Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: M.M. Kumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed under sub-section (5) of Section 15 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 challenging the Appellate Authority, Hoshiarpur's order dated 22.5.2001. The impugned order allowed the landlord-respondent's application to adduce additional evidence on the principles of Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The Appellate Authority directed that a report be obtained from the Rent Controller; the Rent Controller was to record additional evidence of the landlord-respondent, rebuttal evidence of the tenant-petitioner and make such further enquiry as it thought fit, and to submit the report within two months. The Appellate Authority's order provided detailed directions including an opportunity to the respondent and a date for appearance before the Rent Controller (2.6.2001 as recorded in the Appellate Authority’s order). The present petition challenged that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellate Authority under Section 15 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act has jurisdiction to permit adducing of additional evidence in the manner done by the Appellate Authority on 22.5.2001.
  2. Whether the principles of Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure (limiting additional evidence to that which could not with due diligence have been adduced earlier) apply strictly to the Rent Tribunal/Appellate Authority constituted under the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Tenant-Petitioner's Arguments (Shri K.S. Dadwal)

  • Order 41 Rule 27 CPC permits additional evidence only when such evidence could not, with due diligence, have been adduced earlier.
  • Documents now sought to be tendered (ration card, electricity bills and similar papers) were within the landlord-respondent's knowledge and therefore could have been produced earlier; permitting them would allow filling lacunae that existed when the original opportunity to adduce evidence was granted.
  • Relied upon provisions of Order 41 Rule 27 CPC and a decision reported as Balbir Singh v. Balkiar Singh to support this limitation.

Landlord-Respondent's Arguments (Shri P.K. Gupta)

  • The landlord had earlier applied for adducing additional evidence before the Rent Controller; that application was dismissed. Civil Revision No. 5815 of 1999 (Ashok Kumar v. Harcharan Singh) was preferred before this Court but was not pressed; permission was given to challenge the order rejecting the application in appeal (photocopy of the order dated 29.11.1999 placed on record as Annexure “A”).
  • No prejudice would be caused to the tenant because the Appellate Authority considered the additional evidence necessary for pronouncing the order.
  • Order 41 Rule 27 CPC is not applicable strictly to the Rent Tribunal; therefore, the strict limitations under that provision should not constrain the Appellate Authority's exercise of power under sub-section (3) of Section 15 of the Act to call for the Rent Controller’s report and make enquiries.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balbir Singh v. Balkiar Singh, 1993 (1) RCR (Rent) 1 (P&H) : 1983 (1) P.L.R 470 Referenced by tenant's counsel in support of the proposition that under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC additional evidence should be allowed only if it could not with due diligence have been adduced earlier. The opinion records that the tenant relied on this decision. The court's reasoning does not adopt this authority as overriding the statutory powers of the Appellate Authority under the Rent Act.
Ashok Kumar v. Harcharan Singh (Civil Revision No. 5815 of 1999) Referred to by landlord's counsel as a procedural step: an earlier civil revision was filed against an order rejecting an application for additional evidence; permission was given to challenge in appeal. The opinion notes that a photocopy of the order in this matter was placed on record (Annexure “A”) and that the Court had previously permitted the landlord to challenge the order rejecting additional evidence; this factored into the Court's view on not prejudicing the landlord's right to challenge.
Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar, 1987 (1) RCR (Rent) 225 (SC) : 1981 (1) SCC 204 Established that an appellate authority under similar rent-control legislation has, in appropriate circumstances, the jurisdiction to admit additional evidence; appellate authority can have same jurisdiction as trial court to admit additional evidence; sub-section (4) of Section 15 (analogous provision) expressly provides power to make further enquiry. The court quoted this Supreme Court decision at length and relied upon it to hold that the Appellate Authority under the Act had jurisdiction to permit additional evidence and that admission of such evidence may be justified by the facts and pleadings of a particular case.
State of Kerala v. K.M. Charia Abdullah & Co., 1965 (1) SCR 601 Used in the Yudhishter passage: dealt with power under Madras General Sales Tax Act and compared to Income Tax Act provisions, holding that appellate/revisional authority was authorised to make further enquiries or direct enquiries for fair disposal of the appeal. Quoted in the passage from Yudhishter (reproduced in this opinion) to support the view that statutory appellate authorities may be empowered to make such inquiries as thought fit for fair disposal, reinforcing the Appellate Authority's power under the Rent Act.
Gulabbai v. Nalin Narsi Vohra, 1991 (2) RCR (Rent) 453 (SC) : 1991 (3) SCC 483 Referenced as another Supreme Court decision taking a similar view on the power of appellate authorities under rent legislation to admit additional evidence. The opinion cites this decision as supporting authority and relies upon it to conclude that there is no legal infirmity in the impugned order allowing additional evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the submissions of both parties and reached the following conclusions based on the material in the record and applicable legal authorities:

