Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 32 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 - Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act, 1952 read with Section 69 of Registration Act, 1908.
  • Article 35(a)(iii) of Second Schedule of Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952 (hereinafter referred to as the Act of 1952).
  • Rajasthan Finance Act, 1997 in Rajasthan Stamp Law Adaptation Act, 1952. The provision of Article 35(a)(iii)
  • provision of Article 35(a)(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Rajasthan Stamp Act
  • Section 105 of T.P Act read with Section 2(16)(c) of Indian Stamp Act.30.
  • provision of Section 2(10) and Section 2(16) of the Rajasthan Stamp Act
  • Article 35(a)(iii) of Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act
  • provisions of Article 14 and 19 of the Constitution.4.
  • Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952 in Article 35(a)(iii)
  • Section 7 read with Ss. 25, 27, 29, 30, 37, 38, 45
  • SECTION 54 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • SECTION 3 A STAMP ACT
  • Valuation Act - Section 40 and Section 7
  • Rajasthan Amendment Act 16 of 1976
  • Article 35(a)(iii) of the Stamp Act.
  • provision of Article 35(a)(iii)
  • Section 2(10) of the Stamp Act.
  • SECTION 64 STAMP ACT
  • SECTION 22 ADVOCATES ACT
  • provision of Section 7(1)
  • Amendment Act of 1994)
  • FINANCE ACT 1997
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 32 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 - Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act, 1952 read with Section 69 of Registration Act, 1908.
  • Article 35(a)(iii) of Second Schedule of Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952 (hereinafter referred to as the Act of 1952).
  • Rajasthan Finance Act, 1997 in Rajasthan Stamp Law Adaptation Act, 1952. The provision of Article 35(a)(iii)
  • provision of Article 35(a)(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Rajasthan Stamp Act
  • Section 105 of T.P Act read with Section 2(16)(c) of Indian Stamp Act.30.
  • provision of Section 2(10) and Section 2(16) of the Rajasthan Stamp Act
  • Article 35(a)(iii) of Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act
  • provisions of Article 14 and 19 of the Constitution.4.
  • Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952 in Article 35(a)(iii)
  • Section 7 read with Ss. 25, 27, 29, 30, 37, 38, 45
  • SECTION 54 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • SECTION 3 A STAMP ACT
  • Valuation Act - Section 40 and Section 7
  • Rajasthan Amendment Act 16 of 1976
  • Article 35(a)(iii) of the Stamp Act.
  • provision of Article 35(a)(iii)
  • Section 2(10) of the Stamp Act.
  • SECTION 64 STAMP ACT
  • SECTION 22 ADVOCATES ACT
  • provision of Section 7(1)
  • Amendment Act of 1994)
  • FINANCE ACT 1997
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitions challenge the constitutional validity of Article 35(a)(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Rajasthan Stamp Law Adaptation Act, 1952, as amended by the Rajasthan Finance Act, 1997. The amended provision imposes stamp duty on leases exceeding twenty years or in perpetuity based on the market value of the property at the same rate as conveyances. The petitioners executed leases and faced demands for stamp duty under this amended provision. They contend that the provision is ultra vires Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, arguing that leases are distinct from conveyances and that the basis for stamp duty should be rental value rather than market value. The respondents defend the amendment as a valid exercise of fiscal policy by the State Legislature.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the amendment to Article 35(a)(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952, which levies stamp duty on leases exceeding twenty years or in perpetuity based on the market value of the property at the same rate as conveyance, is constitutionally valid.
  2. Whether the provision violates Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution by arbitrarily equating long-term leases with conveyances for stamp duty purposes.
  3. Whether the State Legislature has legislative competence under Entry 63 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to prescribe the basis and rate of stamp duty on leases.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The amended provision is ultra vires Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution as it arbitrarily equates leases exceeding twenty years with conveyances for stamp duty purposes.
  • Leases create a limited interest and are not transfers of ownership; hence, market value of the property is irrelevant for stamp duty computation on leases.
  • The correct basis for stamp duty on leases should be the rent reserved, not the market value of the property.
  • The amendment is discriminatory and arbitrary, lacking justification for a different basis for long-term leases.
  • The amendment was enacted for the fiscal year 1997 only and has lost efficacy thereafter.
  • The provision exceeds legislative competence as per Entry 63 of List II, and the State cannot impose stamp duty based on market value for leases.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The demand for stamp duty based on market value for leases exceeding twenty years is valid and lawful.
  • The amendment does not treat leases as conveyances but prescribes the rate of stamp duty at par with conveyances for fiscal reasons.
  • The State Legislature has competence under Entry 63 of List II to fix both the rate and basis for stamp duty.
  • Long-term leases or leases in perpetuity effectively confer prolonged enjoyment of property, justifying use of market value for stamp duty calculation.
  • The provision is neither arbitrary nor violative of constitutional rights under Articles 14 and 19(1)(g).
