Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns appointment to the post of Reader in Life Science at the 2nd respondent University. The University issued Ext. P7 notification dated 11.1.2005 inviting applications and later published an addendum (Ext. R3(1) dated 31.1.2005) specifying that applicants should have specialisation in Biochemistry. The last date for receipt of applications was 28.2.2005. A selection committee interviewed candidates and prepared a select list. The appellant (who was the 3rd respondent in the writ petition) was placed at rank No. 1 and the Syndicate approved the recommendation (Ext. P11). The appellant was appointed as Reader by memorandum Ext. P12 dated 31.10.2005.

The 1st respondent (the writ petitioner) challenged Exts. P11 and P12 before the High Court on the principal ground that the appellant lacked the prescribed qualification of five years' teaching experience. The 1st respondent contended that the appellant possessed only four and a half years' teaching experience as a Guest Lecturer and much of that experience was prior to acquisition of the Ph.D. The appellant filed a counter affidavit defending her selection and contending, inter alia, that Guest Lecturer experience and research experience after the Ph.D. are reckonable. The University initially filed a counter affidavit supporting the appointment, but later filed an additional counter affidavit asserting irregularities and that the appellant did not possess the prescribed teaching experience.

The learned Single Judge accepted the 1st respondent's contention that Guest Lecturer experience, particularly that obtained before the Ph.D., could not be counted and set aside the appellant's selection. The appellant (3rd respondent in the writ petition) appealed against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether teaching experience gained as a Guest Lecturer can be counted as the teaching experience prescribed by the University Regulations for appointment to the post of Reader in Life Science.
  2. Whether the prescribed teaching experience must have been acquired after obtaining the Ph.D. (i.e., whether experience before acquisition of the research degree is excluded from reckoning).
  3. Whether the 1st respondent (writ petitioner) had locus standi to challenge the selection, given that he did not possess the notified specialisation in Biochemistry.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The 1st respondent lacked the notified specialisation in Biochemistry and therefore had no locus to challenge the selection.
  • The University Regulations prescribed only "teaching experience" and did not require that the experience be acquired after appointment on a regular basis or after approval of appointment; thus experience gained as a Guest Lecturer should be treated as equally valid.
  • The appellant had some research experience after obtaining the Ph.D., which ought to be reckonable when computing total teaching/research experience.
  • No ground was pleaded in the writ petition that only teaching experience gained after acquisition of the Ph.D. could be reckoned.

1st Respondent's and University's Arguments

  • Reliance on the definition of "teacher" in S. 2(27) of the Calicut University Act, which defines "teacher" to include persons "imparting instruction or supervising research in any of the colleges or recognised institutions and whose appointment has been approved by the University." The submission was that a Guest Lecturer is not a "teacher" under that definition because the appointment of a Guest Lecturer is not approved by the University.
  • The teaching experience prescribed by the Regulations must therefore be experience gained by a teacher as defined in the Act, i.e., an appointment approved by the University (regular appointment), not merely Guest Lecturer experience.
  • In the University's additional counter affidavit it was specifically asserted that teaching experience must be that of a regular teacher and that such experience must be gained after acquisition of the Ph.D. qualification.
  • The learned counsel for the 1st respondent also noted that the appellant had not raised the alleged lack of qualification of the 1st respondent before the Single Judge.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Vijayachandran Pillai v. University of Calicut, 2009 (3) KLT 176 : ILR 2009 (2) Ker. 874 The stipulation that five years of teaching and/or research excludes the period spent for obtaining the research degree; Ph.D. is an essential qualification for the post of Reader and experience after acquisition of the Ph.D. is relevant for reckoning the required experience. The court relied on this decision to hold that experience spent before acquisition of the Ph.D. cannot be counted towards the prescribed experience and, applying that principle, concluded that even if Guest Lecturer experience were counted, the appellant would still be unqualified.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the central issue as whether Guest Lecturer experience qualifies as the teaching experience required by the University's Regulations for appointment to a senior post like Reader. The court examined the statutory definition of "teacher" under S. 2(27) of the Calicut University Act, which describes a "teacher" as someone whose appointment has been approved by the University (examples given include principals, professors, readers, lecturers, etc.). From that definition the court observed that a Guest Lecturer is not a "teacher" under the Act because such appointments are typically not approved by the University.

The court considered the practical differences between regular teachers appointed after a formal selection process (whose appointments are subject to University approval or public service selection) and Guest Lecturers (who are often appointed on an ad hoc/hourly basis, frequently after walk-in interviews and public notices). On those factual and normative bases the court concluded that experience as a Guest Lecturer is not of the same character as teaching experience obtained under a regular appointment and therefore ordinarily should not be treated as meeting the teaching-experience requirement for a fairly senior post such as Reader, which is governed by U.G.C. norms.

