AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 16 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Control Act, 1975, (for short, Mundkar Act, 1975).
  • Section 8 A of the Mundkar Act, 1975.(3)
  • Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975,
  • law.6. Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 16 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Control Act, 1975, (for short, Mundkar Act, 1975).
  • Section 8 A of the Mundkar Act, 1975.(3)
  • Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975,
  • law.6. Rule
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Petition challenges the Order dated 26.11.2008 passed by the Administrative Tribunal in Mundkar Revision Application No. 147/2003. The revision application arose from a purchase application filed by the Petitioners' predecessor before the Joint Mamlatdar, Mormugao, concerning a dwelling house situated at Vasco da Gama under the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Control Act, 1975 ("Mundkar Act, 1975"). The Joint Mamlatdar partially allowed the application and directed demarcation of the property based on the external outer wall of the dwelling house. The Petitioners were aggrieved by this demarcation and appealed to the Deputy Collector/S.D.O, Mormugao, but the appeal was dismissed as premature. Subsequently, the Respondent filed a Mundkar Revision Application before the Administrative Tribunal, which set aside the Mamlatdar's order and directed demarcation according to the Survey Plan. The current Petition contests this Tribunal order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the demarcation of the dwelling house should be based on the external walls as directed by the Joint Mamlatdar or as per the Survey Plan as directed by the Administrative Tribunal.
  2. Whether the Petitioners have the right to purchase the demarcated area without a declaration under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975.
  3. Whether the Petitioners can be allowed to raise contentions regarding alleged encroachment before the Mamlatdar.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Petitioners challenged the demarcation based on the external outer wall of the dwelling house and sought a different demarcation.
  • The Petitioners did not dispute that their right to purchase is contingent upon a declaration under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent contended that the demarcation should be as per the Survey Plan, in accordance with the Administrative Tribunal’s direction.
  • The Respondent alleged that the Petitioners had encroached further on the property and thus should be allowed to raise such contentions before the Mamlatdar.
  • The Respondent argued that the Petitioners’ right to purchase only arises upon issuance of a declaration under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, and mere registration as a Mundkar does not confer such right, relying on the Division Bench judgment in Smt. Gulabi Sangtu Devidas v. Smt. Prema Govinda Gaonkar, 1995 (1) Goa L.T 154.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Gulabi Sangtu Devidas v. Smt. Prema Govinda Gaonkar, 1995 (1) Goa L.T 154 Right to purchase under the Mundkar Act, 1975 arises only upon declaration under Section 8-A; mere registration as Mundkar does not confer this right. The Court accepted this principle and held that the Petitioners’ right to purchase depends on obtaining a declaration under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the procedural history and statutory framework under the Mundkar Act, 1975. It acknowledged the Administrative Tribunal’s direction to demarcate the dwelling house as per the Survey Plan rather than the external walls, thereby setting aside the Mamlatdar’s earlier order. The Court recognized the Respondent’s grievance regarding alleged encroachment and clarified that the Mamlatdar, vested with statutory powers, is the appropriate authority for adjudicating such claims. Furthermore, the Court emphasized that the Petitioners’ right to purchase the demarcated area is contingent upon a declaration under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975, consistent with established precedent. The Petitioners were directed to apply for such declaration within two months, and the Mamlatdar was instructed to decide the application on merits and in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The Court upheld the Administrative Tribunal’s order directing demarcation of the dwelling house according to the Survey Plan. It clarified that the Petitioners’ right to purchase the demarcated property is conditional upon obtaining a declaration under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975. The Petitioners were granted two months to apply for this declaration, which the Mamlatdar must decide on its merits. The Court allowed the parties to make submissions regarding any alleged encroachment before the Mamlatdar. The decision directly affects the parties' rights and procedural steps but does not establish any new precedent beyond affirming existing legal principles under the Mundkar Act.

    Shri Roque Fernandes (Since Deceased) Through Legal Heirs v. Francisco Xavier Fernandes

    1. This Petition can be conveniently disposed of at the admission stage. Hence, Rule made returnable forthwith with the consent of the parties.