  • The amendment is not temporary and continues to be effective beyond the fiscal year 1997.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Ramkishori Gupta v. State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1988 MP 145) Legislature's power under Entry 63 of List II and Entry 44 of List III to amend stamp duty rates and mode of computation including use of market value instead of consideration stated in deed. Supported the view that State Legislature can prescribe market value as basis for stamp duty on conveyances or leases.
Calcutta Gas Co. v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1962 SC 1044 Interpretation of legislative entries in Schedule 7 of the Constitution; harmonizing overlapping entries and giving them widest amplitude. Applied to affirm legislative competence and to harmonize entries relating to stamp duty.
Kasturi Lal Harlal v. State of U.P (1986) 4 SCC 704 : AIR 1987 SC 27 Legislative entries must be read in widest amplitude; legislature can make ancillary provisions in aid of main legislation. Used to support State Legislature's competence to amend stamp duty provisions.
Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh v. State of U.P (1973) 1 SCC 261 : AIR 1973 SC 231 Scope of legislative power under different entries of the Constitution relating to stamp duty and professional enrollment fees. Confirmed Entry 63 of List II applies to stamp duty rates and basis, supporting State Legislature's competence.
Bidhannager (Salt Lake) Welfare Association v. Central Valuation Board (2007 AIR SCW 3962) Arbitrariness in tax or valuation increases violates Article 14. Distinguished from instant case as no arbitrary or excessive increase in stamp duty was shown here.
Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597 Arbitrariness may violate Article 14 of the Constitution. Applied to assess arbitrariness in stamp duty provisions; found none in the instant case.
State of Rajasthan v. Bhilwara Spinners Ltd. & Ors. (2001 (2) RLR 311) Stamp duty on lease deeds charged on average annual rent under unamended provision. Held not applicable as provision amended to use market value for leases exceeding 20 years.
Narender Singh Solanki v. State of Rajasthan (1991 (1) WLC 337) Inspector General's circular directing valuation held ultra vires and arbitrary. Distinguished as the instant case concerns legislative competence, not executive circulars.
State of Rajasthan v. Basant Nahata (2005 SCC 77) Delegation of essential legislative function to executive held unconstitutional. Distinguished as the instant case involves legislative enactment, not executive delegation.
Himalaya House Co. Ltd., Bombay v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority (1972) 1 SCC 726 : AIR 1972 SC 899 Revenue must regard consideration stated in instrument; no independent inquiry authorized by Stamp Act. Not applicable as issue here is basis of stamp duty fixed by legislature, not revenue inquiry.
Bajaj Hindustan Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1997 Raj. 262 : RLW 1997 (2) Raj. 891 Valuation of properties for stamp duty to reflect actual conveyance; no extraneous exploration. Distinguished as the instant provision differs in basis and rate for stamp duty.
Khandige Sham Bhat & K. Krishna Bhatta v. Agricultural Income Tax Officer, Kasaragod (AIR 1963 SC 591) Taxation statutes must not be arbitrary; courts reluctant to strike down fiscal measures unless capricious or unjust. Applied to uphold the amended provision as not capricious, arbitrary, or unjust.
Government of Andhra Pradesh v. P. Laxmi Devi (2008) 4 SCC 720 Statute declared unconstitutional only if flagrantly unconstitutional beyond doubt; wide legislative discretion in fiscal matters. Supported refusal to interfere with the stamp duty amendment.
P.M Ashwathanarayana Setty v. State of Karnataka (1989 Supp (1) SCC 696) Choice between ad valorem or ad quantum tax measure is fiscal policy matter. Applied to affirm legislature's discretion in choosing market value basis.
Avinder Singh v. State of Punjab (1979) 1 SCC 137 Wide latitude in classification for taxation; State may pick districts, objects, persons, methods, and rates if reasonable. Supported classification of long-term leases for higher stamp duty as reasonable and non-arbitrary.
R.V Infrastructure Engineers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of M.P (ILR (2010) M.P 608) Stamp duty can only be imposed if transaction fits within legal definition; lease is distinct from sale. Applied to confirm that transaction here is lease and tax basis prescribed is valid.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether the amendment to Article 35(a)(iii) treats leases as conveyances and found that it does not alter the nature of the lease. The amendment merely prescribes the market value of the property as the basis for stamp duty on leases exceeding twenty years or in perpetuity, applying the same rate as for conveyances. The Court recognized that long-term leases confer enjoyment of property for a prolonged period, justifying the use of market value rather than rental value for stamp duty calculation. The Court held that the State Legislature has competence under Entry 63 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to fix both the rate and basis of stamp duty, including the adoption of market value. The Court distinguished precedents involving arbitrary or excessive taxation and executive overreach, finding no arbitrariness or illegality in the present provision. It emphasized the settled principle that courts should not rewrite or recast legislation and must give effect to the plain language of statutory provisions. The Court also rejected the contention that the amendment was temporary for the fiscal year 1997, affirming its continuing validity.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions challenging the constitutional validity of Article 35(a)(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952, as amended by the Rajasthan Finance Act, 1997, are dismissed.