The court also applied the legal principle from Dr. Vijayachandran Pillai that the prescribed teaching/research experience excludes the period spent obtaining the research degree and that the Ph.D. is an essential qualification; consequently, relevant experience must be measured excluding the period of pursuing the research degree and, in effect, after the Ph.D. acquisition. The court observed that even if the appellant's Guest Lecturer experience were to be counted, the appellant would still not satisfy the prescribed experience requirement in view of the timing of her Ph.D. and the experience claimed.

Procedurally, the court rejected the appellant's contention that the 1st respondent lacked locus because he did not have the specialisation in Biochemistry: the court noted that this alleged lack of qualification for the 1st respondent was not argued before the Single Judge nor pleaded in the appeal memorandum as having been so argued; therefore, the court would not permit the selection to be allowed to stand on that technical ground. The court also considered the University's additional counter affidavit (which asserted the requirement that experience be from regular appointment and after Ph.D.) and treated that as raising a pure legal question which the court could consider.

On these combined bases—statutory definition of "teacher", practical distinction between regular appointments and Guest Lecturer appointments, and the precedent excluding experience spent acquiring the research degree—the court concluded that the appellant was not qualified for the post of Reader.

Holding and Implications

Writ Appeal dismissed.

Consequences for the parties: The High Court's decision setting aside the appellant's selection (on the ground that Guest Lecturer experience, much of which was prior to the Ph.D., could not be counted) is upheld; the appellant is therefore not held to be qualified for the post of Reader. The court also declined to allow the challenge to be defeated on the procedural technicality that the 1st respondent lacked the specified specialization, because that contention had not been argued below nor pleaded in the appeal.

The opinion does not state any broader legal reform or create a new precedent; it applies an existing precedent (Dr. Vijayachandran Pillai) and affirms the position that experience spent obtaining the research degree is excluded and that teaching experience for senior posts should ordinarily be derived from regular, approved teaching appointments.

    Vasundhara v. Sallas Benjamin

    JUDGMENT

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    K. Balakrishnan Nair, J.:— The 3rd respondent in the Writ Petition is the appellant. The 1st respondent herein was, the writ petitioner. The point that arises for decision in this appeal is whether the teaching experience of a Guest Lecturer could be taken as the teaching experience prescribed for appointment to the post of Reader in Life Science, as per the Regulations of the University.

    2. The brief facts of the case are the following:

    The 2nd respondent University invited applications for appointment to the post of Reader in Life Science by Ext. P7 notification dated 11.1.2005 Later, an addendum notification was published as per Ext. R3(1) on 31.1.2005, clarifying that the applicants should have specialisation in Biochemistry. The last date for receipt of applications was 28.2.2005 The selection committee conducted an interview of the candidates and prepared a select list. The appellant being rank No. 1, the selection committee recommended the appointment of the appellant to that post and the Syndicate of the University approved the same as per Ext. Pll resolution. Pursuant to that, she was appointed as Reader in the Department of Life Science, as per Ext. P12 memo dated 31.10.2005 The lst respondent herein filed the Writ Petition, challenging Exts. P11 and P12.

    3. The main ground of attack against the selection of the appellant was that she did not have the requisite qualification of five years’ teaching experience. According to the 1st respondent, even the claim of the appellant was that she had only 41/2 years’ teaching experience as Guest Lecturer. It was also pointed out that most part of the experience gained was before she acquired the Ph. D qualification. The appellant filed a detailed counter affidavit, supporting her selection. She also questioned the locus standi of the 1st respondent to impugn the selection, as he was not having the notified qualification of specialisation in Biochemistry. The appellant claimed that when experience is prescribed as a qualification, the same need not be gained after getting appointment on regular basis. The experience gained in the post of Guest Lecturer is equally good. After obtaining the Ph. D degree, she had some research experience also. It was also reckonable for the purpose of computing the total period of teaching experience, it was contended.

    4. The University initially filed a counter affidavit, supporting the selection of the appellant. It submitted that the appellant and the 1st respondent were qualified for the post. But, having regard to the superior merit of the appellant, the selection committee recommended her for appointment. Later, the University filed an additional counter affidavit, pointing out that the selection was full of irregularities and the appellant did not have the prescribed teaching experience and therefore, the selection was bad.

    5. The learned Single Judge, after hearing both sides, upheld the contention of the 1st respondent/writ petitioner that the experience gained in the post of Guest Lecturer and that too, obtained before the acquisition of Ph. D degree, cannot be taken into account. In view of the said finding that the appellant does not have the requisite teaching experience, her selection was set aside. Feeling aggrieved by the said judgment, this appeal is preferred by the appellant, who was the 3rd respondent in the Writ Petition.

