Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Appel No. 132 of 1927

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff sued on a mortgage bond dated 24 October 1907. The present suit was instituted on 17 October 1925. To avoid the bar of limitation, the plaintiff relied on an endorsement on the mortgage bond (Ex. A‑1) purporting to record a payment of Rs. 10 towards interest on 17 October 1913. The Subordinate Judge entered a decree for the plaintiff with further interest. Defendants 1 to 3 appealed; defendants 1 and 2 were appellants before the court in the present opinion, while the appeal of the 3rd defendant was considered separately.

Key evidentiary materials identified by the court include: Ex. A‑1 (the endorsement on the mortgage bond), Ex. D (the plaintiff's day book, including an entry at page 515 purporting to record the Rs. 10 payment), and Ex. F (a letter dated 24 December 1921 relied on as proof of ratification/acknowledgement).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the endorsement dated 17 October 1913 (Ex. A‑1) effectively constituted a payment sufficient to save the plaintiff's cause of action from the bar of limitation.
  2. Whether the endorsement (Ex. A‑1) was interpolated after signatures were made, and, relatedly, whether the endorsement and its signatures were duly proved.
  3. Whether the amendment to Section 68 of the Evidence Act (Act XXXI of 1926) required production of the only surviving attestor to prove the attestation on Ex. A or whether, as a procedural amendment, it operated retrospectively so that calling the surviving attestor was unnecessary.
  4. Whether payments recorded after 1913 (including payments by third persons such as Vadivelu Pillai and Munusami Padayachi) amounted to payments or acknowledgments by a person specifically authorised by the 3rd defendant so as to save the plaintiff's claim against the 3rd defendant under Section 20 of the Limitation Act.
  5. Whether Ex. F (a letter of 24 December 1921) constituted a ratification, acknowledgment, or fresh promise by the 3rd defendant sufficient to take the cause of action out of the operation of the statute of limitation.
  6. How Section 20 of the Limitation Act should be construed in relation to Section 21(2) where there are several joint contractors, partners, executors or mortgagees — in particular, whether acknowledgments or payments by one person can bind the others.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Defendants 1, 2 and 3)

  • Defendants 1 and 2: Although their signatures on Ex. A‑1 are genuine, the endorsements were interpolated after signing — there was in fact no payment on 17 October 1913; rather, the defendants were told that an endorsement would be made reflecting earlier payments actually made.
  • Defendants 1 and 2: Ex. A was not duly proved; attestation was incomplete and the attestors should have been called, invoking Section 68 of the Evidence Act.
  • Third defendant: The endorsement of 17 October 1913 was not signed by him; there is no evidence of specific authority given to those who signed the endorsement to bind the 3rd defendant. Payments recorded later were not relied upon in the plaint to save limitation, and the evidence does not show specific authorisation by the 3rd defendant for the persons who made those payments.
  • Third defendant: Ex. F (the letter) was filed late and, in any event, does not ratify acts done by others on his behalf or amount to an acknowledgment taking the matter out of the statute of limitation.

Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The plaintiff produced oral evidence of the Rs. 10 payment on 17 October 1913 (plaintiff himself gave evidence and the entry appears in the plaintiff's day book, Ex. D, page 515), and the signature/endorsement Ex. A‑1 should be accepted.
  • With respect to the third defendant, the respondent argued that under Section 20 of the Limitation Act it suffices that the interest on the debt was paid by any person liable to pay the debt (i.e., a broad reading of "the person liable to pay the debt").