The Court held that the amendment prescribing stamp duty on long-term leases based on market value at the rate applicable to conveyances is constitutionally valid and intra vires the State Legislature's competence. The provision is neither arbitrary nor violative of Articles 14 or 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. The decision directly affects the parties by upholding the demand for stamp duty under the amended provision. No new precedent beyond affirming legislative competence and fiscal policy discretion is set.

    Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. State & Ors.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Kailash Chandra Joshi, J.:— In these writ petitions, common question arises for consideration as to the constitutional validity of Article 35 of the Second Schedule as inserted by Rajasthan Finance Act, 1997 in Rajasthan Stamp Law Adaptation Act, 1952. The provision of Article 35(a)(iii) as substituted by Rajasthan Act provides that a lease which purports to be for a term in excess of twenty years or perpetuity or where the term is not mentioned, the rate of the stamp duty payable shall be same as on conveyance as mentioned in Article 23, on the market value of the property which is the subject matter of the lease. In these cases, it is not disputed that leases were executed and demand of stamp duty was made in terms of Article 35(a)(iii) of Second Schedule of Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act of 1952’). Following is the amended provision in Article 35 of Second Schedule of the Act of 1952—

    “35. Lease-including and under lease, or sub lease and any agreement to let, or sub let—

    (a) Where, by such lease, the rent is fixed and no premium is paid or deliver.

    (i) where the lease purports to be a term for less than one years, the same duty as on a Bond (No. 15) for the whole amount payable under such lease.

    (ii) where the lease purports to be for a term of not less than one year but not more than twenty years; the same duty as on a conveyance (No. 23) for a consideration equal to the amount of value of the average rent of two years.

    (iii) Where the lease purports to be for a term in excess of twenty years or perpetuity or where the term is not mentioned. The same duty as on a conveyance (No. 23) on the market value of the property which is the subject matter of the lease.”

    2. The validity has been questioned on the ground that the aforesaid provision is ultra vires of Article 14, 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. The lease only creates a limited right or an interest in enjoyment of the demised property for a definite period. A lease is not transfer of ownership and not a conveyance as defined in Section 2(10) of the Stamp Act. On the other hand, sale is transfer of ownership for a price and there is an absolute transfer of all rights in the property sold. Thus, the leases beyond 20 years could not have been compared with the conveyance for the purpose of levy stamp duty. The transaction which is to be subject matter of the stamp duty, lease deed has nothing to be with the market value of the property. Hence, market value could not have been made the basis of levying the stamp duty. The basis ought to have been rental method of valuation and levy of stamp duty could have been made only on the basis of rent reserved in the lease. The prescription of any other method or mode of valuation on the basis of conveyance is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. There was no justification for providing separate basis for levying of stamp duty for the leases beyond 20 years or in perpetuity. Action is illegal and arbitrary. There is no rhyme or reason to levy the stamp duty at the rate prescribed for conveyance. Concept of market value is completely foreign to a lease and providing of such concept for computing stamp duty on lease for a period exceeding 20 years or on transfer of lease is per se illegal. As such, amendment made vide Act of 1997 is ultra vires.

    3. The stand of the respondents in return is that as the deficit stamp duty is not made good, demand was rightly raised in accordance with the amended provision. Stamp duty has rightly been demanded on the basis of market value of the property on a lease beyond 20 years. There is no illegality in the amendment substituted in Article 35 of Second Schedule of the Act. Only the rates have been defined, the document is not being treated as a conveyance. For the purpose of specifying the rate of stamp duty chargeable, different criterion have been applied considering the period of leases which is permissible. It is a matter of fiscal policy in which the Government should have free play. The provisions cannot be said to be illegal or arbitrary. Thus, there is no violation of provisions of Article 14 and 19 of the Constitution.

