AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 9 September 1929 Shyamakanta Lal and Srikanta Lal executed a mortgage in favour of the decree-holder Ram Lal over shares described as a 5 annas 4 pies share in village Semaria and a 6 annas 17 dams odd share in village Baralodhwe. Partition proceedings affecting the mahal (including Semaria) were underway: the Collector approved the partition on 2 September 1929 (one week before the mortgage), but the Commissioner did not approve until 23 May 1930 (after the mortgage). By the partition, the mortgagors were allotted a separate takhta in village Basaria, and their interest in Semaria became negligible.

The decree-holder sued to enforce the mortgage by sale of the mortgaged shares on 27 April 1935. A preliminary decree was obtained on 23 December 1936 and made final on 23 July 1937. Execution proceedings led to sale on 18 December 1937, with the 5 annas 4 pies in Semaria selling for Rs. 2000 and the Baralodhwe share for Rs. 6500; the purchaser in each sale was the decree-holder. Possession was taken through the Court on 11 April 1939. The decree-holder then sought possession of property in Basaria (the takhta allotted by partition) and of a share described as not being in village Baralodhwe but in mahal Baralodhwe; he was resisted.

The decree-holder applied to amend the descriptions of the mortgaged properties in the plaint, preliminary and final decrees and in all consequential execution papers (execution petition, sale proclamation and sale certificate). The learned Subordinate Judge allowed amendment substituting the Basaria property for the Semaria share, but refused the application in respect of Baralodhwe on the ground that that dispute involved identity of the property rather than mere misdescription. The judgment-debtors (mortgagors) filed Civil Revision No. 233 of 1940 against the order permitting substitution of the Basaria property. The decree-holder filed Civil Revision No. 372 of 1940 against the refusal to permit amendment concerning Baralodhwe.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after a partition that allotted substituted property (a takhta in Basaria) to mortgagors in lieu of the originally mortgaged Semaria share, the court could amend the plaint and decrees to substitute the Basaria property for the Semaria share, and to what extent such amendment may properly extend into execution-stage documents (execution petition, sale proclamation, sale certificate) especially where a sale has already occurred.
  2. Whether an application to amend is an appropriate procedure to resolve a dispute as to the identity of the mortgaged property where the decree-holder contends the mortgaged property is in a mahal (Baralodhwe) and the mortgagors contend it was a share in village Baralodhwe—a conflict characterized as one of identity rather than mere misdescription.

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment-debtors' Arguments

  • They initially argued below that the partition preceded the mortgage (i.e., the partition had taken place before the mortgage was executed); the Court found instead that the mortgage preceded final partition approval by the Commissioner.
  • They contended that the method adopted by the learned Subordinate Judge to ascertain precisely what part of the Basaria takhta represented the old Semaria share was not the correct method, and that parties were not given a proper opportunity to present contentions or evidence on that specific calculation.

Decree-holder's Arguments

  • The decree-holder sought amendment to substitute the Basaria takhta for the Semaria share in the pleadings, decrees and all consequential execution documents, asserting a right to proceed against substituted security following partition.
  • With respect to Baralodhwe, the decree-holder contended that there was no village Baralodhwe and that the mortgaged property was actually in the mahal Baralodhwe, seeking amendment accordingly.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1932 PC 235 (Privy Council) The Privy Council laid down that where a partition follows a mortgage and other properties are allotted to the mortgagor in lieu of the mortgaged property, the mortgagee can proceed against the substituted security. The Court accepted the principle that a mortgagee may proceed against substituted security but held that the Privy Council decision did not warrant the extensive amendments made by the learned Subordinate Judge in the execution-stage documents in this case. The Court concluded that amendment to the plaint, preliminary decree and final decree to reflect the substituted security could be justified, but amendment of execution documents (execution petition, sale proclamation, sale certificate) to substitute property that was never put to sale would be inappropriate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first established the chronological and legal context: the mortgage was executed on 9 September 1929, before the Commissioner's approval of the Collectorate partition on 23 May 1930, so the partition is treated as having taken place after the mortgage (even though the Collector had approved on 2 September 1929). By partition the mortgagors lost valuable interest in Semaria and were allotted a takhta in Basaria which represented their prior shares.