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bapanna v. Bheemalingam (1916) 3 L.W. 231 Authority for requiring specific authorisation — used to indicate that mere management of family affairs or payments by an inmate/manager does not constitute specific authorisation under Section 20 of the Limitation Act. The court relied on this authority to hold that payments by Vadivelu Pillai and others did not prove specific authorisation by the 3rd defendant and thus did not save the claim against him.
Askaram Soivkar v. Venkataswami Naidu (1920) I.L.R. 44 M. 544; 40 M.L.J. 218 Construction that the words "the person liable to pay the debt" may be taken to mean any person liable to pay the debt (broad reading of Section 20). The court acknowledged this construction but limited its application because Section 21(2) (which affects cases of multiple parties) curtails the operation of Section 20 in certain situations.
Bolding v. Lane (1863) 1 De G. J. & Sm. 122 Listed as an authority relied upon for the broad construction of "person liable to pay the debt" in earlier decisions. Referenced as one of the precedents supporting the broad construction; the court considered such precedents but analyzed them in light of Section 21(2).
Chinnery v. Evans (1864) 11 H.L. Cas. 115 Authority supporting the broad meaning of "person liable to pay the debt" and related acknowledgment principles. Used to show prior acceptance of broad construction, but the court distinguished such authorities where Section 21(2) would operate to limit the effect of acknowledgments/payments in the case of joint liabilities.
Lewin v. Wilson (1886) 11 App. Cas. 639 Decision under New Brunswick legislation analogous to English sections; discussed in relation to whether acknowledgments by one bind others. The court held Lewin v. Wilson did not assist the respondent because the New Brunswick statute did not clearly correspond to Section 21 of the Limitation Act; the court therefore did not apply it to broaden Section 20's operation.
Achola Sundari Debi v. Doman Sundari Debi (1925) 90 I.C. 774 Interpreted Section 20 (Indian case) but did not advert to Section 21 of the Limitation Act. The court observed that this decision was confined to interpretation of Section 20 alone and therefore did not help where Section 21(2) must be taken into account.
Ibrahim v. Jagdish Prasad A.I.R. 1927 A. 209 Interpreted Section 20 (Indian case) without considering Section 21. The court noted that this authority did not consider Section 21 and so could not be used to support a construction that ignored the limiting effect of Section 21(2).
In re Macdonald; Dick v. Fraser (1897) 2 Ch. 181 Decision under Lord Tenterden's Act concerning acknowledgment by one of several executors and its effect on estate liability; used to compare with Section 21(2). The court treated this case as distinguishable because Lord Tenterden's Act and Section 21(2) of the Limitation Act are not identical; therefore it was unsafe to import its result to the present context of joint contractors/mortgagors.
Hollingshead v. Webster (1888) 37 Ch. D. 651 (In re Hollingshead) Considered in relation to acknowledgments by one party (a devisee for life) and whether they bind remainderman; Chitty, J.'s observations were discussed. The court noted that in Hollingshead the precise point did not arise in the same manner and that Chitty, J.'s commentary could not be used to narrow Section 21's language generally.
Roddam v. Morley (1857) 1 De G. & J. 1 Lord Cranworth's general observations on acknowledgments referenced in later judgments. Referenced as part of the historical line of authority on acknowledgments; used for background but not as dispositive authority to alter statutory interpretation in this case.
Muthu Chettiar v. Muhammad Hussain (1919) 55 I.C. 763 Held that the term "joint contractors" can include two mortgagors. The court cited this decision to support the proposition that in cases of joint mortgagors the limitation provisions affecting joint contractors/partners/mortgagees must be applied sensibly and that one co‑contractor is not automatically bound by the payments of another.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court separated its analysis between the appeals of defendants 1 and 2 on the one hand and the 3rd defendant on the other, applying evidence and statutory interpretation strictly as found in the record.

Defendants 1 and 2

  • The appellants contended interpolation of Ex. A‑1 after signatures. The court found only a bare suggestion of interpolation and no supporting evidence: the 1st and 2nd defendants did not give evidence ("have not gone into the box") to substantiate the allegation.
  • The plaintiff gave direct evidence of the Rs. 10 payment on 17 October 1913 and relied on an entry in Ex. D (day book, p. 515). The actual entry was written by Venkatachala Chetti, whose handwriting was proved by his son (P.W.2). On this evidentiary basis the court rejected the interpolation contention.
  • On attestation, Ex. A bore signatures of five attestors and the writer; all were dead except C. Vadivelu Pillai. The appellants argued Section 68 of the Evidence Act required calling the only living attestor. The court observed Act XXXI of 1926 had recently amended Section 68; it treated that amendment as procedural and retrospective in operation. Moreover, none of the defendants denied the genuineness of the mortgage bond and the 1st defendant admitted her own execution; the 2nd defendant filed no written statement; the 3rd did not plead non-execution. Taking these factors together, the court concluded it was not necessary to call the living attestor and rejected the attestation attack.
  • Result for defendants 1 and 2: their appeal failed and was dismissed with costs.

