Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 304-A of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 166 of the M.V Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 304-A of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 166 of the M.V Act
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Appellate Decision on OP No. 965 of 1990 (Motilal B. Naik, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The claim arises from a motor-vehicle accident on 20-7-1989 in which G. Umamaheshwar Rao (aged 37), a Sub-Manager at Andhra Bank, died. The deceased and his brother were travelling in an auto rickshaw when an RTC bus allegedly driven in a rash and negligent manner struck the auto rickshaw. A criminal case under Section 304-A IPC was registered that day. The legal representatives of the deceased (his wife and two minor children) filed OP No. 965 of 1990 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act before the Tribunal below claiming Rs. 10,00,000 as compensation.

Before the Tribunal, the appellant (the RTC Corporation / the owner of the bus) filed a counter denying negligence by the bus driver and alleging negligence by the auto rickshaw driver; the driver of the RTC bus was set ex parte. The Tribunal found the bus driver guilty of rash and negligent driving, assessed loss of earnings and other heads of damage, and awarded a total of Rs. 6,39,000 with interest at 12% per annum by an order dated 31-7-1992. The appellant challenged that award before this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accident was due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the RTC bus bearing No. AAZ 7701? (Issue as framed by the Tribunal below.)
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to any compensation and if so, to what amount? (Issue as framed by the Tribunal below.)
  3. Whether the compensation claimed is excessive and exorbitant? (Issue as framed by the Tribunal below.)
  4. Whether the respondents are liable to pay the compensation? (Issue as framed by the Tribunal below.)
  5. On appeal before this Court: whether the impugned award made by the Tribunal below is just and reasonable?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Standing Counsel for the Corporation)

  • The Tribunal erred by failing to deduct any amount from the deceased's monthly salary towards his personal expenses; the entire salary (Rs. 4,300) was treated as contribution, contrary to settled law which allows deduction for personal expenses.
  • Relying on the Division Bench decision in Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Gaddamaduga Saibaba (1995 (2) ALT 485 (DB)), counsel argued by analogy that the compensation should be substantially reduced because the deceased's wife was gainfully employed on compassionate grounds and thus the family's overall loss was reduced.

Respondents' Arguments (Claimants)

  • The deceased was only 37 and a Sub-Manager in a nationalised bank; he would likely have obtained future promotions and increased earnings, so future prospects should be considered when awarding compensation.
  • Reliance was placed on decisions of the Supreme Court (General Manager, Kerala State RTC v. Mrs. Susamma Thomas and Smt. Sarala Dixit v. Balwant Yadav) to support the Tribunal's treatment of future prospects and the approach to deductions for personal expenses.
  • Evidence (PW4, the deceased's brother) indicated the deceased contributed almost his entire salary to the family and spent very little on personal expenses; thus the ordinary 1/3rd deduction from income is not appropriate on the facts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation v. Mrs. Susamma Thomas ((1994) 2 SCC 176 / AIR 1994 SC 1631) Explained the difficulties in assessing damages in fatal accident claims; set out the multiplicand/multiplier method and the principle of deducting from net income the part spent on the deceased's personal maintenance and pleasure before capitalising the remainder; described choice of multiplier. The Court relied on this decision for the correct approach to calculating dependency: to determine net contribution, consider deductions for personal expenses on facts, and apply an appropriate multiplier. The judgment supported the Court's conclusion that a 1/3rd deduction is not automatic and must be determined case-by-case.
Nance v. British Columbia Electricity Supply Company Limited (1951 AC 601) Identified as one of the authorities describing methods for determination/calculation of compensation (alternative to Davies). The Court cited it as part of the background on methods (multiplier method and other approaches) but did not apply specific rules beyond acknowledging it as one of the accepted methods for calculation.
Davies case (referenced; no full citation in the opinion) Referenced as the source of the multiplier method for capitalising loss of dependency (as one of the methods for determining compensation). Used as part of the doctrinal basis for the multiplier approach; the Court applied the multiplier method in calculating compensation (ultimately adopting multiplier 15).
Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Gaddamaduga Saibaba (1995 (2) ALT 485 (DB)) Division Bench decision where compensation was reduced because an injured person was re-employed without affecting service conditions; held that where there is no loss of earning capacity, the Tribunal's award could be excessive. The appellant relied on this decision to argue for reduction. The Court distinguished the case: here the claimants are dependants of a deceased person (not an injured person re-employed), so the ratio did not apply and the Court rejected the appellant's submission based on this precedent.
Smt. Sarala Dixit v. Balwant Yadav ((1996) 3 SCC 179 / AIR 1996 SC 1274) Relied upon (with Susamma Thomas) to support consideration of future prospects and related principles in awarding compensation. The Court accepted the respondents' reliance on this decision as part of the legal foundation for considering future prospects when assessing compensation; it contributed to the Court's view that future prospects could properly be taken into account.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a step-by-step analysis based on the evidence and relevant authority cited in the opinion:

  1. Evidence and tribunal finding: The Tribunal had found, on oral and documentary evidence (claimants' PWs 1–4, Exs. A1–A5), that the bus driver was rash and negligent and that the deceased died as a result. The Tribunal fixed monthly contribution at Rs. 4,000 and applied multiplier 13 to arrive at loss of earnings and awarded other heads, totaling Rs. 6,39,000 with 12% interest.
  2. First issue — deduction for personal expenses: The Court reviewed the Supreme Court's guidance (Kerala RTC case) that deduction of one-third for personal expenses is not automatic and must depend on facts. PW4 testified that the deceased spent about Rs. 200 per month personally and contributed almost his entire salary to family maintenance; that testimony was not controverted. The Court, while noting the difficulty of PW4's precise knowledge, concluded that the one-third deduction principle need not be followed rigidly here. Considering the deceased's position as Sub-Manager, the Court instead deducted Rs. 1,000 per month as reasonable personal expenses from the Rs. 4,300 salary, fixing net monthly contribution at Rs. 3,300.
  3. Second issue — effect of the widow's employment: The Court considered the appellant's submission based on Oriental Insurance (where an injured person was re-employed and no loss of earning capacity remained). The Court distinguished that case: here the claimants are dependants of a deceased (not an injured person who retained employment and earning capacity). The wife's compassionate employment did not disentitle claimants to compensation for the death, and therefore the Court rejected the appellant's contention that the award should be reduced on that basis.
  4. Choice of multiplier: The Court examined the question of which multiplier should be applied. Although the Tribunal used multiplier 13 for a 37-year-old deceased, the Court considered the deceased's age, position, and future promotion prospects and concluded that multiplier 15 was appropriate to meet the ends of justice. The Court applied multiplier 15 to the net monthly contribution of Rs. 3,300 to calculate loss of earnings.
  5. Computation and components of compensation: Using Rs. 3,300 × 12 × 15, the Court calculated loss of earnings at Rs. 5,94,000. It affirmed Rs. 15,000 for loss of consortium to the wife and Rs. 15,000 for loss of estate, arriving at total compensation of Rs. 6,24,000. The Court also confirmed interest at 12% per annum from the date of the petition to the date of realisation, as awarded by the Tribunal.
  6. Apportionment among claimants: The Court adjusted distribution in view of changed circumstances: the wife (first claimant) was awarded Rs. 15,000 (loss of consortium) plus one-quarter of the remaining Rs. 6,09,000. From her share, she may withdraw half immediately and the other half shall be placed in fixed deposit for five years, with periodic interest withdrawable every six months. The two minor children (claimants 2 and 3) were each given an equal half share of the remaining amount; their shares to be kept in fixed deposit in a nationalised bank until they attain majority, with the mother permitted to withdraw periodic interest every six months for their maintenance.

Holding and Implications

Final disposition: The appeal was disposed of with modification of the Tribunal's award. The Court fixed total compensation at Rs. 6,24,000 with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the petition till realisation, and specified the apportionment and manner of deposit/withdrawal for the claimants. The appeal was disposed of with no order as to costs.

