1. I am afraid the order of commitment in this case is bad in law. The accused Ramjatan Ahir, an old man of 50, has been sent up on a charge under section 394 of the Indian Penal Code. The case against him is that be robbed Musammat Sitabjan, a prostitute by profession, on the evening of 7th December, 1922, after dark as after getting down from the Railway Station she was going to a village accompanied by one Gharbharan, and after beating both of them carried away from her person a hamuli, a bali and an alwan. The charge is one that was triable by a Magistrate of 1st class, Presidency Magistrate or Court of Sessions. The learned Magistrate, Mr. B.V Bhadkamkar, I.C.S, who committed the accused, is himself a Magistrate of the first class. In his order of commitment he says, “Though the case is of a petty nature, I am committing accused to the Sessions as I am myself a witness of the identification proceedings.” This is the only reason he gives for adopting that course. He does not say that the offence committed was one which, in his opinion, he could not adequately punish. On the other hand, he regarded the crime “of a petty nature” and as such within his competence to pass an adequate sentence. As the case was triable by the learned Magistrate, I think he should have proceeded under section 254 of the Cr PC, which provides that in a case which he is competent to try, if a Magistrate thinks be could adequately punish, he shall frame a charge and proceed with the trial, and be should have committed to Sessions only in case he considered that be could not pass an adequate sentence which in this case he evidently did not think. In any case, he does not express his opinion to that effect. If be felt that by reason of his being a witness in the case he should not himself try it the proper course for him, I think, was to have moved the District Magistrate to transfer it to some other Magistrate, competent to try it and subordinate to him. The ruling in Emperor v. Bindeshri Goshain (1) seems to me in point and governs this case. I, therefore, refer the matter to the Hon'ble High Court with a recommendation that the commitment may be quashed.”
2. Ryves, J.:— I agree with the reasons given by the learned Sessions Judge and quash the commitment to sessions.
3. I send the case back to the District Magistrate of Gorakhpur, who will depute a Magistrate competent to try it other than Mr. Bhadkamkar. Let the papers be returned.
4. Commitment quashed.