AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant before the court was originally the first defendant in O.S. No. 142 of 1920 (Additional District Munsif's Court, Narsapur) and was earlier the decree-holder in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 (Principal District Munsif's Court, Narsapur), where he obtained a money decree against M. Venkataramanayya on 30 September 1913.

The decree-holder applied to execute the decree in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 by attachment and sale of certain immovable property; the District Munsif ordered attachment on 14 March 1914. Meanwhile Venkataramanayya obtained an ad interim stay of execution from the Appellate Court on 13 March 1914; that stay order was received in the District Munsif's Court on 16 March 1914. An amin reported that attachment had been carried out on 17 March 1914 by affixing a copy of the proclamation on the land, and copies were affixed to notice-boards in the Court-house and Collector's Office on 23 March 1914. The ad interim stay was vacated by the Appellate Court on 15 April 1914 for failure to furnish security.

On 6 October 1914 Venkataramanayya filed M.P. No. 1950 of 1914 under Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code, alleging that the 17 March 1914 attachment (after the Appellate Court's stay) was ultra vires and illegal and praying that the Court cancel the attachment and the sale application. The District Munsif ordered that the attachment be raised and subsequent proceedings quashed. That order was confirmed by the Subordinate Judge on appeal.

The decree-holder preferred a Civil Miscellaneous Second Appeal to the High Court, where a Full Bench ultimately held that an order of attachment made by the Court of first instance after an Appellate Court had made an ad interim stay (but before communication of that stay to the executing Court) is not void, but effective only from the time it is communicated to the first Court. The Full Bench decision is reported as Vevkatachalapathi Rao v. Kameswaramma (1917) I.L.R. 41 M. 151 : 33 M.L.J. 515 (Full Bench).

The Full Bench (as part of the High Court disposal) subsequently allowed the appeal, dismissed the respondent's petition and restored the attachment. Later, purchasers (Gadiraju Venkatappayya and others) alleged by a sale deed dated 27 May 1914 that they had purchased the property and on 26 August 1918 petitioned under Order 21, Rule 58, C.P.C. to raise the attachment on the ground that there was no valid attachment on the properties on the date of purchase. Their petition was dismissed on 31 October 1919.

The purchasers then filed O.S. No. 142 of 1920 (purportedly under Order 21, Rule 63, C.P.C.) seeking to set aside the 31 October 1919 order. Lower Courts dismissed that suit; on second appeal the learned Judge concluded there was no valid attachment in March 1914 and set aside the 31 October 1919 order. The present Letters Patent Appeal was preferred against that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the main question — concerning the validity of the March 1914 attachment and the effect of the High Court's order of 18 December 1917 restoring that attachment — has become res judicata so as to bind the present plaintiffs (the purchasers from the judgment-debtor).
  2. Whether the plaintiffs (purchasers) are bound by the final orders passed in the execution proceedings in O.S. No. 38 of 1912, in particular the High Court order of 18 December 1917 restoring the attachment.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs (the purchasers, "Gadiraju people")

  • They contended there was no valid attachment of the properties on the date of their purchase (27 May 1914), and sought to raise the attachment under Order 21, Rule 58, C.P.C.
  • In O.S. No. 142 of 1920 they advanced contentions including: (a) that there was no valid attachment; (b) that the question was res judicata by reason of the order passed by the High Court on 18 December 1917 (they in fact disputed that binding nature in the courts below); (c) that they were estopped from being bound by the prior proceedings; and (d) that the suit was barred by Section 47, C.P.C. (these were listed among the various contentions raised).

Judgment-Debtor (M. Venkataramanayya)

  • By M.P. No. 1950 of 1914 (filed 6 October 1914 under Section 47, C.P.C.), he alleged that the attachment effected on 17 March 1914 after the Appellate Court had ordered a stay of execution was ultra vires and illegal, and that the decree-holder's application for sale based on that attachment was not maintainable; he prayed that the attachment and sale application be cancelled.