On the legal effect of partition, the Court accepted the established principle of substituted security: the mortgagee could have proceeded against that part of the takhta in Basaria which represented the original Semaria share. However, the Court emphasized the factual posture of the case: the mortgagee did not proceed against the substituted security when instituting the suit (27 April 1935) but instead sued for sale of the original Semaria share and pursued execution accordingly. A sale followed and the decree-holder bought the properties at execution sale.

Concerning the Subordinate Judge's amendments, the Court reviewed and limited their scope. While recognizing the principle from the Privy Council that the mortgagee may proceed against substituted security, the Court held that the Privy Council decision did not justify amending all consequential execution papers after a sale has already been conducted in respect of the originally described property. The Court reasoned that permitting amendment of execution-stage documents (execution petition, sale proclamation, sale certificate) to substitute the Basaria takhta would produce the effect that property which had never been offered for sale would be treated as having been bought and sold—an outcome the Court found impermissible.

The Court addressed the proper identification and quantification of the substituted security: the present takhta in Basaria represented not only the former Semaria share but also the mortgagors' previous Basaria share; therefore the whole takhta could not automatically be treated as substituted security. The learned Subordinate Judge had calculated—based on partition papers and valuations—that 6 annas 8 pies of the Basaria takhta represented the old Semaria share. The Court observed that the method of calculation adopted below was not necessarily the only correct one and noted that the parties did not appear to have been given an opportunity to present evidence or contentions on that precise point. The Court directed that before any final finding is recorded as to what constitutes the substituted security, the parties should be given an opportunity to place their contentions and admissible evidence before the Court; after such inquiry the Court should determine the substituted security and insert that description into the relevant documents up to and including the final decree.

Regarding Baralodhwe, the Court agreed with the Subordinate Judge that the dispute concerned the identity of the mortgaged property (share in village Baralodhwe versus share in mahal Baralodhwe) rather than a mere misdescription. The Court held that such a dispute as to identity could not be resolved on an application to amend and that amendment was therefore inappropriate.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The decree in favour of the decree-holder as to the Baralodhwe amendment fails, and the judgment-debtors' revision is allowed in part.

More specifically (as stated in the opinion):

  • The Court held that the decree-holder's Civil Revision (referred to in the opinion as "civil Revision No. 872 of 1940" though earlier references use 372 of 1940) fails in its entirety.
  • Civil Revision No. 233 of 1940, preferred by the judgment-debtors, is allowed in part: the portion of the Subordinate Judge's order permitting amendment of the execution petition, sale proclamation and sale certificate is set aside.
  • The judgment-debtors are stated to be entitled to their costs in Civil Revision No. 372 of 1940 (as recorded in the opinion). The Court made no order as to costs in Civil Revision No. 233 of 1940 and assessed the hearing fee in Civil Revision No. 372 of 1940 at three gold mohurs.
  • Fazl Ali, J. agreed with the opinion. The Bench ordered accordingly.

Implications:

  • The Court affirmed that the principle of substituted security applies where a partition follows a mortgage and substituted property is allotted; however, relief by amendment is constrained by procedural and fairness considerations—particularly that amendment of execution-stage documents to treat as sold property that was never put to sale is impermissible.
  • The Court required further procedure before finalizing the extent of substituted security: parties must be given an opportunity to adduce contentions and admissible evidence as to the correct quantification and identification of the substituted security, and only after such inquiry should the pleadings and decrees (up to and including the final decree) be amended to reflect the substituted security.
  • The decision confirms that disputes regarding identity of the mortgaged property (as distinct from mere misdescription) cannot properly be resolved by an amendment application and must be litigated by suitable proceedings.
  • The immediate direct effect: the prior execution sale cannot be treated as a sale of the substituted Basaria property; fresh steps will be necessary to bring any substituted security to sale after appropriate amendment and inquiry as directed.

Order accordingly.

    Shyama Kant Lal Judgment-Debtor v. Ram Lal And Another Deeree-Holders Opposite Party.