Third Defendant

  • The court began from the uncontested fact that the 17 October 1913 endorsement was not signed by the 3rd defendant. There was no evidence that those who signed the endorsement were specifically authorised by the 3rd defendant to do so.
  • The court examined subsequent payments recorded in Ex. D (years 1915–1920) and identified payors: some payments by Vadivelu Pillai (the attestor), one by Munusami Padayachi, and others unattributed. The court found no proof that any of these persons were specifically authorised by the 3rd defendant to make payments binding on him.
  • Although Vadivelu Pillai had been managing the family affairs and living with the defendants and had paid the erva on their behalf, the court held such facts did not amount to the specific authorisation required by Section 20 of the Limitation Act (relying on Bapanna v. Bheemalingam).
  • The court considered the plaintiff's reliance on Ex. F (letter dated 24 December 1921) as evidence of ratification/acknowledgement. It held that Ex. F was merely a prayer for more time, was filed late, and — even assuming it referred to the suit document — was written more than 12 years after the date of the mortgage and therefore could not operate as an acknowledgement or fresh promise sufficient to take the case out of the statute.
  • The court then undertook a statutory and precedential analysis of Sections 20 and 21(2) of the Limitation Act. It accepted that some authorities construed "the person liable to pay the debt" broadly (e.g., Askaram Soivkar v. Venkataswami Naidu and earlier English authorities), but emphasized that those decisions did not consider the limiting operation of Section 21(2) in cases of multiple liable parties (joint contractors, partners, executors, mortgagees).
  • The court distinguished decisions under other statutory schemes (e.g., Lord Tenterden's Act, New Brunswick statutes) as not identical to the Indian Limitation Act provisions; it therefore declined to adopt results from those cases where they would improperly narrow the clear language of Section 21. The court held the word "chargeable" in Section 21 must prima facie mean every kind of chargeability arising under Sections 19 and 20 and cannot be limited to personal liability only.
  • Applying these conclusions, the court held that payments and acknowledgments shown in the record did not bind the 3rd defendant and thus the cause of action was time‑barred as against him.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal of the 3rd defendant is allowed; the suit is dismissed as against the 3rd defendant with costs (half the pleader's fee allowed).

Additionally, the appeals of defendants 1 and 2 are dismissed with costs. The court extended time for payment to four months from the date of the judgment.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the plaintiff's suit is extinguished insofar as the 3rd defendant is concerned (dismissed with costs and half pleader's fee), while the plaintiff's decree as against defendants 1 and 2 was upheld (their appeal dismissed with costs). Payment time was extended by four months.
  • On broader law: the court applied established authorities but expressly limited the application of a broad reading of Section 20 where Section 21(2) operates to limit acknowledgments and payments among multiple liable parties. The opinion is focused on statutory interpretation and the application of precedent to the facts; it does not purport to create a new general precedent beyond its reasoning on the interaction between Sections 20 and 21(2) in the circumstances presented.

Note: This summary strictly reflects information contained in the provided opinion and does not add facts or conclusions not present in the original text.

    Thayammal v. A. Muthukumaraswami Chettiar

    1. Appel No. 132 of 1927 - In this Appeal defendants 1 to 3 are the appellants before us. The plaintiff brought the suit on a mortgage bond, dated the 24th October, 1907. The present suit was filed on the 17th October, 1925. To save the bar of limitation the plaintiff relied on a payment of Rs. 10 towards interest on the 17th October, 1913, which purports to be endorsed on the mortgage bond and is exhibited as Ex. A-l. The Subordinate Judge decreed the plaintiff's suit as framed with further interest. Hence this appeal.

    2. Ex. A-l the endorsement was signed by the 1st defendant and the 2nd defendant for himself and as guardian of his younger brother the 4th defendant. It is said that the 3rd defendant was then absent at Singapore and that the endorsement was signed on his behalf also, but there is no signature which purports to be on his behalf. So far as the 1st and 2nd defendants are concerned, the main point that was argued for the appellants was that though the signatures on the endorsement are genuine the endorsement was interpolated after the signatures were made, that there was in fact no payment on the 17th October, 1913, and that what was represented to the defendants was that an endorsement will be made consisting of the earlier payments, which were really made. Beyond the bare suggestion, there is nothing to support this contention of the defendants. The 1st and 2nd defendants have not gone into the box to support this contention. On the other hand, the plaintiff has gone into the box and sworn to a payment of Rs. 10 on that date. This payment appears in the plaintiff's day book, Ex. D, at page 515. The actual entry was written by one Venkatachala Chetti and his writing is proved by his son P.W. 2. This contention on behalf of the appellants 1 and 2 therefore fails.