Decree-Holder / Appellant (first defendant in O.S. No. 142 of 1920)

  • The decree-holder initially applied to execute his decree by attachment and sale and contested the challenge to attachment in the District Munsif's Court and on appeal. The decree-holder contested the petition to raise attachment (resulting in dismissal of the petition on 31 October 1919).
  • Before the court in the present Letters Patent Appeal, counsel for both sides raised several points, but the court directed that arguments should be restricted initially to whether the main question had become res judicata by virtue of the High Court order of 18 December 1917; the court heard full arguments on that res judicata question.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vevkatachalapathi Rao v. Kameswaramma (1917) I.L.R. 41 M. 151 : 33 M.L.J. 515 (Full Bench) The Full Bench held that where an Appellate Court makes an ad interim order staying execution without notice to the decree-holder but before its communication to the Court of first instance, an order of attachment made by the latter Court is not void; it is legally valid and effective only from the time it is communicated to the first Court. The court referred to the Full Bench holding and noted that on 18 December 1917 the High Court allowed the appeal, dismissed the respondent's petition and restored the attachment; the present court treated that final order as binding on the plaintiffs.
S'innappan v. Arunachalam Pillai (1917) I.L.R. 41 M. 151 : 33 M.L.J. 515 (Full Bench) Relied upon concerning the question whether the attachment was completed only on 23 March 1914 when copies were affixed in the Court-house and Collector's Office in accordance with Order 21, Rule 54, C.P.C., and the effect of those acts done after the stay was received. The court observed that even if the argument about completion on 23 March were accepted, that would not remove the binding nature of the High Court decision of 18 December 1917 that the attachment was valid and should be restored.
Ram Kirpal Shukul v. Mussumat Rup Kuari (1883) L.R. 11 I.A. 37 : I.L.R. 6 A. 269 (P.C.) Cited as authority for the proposition that orders passed in the course of execution proceedings adjudicating on the rights of the parties are res judicata and cannot be called in question by the parties or their representatives once final. The court relied on this authority (along with others) to support the conclusion that the plaintiffs are bound by the High Court's final orders restoring the attachment.
Mungul Pershad Dichit v. Grija Kant Lahiri (1881) L.R. 8 I.A. 123 : I.L.R. 8 C. 51 (P.C.) Used to support the principle that final orders in execution proceedings operate as res judicata. Referenced by the court to reinforce the binding effect of the prior final orders on the plaintiffs.
Raja of Ramnad v. Velusami Tevar (1920) L.R. 48 LA. 45 : 40 M.L.J. 197 (P.C.) Also cited for the rule that final orders in execution proceedings are res judicata and cannot be questioned later. Invoked to support the court's holding that the plaintiffs are bound by the High Court's prior restoration of the attachment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court limited initial argument to the specific question whether the main issue (validity/effect of the March 1914 attachment) had become res judicata by reason of the High Court's order of 18 December 1917 and whether the plaintiffs (purchasers) were bound by that order. After full argument the court concluded the plaintiffs were bound.

The court's step-by-step legal analysis (as expressly set out in the opinion) proceeded as follows:

  1. Factual foundation: The judgment-debtor (Venkataramanayya) had knowledge of the execution proceedings and related events (including the amin's report of attachment dated 17 March, and the affixing of copies on 23 March), and knew that the ad interim stay was later vacated on 15 April 1914 for failure to furnish security. He nevertheless sold the property on 27 May 1914.
  2. Characterisation of the question: The court treated the dispute over whether the March 1914 acts amounted to a valid attachment as essentially a question arising in the execution of the decree in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 — a matter for the executing Court to decide in its execution department.
  3. Binding nature upon subsequent transferees: The court reasoned that a person purchasing property from the judgment-debtor after such execution proceedings have commenced would prima facie take the property subject to the executing Court's eventual decision as to the effect of those prior proceedings. Allowing the judgment-debtor to neutralise the effects of properly taken execution steps by transferring the property would impair the decree-holder's rights and undermine finality in judicial decisions.
  4. Application of us pendens and related principles: The court applied the doctrine of us pendens by analogy, observing that when proceedings to attach immovable property in execution are pending and actual attachment steps have been taken, a purchaser from the judgment-debtor during that pendency takes subject to the outcome of those proceedings; if the proceedings proved abortive and fresh execution were required after purchase, different considerations would apply, but that was not the present factual matrix.
  5. On the point that attachment was completed only on 23 March (when copies were affixed in Court-house and Collector's Office), the court observed that even if that argument were accepted, it would not detract from the binding effect of the High Court's final order of 18 December 1917 restoring the attachment.
  6. Absence of fraud or collusion: The court noted there was no contention of fraud or collusion in the prior proceedings; indeed one of the plaintiffs admitted acting on behalf of the judgment-debtor's representative. The court found it difficult to accept that the judgment-debtor would have pursued the Section 47 petition after selling the properties, further supporting the inference that plaintiffs were seeking to circumvent earlier decisions.
  7. Reliance on authority: The court invoked established authorities to the effect that orders made in execution proceedings adjudicating rights are res judicata once final and cannot ordinarily be reopened by the parties or their successors.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Allowing the Letters Patent Appeal, the court restored the decision of the Lower Appellate Court and held that the plaintiffs are bound by the final orders passed in the execution proceedings in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 (specifically the High Court's order of 18 December 1917 restoring the attachment).