    4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners submitted that considering the Entry 63 of the State List-II in Seventh Schedule of the Constitution, State is competent to determine the stamp duty subject to Entry 91 of List-I i.e Union List. The market value of the property has no co-relation with the transfer of the right in the lease deed. Thus, making such a provision for levy of the stamp duty is beyond legislative competence. Conveyance is totally different from lease deed. With respect to leases also, different basis for charging stamp duty have been provided in Article 35 which is discriminatory. Yearly rent could have been the basis for levying the stamp duty not the market value of the property. Consequently provision is arbitrary and ultra vires.

    5. Attention has been drawn to the provision of Section 2(10) and Section 2(16) of the Rajasthan Stamp Act which relates to ‘conveyance’ and ‘lease’. Conveyance and lease deed are two different and independent transaction. These could not have been combined for the purpose of levying the stamp duty. It was also submitted that sale is defined under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act. The transaction is not of sale. The provision made under the Finance Act, 1997 was for fiscal year. It has to be treated as temporary provision for the year in question for which the Finance Act was enacted. Thus, it should be held by this Court that amendment made in the year 1997 has lost the efficacy on the lapse of the financial year.

    6. Mr. G.S Bapna, learned Advocate General, Mr. R.L Jangid, learned Addl. Advocate General with Mr. Anil Bachhawat and Mr. Sunil Beniwal, appearing on behalf of the State has submitted that the document in question has been treated to be lease within the meaning of Article 35 and only the rate of stamp duty as that on conveyance has been provided which is permissible. It was also submitted by learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-State that the provision could not be said to be illegal or arbitrary or violative of rights under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. Government has right under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. Government has right to fix the basis for levying of the stamp duty on leases beyond 20 years or in perpetuity which has been done in the instant cases. The leases beyond 20 years or in perpetuity, right to enjoy the property is for a longer duration, value of property is virtually reailsed in such leases. Thus, market value is to be considered as the criteria for the purpose of determination of stamp duty. It was also submitted that value of the property can be determined on the basis of annual usufruct. When lease is in perpetuity or for more than 20 years, the enjoyment of property is for a very long duration. Thus, the basis of same rate as that of conveyance has been adopted which is rationale behind it as property enjoyed for a longer duration, therefore, market value could have been the basis to reliase stamp duty. Even in the cases of conveyance, market value of the property is the basis not the value shown in the deed of conveyance. Thus, it is open for the Legislature to provide for a basis for determination of the levy of stamp duty and rate which has been done by substituting the provision made in Article 35 of Second Schedule of the Act.

    7. The question for consideration is whether by virtue of amendment made in the year 1997 in Article 35(a)(iii) of Second Schedule of the Act, lease has been treated as conveyance. We are of the considered opinion that it is not so. Lease remains lease. Market value is the basis for determination of the stamp duty chargeable on the lease which purports to be for a term in excess of twenty years or in perpetuity or where the term is not mentioned. The stamp duty at the prescribed rate has to be charged as on a conveyance at the market value of the property which is the subject matter of the lease by which the nature of the document is not being changed from lease to conveyance. Only for the purpose of determination of providing basis of stamp duty to be reliased on a lease for more than 20 years or in perpetuity or where the term is not mentioned, market value is relevant and 11% is the rate fixed on the market value of the property. In such cases of lease for longer duration or in perpetuity, enjoyment of property is for a longer period. For leases for short duration, the annual rental method is the basis which has been adopted by the Government.

    8. Similar question came up for consideration in Smt. Ramkishori Gupta v. State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1988 MP 145). Amendment was made in Section 47-A and other provisions. Prior to amendment of Section 47A, Entry 23 of Schedule-I, the amount or value of the consideration for conveyance as set forth in the deed of conveyance constituted the basis for determining the stamp duty payable. The basis after the amendment is the market value of the property which is the subject matter of the conveyance. The Division Bench of M.P High Court held that in exercise of powers conferred on it by Entry 63 of List II and Entry 44 of List III, it was open to the State Legislature not only to make an amendment in the Act in regard to the rates of stamp duty but also in regard to the mode of compensation of stamp duty. In other words, it was open to the State Legislature to lay down that the basis for computing stamp duty shall not be the amount or value of the consideration for the conveyance as set forth therein but it shall be the market value of the property which is the subject matter of conveyance. It was also laid down that entries in the list must be read in its widest amplitude and the legislature must be held to have power not only to legislate with respect to the subject matter of the entry but also to make ancillary or incidental provision in aid of the main topic of legislation. It was open to the legislation to make amendment in the Act in regard to rates of stamp duty and with regard to mode of computation of stamp duty. In Smt. Ram Kishori (supra), it has been laid down thus,—