    3. Another contention raised on behalf of the appellants may also be disposed of. It is that Ex. A has not been duly proved. It bears the signatures of five attestors and the writer. All these are dead except one, namely C. Vadivelu Pillai. It is argued that Vadivelu Pillai has not been called as required by Section 68 of the Evidence Act. This section of the Evidence Act has been recently amended by Act XXXI of 1926. None of the defendants has denied the genuineness of the suit mortgage bond. The 1st defendant only said that it has not been duly attested and that the plaintiff should prove strictly the genuineness but admitted her own execution. The 2nd defendant never filed a written statement. The 3rd defendant also did not plead that he did not execute the bond. We think the amendment is a provision relating to processual law and not to substantive law and, therefore, must be taken to be retrospective in its operation. That being so, it is not necessary to call the only living attestor. This contention, therefore, also fails. The result is the appeal of defendants 1 and 2 should be dismissed with costs.

    4. There remains the appeal of the 3rd defendant. His learned Advocate argues that the suit is barred by limitation as against him. The endorsement, dated 17th October, 1913, was not signed by him and there is nothing on record to show that those who signed the endorsement were specifically authorised for that purpose. The mere fact that the payment of the money enures for the benefit of all the defendants cannot constitute a specific authorisation to sign the endorsement on their behalf within the meaning of Section 20 of the Limitation Act. There are certain later payments towards Ex. A but these were not relied on in the plaint as saving limitation and even if we are inclined to look at them for this purpose, all that we have got is that the payment in191S and one payment in 1918 were made by Vadivelu Pillai, the attestor abovenamed. Another payment in 1918 and another in 1919 do not appear to have been made by any specific person. Another payment in 1920 was made by one Munusami Padayachi. These facts appear from Ex. D, the plaintiff's later day book. There is no evidence that Vadivelu Pillai or Munusami Padayachi was specifically authorised to pay the amounts on behalf of the 3rd defendant. It is true that there is evidence that Vadivelu Pillai had been managing the defendants' family affairs. He was permanently living and messing with the defendants in the same house and he was an inmate of the defendants' house even during his wife's lifetime and he was paying theerva on behalf of the defendants. But in our opinion all these do not constitute a specific authorisation within the meaning of Section 20 of the Limitation Act, vide Bapanna v. Bheemalingam (1916) 3 L.W. 231 We therefore, hold that there is no payment of interest as such by any person authorised by the 3rd defendant to pay on his behalf.

    5. In the plaint there is an allegation that the 3rd defendant, ratified these payments. Paragraph 9 (a) of the plaint says that he "agreed thereto" and "acquiesced therein" and "admitted it" and "ratified it." In proof of this so-called ratification, Ex. F was relied upon. The appellants object that this was filed at a very late stage but it is unnecessary to go into this question as Ex. F does not purport to ratify any act done by others on behalf of the 3rd defendant. It is merely a letter praying for more time. Assuming that it relates to the suit document, the letter being written on the 24th December, 1921, more than 12 years after the date of the document, it cannot operate as an acknowledgment, nor can it amount to a fresh promise. Ex. F, therefore, does not avail the plaintiff so far as the 3rd defendant is concerned.

