1. The plaintiff sues for a declaration of title to, and recovery of possession of, a tank of which the Raja of Jharia is the admitted landlord. The defendant is a coal company and pleads permissive occupation from the landlord. Both the Courts below have found that the plaintiff has been unable to prove the title which he set out in his plaint, namely, that he has a niskar tenancy in the tank, but they have found that the plaintiff and his predecessors have been in possession of the tank for more than 12 years and that, the defendant being a trespasser, the plaintiff is entitled to get the relief which he claims. It is admitted by the learned vakil for the respondent before me that the case rests upon the plaintiff's title by long possession only. Now in order to succeed on the strength of long possession the plaintiff must show that the defendant is a trespasser. It is true that the learned Court of Appeal below finds that no settlement was made in favour of the defendant by the assistant manager of the Raja and that the defendant is actually a trespasser; but the term “trespasser” is a term of law and in second appeal it is competent for me to examine whether the defendant may in law be described as a trespasser. Now the learned Sub-ordinate Judge himself states in the concluding part of his judgment that the defendant is being supported in these proceedings by the landlord.
2. If that is so it is impossible to see how the defendant can be called a trespasser. The defendant must be considered a permissive occupant and in possession coordinate to that of the plaintiff. The case therefore that the plaintiff makes of long possession cannot prevail against the defendant. In this view of the case the decree of the learned lower Court must be set aside and the appeal decreed with costs. The suit will be dismissed with costs.
V.S/R.K
3. Appeal decreed.