Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Sections 161 and 165 IPC.
  • Section 165 IPC and Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Sections 161 and 165 IPC.
  • Section 165 IPC and Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C,
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: A.S. Nehra, J. — Appeal by Hari Kishan

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the conviction and sentence dated 8.5.1987/13.5.1987 by the Special Judge, Jind, which convicted Hari Kishan (appellant) under Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Sections 161 and 165 IPC. The trial court sentenced the appellant to imprisonment and a fine; substantive sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

The prosecution case, as presented at trial, was that Birja Nand (deceased 1983) left behind heirs including Daya Singh (PW‑5). On 19.6.1986 an entry (report) was made in the Patwari's roznamcha and mutation No. 618 was recorded. That mutation was put up to the Tehsildar on 30.9.1986 and kept pending. On 27.10.1986 Daya Singh and Mithu (PW‑7) went to the appellant seeking mutation; the appellant allegedly demanded Rs. 100 as bribe. Daya Singh reported the matter to the State Vigilance Bureau. A trap was arranged by Inspector Brij Kishore (Investigating Officer / PW‑9): a Rs. 100 currency note treated with phenolphthalein was handed to Daya Singh, who delivered it to the appellant; the raiding party recovered the treated note from the appellant's shirt pocket, and handwash, the note, pocket and shirt produced positive chemical reactions. Samples were sealed and one nip each sent to the Chemical Examiner. The prosecution also produced mutation records and the sanction for prosecution signed by the Deputy Commissioner.

At trial the appellant, in his Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement, admitted his posting as Patwari and making the roznamcha entry but denied the remaining incriminating circumstances. The trial court convicted; on appeal the High Court examined whether conviction could be sustained.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the testimony of trap witnesses (the complainant who handed over the treated currency note and the shadow/spot witness) can, without independent corroboration, sustain a conviction under Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Sections 161 and 165 IPC.
  2. Whether the prosecution's failure to produce or withholding of an identified independent witness affected the sufficiency of evidence to prove demand and acceptance of a bribe.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. H.S. Gill, Senior Advocate)

  • To convict under the Prevention of Corruption Act, the prosecution must establish both demand of a bribe and acceptance in pursuance of that demand.
  • Evidence of the trap witnesses (the complainant and the shadow witness) alone is insufficient; because they are interested in the success of the trap, their testimony must be independently corroborated before it can form the basis of conviction.
  • The prosecution withheld an independent witness (identified in the judgment as "Sh. Birja Nand, District Revenue Officer"), and therefore denied the defence the independent corroboration required by law.
  • The appellant relied on authorities (including Darshan Lal v. Delhi Administration, B.C. Goswami, Prem Kumar, Mohinder Singh and Gurmej Singh) to support the proposition that trap witness evidence without independent corroboration cannot safely sustain conviction.

Prosecution's Case (as presented at trial)

  • The prosecution relied on the complainant Daya Singh (PW‑5) and the shadow witness Mithu (PW‑7) who participated in the trap and testified to the demand and acceptance of Rs. 100 by the appellant.
  • The investigating officer (Inspector Brij Kishore, PW‑9) organized and conducted the trap: he had the note treated with phenolphthalein, demonstrated the test, directed the signal and recovery procedure, and recovered the treated note from the appellant's shirt pocket.
  • Chemical demonstrations and handwash/pocket/shirt tests turned pink on application of the reagent and sealed samples were sent to the Chemical Examiner; seizure memos and recovery memos were produced in evidence.
  • Revenue records and the mutation (No. 618) and sanction for prosecution (Ex. PB) were produced to establish the appellant's official position and the institutional context of the alleged demand.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Darshan Lal v. Delhi Administration (1974) Chandigarh Law Reporter 611 Trap witnesses are interested and the court should require independent corroboration of their statements before convicting. The Court applied this principle to hold that trap witness evidence without independent corroboration could not safely sustain the conviction in the present case.
Prem Kumar v. State of Punjab (1976) Chandigarh Law Reporter (Punjab & Haryana) 366 No implicit reliance can be placed on testimony of trap witnesses; independent and trustworthy corroboration is required. The Court relied on this authority to support the requirement of independent corroboration and concluded the requirement was not met here.
Ram Parkash Arora v. The State of Punjab (1972) 3 SCC 652; AIR 1973 SC 498 Interest and partisanship of bribe-giver and shadow witness must be recognized; court may look for independent corroboration before convicting. The Court quoted the passage underscoring the need to test trap witnesses and used it to justify seeking independent corroboration, which was absent.
B.C. Goswami v. Delhi Administration (1974) 3 SCC 85; AIR 1973 SC 1457 This precedent was cited in submissions; the opinion does not elaborate the specific principle from this case. The case was cited by counsel; the judgment does not record a distinct application beyond reliance in submissions.
Mohinder Singh v. State of Punjab (1990) 2 Recent Criminal Reports 371 This precedent was cited in submissions; the opinion does not state its particular rule or principle. Cited by counsel; the Court's decision rests primarily on other authorities explicitly discussed.
Gurmej Singh v. State of Punjab (1987) 2 Recent Criminal Reports 296 This precedent was cited in submissions; the opinion does not set out the specific proposition from it. Cited by counsel; the Court's reasoning and conclusion are based on the requirement of independent corroboration as drawn from other cited authorities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the evidence and applicable principles relating to trap cases. It emphasized established authority that witnesses involved in a trap (notably the bribe-giver and the shadow witness) are interested and partisan; consequently their testimony requires independent corroboration before it can serve as the sole basis for conviction. The judgment explicitly refers to and applies the reasoning in Darshan Lal, Prem Kumar and Ram Parkash Arora to underline this legal requirement.