    “Entry No. 23 in Schedule 1 to the Act which deals with conveyance prior to its amendment by M.P Act No. 8 of 1975 inter alia provides the mode of calculation of stamp duty treating “the amount of value of the consideration for such conveyance as set forth therein.” After its amendment by M.P Act No. 8 of 1975, it inter alia provides “23. Conveyance, not being a transfer charged or exempted under No. 62 where the market value of the property which is the subject matter of conveyance does not exceed….” It is thus apparent that prior to amendment of Entry No. 23 aforesaid by M.P Act No. 8 of 1975 the amount or value of the consideration for such conveyance as set forth in the deed of conveyance constituted the basis for determining the stamp duty payable. The basis after the amendment is the market value of the property which is the subject matter of conveyance.

    While dealing with the rule of interpretation of legislative entries, it was held by the Supreme Court in Calcutta Gas Co. v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1962 SC 1044 that in the matter of construing entries in the lists given in Schedule 7 of the Constitution certain rules of interpretation are now well settled. The power to legislate is given to the appropriate Legislatures by Art. 246 of the Constitution. The entries in the three Lists are only Legislative heads or fields of legislation, they demarcate the area over which the appropriate Legislatures can operate. It is also settled that widest amplitude should be given to the language of the entries. But some of the entries in the different lists or in the same list may overlap and sometimes may also appear to be in direct conflict with each other. It is then the duty of the Court to reconcile the entries and bring about harmony between them. The underlying principle in such cases is that a general power ought not to be so construed as to make a nullity of a particular power conferred by the same Constitution and operating in the same field, when by reading the former in a more restricted sense effect can be given to the latter in its ordinary and natural meaning. Thus, every attempt should be made to harmonize the apparently conflicting entries not only of different Lists but also of the same List and to reject that construction which will rob one of the entries of its entire content and make it nugatory. In a very recent decision in Kasturi Lal Harlal v. State of U.P, (1986) 4 SCC 704 : AIR 1987 SC 27 its was held by the Supreme Court that it is now well settled that an entry in a legislative List must be read in its widest amplitude and the legislature must be held to have power not only to legislate with respect to the subject matter of the entry but also to make ancillary or incidental provision in aid of the main topic of legislation. The scope of Entry 63 of List II and Entry 44 of List III came up for consideration squarely before the Supreme Court in the case of Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh v. State of U.P, (1973) 1 SCC 261 : AIR 1973 SC 231.

    On a conspectus of these authorities it is, therefore, apparent that in the exercise of powers conferred on it by Entry 63 of List II and Entry 44 of List III, it was open to the State Legislature not only to make an amendment in the Act in regard to the rates of stamp duty but also in regard to the mode of computation of stamp duty. In other words, it was open to the State Legislature to lay down that the basis for computing stamp duty shall not be the amount or value of the consideration for the conveyance as set forth therein but it shall be the market value of the property which is the subject matter of conveyance.”

    9. The submission raised by learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners cannot be accepted on the ground that basis for computation of stamp duty should have been the consideration mentioned in the lease deed itself i.e on yearly rent. It is open to the State Legislature to enact a provision with respect to rate and also the basis for computing the stamp duty as per entry 63 of List II of Seventh Schedule which is read thus;—

    “63. Rates of stamp duty, in respect of documents other than those specified in the provisions of List I with regard to rates of stamp duty.”

    10. The lease is defined in Section 2(16) of the Act whereas conveyance has been defined in Section 2(10) of the Act. As document admittedly has been treated to be a lease, market value of property could have been adopted for levy of stamp duty with respect to leases beyond 20 years or in perpetuity as defined in Section 2(16) and we find that there is no arbitrariness in the same. The provision of Art. 35(a)(iii) cannot be said to be violative of Article 14. The provision cannot be said to be imposing any restriction on the right to carry on occupation, trade or business of leasing out of the property. It is open to the Government while dealing with the fiscal matters to prescribe the rates on which such levy has to be made and also the basis for realization of the rate so fixed. The provision cannot be said to be unreasonable or putting any fetter on the rights enshrined under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution.

