Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — Limitation (Art. 182(5) of the Limitation Act)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerns a question of limitation. The appellant is the decree-holder in O.S. No. 174 of 1916 (District Munsif of Tiruvadi). The decree was dated 2 May 1916. The appellant's present execution petition is E.P. No. 368 of 1919, filed on 8 October 1919. The only prior execution petition presented by the appellant had been dismissed on 7 September 1916.

The present execution application is admitted to be time-barred unless the appellant can claim a fresh starting point for limitation under Article 182(5) of the Indian Limitation Act by showing that, within three years of the prior execution petition, he “applied to take some step in aid of execution.”

The appellant relied on three documents as constituting such an application: Ex. E (a counter-statement dated 1 February 1918 to a petition filed by the judgment-debtor), Ex. F (a joint petition by both parties to hear E.P. No. 16 of 1918 along with O.S. No. 452 of 1917), and Ex. C (a plaint in another suit seeking to set aside a settlement deed under Section 53, Transfer of Property Act). The court examined whether any of these constituted an application “to take some step in aid of execution.”

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant's execution petition E.P. No. 368 of 1919 is time-barred under the Limitation Act, absent a new starting point under Article 182(5).
  2. Whether Ex. E (the appellant's counter-statement to the debtor's petition for entry of satisfaction) constitutes an "application to take some step in aid of execution" within Article 182(5), thereby restarting limitation.
  3. Whether Ex. F (petition to hear E.P. No. 16 of 1918 along with another suit) or Ex. C (plaint filed to set aside a settlement deed under Section 53, Transfer of Property Act) qualify as applications within Article 182(5).
  4. Whether the period during which E.A. No. 16 of 1918 was pending should be excluded from the limitation period on equitable grounds (relying on prior Calcutta High Court decisions and their approval).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that Ex. E (a counter-statement filed on 1 February 1918 denying receipt of the decree amount and opposing the judgment-debtor's petition for entry of satisfaction) should be treated as an application to take some step in aid of execution because the entry of satisfaction, if allowed, would effectively prevent execution of the decree.
  • The appellant further relied on Ex. F and Ex. C as additional steps that should be regarded as applications in aid of execution.
  • As an alternative, the appellant argued that the time during which E.A. No. 16 of 1918 was pending should not be counted against him, relying on decisions of a three-judge bench of the Calcutta High Court (Lakhan Chunder Sen v. Madhu Sudan Sen) and subsequent cases, which the appellant read as permitting exclusion of time during which parties were precluded from instituting proceedings.

Respondent's / Other Positions

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's separate legal arguments; it records certain concessions (for example, that if Ex. E cannot be relied upon, Ex. F stands in no better position) but does not set out a fuller respondent submission.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Umesh Chunder Dutta v. Soonder Narain Deo Part of a set of Calcutta High Court decisions addressing what constitutes an application "to take some step in aid of execution." The court cites this as part of a consistent Calcutta High Court view that supports the conclusion that Ex. E is not an application in aid of execution.
Raghunandan Pershad v. Bhugoo Lall Another Calcutta High Court decision referenced with the same theme as above. Included with the Calcutta cluster of authorities relied on to support the view that the counter-petition (Ex. E) is not an application to take a step in aid of execution.
Raghunundun Misser v. Kallydut Misser Also cited among consistent Calcutta High Court decisions about applications in aid of execution. Used to show a line of authority favoring the narrower interpretation of Article 182(5) adopted by the court.
Abdul Kader Rowther v. Krishnan Malaval Nair Example dealing with applications made in the course of a pending execution petition (e.g., for adjournment to produce further evidence). The court treats this as an example of the class of cases concerning applications during pending execution; it “eliminates” that class from the present comparison because such cases are distinguishable from applications made when no execution petition is pending.
Laxmiram Lallubhai v. Balashanker Veniram Held (in its facts) that an appeal against an order adjudging the judgment-debtor an insolvent was a step in aid of execution. The court identifies this as the main case relied upon by the appellant but notes that in that case an execution petition was apparently pending. The court rejects extending that decision beyond its unusual facts.
Sankaranarayana Pillai v. Puthiya Vettil Thangamma Contains a statement by Ramesam, J. suggesting there is no warrant for the view that an application must be made "in execution" (i.e., while execution is pending). The court notes Ramesam, J.'s statement but observes that he gave no reasons and expressly dissents from that view in the present judgment.
Lakhan Chunder Sen v. Madhu Sudan Sen Three-judge Bench of Calcutta High Court: held that relaxations of the ordinary law of limitation in the Limitation Act are not exhaustive; approved on appeal to the Privy Council in the reported records. The court accepts the authority of the decision in principle but distinguishes the facts: in that case the prior decree suspended the plaintiffs' right to sue, a circumstance not present in the present appeal; thus the decision does not aid the appellant here.
Nrityamoni Dassi v. Lakhan Chandra Sen Related authority indicating circumstances where time during which a party was precluded from suing may be treated in the party's favour. The court treats this as part of the same line but holds that the factual differences remove its application to the present case.
Muthu Korakki Chetty v. Mahamad Madar Ammal Turned on construction of Article 180; discussed issues of “suspension” and whether exemptions in the Limitation Act were exhaustive. The court notes this decision but says it turns on Article 180 (not the present article) and observes that the judgments (except one judge) tend against the appellant's contention; none militate against the court's view here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused on the proper interpretation of Article 182(5) of the Limitation Act and whether any of the documents relied upon by the appellant amounted to an “application to take some step in aid of execution” within the meaning of that Article.