On the facts, the Court noted the following:

  • The prosecution relied primarily on the testimony of the complainant Daya Singh (PW‑5) and shadow witness Mithu (PW‑7), the trap arranged and executed by Inspector Brij Kishore (PW‑9), the phenolphthalein tests and subsequent recoveries and seizures.
  • The prosecution produced mutation records and sanction for prosecution to establish the official context and the appellant's posting as Patwari.
  • Crucially, the Court found that an "independent witness" identified in the opinion as "Sh. Birja Nand, District Revenue Officer" had been withheld by the prosecution. The Court treated this withholding as material to the question of independent corroboration.
  • Because the alleged demand and acceptance of the bribe were not supported by independent evidence beyond the trap witnesses, the Court concluded that the requirements of law regarding corroboration in trap cases were not satisfied.

Relying on the cited authorities and the factual finding that independent corroboration was absent (and an independent witness was not produced), the Court concluded that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of doubt.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeal allowed; conviction and sentence of the appellant are set aside and he is hereby acquitted.

Consequences and implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The appellant's conviction and sentence were quashed and he was acquitted. The judgment directs that any fine paid by him be refunded.
  • The Court's disposition was based on application of established principles concerning the need for independent corroboration in trap cases; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle or broader precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts before it.
Appeal allowed.

If specific procedural documents or additional arguments were referenced in the original opinion but not detailed in the text excerpt provided, those specifics are not reproduced here because they were not explicitly set out in the supplied opinion.

    Hari Kishan v. State Of Haryana .

    A.S Nehra, J.:— This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 8.5.1987/13,5.1987 passed by the Special Judge, Jind, by which Hari Kishan, appellant has been convicted under Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act read with Sections 161 and 165 IPC. He was sentenced to undergo R.I for one year and to pay a fine of Rs. 1000/- and in default of payment of fine, to undergo further R.I for 3 months under Section 161 IPC and R.I for one year each under Section 165 IPC and Section 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The substantive sentences awarded to the appellant, however, were ordered to run concurrently.

    2. Briefly stated, the prosecution case is that one Birja Nand of village Amarheri died in 1983 leaving behind his widow Lachhmi Devi, three daughters and six sons including Hukam Singh and Daya Singh, PW-5. On 19.6.1986, Hukam Singh alongwith Hari Chand Lambardar came and lodged a report, Ex. PD, in the roznamcha of the Patwari with regard to the death of Birja Nand and for entering mutation of his estate. The Patwari entered mutation No. 618 on the basis of the said report on 19.6.1986, and it was verified by the Field Kanungo on 25.9.1986 The said mutation together with some other mutations was put up by the Patwari Hari Kishan before Mr. Des Raj Bindal, Tehsildar (PW-1) on 30.9.1986 As none from the heirs of Birja Nand deceased was present, the Tehsildar recorded their absence under his signatures on that date and mutation case was ordered to be taken up later on. On 27.10.1986, Daya Singh (PW-5) alongwith Mithu (PW-7) went to the house of the appellant at Jind and requested him to enter mutation of inheritance relating to his father. The appellant demanded a bribe of Rs. 100/- to get the mutation sanctioned. Daya Singh did not want to give the bribe and instead decided to report the matter to the Vigilance authorities. Thereafter, he alongwith Mithu (PW-7) went to the office of the State Vigilance Bureau, Jind and made a detailed statement, Ex. PE to Inspector Brij Kishore. It was signed by him in token of its correctness. After making his endorsement on the said statement, Inspector Brij Kishore sent the same through Constable Lakhmi Chand for registration of the case, on the basis whereof formal FIR, Ex. PE/1 was recorded by Inspector Norang Singh (PW-6) at 6.30 PM.

