Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Appeal) Rules, 1964 (for short, Appeal Rules) the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 (for short Pension Rules)
  • Rule 24 and Rule 69 of Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969
  • Rule 7 of the Disciplinary Rules
  • Rule 69 of the Pension Rules
  • Rule 7 of the Appeal Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Appeal) Rules, 1964 (for short, Appeal Rules) the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 (for short Pension Rules)
  • Rule 24 and Rule 69 of Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969
  • Rule 7 of the Disciplinary Rules
  • Rule 69 of the Pension Rules
  • Rule 7 of the Appeal Rules,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner sought family pension following the death of her husband, late Md Azgar Ali. The husband had been appointed Assistant Teacher on 24.11.1961 and made permanent Headmaster with effect from 26.9.1963. He was convicted by the Sessions Judge, Nagaon on 19.3.1987 in Sessions Case No.62 (N) of 1981 under sections 302/34 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment and a fine. Following that conviction, the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Nagaon issued Order No. 356 dated 6.4.87 discharging Md Azgar Ali from service with effect from 19.3.87 (the date of conviction). An appeal (Criminal Appeal No.65 of 1987) was preferred to the High Court, but the husband died during the pendency of that appeal and the appeal as to him was abated.

The petitioner alleges she has not received any family pension and approaches the High Court seeking direction for grant of family pension. The State-respondents did not file an affidavit-in-opposition or produce records despite having accepted notice. The Court appointed Mr. KH Choudhury as Amicus Curiae who assisted the petitioner, and Mr. HK Mahanta appeared for the State Government.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a government servant who has been "discharged" from service upon conviction (as opposed to being "dismissed" or "removed") is entitled to pensionary benefits such as family pension.
  2. Whether the absence of an affidavit-in-opposition by State-respondents permits the court to treat the petitioner’s averments as accepted.
  3. Whether the petitioner should be directed to first approach the competent authority by representation for grant of family pension despite the petition being filed before the High Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner, via learned senior counsel Mr. KH Choudhury (appointed as Amicus Curiae), argued that she is an illiterate widow and thus was unable to file a representation herself; her son filed the representation (Annexure 6) on her behalf.
  • It was submitted that the husband was only "discharged" (per the DI of Schools order) and not "dismissed" or "removed", and therefore, he retained entitlement to pension after long service (twenty four years as Headmaster).
  • Counsel relied on the Court's earlier decision in Bapu Ram Hazarika vs. State of Assam & others (Writ Petition (C) No.938 of 2000, disposed on 13.3.2001) to contend that "discharge" is not a recognized punitive termination under disciplinary jurisprudence.
  • Counsel also invoked provisions of statutory rules: Assam Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1964 (specifically Rule 7), Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 (Rules 24 and 69), and Fundamental Rule 52, to support entitlement to pensionary benefits where a person has not been dismissed or removed from service.

State-Respondents' Position

  • No affidavit-in-opposition was filed by the State-respondents despite notice being accepted on 1.9.95. No detailed rebuttal or record was produced on behalf of the respondents at the hearing.
  • Consequently, the Court recorded that there was no opposition evidence presented by the State-respondents in the matter.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smti Naseem Bano vs. State of UP & others, AIR 1993 SC 2592 Principle that, where respondents do not file an affidavit-in-opposition, averments in the writ petition may be deemed accepted. The Court applied this principle to treat the petitioner’s averments as accepted because the State-respondents filed no affidavit-in-opposition despite accepting notice.
Bapu Ram Hazarika vs. State of Assam & others, Writ Petition (C) No.938 of 2000 (disposed 13.3.2001) Interpretation that "discharging of an office after enquiry is unknown in legal jurisprudence" and that the term "discharge" is ordinarily used in the context of probationary officers rather than as a punitive measure. The Court relied on the reasoning in this decision to support the view that "discharge" as used in the DI order did not amount to dismissal or removal and therefore did not automatically disentitle the deceased from pensionary benefits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, grounded on the facts and the legal provisions cited in the opinion:

