Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerns the construction of a will (Ex. A) involving the property rights of Kunjammal, the sixth defendant and mother of the plaintiff. The District Munsiff of Palghat initially held that Kunjammal had an absolute interest in the property, resulting in dismissal of the plaintiff's suit for lack of cause of action. On appeal, the Subordinate Judge construed the will as conferring joint rights in the property to Kunjammal and her children (the plaintiff and seventh defendant) after the death of their mother, the testator's widow. The appeal was allowed and the suit was remanded for fresh disposal pending inquiries into the validity of alienations and other factual matters.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the proper construction of the will regarding the interest granted to Kunjammal and her children?
  2. Whether the bequest to Kunjammal’s children is valid under Section 113 of the Indian Succession Act.
  3. Whether the widow’s interest in the property is a life estate under English law or a widow’s estate under Hindu law.
  4. Whether the reference to Kunjammal’s "issues" confers an absolute estate to her or an immediate interest to her children.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The document marked as Ex. A is not a will but a settlement conferring rights on the testator's wife even during his lifetime, relying on language that the testator and his wife should keep possession and enjoy the properties during their lives.
  • Under Section 113 of the Indian Succession Act, a bequest to the children of Kunjammal would be void as it involves a transfer to unborn persons without the whole remaining interest.

Court's Observations on Arguments

  • The court rejected the contention that the document was not a will, interpreting the language about enjoyment by the testator and his wife as a natural condition, not a settlement conferring immediate rights.
  • The court found no reason why Section 113 would void the bequest to the children, noting that the provision applies where the interest does not comprise the whole remaining interest, and multiple prior life interests do not invalidate such bequests.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Viswanadhan v. Anjaneyalu, A.I.R. 1935 Mad. 865 Application of general principles of the Succession Act to Hindu wills. Supported the principle that Hindu wills should ordinarily be interpreted using general succession principles unless a contrary intention appears.
Krishnadoss v. Dwarkadas, AIR 1936 Bom 459 Consideration of ordinary Hindu notions and wishes regarding property devolution in will construction. Distinguished on facts; involved specific living children, unlike the present case, and was used to argue against joint gift interpretation.
Madhavarao Ganpatrao v. Balabhai Raghunath Observation on disregarding technical English legal meanings in Hindu wills. Not directly applicable to the question but cited for the principle that technical English legal meanings should not override the testator’s intention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the will’s language and rejected the appellant’s argument that the document was a settlement rather than a will. It interpreted the testator’s words about enjoyment by himself and his wife as a natural life interest rather than conferring immediate possession. The court examined Section 113 of the Indian Succession Act and found no reason to void the bequest to Kunjammal’s children, as the law permits multiple prior life interests without invalidating subsequent bequests to unborn persons. The nature of the widow’s interest was left open, with the District Munsiff presuming a widow’s estate under Hindu law, and the Subordinate Judge not addressing the issue.

Applying Section 97 of the Succession Act, the court held that unless a contrary intention appears, a bequest to a person with descriptive words referring to a class (such as "issues") vests the entire interest in that person absolutely. The court found that the testator intended Kunjammal to have an absolute right after the life interest of the widow, rejecting the Subordinate Judge’s view of a joint gift to Kunjammal and her children. The court distinguished the Krishnadoss case, noting the presence of living children there, unlike the present case.

Consequently, since Kunjammal is still alive, the plaintiff has no cause of action to claim a share of the property. The plaintiff could seek a declaration that alienations were not binding, but the court declined to grant such relief under the circumstances.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision was to allow the appeal, set aside the order of the lower appellate court, and dismiss the suit.

DISPOSED OF

The direct effect is that Kunjammal holds an absolute interest in the property after the life interest of the widow, and the plaintiff does not have a cause of action to claim a share during Kunjammal’s lifetime. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles of will construction under the Indian Succession Act and Hindu law.

    Damodara Moothan v. Ammu Amma, And Others

    JUDGMENT

    Horwill, J.

    1. The question that arises in this appeal is with regard to the construction of a will which has been marked as Ex. A. It was held by the District Munsiff of Palghat, who tried the suit, that according to the will one Kunjammal, the sixth defendant and mother of the plaintiff, had an absolute interest and that therefore the plaintiff had no cause of action. He therefore dismissed the suit. In appeal, the learned Subordinate Judge construed the will as conferring upon the sixth defendant and her children the plaintiff and the seventh defendant, joint rights in the property after the death of their mother, the widow of the testator. He therefore allowed the appeal and remanded the suit for fresh disposal, because the disposal of the suit then depended upon the result of certain inquiries as to the binding nature of the alienations and other matters.

    2. After the testator had expressed his regret that he had no male issue and had only a young daughter often years of age, he said that the aforesaid Kunjammal (6th defendant), born to me by my wife Paru, becomes entitled to all my properties and the proceeds thereof. He then goes on to say that he would manage the property for the remainder of his life, that he and his wife during their lifetime should enjoy the property, and that after they were both dead their property...'' should be enjoyed by the daughter Kunjammal and the issues that might be born to her. Mr. Krishna Variar, who appears for the appellant, first contends that this document is not a will at all, but is merely a settlement conferring upon his wife rights even during his lifetime; and he relies on the words, It is settled, however, that till the end of my life and that of my wife, we ourselves should keep in possession and enjoy the properties in any manner we like. The document is, however, described as a will; and I do not think that the testator meant anything more than that his daughter should not come into possession of the property as long as his widow was alive. The reference to enjoyment by himself and his wife was a reference to a natural state of affairs, wherein the wife, equally with the husband, enjoys the income from the husband's property. This recital was intended to emphasise the fact that after the death of one of them the other should continue to enjoy the property.