    11. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners have referred to the decision in State Of Rajasthan v. Bhilwara Spinners Ltd. & Ors., (2001 (2) RLR 311 : RLW 2001 (3) Raj. 1398) in which question arose before Division Bench of this Court was with respect to levy of the stamp duty on the lease deed which was executed in 1968, the supplementary lease was executed in 1983, thus the Division Bench of this Court has laid down that instrument is a lease deed and stamp duty is chargeable under Article 35(a)(iii) of Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act on the consideration equal to amount of average annual rent reserved at that time unamended provision was applicable in which the basis was average annual rent reserved which provision has now been substituted with respect to lease for more than 20 years or in perpetuity or where the term is not mentioned with the market value of the property. In view of amendment in provision, this decision is of no help to the petitioners.

    12. Reliance has also been placed on a decision of this Court in Narender Singh Solanki v. State of Rajasthan (1991 (1) WLC 337) wherein the Court has dealt with the scope of power of Inspector General of Registration with reference to Section 32 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 - Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act, 1952 read with Section 69 of Registration Act, 1908. Circular issued by Inspector General directing registration to be effected on valuation of 20% more than that of previous year was held to be ultra vires, arbitrary, unreasonable and mala fide. Circular was quashed. Decision is of no help as in the instant case as the provision has been made in the statute itself, question in instant case is that of competence of legislature not of Inspector General to issue circular. In our considered opinion, it is open to the State Government to prescribe not only the rate but also to prescribe the criteria/basis for levy of such stamp duty within the parameter of entry 63 List II of Seventh Schedule of the Constitution.

    13. Reliance has also been placed on decision of the Apex Court in State of Rajasthan v. Basant Nahata, 2005 SCC 77 wherein validity of Section 22A as inserted by Rajasthan Amendment Act 16 of 1976 came up for consideration before the Apex Court. Under the said provision, State Govt. was authorised to issue notifications regarding registering officers empowered to refuse to register documents to which such notifications apply. Notification was issued on 1.4.1999 which was amended by notification dated 22.4.1999 declaring that any power of attorney authorising the attorney to transfer any immovable property for a term in excess of six months or irrevocable or where the term is not mentioned would be opposed to public policy. Certain documents were specified by notification dated 26.3.1999 but later on amending notification dated 22.4.1999 was issued exempting such power of attorney executed in favour of brother or sister or son or daughter or father or mother or husband of wife or grandson or granddaughter. The Apex Court held Section 22A to be unconstitutional and consequently the notifications issued thereunder were also quashed. The Apex Court has laid down that said provision was vitiated by reason of delegation of essential legislative function to executive and delegation of power being unguided, uncontrolled and vague, Public policy not capable of being given any precise meaning and words opposed to public policy being vague and uncertain, do not provide any guideline and depend upon nature of transaction.

    14. The decision in Basant Nahata (supra) is not attracted in the instant case as no legislative function has been delegated to the executives. Legislation itself has made a specific provision by substituting the basis for levy of stamp duty in Article 35(a)(iii) of the Stamp Act. The provision cannot be said to be unguided, uncontrolled or couched in vague manner.

    15. Reliance has also been placed by learned counsel for the petitioners on a decision of the Apex Court in Himalaya House Co. Ltd., Bombay v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority ((1972) 1 SCC 726 : AIR 1972 SC 899) wherein it is held that Revenue must have regard only to what the parties to the instruments have elected to state the consideration to be, or that it can also consider the value of the consideration as disclosed upon an examination of the terms of the instrument as a whole. A close reading of the aforesaid decision indicates that the Apex Court has laid down that as per Section 27, the parties to a document are required to set forth in the document fully and truly the consideration if any and all other facts and circumstances affecting the changeability of that document with the duty or the amount of the duty with which it is chargeable. But a failure to comply with the requirements of that section is merely punishable under Section 64 of the Stamp Act. Their Lordships also observed that no provision in the Stamp Act empowers the Revenue to make an independent inquiry of the value of the property conveyed for determining the duty chargeable. At the same time, the Apex Court has left the question open whether for the purpose of Article 23, the value of consideration must be taken to be one as set forth in the conveyance deed, revenue must have regard only to what the parties to the instruments have elected to state the consideration to be, or that it can also consider the value of the consideration as disclosed upon an examination of the terms of the instrument as a whole. In the instant case, the decision is of no assistance as the question raised in Himalya House Co. Ltd. was totally different.

    16. Reliance has also been placed on decision of the Apex Court in Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh v. State of U.P ((1973) 1 SCC 261 : AIR 1973 SC 231) wherein challenge was to the constitutional validity of the provision made with respect to imposition of stamp duty on the certificate of enrollment under Section 22 of Advocates Act. Various entries came up for consideration. The Apex Court has observed that the power to legislate in regard to persons entitled to practice before the Supreme Court and the High Courts is altogether excluded from Entry 26 in List III, and is made the exclusive field for Parliament. The Parliament has the exclusive power under Entry 77 and Entry 78 in List I to prescribe, inter alia, the qualifications and conditions on the fulfillment of which persons would be entitled to practice before the Supreme Court or the High Courts. The prescription of fee falls under Entry 96 of that List. Entry 44 of List III enables legislation with regard to its levy but the rates of the stamp duty can be prescribed by the Parliament only with regard to instruments falling within Entry 96 of List I and by the State Legislature under Entry 63 of List II.