  1. Absence of Opposition: The Court first noted that the State-respondents had accepted notice but filed no affidavit-in-opposition and produced no record. Applying the principle from Smti Naseem Bano (AIR 1993 SC 2592), the Court treated the petitioner's averments as accepted for purposes of deciding the writ petition.
  2. Factual Findings: The Court summarized the factual chronology — appointment dates, conviction on 19.3.87, the DI of Schools' order dated 6.4.87 discharging the deceased from service with effect from the date of conviction, the lodging of a criminal appeal which was abated upon the husband's death, and the absence of any claim for family pension having been made directly by the petitioner (the son had made a representation which was annexed).
  3. Petitioner's Procedural Posture: The Court observed that the petitioner had not herself approached the competent authority by representation; instead her son had done so and the Government had not acted upon that representation. The petitioner’s counsel explained the petitioner's illiteracy and inability to file the representation personally.
  4. Statutory and Rule-Based Analysis: The Court examined the relevant disciplinary and pensionary rules cited by counsel:
    • Assam Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1964 — Rule 7 lists the nature of penalties (censure, withholding increments, recovery, reduction, compulsory retirement, removal, dismissal) and does not include the term "discharge" as a penalty.
    • Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 — Rule 24 precludes pension to officers dismissed or removed for misconduct/inefficiency; Rule 69 contemplates "discharge" where a post is abolished and gives options regarding compensation pension or reappointment.
    • Fundamental Rule 52 — provides that pay and allowances of a government servant who is dismissed or removed cease from the date of such dismissal or removal.
    Based on these provisions, the Court observed that the statutory scheme treats "dismissal" and "removal" as penal terminations which carry specific consequences on pension and pay; the term "discharge" does not appear as a penalty under Rule 7 and occurs in Rule 69 in the context of abolition of a permanent post.
  5. Legal Conclusion: The Court reasoned that because the DI's order used the term "discharged" and the statutory disciplinary scheme did not classify "discharge" as a punitive removal/dismissal, the deceased was not shown to have been "dismissed" or "removed" for purposes of pension forfeiture. Therefore, the petitioner (as widow) is, in principle, entitled to family pensionary benefits of her deceased husband.
  6. Relief and Procedural Direction: Noting that the petitioner had not approached the competent authority, the Court did not itself grant pension but directed the petitioner to file an appropriate representation to the competent authority within two months. On presentation, the authority was directed to investigate and consider the petitioner's claim for family pension and all retiral benefits in accordance with law and to complete the process within six months from presentation. The petitioner was also directed to furnish a certified copy of the order and the writ petition with annexures to the competent authority.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court held that the petitioner is entitled, in principle, to the family pension of her deceased husband, who had been "discharged" from service and died during the pendency of the criminal appeal; accordingly, the writ petition was disposed with directions to the competent authority to consider the claim.

Direct Effect on the Parties:

  • The petitioner is directed to file an appropriate representation before the competent authority within two months of the date of the order.
  • On presentation, the competent authority must look into the matter, conduct proper investigation/enquiry, and consider the petitioner's case for grant of family pension and all retiral benefits of late Md Azgar Ali in accordance with law, completing the process within six months from presentation.
  • The petitioner must furnish a certified copy of the High Court order together with the writ petition and annexures to the competent authority.
  • The writ petition is disposed of by the Court with no costs awarded.

Broader Implications:

The Court's decision applies the existing statutory scheme and precedents to the facts and directs administrative consideration rather than pronouncing a novel principle of law. The opinion does not purport to create a new precedent; it interprets the difference between "discharge" and penal terminations such as "dismissal" or "removal" for pensionary consequences in the circumstances of this case.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer information not present in that text.

    Rejia Khatun v. State Of Assam And Ors.

    Heard Mr. KH Choudhury, learned senior counsel who has been appointed by this Court as Amicus Curiae, assisted by Mr. MA Sheikh, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. HK Mahanta, appearing on behalf of the State Govt.

    2. This is a case of 1995. Despite the notice issued on the Govt counsel who accepted the same on 1.9.95 at the time of issuing Rule, no affidavit-in-opposition has been filed as usual, nor has any record been produced on behalf of the respondents where the matter has been taken up for hearing. Since no affidavit-in-opposition is forthcoming on behalf of the State-respondents, in view of the settled position of the law laid down in the case of Smti Naseem Bano vs. State of UP & other reported hi AIR 1993 SC 2592, the averments made in this writ petition are deemed to be accepted by the State-respondents.