    3. Daya Singh PW-5 had also handed over one currency note of Rs. 100/- Ex. P-1 to Inspector Brij Kishore (PW-9), who after preparing memo Ex. PF and noting the serial number of the currency note, treated the said note with phenolphthalein powder and kept it aside. He then searched the person of Daya Singh (PW-5) and having found nothing else, prepared memo, Ex. PG and handed over that currency note to Daya Singh, PW-5. The Inspector then applied that very phenolphthalein powder on a piece of paper and put sodium carbonate powder in a glass containing water. When the said piece of paper was dipped in the chemical solution, the colour of the water turned pink. He then threw away that slip of paper and the water. This demonstration was carried out in presence of Daya Singh (PW-5), Mithu (PW-7), District Revenue Officer Shri Bishna Ram and Head Constable.

    4. In the morning, complainant Daya Singh went to the house of the appellant, who told him that he was going to village Ahirka and on his return from there, he would visit complainant's house at village Amarheri at about 5.00/5.15 PM. Daya Singh passed on that information to Inspector Brij Kishore (PW-9). Thereafter, Inspector Brij Kishore, accompanied by DRO Bishna Ram complainant, Daya Singh and Mithu (PW. 7) went to village Amarheri on bicycles, reaching there at about 5.30 PM. Inspector Brij Kishore directed complainant Daya Singh to hand over the treated currency note to the accused if he asked for bribe, and thereafter to give a signal to Mithu, who was to follow him at some distance, by touching his head with his hand. The signal was to be passed on by the shadow witness Mithu to the raiding party.

    5. Daya Singh went ahead of the raiding party and found the appellant sitting on a cot in the internal court-yard of his house. The appellant asked him to give him money and that he would get the work done; whereupon Daya Singh gave that currency note to the appellant who took the same in his hand and put it in the pocket of his shirt. Daya Singh then gave the pre-arranged signal, which was passed on by Mithu to the raiding party; as a result whereof Inspector Brij Kishore, DRO Bishna Ram and other members of the raiding party came there. Inspector Brij Kishore disclosed his identity and on search of the appellant, he recovered the currency note, Ex. P. 1, from the pocket of the shirt of the accused. It was found to be the same currency note which had been treated with phenolphthalein powder and handed over to Daya Singh (PW-5) by the Inspector. The appellant was made to dip his hand in a solution. The handwash turned pink. In was put into two nips which were then sealed. One of those nips was sent to the Chemical Examiner.

    6. Similarly, the currency note, Ex. P. 1, was also dipped in another solution of water. The same turned pink. The water which turned pink, was also transferred in two other nips, and one such nip was sent to the Chemical Examiner. In a similar manner, the pocket of the shirt of the appellant from which the currency note had been recovered, was also dipped in fresh solution of water. The colour of the water turned pink and so was the pocket of the shirt. The solution was transferred into two nips and sealed. One of the nips was sent to the Chemical Examiner and the shirt of the appellant Ex. P. 5, was also taken into possession vide recovery memo. Ex. PK. The seal after use was handed over to Mithu PW. Supplementary statements of Daya Singh and Mithu were also recorded.

    7. At the trial, the prosecution produced the original roznamcha containing original report No. 359 dated 19.6.1986, Ex. PD, made by the appellant with regard to the estate of Birja Nand on the basis of the statement of Hari Chand Lambardar, Amarheri. The appellant did not dispute that the said report was made by him in his hand. Mutation No. 618, Ex. PA, was entered on the basis of the said report on the same day and it was verified by Field Kanungo on 25.9.1986 It was put up before Mr. Des Raj Bindal, Tehsildar, PW. 1, on 30.9.1986 at Jind alongwith some other mutations. Mr. Desraj Bindal (PW. 1) stated that while he sanctioned some other mutations, none appeared in connection with mutation No. 618 and, therefore, he noted the words “gair hazir” under his initials and dated the order as 30.9.1986 The mutation was, thus, pending on 27.10.1986, the date of occurrence. It was ultimately sanctioned by the Tehsildar on 30.12.1986 as deposed by Kundan Lal, Patwari (PW-2). Desraj Bindal Tehsildar (PW-1) stated that it was not an invariable rule to go to the village concerned for attestation of the mutation. In fact, mutations relating to an area within 3-4 kilometres were kept and dealt with at one place. Notice of attestation of mutation was given by the Patwari through Chowkidar. Kundan Lal, Patwari (PW-2) produced the original mutation No. 618 sanctioned on 30.12.1986 by the Tehsildar. In cross-examination he stated that mutation was sanctioned in the presence of the parties and in accordance with the tour programme made by the Revenue Officer.