    6. We heard the learned senior counsel Sri. K.R.B Kaimal for the appellant, learned counsel Sri. K. Jaju Babu for the 1st respondent and learned standing counsel Sri. P.C Sasidharan for the University. The learned senior counsel for the appellant submitted that the 1st respondent/writ petitioner does not have the specialisation in Biochemistry and therefore, he is disqualified for the post. So, the challenge at his instance should not have been entertained by the learned Single Judge. Though that point was raised as a ground in the counter affidavit, the learned Single Judge did not deal with that aspect. The Regulations of the University prescribing the qualification for the post of Reader only speak of teaching experience. It does not say, the teaching experience should be one gained after regular selection and appointment or approval of the appointment. It also does not say that the teaching experience must be one acquired after the acquisition of Ph. D qualification. It is also pointed out that in the Writ Petition there was no ground that teaching experience after the acquisition of the Ph. D qualification alone could be reckoned. In view of the above position, the learned senior counsel prayed for allowing the appeal and dismissing the Writ Petition.

    7. The learned counsel for the 1st respondent/writ petitioner and the learned standing counsel for the University supported the judgment under appeal. The learned standing counsel brought to our notice the definition of “teacher”, contained in S. 2(27) of the Calicut University Act. The said definition reads as follows:

    “(27) ‘teacher’ means a principal, professor, associate professor, assistant professor, reader, lecturer, instructor or such other person imparting instruction or supervising research in any of the colleges or recognised institutions and whose appointment has been approved by the University.”

    8. Going by the definition quoted above, a Guest Lecturer is not treated as a teacher. When the Regulations speak of teaching experience, it must be the experience gained by a teacher as defined in the Act, it is submitted. The learned standing counsel further pointed out that in the additional counter affidavit filed, it was specifically pointed out that the teaching experience must be that of a regular teacher and the experience must be one gained after the acquisition of the Ph. D qualification. The learned counsel for the 1st respondent supported the above submissions and pointed out that when the University in its first counter affidavit submitted that both the appellant and 1st respondent were qualified, thereafter the lack of qualification of the 1st respondent/writ petitioner was not argued by the learned counsel for the appellant/3rd respondent before the learned Single Judge.

    9. The point whether teaching experience should be one acquired before or after the acquisition of the Ph. D qualification, is no longer res integra. That point is covered by the decision of this Court in Dr. Vijayachandran Pillai v. University of Calicut (2009 (3) KLT 176 : ILR 2009 (2) Ker. 874). In the said decision, it was held as follows:

    “8. The stipulation in Ext. P1 regarding teaching experience is as follows:

    ‘Five years of teaching and/or research excluding the period spent for obtaining the research degree and has made some mark in the areas of scholarship as evidenced by quality of publications, contribution to educational innovation, design of new courses and curricula.

    Ph. D degree is an essential qualification for the post of Reader. The 3rd respondent was awarded Ph. D degree only on 23.9.2003 The last date for receipt of applications was 15.10.2003 That means, after the acquisition of the basic qualification of Ph. D., the 3rd respondent did not have any teaching or research experience.”

    10. I view of the above legal position, even if the appellant's experience as a Guest Lecturer is taken into account, she is not qualified. Even assuming this point was not specifically raised by the 1st respondent/writ petitioner, the same was brought to the notice of the Court by the University through its additional counter affidavit. When this fact was brought to the notice of this Court, we think, this Court is not justified in ignoring that, as it is a pure legal question. The nature of the teaching post held by the incumbent, based on which experience is claimed, according to us, is also relevant in this case. Normally, a Lecturer in a University or in an aided College is appointed by a duly constituted selection committee. Thereafter, the appointment has to be approved by the University. In the case of Government Colleges, appointment is made based on the selection held by the Public Service Commission. A Guest Lecturer is appointed, in most of the cases, based on walk-in interview. Publications are usually made in local newspapers and based on that the candidates approach the head of the institution concerned and the incumbent is appointed as Guest Lecturer on hourly basis. The experience gained by such a candidate cannot be treated as the qualification prescribed by the University, based on U.G.C norms, for appointment to the post of Reader, which is a fairly senior teaching post. Normally, the candidate should be one, who must have teaching experience in the post of Lecturer, who got appointment after a regular selection. We think, the same is the reasonable view that should be taken, having regard to the qualification prescribed by the University, which is based on the norms formulated by an august body like the U.G.C So, the view taken by the learned Single Judge, accepting the contention of the University in its additional counter affidavit that teaching experience should be one which is gained after regular selection and appointment to a teaching post, is a plausible view on the facts of the case. We think, it is a correct view also. In view of the above position, we find that the appellant was not qualified for the post of Reader. Even assuming the 1st respondent/writ petitioner was not qualified in some respects, we think, the Court would not be justified in non-suiting him on that technical ground. We find considerable force in the submission of the learned counsel for the 1st respondent that the alleged lack of qualification of the said respondent was not argued before the learned Single Judge. If it was argued and the same was not considered, at least there should be a pleading in the appeal memorandum that the said point was argued but it was not considered by the learned Single Judge. In the absence of such a pleading, the technical contention that the 1st respondent was not qualified and therefore, at his instance the validity of the selection should not have been reviewed, cannot be accepted.

    11. In the result, the Writ Appeal fails and it is, accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vasundhara v. Sallas Benjamin
    (Jan 18, 2010)