Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Salaries Act, 1971.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Salaries Act, 1971.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was filed by primary section teachers of Sri Alpeshwarnath Sanskrit Maha Vidyalaya seeking a mandamus directing respondents to pay their salaries in regular grade from 1-10-1989 along with other consequential benefits. The institution is a recognised Sanskrit educational establishment providing education from primary level to graduate level, affiliated with Sampurnanand Shastri University, Varanasi. While teachers from Junior High School level upwards are paid salaries through State funds, the primary section teachers, including the petitioners, receive salaries only from the institution's private resources, supplemented by nominal State compensation grants which are insufficient. The petitioners have been teaching since 1972-73 and contend that they have been discriminated against compared to other teachers who receive State-paid salaries. Despite representations to authorities, no relief was granted, prompting this writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the refusal to pay primary section Sanskrit teachers salaries through State funds constitutes a violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India by discriminating against them vis-à-vis other teachers in the institution and other primary school teachers.
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to salary and other benefits on par with primary section teachers in other recognised institutions as per the Government Orders referenced.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners are paid a nominal salary of Rs. 250/- per month, which is grossly inadequate and insulting considering their long service and the cultural importance of Sanskrit.
  • The State Government pays salaries to teachers from Junior High School level upwards but excludes primary section Sanskrit teachers, resulting in unjustified discrimination.
  • Government Orders dated 6-9-1989 and 28-2-1990 provide for payment of salaries to primary section teachers in other institutions, but the petitioners' institution has not been accorded the same benefit.
  • Despite representations, no action has been taken to remedy the discrimination.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents stated in their counter affidavit that the petitioners' demand relates to State policy.
  • No substantive justification was offered for the discrimination or the refusal to pay salaries through State funds.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court found that the refusal to pay salaries to primary section Sanskrit teachers through State funds violated Article 14 of the Constitution, which guarantees equality before law and prohibits arbitrary discrimination. The court identified two grounds of discrimination: first, teachers from Junior High School level upwards in the same institution receive State-paid salaries while primary section teachers do not, lacking any rational basis; second, primary section Sanskrit teachers are discriminated against compared to primary section teachers in other institutions who receive State salaries.

The court emphasized the cultural and intellectual significance of Sanskrit as a classical language of India, highlighting its historical contributions to philosophy, science, literature, and law. It lamented the neglect and disrespect shown towards Sanskrit and its teachers, deeming the nominal salary an insult to the language and its heritage.

Rejecting the respondents' plea that the matter was one of State policy, the court held that no policy can override constitutional guarantees, particularly the right to equality under Article 14. The court drew from historical and cultural speeches and constitutional references to underscore Sanskrit’s importance and the necessity of supporting its teachers adequately.

Ultimately, the court directed the respondents to pay salaries to primary section Sanskrit teachers through State funds on the same scale and with the same benefits as primary section teachers in other recognised institutions, including group insurance, provident fund, and retirement benefits.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed and a mandamus is issued directing the respondents to pay salaries and provide consequential benefits to primary section Sanskrit teachers through the State Government on par with other primary section teachers.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioners and similarly situated primary section Sanskrit teachers will receive regular salaries and associated benefits from the State, eliminating the discriminatory treatment they faced. The opinion does not establish a broader precedent beyond the immediate relief granted but underscores constitutional equality principles in the context of educational employment and cultural respect for Sanskrit.

    Ramesh Upadhya And Others v. State Of U.P And Others

    M. Katju, J.:— This writ petition has been filed with a prayer for mandamus directing the respondents to pay salary to the petitioners in regular grade with effect from 1-10-1989 and to provide other consequential benefits to the petitioners. The petitioners are teachers of the primary section of Sri Alpeshwarnath Sanskrit Maha Vidyalaya, Janewar, Fatehganj, Jaunpur which is a recognised Sanskrit Institution imparting education for the Primary Section, Junior High School, Purva Madhyama (High School), Uttar Madhyama (Intermediate) and Shastri (B.A) section. The Maha Vidyalaya is thus imparting education from Class I upto graduate level and it is a recognised institution affiliated to Sampurnanand Shastri University, Varanasi. The teachers of the institution teaching in the Junior High School Section, High School, Intermediate and Bachelor of Arts Section are paid salary through State funds i.e, by the State Government. It is only teachers teaching in the primary section (such as the petitioners) who are not paid salary through State funds, and they are paid salary through the private resources of the institution is on the maintenance grant in-aid list of the State Government. The primary section of the institution has been duly approved by the District Inspector of Schools, Jaunpur on 23-4-1958. In this connection the certificate of the District Inspector of Schools, Jaunpur dated 17-3-1971 is Annexure-2 to the petition. The certificate of the Banaras Sanskrit Vishwa Vidyalaya stating that the institution is recognised upto B.A level (Shastri) is Annexure-3 to the petition.