    8. The prosecution also proved the sanction, Ex. PB, granted by the Deputy Commissioner, Jind, for the prosecution of the appellant. Karan Singh, clerk of the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Jind, for the prosecution of the appellant. Karan Singh, clerk of the office of the Deputy Commissioner (PW-4) stated that the investigation file was brought by Inspector Brij Kishore of S.V.B and the same was submitted to Shri Sajjan Singh, Deputy Commissioner, alongwith docket of S.V.B Hissar, and after going through the same, Shri Sajjan Singh, D.C signed the sanction order Ex. PB. Baldev Singh, Sadar Kanungo (PW-3) also identified the signatures of the Deputy Commissioner on the sanction order, Ex. PB. Baldev Singh PW-3 deposed, on the basis of the order Ex. PC, that the appellant had been posted at Ahirka Patwar Circle on 21.8.1984 and he was still working there as such on 27.10.1986, the date of incident. The appellant did not dispute that he was posted as Patwari at Ahirka Patwar Circle comprising Ahirka, Amarheri and Kair Kheri on 27.10.1986

    9. PW-8 Constable Lakhmi Chand is a formal witness who had produced his affidavit Ex. PM. The Investigating Officer had sent statement, Ex. PE of complainant Daya Singh through him; on the basis whereof he had got registered FIR Ex.PE/1 at PS Hissar at 6.30 PM. PW-9 is Inspector Brij Kishore who gave the entire version about the manner in which investigation was conducted by him. He further added that he had met Deputy Commissioner, Jind, and obtained permission for raid and had also requested him to make available some responsible officer to join the raid. The Deputy Commissioner directed Bishna Ram, D.R.O to join the raiding party. The Investigating Officer had also held a demonstration before starting for the raid and prepared memo. Ex. PH in this connection. He had also got prepared scaled site plan, Ex. PR from Devi Dayal draughts man. In his cross-examination, he stated that there was notification of the State Government empowering Inspector, State Vigilance Bureau to investigate a case under the Prevention of Corruption Act. He further stated that he had obtained permission of the Deputy Commissioner for conducting the raid at about 3.45 PM and he himself had gone to the residence of Deputy Commissioner for the purpose. The prosecution also placed on record application, Ex. PT, made by Inspector Brij Kishore to the Deputy Commissioner as also endorsement Ex. PT/1 of the D.C to the effect that the raid should be conducted in the presence of D.R.O The investigating officer further stated that solution of sodium carbonate was prepared by mixing water and sodium carbonate. He denied the suggestion that the case was fabricated one. The prosecution also tendered in evidence affidavit, Ex. PN of HC Balbir and gave up Bishna Ram, District Revenue Officer, Devi Dayal Draughtsman and also Dy. S.P Ram Chander, as un-necessary.

    10. The appellant in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C, admitted that he was posted as Patwari, Ahirka Patwar Circle comprising Ahirka, Amarheri and Kair Kheri, on 27.10.1986 and that he had entered report in the roznamcha, Ex. PD, with regard to death of Birja Nand, father of Daya Singh (PW-5) who died in 1983 leaving behind 3 killa of land at village Amarheri. He further stated that Birja Nand was survived by his widow, three daughters and six sons including Daya Singh PW-5. He further admitted that the said mutation was taken up by the Tehsildar, Jind on 30.9.1986 and the heirs of Birja Nand having failed to appear, the mutation was kept pending. He, however, denied the other facts and circumstances appearing against him in the prosecution evidence.” He also stated that under instructions of the Tehsildar, he had put up 4-5 mutations relating to village Amarheri on 30.9.1986 at Jind, adding further that notice was sent through Chowkidar to the parties concerned and that the parties had come to Tehsil office, Jind in the morning while the Tehsildar had returned from tour only at 3.00 PM, when the cases regarding mutations were put up before him. He sanctioned the mutation cases in which the parties were available. Daya Singh, however, had gone away after waiting for the Tehsildar upto 3.00 PM and the mutation in question was, thus, not sanctioned. He further stated that one of the persons, whose mutation was sanctioned that day, was Chhattar son of Jhandu, who had enquired from Daya Singh as to why his (Daya Singh's) mutation had not been sanctioned, as a result whereof Daya Singh got enraged and got the appellant falsely implicated in this case.