    6. It is then contended for the respondent that under Section 20 of the Limitation Act it is enough if the interest on the debt is paid as such by any person liable to pay the debt. It is true that the words "the person liable to pay the debt" were construed to mean any person liable to pay the debt. Vide Askaram Soivkar v. Vdnkataswami Naidu (1920) I.L.R. 44 M. 544: 40 M.L.J. 218 relying on Bolding v. Lane (1863) 1 De G.J. & Sm 122 and Chinnery v. Evans. (1864) 11 H.L. Cas 115 But that was a case to which Section 21 of the Act would not apply and there could be no suggestion that the operation of Section 20 was cut down by that of Section 21, Clause (2). In the case of several joint contractors, partners, executors or mortgagees, the operation of Section 20 seems to be cut down or limited by Section 21(2) of the Act. The decision in Lewin v. Wilson (1886) 11 App. Cas. 639 does not help the respondent. That was an appeal from New Brunswick and though Sections 29 and 30 of the New Brunswick Act are a reproduction of the corresponding Sections in the English Statute, 7 Will. and 4 and 1 Viet. c. 28, and they correspond to our Sections 19 and 20, it does not appear that there is a section in the New Brunswick Act corresponding to our Section 21 and if there is one, what its exact terms are. It is then argued by Mr. Krishnaswami Aiyar, the learned Advocate for the respondent, that in Section 21 the word "chargeable" means personally chargeable and does not affect chargeability as to property; and therefore where the main liability included liability as to property and a personal liability, while the personal liability is cut down by Section 21, the liability as to property remains on the construction of Section 20; only where the main liability itself is a personal liability, the result of Section 21 is to make the suit wholly barred. In support of this contention Achola Sundari Debi v. Doman Sundari Debi (1925) 90 I.C. 774 and Ibrahim v. Jagdish Prasad A.I.R. 1927 A. 209 are the only Indian cases referred to, but in those cases the learned judges have not adverted to Section 21 of the Limitation Act at all. They were confined merely to the interpretation of Section 20. Those decisions therefore do not help us. The learned Advocate then relied on a decision in In re Maodonald, Dick v. Frascr (1897) 2 Ch. 181 a decision of Stirling, J., as he then was. It was a decision under Lord Tenterden's Act (9 Geo. 4, c. 14), Section 1. The question there was whether an acknowledgment made by one of several executors binds a testator's estate in the hands of the surviving executor, the original liability being that of the testator. In the first place, that section and our Section 21(2) are not identical. Section 21 refers to "partners" and also "mortgagees," but these are not mentioned in Lord Tenterden's Act. Whereas Section 21 refers generally to executors, Lord Tenterden's Act refers to executors of any contractor. Again S.. 21 refers to both cases of acknowledgment and payment, whereas Lord Tenterden's Act refers to acknowledgment or promise only and not to payment. It is unsafe to assume that the same result was intended in the two Acts even in the case of joint contractors or executors. The case did not go to the Court of Appeal and the point has not since arisen. So far as executors are concerned, its effect has been incorporated in the text books vide, for example, Lightwood on Limitation of Actions--but such statements are confined to executors only. In the course of Stirling, J.'s judgment he relied on Chitty's judgment in In re Hollingshead. Hollingshead v. Webster (1888) 37 Ch. D. 651 where reference to a similar section, namely, Section 14 of the Mercantile Law Amendment Act, was made. In that case the payment was made by a devisee for life and the question was whether it was a sufficient acknowledgment to bind the remainderman. Chitty, J., relied on the general observations of Lord Cranworth in Roddam v. Morley (1857) 1 De G. & J. I and held that it was a sufficient acknowledgment. This view is in consonance with the view since adopted by the House of Lords in Chinnery v. Evans (1864) 11 H. L. Cas. 115 and Lewin v. Wilson (1186) 11 App. Cas. 639. In the course of the argument Mr. Swinfen Eady (as he then was) said that the admission of a debt by an executrix will not take it out of the statute so as to enable a creditor to obtain payment out of the testator's real estate. What use he actually made of Section 14 of the Mercantile Law Amendment Act does not appear from the report, but Chitty, J., in the course of the judgment says that Mr. Swinfen Eady's argument was that the estate was not liable and that the executor who made the acknowledgment was personally liable, and he said that this argument was founded on Section 14 of the Mercantile Law Amendment Act. Chitty, J., then observed that that was an extraordinary result and he proceeded to observe that some reasonable interpretation should be put on the words "so as to be chargeable." The interpretation that he suggested was that the co-executor who has not paid is not to be personally chargeable as for a devastavit. Thus it is seen that the interpretation of the word "chargeable" did not actually arise in the case. The discussion about it arose only because Mr. Swinfen Eady tried to support his argument by the analogy of the case of two executors and his further argument as to who would be liable in their case. We think it is unsafe to cut down the plain language of Section 21 by reason of these two cases in In re Macdonald. Dick v. Fraser (1897) 2 Ch. 181and in In re Hollingshead. Hollingshead v. Webster (1888) 37 Ch. D. 651.The former related to the case of executors and in the latter the point did not actually arise. Whatever may be the law as to executors, it is impossible to say that of two joint contractors'--which term has been held to include two mortgagors in this Court (vide Muthu Chettiar v. Muhammad Hussain (1919) 55 I. C. 763 one contractor is bound by the payments of the other. The word "chargeable" in Section 21 must prima facie mean every kind of chargeability possible by reason of Sections 19 and 20 of the Act, that is, every kind of chargeability under the original contract, and the term cannot be limited to personal liability only.

    7. The result is, we think, that the suit is barred so far as the 3rd defendant is concerned. We allow this appeal and the suit is dismissed as against him with costs throughout. Half the pleader's fee only is allowed. But the appeal of defendants 1 and 2 is dismissed with costs. Time for payment is extended to four months from this date.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thayammal v. A. Muthukumaraswami Chettiar
    (Aug 2, 1929)