Direct implications for the parties:

  • The plaintiffs (purchasers under the 27 May 1914 sale) are bound by the High Court's final decision that there was a valid attachment in March 1914 and that the attachment should be restored.
  • The plaintiffs' purchase from the judgment-debtor must be taken to be subject to that attachment; the Letters Patent Appeal succeeds and the decision of the Lower Appellate Court (which had held for the decree-holder) is restored with costs awarded to the appellant here and in the Second Appeal.

Broader implications:

The court emphasized enforcement of the principle that final orders in execution proceedings are res judicata and bind successors in title who purchase subject to the consequences of execution steps already taken; the opinion did not purport to establish a new doctrinal rule beyond applying and reinforcing existing authorities on res judicata and the binding effect of execution orders.

    Kasarabada Venkatachalapathi Rao v. Gadiraju Venkatappayya

    1. The first defendant in O.S. No. 142 of 1920 on the file of the Additional District Munsif's Court of Narsapur is the appellant before us. He was the plaintiff in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 on the file of the Principal District Munsif's Court, Narsapur, wherein he obtained a decree for money against M. Venkataramanayya on 30th September, 1913. He applied to execute his decree in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 by attachment and sale of certain immovable property and on the 14th of March, 1914, the District Munsif passed an order for attachment. In the meantime, M. Venkataramanayya, having filed an appeal against the District Munsif's decree, obtained an ad interim order staying execution, from the Appellate Court on 13th March, 1914. The interim stay order was received in the District Munsif's Court on 16th March, 1914, and before the amin was informed of the order, the amin reported on the 17th March, 1914, that attachment was carried out on that very date (17th of March) by affixing a copy of the proclamation on the land. Subsequently ad interim order was vacated on the 15th of April, 1914, as the judgment-debtor failed to furnish security as required by the Appellate Court. Venkataramanayya filed an application, M.P. No. 1950 of 1914, on 6th October, 1914, under section 47 of the code alleging that the attachment made on 17th March, 1914, after the Appellate Court ordered stay of execution was ultra vires and illegal, and that the application for sale made by the decree-holder on the strength of the said attachment was not maintainable, and he prayed that "the Court may cancel the attachment and the sale application made by the decree-holder". The District Munsif overruled the contentions of the decree-holder and directed that "the attachment in question be raised and all further proceedings following thereon quashed." On appeal the said order was confirmed by the Subordinate Judge. When the appeal was pending, Venkataramanayya died and his widow Kameswaramma was brought in as his legal representative by the Appellate Court. The decree-holder in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 preferred a Civil Miscellaneous Second Appeal to the High Court. There was a reference to the Full Bench in that Civil Miscellaneous Second Appeal. The Full Bench held:

    Where subsequent to an ad interim order for stay of execution

    "made by an Appellate Court without notice to the decree-holder, but before its communication to the Court of first instance, an order of attachment is made by the latter Court, the order of attachment is not void and ineffectual as having been made without jurisdiction, but is legally valid, and that the order is effective only from the time it is communicated to the first Court"
    : Vevkatachalapathi Rao v. Kameswaramma ( 1917) I.L.R. 41 M. 151 : 33 M.L.J. 515 (F.B.).