    11. The appellant examined four witnesses in his defence. DW-1 Arjun Dev, Steno to Deputy Commissioner, Jind, deposed that according to entry at serial No. 704 dated 27.10.1986 in the log book regarding the official car of D.C containing entries in his hand, the Deputy Commissioner had left for tour of six villages for checking girdawari at 1.30 PM and returned to Jind at 8.00 PM. In cross-examination, he stated that the Deputy Commissioner had left office for his residence at 1.00 PM and left for the tour at 1.30 PM. DW 2 Kundan Lal, Patwari, deposed on the basis of mutation register that copies of mutations, Ex. DA to DD, were attested by the Tehsildar on the dates mentioned therein. These included mutation No. 622 of Chhatar Ram son of Jhandu. He further stated that the work of appellant, Hari Kishan Patwari was commended by the Deputy Commissioner as per entries in the proceeding book dated 28.10.1985 and 22.4.1986 DW-3 Partap Singh, resident of village Ahirka, stated that Hari Kishan Patwari was maintaining a Patwarkhana in his house at village Ahirka. He further stated that he had taken that room on rent at the rate of Rs. 30/- per month. In his cross-examination, he stated that he had never issued receipt to the appellant. DW-4 Hari Chand Lainbardar, Amarheri stated that he had accompanied Hukam Singh, brother of Dayal Singh to the office of Hari Kishan, Patwari, who entered mutation and got his thumb impression on it. In cross-examination he stated that he had gone to the house of the appellant at Jind.

    12. Mr. H.S Gill, Senior Advocate, for the appellant, contended that in order to bring home the guilt to the appellant, it had to be established by the prosecution that the appellant had demanded the bribe from complainant Daya Singh (PW-5) and had accepted the same in pursuance of the said demand. He further contended that to prove these ingredients, merely the statement of complainant Daya Singh (PW-5) or the trap witness Mithu (PW-7) cannot be relied upon without independent corroboration. He further contended that the solitary independent witness Birja Nand, District Revenue Officer, was not examined by the prosecution and, therefore, the appellant was entitled to be acquitted. In support of his argument, he relied upon ‘Darshan Lal v. Delhi Administration ’, 1974 (2) Chandigarh Law Reporter 611, B.C Goswami v. Delhi Administration, (1974) 3 SCC 85 : AIR 1973 (SC) 1457, ‘Prem Kumar v. State of Punjab’, 1976 Chandigarh Law Reporter (Punjab & Haryana) 366, Mohinder Singh v. State of Punjab, 1990 (2) Recent Criminal Reports 371 and Gurmej Singh v. State of Punjab, 1987 (2) Recent Criminal Reports 296.

    13. In Darshan Lal v. Delhi Administration (supra) it was held that trap witnesses in a case under Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, being interested in the success of the trap, the Court should require independent corroboration of their statements before convicting the accused. In Prem Kumar v. State of Punjab (supra), it has been held that no implicit reliance can be placed on the testimony or trap witnesses in the absence of independent corroboration. Trap witnesses are interested and partisan witnesses and on that count they spring from a tainted source. It was further held that unless there is independent and trust-worthy corroboration of the evidence of all these prosecution witnesses, the same could not form basis for conviction of the accused. In Ram Parkash Arora v. The State of Punjab, (1972) 3 SCC 652 : AIR 1973 SC 498 it has been held by the Apex Court as under:—

    “It must be remembered that both Joginder Singh (bribe giver) and Dalbir Singh (shadow witness) P.Ws were interested and partisan witnesses. They were concerned in the success of the trap and their evidence must be tested in the same way as that of any other interested witness and in a proper case the court may look for independent corroboration before convicting the accused person.”

    14. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, I hold that in the present case afore-mentioned requirements of law have not been satisfied. The independent witness, Sh. Birja Nand, District Revenue Officer, has been withheld by the prosecution.

    15. Thus, the alleged demand of bribe and acceptance thereof by the appellant is not supported by any independent evidence and as such, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt in view of the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in the Darshan Lai's case (supra).

    16. In the net result, this appeal is allowed, conviction and sentence of the appellant are set aside and he is hereby acquitted. The fine, if already paid by him be refunded.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hari Kishan v. State Of Haryana .
    (Jan 30, 1997)