Implications and consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The claimants are awarded Rs. 6,24,000 (instead of the Tribunal's Rs. 6,39,000), interest at 12% as above, and specific directions concerning distribution: the wife receives Rs. 15,000 (consortium) plus one-quarter of the remaining amount (half withdrawable immediately, half to be fixed for five years); each minor child receives an equal half of the remaining compensation to be kept in fixed deposit until majority with interest available semi-annually to the mother for maintenance.
  • On legal principle: The Court reiterated that the standard 1/3rd deduction for personal expenses is not an inexorable rule and must be applied depending on the facts; it distinguished cases where an injured person retains earning capacity and is re-employed from cases of death where dependants remain entitled to compensation.
  • No new precedent was expressly proclaimed by the Court; the decision applied and distinguished existing authorities to the facts of the case and adjusted the compensation and apportionment accordingly.

This summary is strictly limited to the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add, infer, or extrapolate facts or legal conclusions beyond that text.

    Apsrtc, Hyd. v. G. Jana Bai

    Motilal B. Naik, J.:— Appellant herein is the 1st respondent in OP No. 965 of 1990 on the file of the Court of the I Additional Special Judge for SPE and ACB Cases-cum-Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. The respondents who are the legal representatives of late G. Umamaheshwar Rao, who died in a motor accident on 20-7-1989, laid a claim in OP No. 965 of 1990 under Section 166 of the M.V Act before the Tribunal below seeking a total compensation of a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs.

    2. The 1st respondent herein is the wife and respondents 2 and 3 are the minor children of the deceased G. Umamaheshwar Rao, who was serving as Sub-Manager in Andhra Bank, Bhimadole Branch in West Godavari District. He was aged 37 years at the time of his death. On 20-7-1989 at 8-30 a.m, the deceased and his brother G. Suryanarayana Murthy, Manager, Andhra Bank, Mallavaram Branch, West Godavari District were travelling in an auto rickshaw bearing No. AHT 8271 to go to Secunderabad Railway Station and on the way near Hockey Stadium Road, the RTC bus bearing No. AAZ 7701 driven by the 2nd respondent in the OP, in a rash and negligent manner hit the auto rickshaw, due to which G. Umamaheshwar Rao sustained serious injuries and was taken to Gandhi Hospital by his brother, who was with him at that time, where he was declared dead. A case in Crime No. 116 of 1998 under Section 304-A of the Indian Penal Code was registered by the Police Ramgopalpet Police Station at about 10-15 p.m, on the same day. The claimants being the legal representatives of the deceased laid OP No. 965 of 1990 before the Tribunal below claiming compensation of Rs. 10 lakhs for the untimely death of the deceased.

    3. Before the Tribunal below, in OP No. 965 of 1990 a counter was filed by the appellant who is the first respondent in the said OP, denying the rashness and negligence on the part of the driver of the bus bearing No. AAZ 7701. It was alleged that due to the rashness and negligence on the part of the driver of the auto rickshaw bearing No. AHT 8271 the accident took place. It was also pleaded in the counter that the compensation claimed by the claimants is exorbitant.

    4. The driver of the RTC bus which involved in the accident who is the 2nd respondent in the above OP, was set ex-parte.

    5. Basing on the above pleadings, the Tribunal below framed the following issues for consideration, viz.,—

    1. Whether the accident was due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the RTC bus bearing No. AAZ 7701?

    2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to any compensation and if so, to what amount?

    3. Whether the compensation claimed is excessive and exorbitant?

    4. Whether the respondents are liable to pay the compensation?

    6. On behalf of the claimants, P.Ws 1 to 4 were examined and Exs. A1 to A5 were marked. PW1 is the wife of the deceased. On behalf of the 1st respondent/APSRTC no witness was examined and no documents were marked.