    2. The case came on for final disposal before the referring Judges (Abdur Rahim and Bakewell, JJ.) and they passed the following judgment in the case on 18th December, 1917:

    The appeal will be allowed, the respondent's petition dismissed, and the attachment restored. The appellant will recover his costs from the respondent throughout.

    3. On the allegation that by a sale deed, dated 27th May, 1914, Gadiraju Venkatappayya and others had purchased the property in question from Venkataramanayya, they (the vendees) filed a petition on 26th August, 1918, under Order 21, Rule 58, Civil Procedure Code, to raise the attachment on the ground that there was no valid attachment on the properties on the date of their purchase. The decree-holder contested the position with the result that the petition was dismissed on 31st October, 1919. The vendees (Gadiraju people) filed O.S. No. 142 of 1920 purporting to be under Order 21, Rule 63, Civil Procedure Code, for setting aside the order passed on the 31st October, 1919, and they made the decree-holder in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 as the first defendant to their suit and Kameswaramma (the widow of the judgment-debtor in O.S. No. 38 of 1912) was made the second defendant. Various contentions were raised by the parties, such as, for example, whether there was a valid attachment of the properties, whether the question was res judicata by reason of the order passed by the High Court on the 18th December, 1917, whether the plaintiffs were estopped from questioning the attachment, and whether the suit was barred by Section 47 of the Civil Procedure Code. Both the Lower Courts having dismissed the suit, the plaintiffs (Gadiraju people) preferred a second appeal to the High Court. The learned Judge who heard the second appeal was of opinion that on the facts disclosed by evidence in the present case there was no legal and valid attachment on the properties, that the plaintiffs who were not parties to the proceedings that came before the High Court in connection with the execution of the decree in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 were not bound by the orders passed therein, and that it was open to the plaintiffs to show that there was no valid attachment on the property when they purchased the same on the 27th of May, 1914. The learned Judge came to the conclusion that after the ad interim stay order passed by the Appellate Court on the 13th of March, 1914, was received in the District Munsif's Court on the 16th March, 1914, no proceedings in execution could be legally taken in the case, and that the attachment which was effected by affixing a notice on the properties on the 17th March, 1914, and on the Court-house and the Collector's Office on the 23rd March, was not merely irregular but illegal and void. Holding that the plaintiffs were not bound by the orders passed against their vendor--the judgment-debtor--after the judgment-debtor had sold the properties to them, the learned Judge reversed the judgments of both the Lower Courts and set aside the order passed in the claim petition on the 31st of October, 1919.

    4. The 1st defendant has preferred this Letters Patent Appeal.

    5. Though several points were sought to be raised before us by the earned Counsel on either side, we thought it advisable to restrict arguments in the first instance to the issue whether the main question has become res judicata by reason of the order passed by the High Court on the 18th December, 1917, and whether the plaintiffs are bound by the said order. After hearing full arguments on that question, we have come to the conclusion that the plaintiffs are so bound, and that it is not necessary to consider the other points raised in the case.