The court construed Article 182(5) as classifying two kinds of matters together: (a) an application for execution and (b) an application to take some step in aid of execution. The court explained that the phrase “to take some step in aid of execution” should be understood as referring to an application intended to advance an execution proceeding that is already pending (for example, an application to bring to sale properties already under attachment). In other words, the “aid” is to a proceeding already initiated.

Applying that construction, the court concluded that Ex. E (the counter-statement filed by the appellant denying receipt of the decree amount and opposing the judgment-debtor's petition for satisfaction) was not an application to take a step in aid of execution. The court reasoned that Ex. E did not ask the court to take any step to further execution; even if Ex. E had succeeded, execution would not have been advanced beyond its prior position. The court explicitly aligned this view with a consistent line of decisions of the Calcutta High Court.

The court then disposed of Ex. F and Ex. C succinctly. Ex. F was merely a joint petition to hear E.P. No. 16 of 1918 along with another suit; it was conceded by opposing counsel that Ex. F could not stand if Ex. E failed to save limitation. Ex. C (the plaint under Section 53, Transfer of Property Act seeking to set aside a settlement deed) related to a different remedy (a suit to set aside a deed) and did not relate to the execution petition seeking attachment and sale of immovable property; the court held there was no viable argument that presenting that plaint could be treated as an application in aid of execution of O.S. No. 174 of 1916.

As to the appellant's alternative equitable contention that the period during which E.A. No. 16 of 1918 was pending should be excluded from limitation, the court examined the Calcutta authorities relied upon (notably Lakhan Chunder Sen and related decisions). It accepted the general authority of those decisions but distinguished their facts: in the Calcutta cases the prior decree so long as it stood undischarged effectively suspended the plaintiffs' right to bring the new proceedings, making institution impossible. By contrast, in the present case the pendency of EA No. 16 of 1918 did not bar the appellant from instituting execution proceedings; the appellant may have chosen in policy to await disposal of EA No. 16, but that policy choice does not equate to the absolute suspension of right present in the Calcutta cases. The court emphasized that any equitable relief outside the statutory provisions of the Limitation Act should be granted only where justice and equity clearly require it, which the court found absent here.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The court dismissed the appeal and awarded costs against the appellant.

Direct effect on the parties: the appellant's execution petition remains time-barred; none of Ex. E, Ex. F, or Ex. C qualified as an application "to take some step in aid of execution" within Article 182(5), and the court declined to exclude the period during which E.A. No. 16 of 1918 was pending from the limitation calculation on equitable grounds in the present factual circumstances.