    2. The petitioners who are teaching in the primary section are getting salary of only Rs. 250/- per month as is evident from the certificate of the Manager dated 2-7-1990 (Annexure-4 to the petition). The State does not pay salary to the teachers of the primary section but is only gives some nominal compensation as is evident from Annexures-5 and 6. This compensation as clearly not sufficient to pay adequate salary to the teachers of the primary section. For example in the petitioners' institution the compensation grant for the year 1986-1987 was Rs. 2,844/-, for the year 1987-1988 was Rs. 2,914/- and for 1988-1989 was again Rs. 2,914/-. Learned counsel for the petitioners could not tell me whether there are any other teachers in the primary section apart from the two petitioners, but even if there are no other such teachers the compensation would give the petitioner about only Rs. 125/- per month, which in these hand days of inflation is next to nothing. The petitioners have been teaching since 1972-1973 i.e, for 20 years. Sanskrit is a great language of this country and to pay a salary of Rs. 250/- per month to a Sanskrit teacher is an intolerable insult to a great language and the teachers of such a great language. In this connection it has been stated in Paragraph 10 of the writ petition that by a government order dated 6-9-1989, 339 institutions upto the level of High School and Intermediate in U.P, were approved by the State Government for payment of salary under the payment of Salaries Act, 1971. A true copy of the G.O, dated 6-9-1989 is Annexure-7 to the petition. The petitioners have stated that in these 339 institutions teachers in Primary Section are now being paid by the State Government Salaries in accordance with the G.O dated 28-2-1990 (which has prescribed the grade of Rs. 1100-1710 for high school tryined teachers and of Rs. 950-1,325 for junior high school trained teachers) but the teachers of primary sections of the Sanskrit institutions have not been given the same benefit, and thus they have been discriminated against. The petitioners made representations to the authorities as stated in Paragraph-12 of the writ petition, but to no avail.

    3. A counter affidavit has been filed. In Paragraph-4 thereof it has been stated that the demand of the petitioners is a matter of policy of the State Government. In my opinion this is no reply to the allegations of the petitioners. No policy can violate Article 14 of the Constitution. In the present case Article 14 of the Constitution has been violated since the petitioners have been discriminated against in two ways. Firstly, the teachers of the Sanskrit institutions from Junior High School level upto post graduate level are admittedly being paid salary through the State Government, and hence there is no basis for not paying the primary section teachers also through the State. Afterall, the foundation of knowledge is laid in the primary section, and if the foundation is weak the edifice built it cannot be strong. Hence there is no rational basis for discriminating against primary section teachers in the matter of salaries. Secondly, there is no good reason for discriminating against primary section teachers of Sanskrit institutions as against Primary Section Teachers of other institutions.

    4. I am constrained to say that in our country Sanskrit is hardly getting the respect it deserves. A language which was declared by that outstanding scholar, Sir William Jones, to be “more perfect than Greek, more copious than Latin, and more exquisitely refined than either” is today practically regarded as worthless, audits teachers are treated shabbily. This just ahows the level of degradation to which we have fallen.

    5. The word “Sanskrit” means “prepared, pure, refined or perfect”. It was not for nothing that it was called the “deva vani” (Language of the Gods). It has an outstanding place in our culture, and indeed was recognized as a language of care sublimity by the whole world. Sanskrit was the language of our philosophers, our scientists, our mathematicians, our poets and play-writes, our grammarians, our jurists. In grammar Panini and Patanjali (authors of Ashtadhyayi and the Mahabhashya) have no equals in the world; in astronony and mathematics the works of Aryabhatta, Brahmagupta, and Bhaskar opened up new frontiers for mankind) as did the works of Charak and Sushrit in medicine; in philosophy Gautam (founder of the Nyaya System), Ashvaghosha (author Buddha Charita), Kapila (founder of the Sankhya System), Sankaracharya, Biharrati etc. present the widest range of philosophical systems the world has ever seen. Jaimini's Mimansas Sutras laid the foundation of a whole system of rational interpretation of texts which was used not only in religion but also in law, philosophy, grammar, etc. In literature the contribution of Sanskrit is of the foremost order. The works of Kalidas (Shaknntal, Meghdoot, Molevikagnimitra, etc.). Bhavabhuti (Malti Madhav, Uttar Ramcharit, etc.) and the epics of Valmiki, Vyas, etc. are known all over the world. These, and countless other Sanskrit works, kept the light of learning ablaze in our country upto modern times.