    2. This Petition takes exception to the Order dated 26.11.2008 passed by the Administrative Tribunal in Mundkar Revision Application No. 147/2003. The said Mundkar Revision Application has arisen out of the purchase application filed by the Predecessor of the Petitioners herein, before the Joint Mamlatdar, Mormugao, with respect to dwelling house in the property surveyed under chalta no. 13 P.T Sheet no. 91 of City Survey, situated at Vasco da Gama. The said application was filed by the Predecessor of the Petitioners under Section 16 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Control Act, 1975, (for short, ‘Mundkar Act, 1975’). The said application was considered by the Joint Mamlatdar and was partially allowed and direction was issued to the Court Surveyor to demarcate the area taking into consideration the external outer wall of the dwelling house of the Applicants. In so far as the purchase price is concerned, the Joint Mamlatdar directed that the same will be done after the demarcated plan is confirmed by both the parties. The Applicants i.e the Petitioners herein, were aggrieved by the said direction issued by the Mamlatdar in respect of the demarcation of the property taking into consideration the external walls of the dwelling house of the Applicant. They, therefore, filed an Appeal before the Deputy Collector/S.D.O, Mormugao, which Appeal in so far as the issue of demarcation was concerned, was held to be premature and, therefore, dismissed. Thereafter, the Respondent no. 1 filed the Mundkar Revision Application no. 147/2003, before the Administrative Tribunal, Goa, which Revision came to be allowed and the Order of the Mamlatdar came to be set aside and the Tribunal issued a direction to the Joint Mamlatdar to demarcate the area of the dwelling house considering the location and the area of the dwelling house shown in the Survey Plan. The direction, therefore, which is in operation i.e the demarcation of the dwelling house in terms of the Mundkar Act, 1975, has to be as per the Survey Plan.

    3. Both the learned Counsel for the Petitioners Shri Shirodkar and learned Counsel for the Respondent no. 1, Ms. Kamat, i.e the Bhatkar, have no objection if the Order of the Administrative Tribunal is impleaded. A grievance is made on behalf of the Respondent no. 1 by Ms. Kamat, that the Petitioner has encroached further in the said property and, therefore, the Petitioners should be given the liberty to raise contention in that behalf before the Mamlatdar. Since the Mamlatdar is vested with the necessary powers under the Mundkar Act, 1975, it would be open for the parties to make their respective submissions before the Mamlatdar in respect of the alleged encroachment.

    4. An issue is also sought to be raised on behalf of the Respondent no. 1 that the right of the Petitioners to purchase only ennures if a declaration is issued under section 8-a of the said mundkar act, 1975 and mere registration as a Mundkar, confers no such right. In support of the said submission, reliance is placed on a Judgment of the Division Bench of this Court reported in 1995 (1) Goa L.T 154, in the matter of Smt. Gulabi Sangtu Devidas v. Smt. Prema Govinda Gaonkar.

    5. Since admittedly the Petitioners have not been declared as Mundkars pursuant to any proceedings under Section 8-A of the Mundkar Act, 1975, therefore, though the demarcation as ordered by the Administrative Tribunal is allowed to be carried out, the right eventually of the Petitioners, would hinge upon the declaration, that would be issued in that favour under Section 8-A. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner does not dispute the said position. The Petition is, therefore, disposed of in the following terms:

    (1) That the demarcation of the dwelling house will be carried out in terms of the impugned Order of the Administrative Tribunal dated 26.11.2008

    (2) The right of the Petitioners to purchase the demarcated area would ultimately hinge upon the declaration if any that would be issued under Section 8 A of the Mundkar Act, 1975.

    (3) The Petitioners would therefore take steps to apply for such declaration within two months from date. If such an application is filed, the same would be decided by the concerned Mamlatdar on its own merits and in accordance with law.

    6. Rule is accordingly made absolute in the aforesaid terms, with parties to bear their respective costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Roque Fernandes (Since Deceased) Through Legal Heirs v. Francisco Xavier Fernandes
    (Dec 9, 2009)