    7. On the basis of the oral and documentary evidence, the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the accident in question took place due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the RTC bus bearing No. AAZ 7701 on account of which the deceased died. While considering the claim for compensation, the Tribunal took into consideration the gross income of the deceased as on the date of the accident and also took into account the future prospects of the deceased and determined his monthly contribution to his family at Rs. 4,000/- per month. The Tribunal applied the multiplier 13 and granted compensation of Rs. 6,24,000/- towards loss of earnings and also awarded Rs. 15,000/- to the wife of the deceased towards loss of consortium. Thus, the Tribunal awarded a total compensation of Rs. 6,39,000/- to the claimants with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the petition till the date of realisation, by the impugned order dated 31-7-1992. It is this order which is challenged before this Court in this appeal by the appellant, who is the 1st respondent in the claim petition in OP No. 965 of 1990.

    8. Smt. Nanda R. Rao, Standing Counsel for the appellant-Corporation raised two grounds while attacking the impugned order passed by the Tribunal below. Firstly, according to the Counsel, for the purpose of determining the just and reasonable compensation to be awarded to the dependents of a deceased, some amount has to be deducted from the monthly contribution of the deceased for the maintenance of his family, towards personal expenses of the deceased. Counsel stated, in the impugned order, the Tribunal below has failed to set apart any reasonable amount towards personal expenses of the deceased from his monthly salary but has taken the entire monthly salary of Rs. 4,300/- of the deceased as his contribution for the maintenance of his family determining the compensation, which according to the Counsel, is contrary to settled legal prepositions. Secondly, placing reliance on a decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Oriental insurance Company Limited v. Gaddamaduga Saibaba, 1995 (2) ALT 485 (DB), Counsel submitted that in the said case, an injured person after the accident was re-employed by his employer without affecting his service conditions and though he claimed substantial amount towards compensation for the said injuries which has been granted by the Tribunal, on appeal, the Division Bench of this Court held that since there is no loss of earning capacity of the claimant therein, the compensation amount awarded by the Tribunal was excessive and reduced the compensation. Laying emphasis on the said decision, Counsel submitted that by applying the same analogy to the facts of this case, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal below could be substantially reduced as the first claimant who is the wife of the deceased is gainfully employed on compassionate grounds in the Bank in which the deceased was working.

    9. Sri M.R.K Chowdary, learned senior Counsel for the respondents-claimants submitted that the deceased at the time of his death was working as Sub-Manager in Andhra Bank and was aged only 37 years and had he been alive, he would have got promotions in his service in course of time. He also placed reliance on the decisions of the Supreme Court in General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation v. Mrs. Susamma Thomas, (1994) 2 SCC 176 : AIR 1994 SC 1631, and in Smt. Sarala Dixit v. Balwant Yadav, (1996) 3 SCC 179 : AIR 1996 SC 1274, and submitted that in view of the ratio laid down in these decisions, the Tribunal below has rightly taken into consideration the future prospects of promotion of the deceased in his service and has deliberately not deducted 1/3rd amount towards personal expenses of the deceased from his monthly income as the evidence on record adduced by the claimants suggested that the deceased was hardly spending any amount towards his personal expenses. Learned senior Counsel, therefore, submitted that the well-considered decision of the Tribunal below need not be interfered with.

    10. In the wake of the above submissions, the point for determination is whether the impugned award made by the Tribunal below is just and reasonable?

    11. Admittedly, as on date of the accident i.e, 20-7-1989, the deceased was 37 years old and was working as Sub-Manager in Andhra Bank at Bheemadolu Branch of West Godavari District drawing a monthly salary of Rs. 4,300/-. The Tribunal below, at para 13 of the impugned order has recorded a finding that the future prospects of the deceased have to be taken into account and also taking into consideration the life expectancy of the deceased had he not died in the accident, applied multiplier 13 and determined the loss of future earnings at Rs. 6,24,000/-.

    12. In Kerala Road Transport Corporation's case (supra) the Supreme Court at para 7 of the judgment held thus:

    “The assessment of damages to compensate the dependants is beset with difficulties because from the nature of things, it has to take into account many imponderables, e.g, the life expectancy of the deceased and dependants, the amount that the deceased would have earned during the remainder of his life, the amount that he would have contributed to the dependants during the period, the chances that the deceased may not have lived or the dependants may not live up to the estimated remaining period of their life expectancy, the chances that the deceased might have got better employment or income or might have lost his employment or income altogether.