    6. In this connection I would like to quote from the Constituent Assembly debate that took place on 12-9-1949 in our Constituent Assembly:—

    “The Hon'ble Shri Ghanshyam Singh Gupta:

    We want to hear your views on Sanskrit.

    Mr. Naziruddin Ahmed: I am extremely thankful to the Hon'ble Member, Mr. Gupta. If you have to adopt any language, why should you not have the world's greatest language? It is today a matter of great regret that we do not know with what reservation Sanskrit is held in the outside world. I shall only quote a few brief remarks made about Sanskrit to show how this language is held in the civilized world. Mr. W.C Taylor says “Sanskrit is the language of unrivalled richness and purity”.

    Mr. President: I would suggest you may leave that question above, because I propose to call representatives who have given notice of amendments of a fundamental character, and I will call upon a gentleman who has given notice about Sanskrit to speak about it.

    Mr. Naziruddin Ahmed: Yes, Sir, shall not stand in between. I will only give a few quotations. Prof. Max Muller says that Sanskrit is the “greatest language in the word, the most wonderful and the most perfect”. Sir William Jones said “whenever we direct our attention to the Sanskrit litetature the notion of infinity presents itself. Surely the longest life would not suffice for a perusal of works that rise and swell, protuberant like the Himalayas, above the bulkiest compositions of every land beyond the confines of India.” Then, Sir W. Hunter says that “the Grammar of Panini stands supreme among the grammars of the world. It stands forth as one of the most splendid achievements of human invention and industry”. Prof. Whitney says “Its unequalled transprency of structure gives it (Sanskrit) undisputable right to the first place amongst the tongues of the Indo-European family”. M. Dubois says “Sanskrit is the origin of the modern languages of Europe”. Prof. Weber says “Panini's grammar is universally admitted to be the shortest and fulfest grammar in the word”. Prof. Wilson says “No nation but the Hindu has yet been able to discover such a perfect system of phonetics”. Prof. Thompson says “The arrangement of consonants in Sanskrit is a unique example of human genius”: Dr. Shahidullah, Professor of Dacca University, who has a world wide reputation as a Sanskrit Scholar, says “Sanskrit is the language of every man to whatever race he may belong”.

    An Hon'ble Member: What is your view?

    Mr. Naziruddin Ahmed: My own view is that it is one of the greatest languages, and ……..

    An. Hon'ble Member: And should it be adopted as the National Language or not? It is not spoken by any one now.

    Mr. Naziruddin Ahmed: Yes, and for the simple reason that it is impartially difficult to all. Hindi is easy for the Hindi speaking areas, but it is difficult for other areas. I offer you a language which is the grandest and the greatest, and it is impartially difficult, equally difficult for all to learn. There should be some impartiality in the selection. If we have to adopt a language it must be grand, great and the best. Then why should we discard the claim of Sanskrit?

    Pandit Lakshmi Kant Mitra: If today India has got an opportunity to shape her own destiny I ask in all seriousness if she is going to feel ashamed to recognize the Sanskrit Language—The revered grandmother of Languages of the world, still alive with full vigour, full vitality? Are we going to deny her nightful place in Free India? That is a question which is solemnly ask. I know it will be said that it is a dead language. Yes, Dead to whom? Dead to you because you have become dead to all which is great and noble in your own culture and civilization. You have been chasing the shadow and have never tried to graps the substance which contained in your great literature. If Sanskrit is dead may I say that Sanskrit is ruling us from her grave? Nobody can get away from Sanskrit in India”.

    7. The above were some of the speeches delivered in the Constituent Assembly and though Sanskrit was not accepted as the natural language it was placed in the 8th Schedule to the Constitution, and is also referred to in Article 351.

    8. The high development of the Sanskrit language was not accidental. It took place because a vehicle of expressing highly abstract, subtle and deep thoughts was required to fulfil the intellectual needs of the educated people in India. As is well known, our ancestors were highly intelligent, and they questioned everything (like the ancient Greeks). Mathematics, Physics, Literature. Philosophy, Law etc., became highly developed in our country, and hence a correspondingly highly developed and powerful vehicle of expression was required to communicate words or thoughts with elegance, precision and exactitude, Hence the crude Sanskrit of the Vedic Literature was refined and systematized by Panini and Patanjali who made it perhaps the most highly developed of all the languages of the world.