    17. In the instant case, Entry 63 of List II of Seventh Schedule of Constitution is attracted and not the other lists, List I or III. Thus, In our considered opinion, State Legislature has the competence not only to prescribe the rate but the basis also. The decision rather counters the submission espoused by the petitioners.

    18. Reliance has also been placed on a decision of the Apex Court in Bidhannager (Salt Lake) Welfare Association v. Central Valuation Board (2007 AIR SCW 3962) in which general valuation prepared without giving opportunity of hearing to residents by appointing Surveyor in view of proviso to Section 9 (as added by Amendment Act of 1994) and exorbitant increase in tax on public ranging from 39.5 times to 1.4 times was held to be violative of Article 14 being arbitrary. The Apex Court considered the study and held that such an unscientific study may produce a disastrous result and such exorbitant increase in the tax on the public was held to be arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. Excess increase in the tax burden on the public is surely not for the public welfare. The Apex Court has laid down thus,—

    “18. The result of such an unscientific study may produce a disastrous result and in fact from the pattern of increase in demands by the Bidhangar Municipality it appears that the increase in the valuation ranges from 3954%, i.e 39.5 times to 137%, i.e, 1.4 times. Such exorbitant increase in the tax on the public is, in our opinion, itself indicative of arbitrariness, and hence, violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. In a democracy, the people are supreme, and all authorities must function for the public welfare. Excessive increase in the tax burden on the public is surely not for the public welfare. Also, in the aforementioned context, in our opinion, the very method applied by the Municipality and the Central Valuation Board must be held to be arbitrary in nature and hence violative of the Constitution. In Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India ((1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597), it was held that arbitrariness may be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.”

    19. However the instant case is not a case based on unscientific study nor it can be said that there is excessive increase of stamp duty burden, increase is not shown to be arbitrary. It is open to the Legislature to fix rates and basis and legislate provision in question.

    20. Reference has also been made on a decision of the Apex Court in Satheedevi v. Prasanna (AIR 2010 SCW 3754) in which the Apex Court has laid down the rule of interpretation of Statutes that words used in material provisions of Statute must be interpreted in their plain grammatical meaning. Question of giving effect to policy or object of Act can legitimately arise only when such words are capable of two constructions. It is not for the court to rewrite, recast or reframe legislation because it has no power to do so. Court cannot correct defect or supply omission in a Statute. The Apex Court has further observed in the context of Kerala Court-Fees and Suit Valuation Act - Section 40 and Section 7 with respect to levy of the court fees, that value of property for which document was executed, and not, its market value, is relevant for purpose of Court fee. The Apex Court has noted the difference in various provisions and has observed that if the provision of Section 7(1) is considered, there is a clear departure from the one contained in Section 7 read with Ss. 25, 27, 29, 30, 37, 38, 45 and 48 which provide for payment of court fee on the market value of the property. In that sense, Section 40 contains a special rule. The Apex Court has held that in view of Section 40(1) of the said Act, in a suit filed for cancellation of a document which creates any right, title or interest in immovable property, the Court fees is required to be computed on the value of the property for which the document was executed and not on the basis of market value which was not relevant for the purpose of payment of Court fees.

    21. In the instant case, applying the aforesaid rule of interpretation, the language of Article 35 is clear, the basis of market value as well as the rate are clear and that is similar to that of conveyance. Such a provision could have been enacted. Thus, we are not inclined to strike down the same. We cannot do rewriting, recast or reframing of the legislation, the courts have no power to do as laid down in the aforesaid decision.

    22. Reliance has also been placed on a decision of this Court in Bajaj Hindustan Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan (AIR 1997 Raj. 262 : RLW 1997 (2) Raj. 891) wherein Division Bench of this Court considered the provision of Section 3 of the Stamp Act as applicable to Rajasthan and observed that determination and evaluation of properties mentioned in sale deeds submitted for registration, valuation is to be made on basis of what was sought to be really conveyed through deeds presented only to be looked into and no fishing exploration is to be made as to what other articles/items were sought to be conveyed without there being any specific mention thereof in documents. In our opinion, the provision in question in the instant case is altogether different. Consequently, the said ratio is not attracted in the instant case.