    Harries, C.J:— These are two civil revisions preferred by the decree-holder and judgment-debtors praying for revision of an order of the learned Subordinate Judge passed in an execution matter. To appreciate the points at issue it will be necessary shortly to set out the facts of the case. On 9th. September 1929, Shyamakanta Lal and his brother Srikanta Lal executed a mortgage in favour of the decree-holder Ram Lal. The properties mortgaged were 5 annas 4 pies share in village Semaria and 6 annas 17 dams odd share in village Baralodhwe. It appears that at the date of this mortgage partition proceedings were proceeding in, respect of the mahal which included the village of Semaria. On 2nd September 1929, (that is a week before this mortgage was executed) the partition was actually approved of by the Collector, but it did not receive the approval of the Commissioner until 23rd May 1930 (that is, a considerable time after the mortgage was executed). In this Collectorate partition the mortgagors were given a separate takhta in village Basaria and their interest in village Semaria became negligible.

    2. On 27th April 1935, the decree-holder brought a suit to enforce his mortgage by sale of the shares in these two villages. On 23rd December 1936, he obtained a preliminary decree which was made final on 23rd July 1937. On 23rd August 1937, proceedings were taken to sell the mortgaged properties, and on 18th December 1937, the two properties were sold, the 5 annas 4 pies share in Semaria being sold for Rs. 2000 and the share in Baralodhwe for Rs. 6500, the purchaser in each case being the decree-holder. On 11th April 1939, the decree holder took delivery of possession through Court. He, however, sought to take possession of the mortgagor's property in Basaria and of a share not in village Baralodhwe bub in mahal Baralodhwe. He was resisted and eventually the decree holder applied to the Court for amendment of the description of the mortgaged properties in the preliminary and final decrees in the suit and in all the consequential papers of the execution proceedings, that is in the execution petition, sale proclamation and sale certificate.

    3. The learned Subordinate Judge who heard this application for amendment allowed it in the case of Semaria property and permitted the Basaria property to be substituted in place of the share of Semaria stated in the documents throughout the proceedings. With regard to Baralodhwe, however, the learned Subordinate Judge held that the dispute re-lated not to a misdescription of property but rather to the identity of the property’ actually mortgaged. In his view amendment was not the proper procedure with regard to Baralodhwe, and he refused that part of the application. The judgment-debtors being dissatisfied with the order relating to amendment and substituting the Basaria property for the share in Semaria have preferred civil Revision No. 233 of 1940, whereas the decree, holder being dissatisfied with the order refusing to allow an amendment with regard to the Baralodhwe property has preferred Civil Revision No. 372 of 1940.

    4. It will be convenient in the first place to deal with civil Revision No. 233 of 1940. The judgment-debtors argued in the Court below that this was not a case where the mortgage preceded the partition but on the contrary it was a case where the partition preceded the mortgage. However, it is clear from the facts that the mortgage was entered into before this partition was finally concluded and approved of by the Commissioner, and it has not been argued before us that the Court below was wrong in treating the partition as taking place after the mortgage. By the partition the mortgagors lost all the property of any value in Semaria but were given a separate takhta in Basaria. It appears that the mortgagors owned a 5 annas 4 pies share in both Semaria and Basaria and they received a separate takhta in Basaria representing their previous shares in both the villages. There can be no doubt that on the principle of substituted security the mortgagees could have proceeded against such part of the property allotted to the mortgagors in Basaria as represented their original share in Semaria which had been mortgaged by the mortgage of 9th September 1929. However, the mortgagees, for reasons best known to themselves, took no steps when they instituted their suit on 27th April 1935, to proceed against the substituted security. The suit prayed for sale not of the substituted security but of the original security, namely 5 annas 4 pies share in village Semaria. The preliminary and final decrees were for the sale of that share in Semaria and such was the share mentioned in the execution petition, the sale proclamation and the sale certificate. After the whole proceedings were over and difficulties arose as to obtaining possession of the substituted security, this application for amendment was preferred.