    The manner of arriving at the damages is to ascertain the net income of the deceased available for the support of himself and his dependants, and to deduct therefrom such part of his income as the deceased was accustomed to spend upon himself, as regards both self-maintenance and pleasure, and to ascertain what part of his net income the deceased was accustomed to spend for the benefit of the dependants. Then that should be capitalised by multiplying it by a figure representing the proper number of year's purchase.

    Much of the calculation necessarily remains in the realm of hypothesis and in that region arithmetic is a good servant but a bad master since there are so often many imponderables. In every case, it is the overall picture that matters and the Court must try to assess as best as it can the loss suffered.”

    13. At Para 8 of the said judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court further held thus:

    “There were two methods adopted for determination and for calculation of compensation in fatal accident actions, the first the multiplier mentioned in Davies case (supra) and the second in Nance v. British Columbia Electricity Supply Company Limited, 1951 Appeal Cases 601.

    The multiplier method involves the ascertainment of the loss of dependency or the multiplicand having regard to the circumstances of the case and capitalizing the multiplicand by an appropriate multiplier. The choice of the multiplier is determined by the age of the deceased (or that of the claimants whichever is higher) and by the calculation as to what capital sum, if invested at a rate of interest appropriate to a stable economy, would yield the multiplicand by way of annual interest. In ascertaining this, regard should also be had to the fact that ultimately the capital sum should also be consumed up over the period for which the dependency is expected to last.”

    14. On a careful analysis of the above decision, it would appear to us that 1/3rd deduction towards the personal expenses of the deceased from out of his monthly salary could not be resorted to in all accident cases but it could be done depending upon the facts and circumstances of each case.

    15. In the instant case, the claimants have examined PW4 who is the brother of the deceased. PW4 deposed that his deceased brother was contributing his entire monthly salary for his family and was hardly spending Rs. 200/- per month towards his personal expenses. This evidence of PW4 has not been controverted by the appellant. As held by the Supreme Court in the decision (supra) deduction of 1/3rd amount from the monthly salary towards the personal expenses of the deceased cannot be resorted to in all cases but only depending upon the facts and circumstances of each case. In this case, though PW4 testified that the monthly personal expenses of his brother (deceased) were around Rs. 200/-, we are of the view, it would be difficult for PW4 who is working at Hyderabad at the relevant point of time, to know the exact amount the deceased was spending towards this personal expenses per month. However, in view of the facts and circumstances of this case, we are inclined to say that the general principle of 1/3rd deduction need not be followed in this case. Nonetheless, taking into account the position of the deceased i.e, Sub-Manager in a nationalised bank, we deduct an amount of Rs. 1000/- per month towards the personal expenses of the deceased from out of his monthly salary of Rs. 4,300/- per month. Thus, the net contribution of the deceased per month for the maintenance of his family is fixed at Rs. 3,300/-.

    16. Insofar as the second contention of the appellant that the first respondent who is the wife of the deceased was gainfully employed and as such, substantial deduction has to be made from the compensation amount awarded by the claimants in view of the decision cited (supra), we are not inclined to accept this submission. It must be remembered that though the wife of the deceased has secured employment on compassionate grounds, her employment has nothing to do with the compensation to be awarded to the claimants as a result of the death of the deceased due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the appellant's bus. Merely because the wife was provided with employment, it would not disentitle the claimants to claim just and reasonable compensation for the death of the deceased. Though Counsel for the appellant relied on a decision (supra) in support of her contention in this regard, we are afraid, the ratio laid down in the said decision would not enure to the benefit of the appellant inasmuch as in the said case, the claimant himself was the injured person and even after sustaining injuries, he was re-employed by his employer without affecting his service conditions. Under those circumstances, a Division Bench of this Court in the said decision held that since there is no loss of earning capacity of the claimant therein, and as such the amount granted by the Tribunal was reduced. However, in the instant case, the claimants are not the injured persons but they are the dependants of the deceased who died in a motor accident on account of the rash and negligent driving of the bus by the driver of the appellant. This is not the case where there is no loss of earning capacity of the injured but this is a case of death on account of the rash and negligent driving of the appellant's bus for which the claimants being the legal representatives of the deceased are entitled for just and reasonable compensation. Therefore, the mere fact of the wife of the deceased gainfully employed on compassionate grounds cannot be a ground for awarding less compensation though the claimants are entitled for more compensation. We, therefore, reject the submission of the Counsel for the appellant in this regard having regard to the view taken by us.