    3. The case of the petitioner in this writ petition is that her husband late Md Azgar Ali was appointed as Assistant Teacher at Koladuba Muktab with effect from 24.11.1961 and later on he was made permanent Headmaster in the said school with effect from 26.9.1963. While the petitioner's husband was working as Headmaster in the said school, he was involved in a criminal case i.e. QR Case No. 1731/1980 under section 302/34 IPC and accordingly, he was convicted in the said case vide judgment and order dated 19.3.87 passed by Sessions Judge, Nagaon, hi Sessions Case No. 62 (N) of 1981 under section 302/34 IPC along with four others and sentenced to suffer imprisonment of life and to pay fine of Rs. 200 (Rupees two hundred) each. Being aggrieved by the said judgment and order referred above, the husband of the petitioner along with others preferred a Criminal Appeal being No. 65 of 1987 before this Court. But during the pendency of the said criminal appeal, the husband of the petitioner Md Azgar Ali died and the said appeal as regards the appellant Mr. Azgar Ali was abated.

    4. Be it mentioned here that immediately after the conviction of the husband of the petitioner, the DI of Schools, Nagaon, Assam, vide its order dated 6.4.87 discharged the said Azgar Ali from service with effect from 19.3.87, on the date of his conviction by the Sessions Judge, Nagaon. The said order is made available as Annexure 3 of the writ petition and is extracted as under:

    "Office of the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Nagaon, Assam.

    Order No. 356 dated 6.4.87

    Order: Md Azgar Ali, the Headmaster of Balikotia is discharged from service wef 19.3.87 as the Court held him guilty of murder.

    Sd/- Sri Dharmeswar Nath,

    Deputy Inspector of Schools, Nagaon, Assam."

    5. A perusal of the said order clearly shows that the deceased Md Azgar Ali, Headmaster of the school was discharged from service from the date of his conviction by the trial Court.

    6. It is stated that immediately after the death of her husband during the pendency of the criminal appeal in this High Court, the petitioner had approached the authority praying for family pension etc to her. Since she has not been paid any family pension, the petitioner has moved this Court claiming the relief of granting family pension to her.

    7. On perusal of the records including the writ petition, it is found that the petitioner has not approached the concerned authority praying such relief of granting family pension to her. Instead, one Md Mujahidul Islam, the son of late Azar Ali, the husband of the petitioner, had approached to the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Nagaon, for granting family pension to his father's family by a representation which is annexed as Annexure 6 to this writ petition. I have not found any other demands made on behalf of the petitioner before the competent authority.

    8. Be that as it may, Mr. KH Choudhury, the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner vehemently argues that since the petitioner is an illiterate uneducated widow, she could not file any representation before the concerned , authority and the representation as Annexure 6 was only filed on behalf of her son and since the Government has not paid any heed to the said representation she has no other alternative but to approach this Court.

    9. Mr. Choudhury, learned senior counsel in support of his submission, relies on the decision of this Court in Writ Petition (C) No.938 of 2000 hi the case of Bapu Ram Hazarika vs. State of Assam & others, disposed on 13.3.2001 wherein this Court held as follows :

    "Before adverting to other points, I am at this stage point out that discharging of an office after enquiry is unknown in legal jurisprudence. Normally if a person is punished on enquiry, he is either dismissed or removed. The terminology of 'discharge' is applied only in case of probationary officer."

    10. It is submitted, from the record itself, it reveals that the petitioner was only 'discharged' from his service and once he is discharged, not being dismissed or removed, the deceased himself is entitled to pension as he has already rendered if twenty four years of service as Headmaster.

    11. Supporting the submission, Mr. Choudhury, learned senior counsel has referred to the various provisions of law laid down hi the Assam Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1964 (for short, Appeal Rules) the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 (for short Pension Rules) and also FR 52.

