AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Jatindra Kumar Das Decree-Holder, v. Ramesh Chandra Majumdar Judgment-Debtor,

    The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—

    This appeal is on behalf of the decree-holder and arises out of an order passed by the learned District Judge of Dacca in which it has been held, that an application for execution presented in the Court of the second Munsif at Dacca on the 6th of July, 1936 was not maintainable in that Court on that date. The learned Munsif of the second Court at Dacca to whom that application was presented had, however, taken a different view. The only question, therefore, before us is whether the application for execution presented by the decree-holder in the second Court on the 6th July, 1936 was an application to a Court which had jurisdiction to execute the decree.

    The Appellant filed a suit for recovery of money at a time when there was a Central Court at Dacca. Accordingly to the practice prevalent, when he filed his plaint, all plaints had to be presented in the Central Court and the Central Court used to send cases for disposal by other Munsifs sitting at Dacca. This particular suit was sent to the Munsif, 2nd Court, at Dacca and it was tried by him.

    On the 9th July, 1931, the second Munsif at Dacca gave the Appellant a decree for about Rs. 1400. In 1932, the Appellant applied for execution of the decree, in the Court of the second Munsif at Dacca which had passed the decree, but that attempt proved to be an abortive one. He then, in 1933, after the disposal of his first execution case, made an application to the second Court at Dacca for transfer of his decree to the Court of the first Munsif of that place for execution. On the 4th July, 1933 the decree was transferred by the second Court to the first Court and in the first Court the Appellant made an application for execution of his decree. His application, however, to that Court was dismissed for default within a short time. On the 8th August, 1933, it appears from the Suits Register maintained in the Central Court, that the result of the execution was intimated by the Munsif, first Court to Central Munsif's Court, that is to say, immediately on the dismissal of the execution pending before it, the first Munsif intimated the result to the Central Court. It appears, however, that the Central Munsif did not communicate this intimation to the second Munsif who had passed the decree.

    On the 6th July, 1936 the Appellant presented a fresh application for execution in the first Court, but that Court returned the application for presentation to the proper Court on the footing that it had no jurisdiction to entertain it. The basis on which the application for execution presented on the 6th July, 1936 was returned, was that the first Court had already sent the intimation, that the earlier application before it had already terminated. We are told that the channel through which all such intimations were to pass through at that time was the Central Munsif's Court. The facts, therefore, were these, that the certificate of non-satisfaction had been sent by the first Court on the 8th August, 1933 for communication to the second Court through the Central Court. That communication reached the Central Munsif's Court, but for some reason which does not appear, it was not transmitted by the Central Munsif's Court to the second Munsif's Court which had passed the decree.

    After the return of the application for execution by the first Court on the 6th July, 1936 it was presented on the same day in the second Munsif's Court which had passed the decree. The judgment-debtor objected that Court had no jurisdiction, inasmuch as the first Court to which the decree had been previously transferred for execution had not sent the certificate of non-satisfaction to the second Court. This objection was overruled by the learned Munsif, but on appeal the learned District Judge has given effect to that objection.

    The learned District Judge has relied on the: case of Maharaja of Bobbili v. Narasarajupeda Srinhulu and on the decision of a Division Bench of this Court, Jatindra Kumar Das v. Mahendra Chandra Banikya . The case of Rajani Kanta Pattadar v. Kazi Saiyad Golam Mahiuddin , was cited before the Judge, by the decree-holder. The learned Judge, however, distinguished on the facts the last-mentioned case and has held that the case before him fell within the purview of the two first-mentioned cases, namely, the cases of Maharajah of Bobbili and Jatindra Kumar Das . He has accordingly held that the application of the decree-holder presented to the second Court of the Munsif at Dacca, in those circumstances, was not maintainable.

    Apart from the question of the correctness of the decision of the learned District Judge, the fact remains that the decree-holder has been driven from Court to Court. He presented the application for execution in question in the first Court on the 6th July, 1936. He was told by the first Munsif that he could not entertain the application but the proper Court to entertain the application was the second Court. On the same day he came to the Munsif second Court and put in the application there. He has been now told by the District Judge that he was to go not to the second Court but to the first Court, after a considerable time. Even if the learned Judge was right in his view, proper order has not been made. The proper order, in any event, would have been to send the application to the first Court.

    However, be that as it may it does not matter much on the view we are taking in this case, for in our judgment the learned District Judge was not right. The cases of Maharaja of Bobbili and Jatindra Kumar Das on which he has placed reliance are distinguishable. In both those cases, the application before the transferee Court for execution had been dismissed at a time when the next application was made to the Court which had passed the decree, but in both those cases the transferee Court had not sent out any communication to the effect that the decree had not been satisfied in the course of the execution proceedings that were taken. In the case before us that was done by the transferee Court. The communication was made, it was received so to say by the distributing centre but the distributing centre had not passed it on, which it was required to do and in these circumstances we hold that the cases on which the Court of appeal below has relied are distinguishable, for in the case before us the transferee Court had at the time of the presentation of the application for execution in the second had no seisin of the case.

    The order which we are proposing to make has the advantage of relieving the decree-holder from the position in which he has been placed not by reason of his own fault, but by reason of the Court's order.

    The result is that this appeal is allowed, the order of the learned District Judge is set aside and that of the learned Munsif restored. The execution case is sent back to the second Court of the Munsif at Dacca to be proceeded with in accordance with law.

    As there is no appearance, inasmuch as we have already allowed Mr. Chuckraburtty to retire from the case, we do not make any order for costs. Let the record go down early.

    C.C

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jatindra Kumar Das Decree-Holder, v. Ramesh Chandra Majumdar Judgment-Debtor,
    (Jan 24, 1939)