    6. Venkataramanayya, the judgment-debtor in O.S. No. 38 of 1912, must be taken to have had full knowledge of all the proceedings that took place in execution of the decree in that suit, and pending the disposal of the appeal he got an ad interim order of stay of execution on the 13th March, 1914. The further proceedings that took place in the District Munsif's Court in connection with the attachment proceedings also must have been known to him, viz., that the amin reported on the 17th March, 1914, that he had in pursuance of the order passed by the District Munsif on 14th March, 1914, carried out attachment by affixing a copy of the proclamation on the lands on 17th March, 1914, and that similar copies were affixed to the notice-board in the Court-house and in the Collector's Office on 23rd April, 1914, though the stay order passed by the Appellate Court was received in the District Munsif's Court on the 16th of March, 1914. All this is not denied. He also knew that the said ad interim stay order was vacated on 15th April, 1914, by the Appellate Court as he had failed to furnish security as directed by that Court. It is in these circumstances that he sold the property to the Gadiraju people on 27th May, 1914. What the exact effect of the proceedings that had taken place in the District Munsif's Court would be, in the circumstances, is a matter essentially relating to the execution of the decree in O.S. No. 38 of 1912. The judgment-debtor would be bound by the decision of the executing Court as regards the effect of these proceedings, and prima facie any person who claims title under the judgment-debtor after the happening of those events would also be bound by the decision of the executing Court as to the exact effect of those proceedings. The judgment-debtor could not, by transferring the property at that stage, render the decision that may be--and in ordinary circumstances would be--passed by the executing Court as regards the effect of those past events, nugatory as far as the decree-holder is concerned. On the other hand, the purchaser from the judgment-debtor in such circumstances would prima facie take the property only subject to the disabilities they were under when in the hands of the judgment-debtor. When, therefore, the decree-holder sought to proceed further with his execution application which he had already filed in March, 1914, and wanted to bring the property to sale in pursuance of the steps taken by him in March, 1914, the executing Court had to decide whether there was a valid attachment of the properties in March, 1914. The circumstance that the Court was called upon to decide that question formally only after the judgment-debtor has sold the properties to the plaintiffs should not alter the essential nature of the said proceedings, nor take away the jurisdiction of the Court in which the said execution proceedings were then pending to adjudicate on that question; nor is it material that the question came up for consideration on a petition filed by the judgment-debtor. It is clear from that petition (C.M.P. No. 1950 of 1914) that the decree-holder in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 had applied for sale in pursuance of the attachment effected in March, 1914. The Courts had accordingly to consider what exactly would be the effect of the proceedings that had taken place in March, 1914, and the High Court on 18th December, 1917, passed final orders on that question in the following terms:

    The appeal will be allowed, the respondent's petition dismissed, and the attachment restored.

    7. The judgment-debtor's widow was a party to the said proceedings in the High Court, and she could not therefore contest the binding nature of the said decision; but are the present plaintiffs (the vendees from the judgment-debtor under a sale-deed dated in May, 1914) in a better position?

    8. We are not referred to any reported decision directly bearing on the point.

    9. After consideration of the question we have come to the conclusion that they are not.

    10. In our opinion, when proceedings by way of attachment of immovable property in execution of a money decree have been taken by the executing Court in an execution application filed by the decree-holder, any question that might be raised whether the proceedings taken by the Court did amount to a valid attachment or not is one that falls to be decided by the Court in the execution department; any stranger purchasing the property from the judgment-debtor in those circumstances would only take the property subject to the Courts' decision as to the effect of the proceedings actually taken before his purchase. Such purchaser would be bound by the Courts' decision of the question in the execution department though he was not a party to the same. To hold otherwise would be to impair the rights of the decree-holder and to enable the judgment-debtor to set at naught decisions of Courts competent to adjudicate on the rights of parties, and give the go-by to the principle of law giving finality to decisions of Courts in matters properly before them.

    11. The present is not a case where the proceeding pending before the Court is only an execution application to attach property Further proceedings by way of actual attachment had taken place; and the proceedings by way of attachment of the properties in dispute took place in a Court of competent jurisdiction; it was when those proceedings were pending that the present plaintiffs purchased those properties from the judgment-debtor; prima facie they must be taken to have purchased it subject to the result of those proceedings. The principle of the doctrine of Us pendens would apply to such a case. If for any reason the proceedings that were had relating to the properties in question prior to the plaintiff's purchase should prove abortive and infructuous, and the decree-holder had to take entirely fresh execution proceedings after the plaintiff's purchase, then there would be force in the respondents' contention that such fresh execution proceedings would not be binding on them unless they were made parties to the same. On the other hand, it is not open to a party to a proceeding to nullify the effect of proceedings already properly taken with reference to that property by transferring the same to strangers. As already remarked, it does not really matter whether the actual decision of the Courts as to the effect of the past proceedings is given only after the plaintiff's purchase, if the adjudication is really with reference to matters that happened before such purchase and regarding the effect of the legal proceedings that were had prior to the same. To safeguard the purchasers' rights, the purchasers should in such circumstances get themselves impleaded as parties.