    12. Now let us see those provisions. Rule 7 of the Disciplinary Rules which runs as follows:

    "7. Nature of penalties - The following penalties may, for good and sufficient reasons and as herein after provided, be imposed on a Govt servant, namely :

    (i) Censure;

    (ii) Withholding of increments or promotion;

    (iii) Recovery from pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused by negligence or breach of orders to the Govt of Assam or the Central Govt or any other State Govt or any local or other authority to whom services of a Govt servant had been lent;

    (iv) Reduction to a lower service, grade or post, or to a lower time scale, or to a lower stage in a time scale;

    (v) Compulsory retirement;

    (vi) Removal from service which shall not be a disqualification for future employment;

    (vii) Dismissal from service which shall ordinarily be a disqualification for future employment."

    Rule 24 and Rule 69 of Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 read as follows:

    "24. Misconduct or inefficiency. No pension may be granted to an officer dismissed or removed for misconduct, insolvency or inefficiency; but to officers so dismissed or removed compassionate allowances or/and compassionate gratuity may be granted when they are deserving of special consideration; provided that the allowance gratuity granted to any officer shall not exceed two thirds of the pension/ gratuity which would have been admissible to him if he had retired on medical certificate.

    69. If an officer is selected for discharge owing to the abolition of a permanent post, he shall, unless he is appointed to another post the conditions of which are deemed by the authority competent to discharge him to be at least equal to those of his own, have the option-

    (a) of taking any compensation pension or gratuity to which he may be entitled for the service he has already rendered, or

    (b) of accepting another appointment or transfer to another establishment even on a lower pay, if offered, and continuing to count his previous service for pension." The FR 52 of the Fundamental Rules runs as under :

    "FR 52. The pay and allowances of a Government servant who is dismissed or removed from service cease from the date of such dismissal or removal."

    13. On a bare perusal of those provisions of law, it appears that the word 'discharge' has nowhere been defined or mentioned in those provisions except in Rule 69 of the Pension Rules wherein the word 'discharge' occurs in relating to abolition of some permanent post as mentioned herein above.

    14. It is seen that under Rule 7 of the Appeal Rules, penalty can only be imposed as censure, withholding increment of compulsory retirement, removal from service, dismissed from service etc, but the word 'discharge' does not come within the purview of Rule 7 of the Appeal Rules which clearly goes to show that the discharge is not a punishment. From the interpretation of those provisions of law, it also goes to show that once the person is not dismissed or removed f from the service, he is entitled to for all his benefits like pension, gratuity on his retirement of death. In the instant case, the husband of the petitioner was admittedly discharged from service and as such by a discharge being simpliciter from service, the petitioner is entitled to family pension in view of the above previsions of law.

    15. FR 52 of the other hand, has clearly showed about the situation of pay and allowances of one person who is dismissed or removed from service. That being the position, the petitioner's husband not being dismissed or removed from service, the pensionary benefits like family pension cannot be withheld by the authority.

    16. Being situated with such legal position, I am of the view that the petitioner is entitled to family pension of her husband who was discharged from service and died during the pendency of this criminal appeal.

    17. But from the record what appears is that the petitioner, has not approached the authority concerned for redressal of for such relief. Since she failed to approach the authority for such relief, I am of the considered view that ends of justice will be satisfied if the petitioner is directed to approach the authority by filing a representation praying for grant of family pension of her deceased husband.

    18. In that view of the matter, it is directed that the petitioner shall approach the competent authority by filing an appropriate representation in this regard within a period of two months from today and on such presentation of the representation before the competent authority, the authority shall look into the matter and on proper investigation and enquiry, he shall consider the case of the petitioner for giving family pension with all retiral benefits of late Azgar Ali in accordance with law. The entire process of such consideration be completed within 6 months from such presentation of the representation as mentioned above.

    19. The petitioner shall furnish a certified copy of the order along with a copy of the writ petition with all Annexures appended thereto before the competent authority who shall do the needful as indicated herein above.

    20. Before parting with the case, I would like to offer my thanks to Mr. KH Choudhury, learned senior counsel for rendering his valuable assistance to this Court on being appointed as Amicus Curiae to assist this Court in this regard.

    This disposes the writ petition. No Costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rejia Khatun v. State Of Assam And Ors.
    (Aug 27, 2001)