Broader implications: the court applied a narrow and textual construction of Article 182(5), distinguishing between steps taken to advance pending execution proceedings and other types of interlocutory or collateral petitions. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new broad rule beyond this interpretation; it confines its reasoning to the facts and authorities considered.

Disposition: Appeal dismissed with costs (judgment by Sir William Ayling, J.; concurrence by Venkatasubba Rao, J.).

    Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Rajagopala Aiyar

    Sir William Ayling, J. — The sole question for disposal in this appeal is one of limitation. Appellant is the decree-holder in O.S No. 174 of 1916 on the file of the District Munsif of Tiruvadi and the appeal arises out of his execution petition, E.P No. 368 of 1919 filed on 8th October 1919. The decree is dated 2nd May 1916; and the only prior execution petition presented by appellant was dismissed on 7th September 1916. The present application is admittedly time-barred, unless appellant can claim a new starting point for limitation under Art. 182 (5) of the Indian Limitation Act by showing that he applied within 3 years of the prior execution petition “to take some step in aid of execution.”

    There are two petitions (Exs. E and F) and a plaint in another suit (Ex. C) which, as appellant contends, should be regarded as such applications. I shall deal with them in order beginning with Ex. E.

    On 3rd January 1918 the judgment-debtor (respondent) filed a petition E. A. No. 16 of 1918, for entering satisfaction of the decree, which he claimed to have discharged. On this appellant filed a ‘counter statement’ Ex. E dated 1st February 1918, denying receipt of the decree amount, and asking that the petition should be dismissed. (It was eventually dismissed on 16th August 1918 owing to respondent's default).

    It is argued that the entry of satisfaction asked for by respondent would have effectively prevented the execution of the decree and that for this reason the counter statement, Ex. E should be treated as an application to take a step in aid of execution of the decree.

    The argument really amounts to this: that any application which, if successful, would facilitate, execution or present an obstacle being raised to the execution of a decree, whether an application for execution is pending or not should be treated as coming within the words quoted. Such a construction seems to me altogether unwarranted and to fail to give effect to the words of the article. The article classes together an application for execution and an application to take some step in aid of execution: and the latter words appear to be intended to cover an application which is not an initial application for execution but is an application to take some step to advance an execution proceeding, which is already pending, e.g, an application to bring to sale properties already under attachment.

    The petition Ex. E may tend to prevent the Court placing an obstacle in the way of future execution of the decree: but it does not ask the Court to take any step in aid of execution. Supposing it to be successful, execution of the decree is not further advanced than it was before the petition was presented. This is the view which has been consistently taken by the Calcutta High Court (vide Umesh Chunder Dutta v. Soonder Narain Deo, Raghunandan Pershad v. Bhugoo Lall and Raghunundun Misser v. Kallydut Misser), and it is one in which I respectfully concur, as based on the only natural interpretation of the article.

    We have been referred by the learned vakils on both sides to numerous other cases in which the interpretation of this article has been in question. Some of these call for consideration; but I propose to at once eliminate the class which deal with applications made in the course of a pending execution petition of which Abdul Kader Rowther v. Krishnan Malaval Nair, is a fair example, dealing with an application by the decree-holder for adjournment of execution proceedings in order to enable him to produce further evidence which of such applications should be treated as falling within the article has become a very difficult question, to decide, if effect is to be given to all the views expressed in the different judgments. It seems to me, if I may say so with respect, that in some cases the Courts in their anxiety to prevent decree-holders being deprived of the fruits of their decrees by the “technical” plea of limitation have stretched the article to such a point that it has become difficult for the most experienced lawyer (to say nothing of laymen) to say when many decrees will become time-barred. In a matter like limitation certainty is the first desideratum; it matters comparatively little whether a decree-holder is allowed 3 years or 10 to execute his decree as long as he knows for certain when the time allowed him will come to an end.

    But whatever case may be made out for an application made in connection with a pending execution petition as one for taking a step in aid or furtherance of it; an application made at a time when no execution petition is pending stands on an obviously different footing. A man cannot be said to take some step in aid of a petition which has not been initiated.