    17. As discussed by us in the foregoing paragraphs, the net contribution by the deceased per month for the maintenance of his family is Rs. 3,300/-. The question, therefore, would be what is the relevant multiplier which is to be applied for determining just and reasonable compensation to be awarded to the claimants. The Tribunal below has applied the multiplier 13 basing on the age of the deceased which was 37 years at the time of his death. As indicated above, in Kerala Road Transport Corporation's case (supra), the Supreme Court has held that the future prospects of the deceased could also be considered as one of the criterion for awarding just and reasonable compensation. It is to be noted life is uncertain and none can be definite about his/her life span. As long as the vagaries of uncertainties are associated with life span, it would be difficult to fix any criterion for determining higher compensation. But some guess work has to be done having regard to the age of the deceased, his qualifications in a particular specialized field and the position held by him at the time of death, while determining the loss of earnings.

    18. In this case, the deceased, admittedly, was aged 37 years at the time of his death and was working as Sub-Manager in Andhra Bank. There cannot be any doubt that had the deceased been alive, he would have probably got promotions with higher salary. However, these are all questions of uncertainty surrounding life span and therefore, a specific criterion cannot be evolved in case of this nature. Nonetheless, depending upon several aspects, Courts could, in order to meet the ends of justice, adopt different methods for awarding just and reasonable compensation to the claimants. Though the Tribunal below applied the multiplier 13, but having regard to our discussion and in view of the age and earning capacity of the deceased had he been alive, we are of the view, multiplier 15 could be applied for the purpose of determining the just and reasonable compensation which would meet the ends of justice. Therefore, by applying the multiplier 15, the claimants are entitled for the compensation under various heads, viz., (1) Loss of earnings at Rs. 5,94,000/- (Rs. 3,300/- 12 × 15); (2) Loss of consortium to the first claimant = Rs. 15,000/- and (3) Loss of estate = Rs. 15,000/-. Thus, in all, the claimants are entitled to an amount of Rs. 6,24,000/- towards total compensation on all counts. The claimants are also entitled to interest at 12% per annum on the said amount as awarded by the Tribunal below i.e, from the date of the petition till the date of realisation.

    19. The next question would be about the apportionment of the compensation amount among the claimants. The first claimant is the wife and claimants 2 and 3 are the children of late G. Umamaheshwar Rao. Since the first claimant is gainfully employed, though the Tribunal has awarded half of the compensation amount, in view of the changed circumstances, we hold that she is entitled for Rs. 15,000/- towards loss of consortium and 1/4th amount from the remaining compensation amount of Rs. 6,09,000/-. Out of the share of the first claimant, she is entitled to withdraw half of the said amount and also accrued interest thereon and the other half share shall be kept in fixed deposit for a period of five years and she is entitled to withdraw periodical interest once in six months on this amount. Insofar as claimants 2 and 3 are concerned who are minor children of the deceased, they are entitled for half share each in the remaining amount of compensation. The compensation amount of the minor claimants 2 and 3 shall be kept in fixed deposit in any nationalized bank till they attain the age of majority. The first claimant being their mother shall, however, be entitled to withdraw periodical interest on the said amount once in six months for the maintenance of the minors. The impugned award of the Tribunal is modified to the extent indicated above.

    20. This appeal is disposed of accordingly. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Apsrtc, Hyd. v. G. Jana Bai
    (Jun 12, 2001)