    5. The learned Subordinate Judge allowed the amendment, feeling that he was bound by a decision of the Privy Council in AIR 1932 PC 235.1 In my view that decision of their Lordships does not warrant the various amendments by the learned Subordinate Judge in this case. Their Lordships lay down that where a partition has followed a mortgage and other properties are allotted to the mortgagor in lieu of the mortgaged property then the mortgagee can proceed against the substituted security. The difficulty in this case is that the mortgagee did not proceed against the substituted security but ignored the fact of partition and proceeded against the property originally mortgaged. There can be no doubt that he could have brought for sale such part of the property in Basaria as represented the property originally mortgaged, and that being so the learned Subordinate Judge was right in my judgment in allowing an amendment of the plaint, the preliminary decree and the final decree, but no further amendment, in my view, could be justifiably made. It must be remembered that if an amendment is made in the execution petition, sale proclamation and sale certificate, the result will be that property will have been bought and sold which has never been even put up for sale. If a part of the Basaria property be substituted for the share in Semaria in the sale certificate, it will have the effect of a purchase by the decree-holder of property which has in fact never been offered for sale. That being so, it is clear that no amendment can be made in any of the relevant documents and proceedings following the final decree.

    6. The question now arises what amendment should be made in the plaint, preliminary and final decree. The present takhta in Basaria given to the mortgagors by the partition represents not only their previous share in Semaria but also their share in Basaria. That being so, the whole of the takhta given in the partition cannot be treated as the substituted security. The learned Judge, after making a calculation based entirely upon the partition papers and valuations, has come to the conclusion that 6 annas 8 pies share of the Bararia takhta represents the old Semaria share which was the subject of the mortgage: in other words, the substituted security is now 6 annas 8 pies share in the takhta given to the mortgagors in Basaria on partition. Mr. Khurshaid Husnain on behalf of the judgment-debtors has urged that the method adopted by the learned Judge of ascertaining what precisely is the substituted security is not the true one. There is nothing in the judgment to suggest that the parties were given an opportunity of urging their respective points of view as to how the extent of the substituted security should be ascertained. The partition papers and the valuation of the properties made in the partition proceedings are clearly of the utmost importance in the case; but, in my view, it would be advisable that before a finding is recorded as to what the substituted security is, the parties should be given an opportunity of placing their contentions before the Court and any evidence which they may seek to adduce and which the Court may consider to be properly admissible. After such inquiry the Court should come to the conclusion as to what is the substituted security, and such should be inserted in all the relevant documents up to and including the final decree in place of the share in Semaria which was the property originally mortgaged.

    7. After such amendment is made fresh steps will have to be taken in bringing this property in Basaria to sale. It is needless to say that in view of the observations which I have made that the sale which has already taken place is in no sense a sale of the mortgaged property and cannot possibly affect the mortgagor's interest in the takhta granted to them in Basaria. Fresh proceedings will have to be taken to bring the substituted security to sale after amendment has been made.

    8. The decree-holder preferred Civil Revision No. 372 of 1940 seeking revision of that part of the order which refused to allow any amendment with regard to Baralodhwe property. In my judgment the learned Subordinate Judge was right in refusing to make any amendment with regard to this property. The mortgaged property was certainly stated to be village Baralodhwe; but it was contended by the decree-holder that there was no such village and that the mortgaged property was in fact the mahal Baralodhwe. Certain documents were adduced by the parties to support their respective cases, and eventually the learned Judge came to the conclusion that this was not a case of misdescription merely but involved a question of the identity of the property mortgaged. That being so, proceedings to amend the relevant documents in the case did not appear to him to be appropriate. In my view a question involving the identity of the property mortgaged cannot be dealt with on an application to amend. There in here a serious dispute as to what was the subject-matter of the mortgage. The mortgagors contend that it was a share in village Baralodhwe, whereas the mortgagees contend that it was a share in a mahal known as Baralodhwe. It appears to me that this dispute can never be decided by an application such as that preferred by the decree-holder, and in my view the lower Court was right in rejecting the application to amend.

    9. The result, therefore, is that civil Revision No. 872 of 1940 preferred by the decree, holder fails in its entirety. Civil Revision No. 233 of 1940 preferred by the judgment-debtors is allowed in part and so much of the order of the lower Court relating to amendment of the execution petition, proclamation of sale and sale certificate is set aside. The judgment-debtors are entitled to their costs in Civil Revision No. 372 of 1940, whereas I would make no order as to costs in civil Revision No. 233 of 1940. I would assess the hearing fee in civil Revision No. 372 of 1940 at three gold mohurs.

    Fazl Ali, J.:— I agree.

    G.N/R.K

    10. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shyama Kant Lal Judgment-Debtor v. Ram Lal And Another Deeree-Holders Opposite Party.
    (Jan 21, 1941)