    The main case relied on by appellant is Laxmiram Lallubhai v. Balashanker Veniram in which it was held that an appeal against an order adjudging the judgment-debtor an insolvent was a step in aid of execution. As a matter of fact in that case an execution petition filed by the objector apparently was pending at any rate at the time the insolvency petition was filed: but apart from this it seems to me, with all respect, that the reasoning of the learned judges does not justify such an extension of the article, and I observe that they expressly say they do not seek to lay down any general principle, and desire to confine their judgment to the unusual facts before them.

    In the other case (Sankaranarayana Pillai v. Puthiya Vettil Thangamma) Ramesam, J. certainly says there is no warrant for the view that an application to take a step in aid of execution should be made “in execution” meaning apparently while an execution is pending. But he gives no reasons, and does not discuss the point: and, with all respect, I feel compelled to dissent.

    I must therefore hold that the counter-petition, Ex. E is not an application to take a step in aid of execution.

    Exs. F and C may be more briefly disposed of. Ex. F is merely a petition by both parties to hear E. P. No. 16 of 1918 along with another suit between the parties (O. S. No. 452 of 1917): and it is conceded that if Ex. E cannot be relied on to save limitation, Ex. F stands in no better position.

    Nor does Ex. C. This is the plaint filed by appellant in the last mentioned suit seeking to set aside a settlement deed executed by respondent in respect of certain immoveable properties as void under Sect. 53 of the Transfer of Property Act. The present execution petition is for attachment and sale of immoveable property, to which that suit had no application. I cannot see how by any stretch of reasoning the presentation of this plaint could be treated as an application to take a step in aid of execution of the decree in O. S. No. 174 of 1916.

    An alternative contention put forward by appellant is that he is entitled to ask that the time during which E. P. No. 16 of 1918 was pending should not be counted against him. This plea does not profess to be based on anything in the Limitation Act: but reliance is placed on the decision of a Bench of three Judges of the Calcutta High Court. Lakhan Chunder Sen v. Madhu Sudan Sen, approved on appeal to the Privy Council; Nrityamoni Dassi v. Lakhan Chandra Sen, in which it appears to have been held that the relaxations of the ordinary law of limitation provided in the Limitation Act are not exhaustive and that in the case then under consideration the plaintiffs were entitled to count in their favour the preiod during which they were precluded from bringing their suit by reason of the existence of a decree in a previous suit which covered the same matter. The authority on the first point may be allowed: but in considering whether any concession should be allowed to the appellant before us, the difference in the facts of the two cases deprives the decision of all force. In that case stress was laid on the fact that the prior decree “so long as it stood undischarged was susceptible of execution at the hands of the present appellants (plaintiffs) and whilst that decree existed it was not open to them in the circumstances to institute a fresh suit for the attainment of the very object which had been successfully attained by them in the previous suit.” For this reason, because the plaintiffs' right to bring the action was absolutely suspended as long as the prior decree remained in force, this period was not allowed to count against him for purposes of limitation.

    In the present case no such consideration arises. The pendency of E.A No. 16 of 1918 was no bar to the institution of execution proceedings by appellant. He may have deemed it good policy not to start fresh proceedings until E.A No. 16 of 1918 was disposed (which happened on 16th August 1918) but that is a very different matter. If relief against limitation is to be allowed in cases not provided for in the Limitation Act, surely this should only be done in cases where justice and equity clearly require it. It is not so here.

    Our attention was also drawn to Muthu Korakki Chetty v. Mahamad Madar Ammal, The decision in that case turned on a construction of Art. 180, Limitation Act, with which we have no concern: but the principle of “suspension” and the question of whether the Privy Council intended to lay down any rule as to the exhaustiveness of the exemptions contained in the Limitation Act were no doubt discussed and were in fact the points raised in the reference. It is sufficient to say that the judgments of all the learned Judges except Sadasiva Aiyar, J., tend against appellants’ contention and that none of them militiate against the view I have expressed above; viz., that even if it is open to us to allow a suspension of time not provided for in the Limitation Act, there is no jurisdiction for doing so here.

    I would dismiss the appeal with costs.

    Venkatasubba Rao, J.—I agree.

    S.SAppeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kuppuswami Chettiar v. Rajagopala Aiyar
    (Dec 22, 1921)