that the respondent had not raised seasonal crops.
  • The petitioners stated they intended to level the land using a bulldozer and that the land had already been levelled to some extent; absent a Commissioner, valuable evidence would be lost and they would suffer loss and hardship.
  • They argued the Commissioner was necessary to note whether the land was suitable for cultivation.

Opposing Contentions and Court Observations

  • The opinion notes that if the petitioner wished to level the land he could do so at his own risk and expense; the respondent/landlord had not objected to levelling.
  • The court observed that cultivation, if any, would be reflected in the Adangal extract and the village cultivation account; absence of such entries weakens a claim that crops were raised.
  • The court emphasized that a Commissioner can record existing (positive) features such as standing crops, but cannot establish a negative (i.e., prove that crops were not raised) and that if crops were harvested before the Commissioner's visit the land would appear fallow.
  • The petitioner admitted not having the benefit of an interim injunction, which the court noted casts doubt on the petitioners' possession.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded step-by-step as follows:

  • It reviewed the petitioners' affidavit, which stated the petitioners intended to level the land and had partly done so, and that a Commissioner was sought to record physical features and the absence of seasonal crops.
  • The court treated the request for a Commissioner as aimed at documenting present physical conditions and establishing a negative fact (that the respondent had not raised crops).
  • It reasoned that a Commissioner is useful to note positive, observable facts (for example, standing crops) but is unsuitable to prove a negative fact (that no crops were raised), particularly because crops might be harvested before a Commissioner's inspection and thus not be provable by such an inspection.
  • The court noted alternative evidentiary means: entries in the Adangal and cultivation accounts or oral evidence can establish cultivation or its absence, reducing the necessity for appointment of a Commissioner.
  • The court observed that the petitioner could level the land at his own risk and that the respondent had not objected to levelling, undermining the claimed urgency for preservation of evidence by a Commissioner.
  • Because the petitioner admitted absence of an interim injunction, the court found the petitioners' possession status doubtful, weighing against the relief sought.
  • Given the suits originated in 1992, the court directed the lower court to dispose of the suits on a priority basis if they had not already been disposed of; on these bases the court dismissed the revision petitions and connected miscellaneous petitions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petitions (C.R.P.s) were dismissed, and consequentially C.M.P. Nos. 9463 and 9464 of 1992 were also dismissed.

Implications:

  • The immediate effect is that the applications for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner were not sustained by the revisional court and remain dismissed as per the impugned order.
  • The court directed that the lower court should dispose of the underlying suits (filed in 1992) on a priority basis if they remain pending.
  • The opinion does not articulate any broader legal principle or new precedent beyond applying ordinary evidentiary and procedural considerations about the limited usefulness of Commissioners to record positive facts and the availability of alternative evidence; no new precedent was set in the text of the opinion.
RR/VCS

    Kalpana Poongothai (Minor), Rep. By Mother And Guardian, Mrs. Amsaveni. v. L. Kalianan.

    The petitioners herein have filed two suits O.S No. 90 of 1992 and 89 of 1992 respectively on the file of the Sub-Court, Erode seeking an order of injunction restraining the respondent from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property contending that they are the tenants under the respondent pursuant to an oral agreement of lease. Pending the suit both the petitioners filed application Nos. I.A No. 220/92 and I.A 302/92 respectively for the appointment of the Advocate Commissioner. The lower Court has dismissed the application against which tile present revision has been filed.

    2. The petitioners have stated in the affidavit filed in support of their application for the appointment of Commissioner as follows: —

    “The respondent has filed the above suit claimed that he is the tenant of the suit property. The suit property is having ups and downs, therefore, I wanted to level the kind by using bulldozer and it is already levelled to some extent. Only after levelling the entire land it will become more fit for the agricultural purpose. The land cannot be cultivated properly since the lie of the land is with ups and downs If the Commissioner is appointed to note down the existing physical features, it will show that the respondent has not raised any seasonal crops Unless the Commissioner is appointed very valuable evidence will be lost and 1 will be put to much loss and great hardship.”

    From the extracted averments it is clear that the petitioner wanted to level the land by using bulldozer and further the land has already been levelled to a certain extent. The appointment of Commissioner is sought for to find out the existing physical features of the suit land and to show that the respondent has not raised any seasonable crops.

    3. The contention of the counsel for the petitioners is that the appointment of the Commissioner is necessary to note down the physical features and also to note down whether the land is suitable for cultivation. If the petitioner wants to level the land he could do so by incurring expenses at his risk. The respondent/landlord has not raised any objection with regard to the levelling of the land. So far as the cultivation of the land is concerned, if the petitioner had raised any crops then it would have been entered in the Adangal extract and in the cultivation account of the village. In the absence of any such entry, it cannot be said that the land has been cultivated. If the land is not suitable for any cultivation, it can be established by oral evidence.

    4. More over the application has been filed in the year 1992 to note down that the respondent has not raised any seasonal crops. The appointment of Commissioner may be of use to note down the standing crops but not to establish the negative. If prior to the Commissioner's visit the crops had been, harvested then the land would lie fallow. When there are other means to establish the case of the petitioner, the appointment of Advocate Commissioner is not necessary.

    5. Further the counsel for the petitioner has admitted that the petitioner did not have the benefit of interim injunction pending the suit. If that be so his possession itself is doubtful. Since the suit is of the year 1992, I direct the lower Court to dispose of the suit on priority basis, in case if the suit has not been already disposed of. Accordingly the C.RP.s are dismissed. Consequently the C.M.P Nos. 9463 and 9464 of 1992 are also dismissed.

    RR/VCS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kalpana Poongothai (Minor), Rep. By Mother And Guardian, Mrs. Amsaveni. v. L. Kalianan.
    (Aug 18, 1997)