    9. To give a simple example, the arrangement of the alphabets as given by Panini in his first fourteen sutras is so amazingly scientific that even learned men of the whole world are wonder-struck. We may contrast this with the arrangement of alphabets in the English Language (from A to Z) which is arbitrary, unsystematic and unscientific. On the other hand the arrangement of the Sanskrit alphabets is not accidental or arbitrary. It has been done on a scientific pattern, obviously after close observation of the are arranged according to the shape of the mouth when these sounds are emitted— and are pronounced from the throat, and from the palate and from the lips, etc. In the same way, consonants have been arranged in sequences on a specific pattern. The i.e, are emitted from the throat, the from the palate, the from the roof of the mouth, the from the teeth, and the from the lips. These principles are given by Panini as follow:

    10. I venture to say that no language in the world has its alphabets arranged in such a rational and systematic manner. And when we see how deeply our ancestors went in the seemingly simple matter of arranging the alphabets we can realise how deeply they went in more advanced matters.

    11. Real knowledge of Sanskrit shows that it was the language of an enquiring man which enquires into every aspect of life. It is for this reason that Sanskrit has been an excellent mode of expression and communication in all fields e.g, Literature, Philosophy, Science, etc. In philosophy Sanskrit was the language used not only by the metaphysical thinkers but also the materialist thinkers like the Nyayiks, Vasheshiks, Charvaks, etc. Thus, Sanskrit was the language of free thinkers, expressing the widest spectrum of thoughts.

    12. Later on, due to ignorance of this language, amongst the people, the vested interests made it the language of the clergy which exploited the ignorance of the people and used Sanskrit Shlokas as some sort of magical formulas. The Mantras, when translated in common language, express great thoughts (and also paltry thoughts), but there is nothing maginal in them. People in their ignorance thought that the words spoken in mantras were some sort of mumbo-jumbo which will grant them the desire of their hearts. This veil of ignorance has to be broken, and this great language rich in all fields must come to the people in its explicable forms. All aspects of our culture are indisslubly linked with it. Hence it is a national crime to treat this language with contempt by giving its primary section teachers a pittance of Rs. 250/- per month as salary. What interest in their work will such teachers take? Even a beggar may be earning more than that. Sweepers often get Rs. 700/- or more. It is equally a national crime to treat Sanskrit in a bigoted manner and regard it as a special preserve of the so-called Pandits who treat it as a source of livelihood.

    13. Today our nation requires scientific thinking and the development of science and technology. For this we have to become disciples of the West, because Modern Science is much more developed in the West than in India. Hence we have to learn English, because most of our science books are in English. However, we must not reject the goods things in our own culture. In this connection it may be mentioned that after the Russion Revolution took place in October, 1917 a School of thought known as proletcult (short for “Proletariani culture”) sprang up in Russia, of which one of the foremost proponents was the famous poet Mayakovsky. The proletcult school asserted that the entire Russian culture of the period prior to the Revolution should be rejected, since it was the culture of exploiters and oppressors. Lenin, and his education minister Lunacharsky, however, resolutely opposed the proletcult school, and proclaimed that the good part in the old culture should not be rejected, and only the bad or outdated part should be rejected. In my opinion we, too, should take a similar stand as Lenin. And one of the things in our culture which we should not reject as Sanskrit. Knowledge of Sanskrit and the great achievements of our ancestors will inspire us and give us the morale and courage to face upto our present difficulties and resolve them.

    14. In my opinion alongwith Sanskrit Urdu should also be taught for at least 5 years in our schools (say upto class 8). Urdu is also a great language of our country, and it was falsely given out to language of Muslims alone. The British wanted to divide our people, and hence they created the false propoganda that Hindi was the language of Hindus and Urdu of Muslims. In fact Urdu was the common language of the educated North Indian people, both Hindus and Muslims. The great Urdu poet like Mir, Ghalib Faiz, Firaq and Josh were thoroughly secular, and their poetry is of the highest order. Today our young generation is thoroughly deculturized, cymical, and lacking in all moorings. They are ignorant of two great languages of India, Sanskrit and Urdu. Hence if they are thought these languages for at least 5 years in schools it will provide the young generation at least a rudimentary knowledge of these great languages (which can later be increased by their own effort), and thus acquaint them with their own culture. This will also blunt the effort of the fundamentalist (both Hindu and Muslims) who are trying to divide our country on religious lines.

    15. In the circumstances the writ petition is allowed and a mandamus is issued directing the respondents to pay salary to the primary section teachers in Sanskrit institution through the State as is done in the case of primary school teachers of High School and Intermediate Colleges. Also, the salaries be paid to the former must be the same as that paid to the latter. The petitioners will also be entitled to other consequential benefits like group insurance, General Provident Fund, retirement benefits etc., which are being made available to the primary section teachers in High School and Intermediate Colleges.

    16. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramesh Upadhya And Others v. State Of U.P And Others
    (Jan 18, 1993)