Walmsley, J.:— The plaintiffs as muttawalis of certain wakf property brough this suit to recover possession of land belonging to the wakf and for a declaration that a mukarari maurusi lease, dated 30th Aswin 1313, executed by a previous muttawali, their father Jamiruddin, in favour of defendants 1, 2 and 3 was void. The first Court decreed the suit on the ground that the maurasi lease was void. On appeal it was held that the lease was not void if it could be shown that there was urgent necessity for granting it and the case was remanded to the first Court for a finding on that question. This remand was based on the authority of the case of Nemai Chand Adhya v. Mir Golam Hossein (1). On remand, the first Court found that there was no urgent necessity for the lease and, in consequence, it decreed the plaintiff's suit.
2. The lower appellate Court however has reversed this finding, and dismissed the suit and, in consequence, the plaintiffs have preferred this appeal. As already observed, when the case first went before the lower appellate Court it was remanded on the authority of the case of Nemai Chand Adhya v. Mir Golam Hossein and the learned vakil on behalf of the respondents has urged in this Court, first, that case is an authority which we should follow in this appeal and secondly, that there is a finding of fact by the learned Subordinate Judge to the effect that there was urgent necessity for the granting of this lease. I think however that the circumstances of this case are so very different from those of Nemai Chand Adhiya's case that the principles there enunciated have no application whatever here, and with regard to the suggestion that there is a finding of fact by the appellate Court to the effect stated, I cannot agree because it appears to me that the words of the Subordinate Judge simply came to this that he regarded the substitution of a pucca durga for the thatched hut as desirable and prudent.
3. That is not a finding that there was any urgent necessity.
4. Now, if the rule already mentioned is not applicable in the present case then it appears to me clear on the authorities that this lease is void. It is not necessary to do more than to refer to the cases of Jewan Does Sahoo v. Shah Kubeerooddeen (2) and Shoojat Ali v. Zumeerooddeen (3). On the authority of these two cases, I am satisfied that this maurusi lease is void. It is contended however on behalf of the respondents that the finding of the lower appellate Court operates as a retrospective sanction, as effective as a previous sanction by the District Judge, and in support of that suggestion the learned vakil refers to a passage in the case of Nemai Chand Adhya v. Mir Golam Hossein . Again the circumstances are so entirely different that I do not think the remarks there made have any application in the present case.
5. The third point which is raised is this that as the then muttawali Jamiruddin actually received Rs. 400 by way of selami the present muttawalis cannot have the lease set aside without refunding that sum. I take it that the learned Judge of the lower appellate Court found that, as a matter of fact, the sum of Rs. 400 out of the selami was spent by the then muttawali in building a pucca house and I think the present plaintiffs ought to refund that sum. The plaintiffs as muttawalis of the wakf property should refund that sum minus such sum as may be due by the lessees for rent in respect of the leased property and also minus the sum due to the plaintiffs by defendants 1, 2 and 3 by way of the costs of this litigation in all Courts. An account of this sum will be taken by the Munsif and the muttawalis will be entitled to raise such sum by mortgage of the wakf property and pay the amount so raised to defendants 1, 2 and 3, or they can mortgage the property to defendants 1, 2 and 3 to secure the sum found due; the Munsif will fix the rate of interest under the mortgage.
6. This order does not impose any personal liability on the plaintiffs or on the muttawalis of the wakf property in respect of the sum found due. The Munsif after taking the account and determining the sum payable by the plaintiffs will fix a date within which the sum so found due is to be paid or a mortgage to secure the same executed by the muttawalis in favour of defendants 1, 2 and 3.
7. If the sum so found due is not paid within the time fixed or secured by mortgage, defendants 1, 2 and 3 will have a charge for that amount on the wakf property.
Greaves, J.:— I agree.
V.B/R.K
8. Appeal allowed.