    12. To take an analogous case, in a suit to recover money, if questions should arise whether the plaint contained sufficient allegations claiming and justifying a charge, and whether the prayer claiming a charge on certain properties was specific or not, the Trial Court would have to decide those questions by its final judgment and decree, and if the Court should decide the questions in favour of the plaintiff and give him a decree for money charged on the properties mentioned, it would seem that the decision would be binding on a purchaser from the defendant pending suit, though he be not actually a party to the decree. He would not be allowed to show in a subsequent suit that the prior decision was wrong in the absence of fraud or collusion. The case might be different if the plaint was subsequently amended so as to claim a charge on a particular property, after that property had been sold away by the defendant to a stranger.

    13. In the case before us, it is not contended (not even suggested) that the proceedings conducted by the judgment-debtor were not conducted bona fide or that there was any fraud or collusion between the judgment-debtor and the decree-holder in connection with the same. On the other hand, it is admitted by one of the present plaintiffs, when examined as a witness in the present suit, that he was really conducting those proceedings on behalf of the judgment-debtor's representative--the widow. After the sale of the suit properties to the plaintiffs on 27th May, 1914, it is difficult to understand why the judgment-debtor should have troubled himself, and why a petition, CM.P. No. 1950 of 1914, should have been filed on 6th October, 1914, to 'cancel the attachment and the sale application made by the decree-holder.' As remarked by the Lower Appellate Court:

    It seems difficult to avoid the inference that the plaintiffs having been worsted in their attempt to get the attachment set aside by proceedings in the name of Venkataramanayya have hit upon the expedient of a claim petition and the suit to achieve the same object.

    14. It was further argued that the attachment made in March, 1914, should be taken to have been completed only on 23rd March, 1914, when copies of the proclamation were affixed in the Court-house and in the Collector's Office in accordance with the provisions of Order 21, Rule 54, Civil Procedure Code, and as the stay order was perused by the District Munsif on 17th March, 1914, the subsequent acts done on 23rd March, 1914, should be taken to be ultra vires, and that there was no complete and valid attachment in the eye of the law; and the decision of the Full Bench in S'innappan v. Arunachalam Pillai (1917) I.L.R. 41 M. 151 : 33 M.L.J. 515 (F.B.) was relied on. Assuming the argument to be correct, that does not take away the binding nature of the decision passed by this Court on 18th December, 1917, that the attachment was valid and restoring the attachment.

    15. Orders passed in the course of execution proceedings adjudicating on the rights of the parties are res judicata and could not be called in question by the parties or their representatives. When once the said orders become final, that effect could not be sought to be avoided by making allegations that the previous decisions were wrong on the merits because full facts were not placed before the Court or that all available evidence was not let in on the former occasion. See Ram Kirpal Shukul v. Mussumat Rup Kuari (1883) L.R. 11 I.A. 37 : I.L.R. 6 A. 269 (P.C.), Mungul Pershad Dichit v. Grija Kant Lahiri (1881) L.R. 8 I.A. 123 : I.L.R. 8 C. 51 (P.C.) and Raja of Ramnad v. Velusami Tevar (1920) L.R. 48 LA. 45 : 40 M.L.J. 197 (P.C.)

    16. It therefore seems to us that the present plaintiffs are bound by the orders passed by the High Court restoring attachment.

    17. It is a matter for satisfaction that we have been able to reach this result, since there is no doubt that the conduct of the judgment-debtor in getting an interim stay from the Appellate Court (which was finally dismissed as no security was furnished) and then transferring the properties to the plaintiffs who had (there is no doubt) notice of all the proceedings--thus defeating the decree-holder--would surely be reprehensible from the moral point of view.

    18. We accordingly hold that the present plaintiffs are bound by the final orders passed in execution proceedings in O.S. No. 38 of 1912 in which it was held by the High Court in effect that there was a valid attachment in March, 1914, of the properties in dispute, and that the said "attachment should be restored". The plaintiff's purchase from the judgment-debtor in May, 1914, should be taken to be subject to that attachment. Allowing this Letters Patent Appeal, we restore the decision of the Lower Appellate Court with costs here and in Second Appeal.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kasarabada Venkatachalapathi Rao v. Gadiraju Venkatappayya
    (Sep 1, 1931)