    3. Another preliminary argument of Mr. Krishna Variar is that under Section 113 of the Indian Succession Act, a bequest to the children of Kunjammal would be void; but I see no reason why it should be. Section 113 of the Indian Succession Act, and the corresponding Section 13 of the Transfer of Property Act, make void a bequest or a transfer to a person unborn at the time of the bequest or transfer if the interest does not comprise the whole of the remaining interest in the testator or transferor. I see no reason why a reference to a prior bequest or a prior transfer excludes the idea of more than one prior bequest or transfer. The illustrations given in the text beneath these sections do not indicate that when there are two or more prior life interests the bequest or transfer would be void even if it comprised the whole of the interest of the testator.

    4. An incidental question which might under certain circumstances have had some importance was whether the widow had merely a life estate as known to English law or a widow's estate, which is the common form of enjoyment by a woman under Hindu law. The District Munsiff was of opinion that it must be presumed that the widow was intended to have a woman's estate. The Subordinate Judge does not discuss that question; and presumably left it open for future consideration after the District Munsiff had considered the various issues of fact that arose in the suit.

    5. The question is whether Kunjammal obtained the property absolutely, the reference to her issues being merely a customary form for the conferring of an absolute estate, or whether it was meant that the issue should at once have some indefeasible interest in the property. Section 97 of the Succession Act says that Where property is bequeathed to a person, and words are added which describe a class of persons but do not denote them as direct objects of a distinct and independent gift, such person is entitled to the whole interest of the testator therein, unless a contrary intention appears by the will. This section does not apply directly to wills by Hindus; but it lays down a general principle of interpretation of wills which could equally be applied to a will by a Hindu, though if the clear intention of the testator appeared otherwise the section should not be applied. Pandrang Row, J., in Viswanadhan v. Anjaneyalu A.I.R. 1935 Mad. 865 relied on by the learned Subordinate Judge, holds that the general principles laid down in the Succession Act should ordinarily be applied to Hindu wills. The use of the words such as santhathi --as used here--is a common way of expressing the intention of a testator that the property should be enjoyed absolutely by the person to whom the property is bequeathed. This much is conceded by the learned Subordinate Judge by reference to a number of cases in which that word has been held to imply succession or heirship; but he relies on two cases which he considers point to a different interpretation; One is a case by a single Judge of the Bombay High Court in Krishnadoss v. Dwarkadas AIR 1936 Bom 459 who said that in construing Hindu wills it is not improper to take into consideration what are known to be ordinary notions and wishes of Hindus with respect to the devolution of property. That is very true. But in the case that he was considering there was a bequest to a person and his sons and daughter. The conventional expression was not there used. There is no mention of Tulsidas and his children or his issue in a general way but specifically to his sons and daughter, in the singular. It seemed in that case that the testator had in mind not a general class of persons but specific sons and a specific daughter that were living at the time when he drew up the will and that he intended that they equally and jointly with their father Tulsidas should enjoy the property. The learned Subordinate Judge also refers to a decision of the Privy Council in Madhavarao Ganpatrao v. Balabhai Raghunath but the question we are considering did not arise there at all. Perhaps the learned Judge quoted that case more for an observation of Lord Buckmaster contained therein that the technical meaning given to words in English law should there be disregarded; but it cannot be considered as an authority for ignoring the principle found in Section 97 of the Succession Act. It is perhaps correct to say, as the learned Judge has, that the use of the words santhanam and santhanamgal' has not the same rigidity as the words and his issues in English and does not exclude the possibility that the testator intended to benefit them as individuals. An earlier part of the will confirms the view that one would take from a strict interpretation of Section 97; because the testator there said that as he had no male child and only a minor female child named Kunjammal and that it appeared that his wife was incapable of further child bearing, Therefore the aforesaid Kunjammal, born to me by my wife Paru, becomes entitled to all my properties and proceeds thereof. He seems therefore not to be considering the possibility of enjoyment of the property by anybody but his daughter Kunjammal. I think, therefore, that the learned District Munsiff was right in holding that after the life interest of the widow there was an absolute right to Kunjammal.

    6. Even if Ex. A be so interpreted as to give an interest to the children of Kunjammal, it could be only after her lifetime. I cannot interpret the will in the way that the learned Subordinate Judge has, as a joint gift to Kunjammal and such children as might be alive when she came to enjoy the property. In the Bombay case Krishnadoss v. Dwarkadoss A.I.R. 1936 Mad. 459 quoted by the learned Judge it is obvious that the sons and a daughter were living at the time when the will was drawn up and that that was one of the reasons why the learned Judge construed the will as one in favour of all of them jointly. If the bequest in this case was not to Kunjammal absolutely, then there could be little doubt that she was to enjoy for her life and her children after her. As Kunjammal is still alive, the plaintiff would have no cause of action to sue for a share of the property. She would be entitled to ask for a declaration that the alienations were not binding on her; but I do not think, in the circumstances of this case, whatever the facts might prove to be, that that declaration should be granted.

    7. In any view of the matter, therefore, the suit must fail. The appeal is allowed with costs throughout and the order of the lower appellate Court set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Damodara Moothan v. Ammu Amma, And Others
    (Jul 19, 1943)