    23. Shri G.S Bapna, learned Advocate General has relied upon decision in Khandige Sham Bhat & K. Krishna Bhatta v. Agricultural Income Tax Officer, Kasaragod (AIR 1963 SC 591). The Apex Court has observed that taxation statute shall not also be arbitrary and oppressive, but at the same time the Court cannot, for obvious reasons, meticulously scrutinize the impact of its burden on different persons or interests. Where there is more than one method of assessing tax and the Legislature selects one out of them, the Court will not be justified to strike down the law on the ground that the Legislature should have adopted another method which, in the opinion of the Court, is more reasonable, unless it is convinced that the method adopted is capricious fanciful, arbitrary or clearly unjust.

    24. The criteria prescribed by substituting the provision of Article 35(a)(iii) is not shown to be capricious, fanciful, arbitrary or unjust. Thus, in the instant case, we are not inclined to make any interference to strike down the provision in question.

    25. Reliance has also been placed on a decision of Apex Court in Government of Andhra Pradesh v. P. Laxmi Devi (Smt.), (2008) 4 SCC 720) in which the Apex Court has laid down that a court can declare a statute to be unconstitutional only when there can be no manner of doubt that it is flagrantly unconstitutional, and there is no way of avoiding such decision. Full and free play must be permitted to that wide margin of considerations which address themselves only to the practical judgement of a legislative body.

    26. The Apex Court in P.M Ashwathanarayana Setty v. State of Karnataka (1989 Supp (1) SCC 696) has laid down that the question whether the measure of a tax or a fee should be ad valorem or ad quantum is again a matter of fiscal policy.

    27. We are not inclined to make any interference. It is settled proposition of law that in the matter of fiscal policy, the basis and rate for levying of stamp duty are prescribed in questioned provision and in such provision for levying of stamp duty, the Court has to be reluctant to make an interference. We find no arbitrariness nor the provision can be termed to be capricious, illegal.

    28. Reliance has also been placed on decision of the Apex Court in Avinder Singh v. State of Punjab, (1979) 1 SCC 137) in which the Apex Court has observed that State is allowed to pick and choose districts, objects, persons, methods and even rates for taxation if it does so reasonably. The Court has to be practical and has permitted a very wide latitude in classification for taxation. In our opinion, the classification made under Article 35 for longer duration leases beyond 20 years or in perpetuity cannot be said to be arbitrary or unreasonable. The Apex Court in Avinder Singh (supra) has laid down thus,-

    29. In R.V Infrastructure Engineers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of M.P (ILR (2010) M.P 608, the decision of J.K Jute Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh (AIR 1961 SC 1534) came up for consideration before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. A Division Bench has observed thus,—

    “Learned senior counsel has also submitted that the instrument should be liable to the stamp duty in fact only then it can be imposed not otherwise. Under the law stamp duty cannot be imposed on a transaction which is not a lease. He has also relied upon decision of Apex Court in J.K Jute Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1961 SC 1534 wherein Entry 54 in List 2 of 7th Schedule of the Constitution came for consideration which confers on the State authority to enact a law with respect to tax on sale of goods. Considering what is the extent of that authority?, there must be infact a sale as recognized by law, it is only then that a tax could be imposed. But, if the transaction sought to be taxed is not a sale, a law which seeks to tax it, treating it as a sale will be ultra vires. There is no dispute with the aforesaid proposition. In the instant case, the transaction has been found to be a lease, thus, there is no question of Schedule 1-A Entry 33 as amended in MP being ultra vires as the transaction is covered within the ambit of lease as defined in Section 105 of T.P Act read with Section 2(16)(c) of Indian Stamp Act.”

    30. In the instant case also, we have found that transaction is a lease. There is no dispute that transaction is that of lease, only rate and basis has been prescribed under Article 35 of the lease in question on the basis of market value of the property and the rate of stamp duty is that of conveyance, which is permissible.

    31. The submission that amendment was for year 1997 is misconceived. We find that provision is not confined for fiscal year 1997. Amendment was not for temporary duration. Submission is baseless and stated simply to be rejected.

    32. We find no legislative incompetence in the provision of Article 35(a)(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Rajasthan Stamp Act which has been substituted in 1997 neither it is arbitrary.

    33. In view of the aforesaid, we find that the provision as substituted by Rajasthan Stamp Act, 1952 in Article 35(a)(iii) is intra vires. The writ petitions being devoid of merits, deserve dismissal. They are hereby dismissed. Stay applications are also dismissed. Parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. State & Ors.
    (Jul 12, 2011)