  1. The petition was found to be devoid of merit primarily because this Court had earlier permitted the landlord-respondent to challenge the order rejecting his application for additional evidence; accordingly, the landlord's right could not be further prejudiced by the present challenge to the Appellate Authority's order which the Appellate Authority itself found necessary for pronouncing the order.
  2. The Court observed that the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure do not automatically apply to statutory tribunals created by special statutes. Tribunals are creatures of statute and, with the object of doing justice, may devise their own procedures within the scope of the statute.
  3. The Court relied on sub-section (3) (and referenced sub-section (4)) of Section 15 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, finding that there is ample power vested in the Appellate Authority to call for a report from the Rent Controller and to make such enquiry as it thinks fit — powers which support the Appellate Authority’s direction to record additional evidence and obtain a report.
  4. The Court extensively relied on Supreme Court authority (Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar) which holds that, in appropriate circumstances, an appellate authority under rent-control legislation has the jurisdiction to admit additional evidence and may possess jurisdiction similar to that of the trial court to admit such evidence. The opinion reproduces the Supreme Court's reasoning that where the interest of justice so demands, the appellate authority is justified in admitting additional evidence and that such admission does not necessarily cause prejudice if the parties have opportunity to test and examine the evidence.
  5. The Court also referenced State of Kerala v. K.M. Charia Abdullah & Co. and Gulabbai v. Nalin Narsi Vohra as supportive authorities for the proposition that appellate/revisional authorities have statutory power to make enquiries and admit additional evidence where justified.
  6. On these bases, the Court concluded that there was no legal infirmity in the Appellate Authority's order allowing additional evidence and directing the Rent Controller to record such evidence and submit a report.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Petition dismissed.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The impugned order dated 22.5.2001 of the Appellate Authority allowing the landlord-respondent to adduce additional evidence and directing the Rent Controller to record evidence and submit a report stands upheld by this Court as not suffering from legal infirmity.
  • The parties, through their counsel, were directed to appear before the Rent Controller in accordance with the directions issued by the Appellate Authority (the opinion records a direction that parties appear in accordance with directions issued on 28.2.2003).
  • No new legal principle was formulated by this Court beyond applying and following existing Supreme Court precedents that appellate authorities under rent legislation may admit additional evidence in appropriate circumstances; the decision operates to affirm the Appellate Authority's exercise of its statutory powers in this case.

Disposition recorded in the opinion: "For the reasons stated above, this petition fails and the same is dismissed. Parties through their counsel are directed to appear before the Rent Controller in accordance with the directions issued by the Appellate Authority on 28.2.2003. Petition dismissed."

    Harcharan Singh Petitioner v. Ashok Kumar

    M.M Kumar, J. — This petition filed under sub-section (5) of Section 15 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (for brevity ‘the Act’) challenges the order dated 22.5.2001 passed by the Appellate Authority, Hoshiarpur allowing the application of the landlord-respondent for adducing additional evidence on the principles enunciated in Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for brevity ‘the Code’). The principal ground granting permission to adduce evidence is that the aforementioned evidence is necessary to enable the Court to pronounce the order. For the purposes of adducing additional evidence, a report has been asked for by the Appellate Authority from the Rent Controller who has directed to record the additional evidence of the landlord-respondent, rebuttal evidence of the tenant-petitioner and also to make such further enquiry as it thinks fit. The report is required to be submitted within a period of two months. The Appellate Authority has recorded the following order while allowing the application of the landlord-respondent :

    “Appellant is relying upon the documentary evidence and, therefore, question of fabricating the same does not arise. Selection 15 of the Act gives powers to the Appellate Court in appeal not only to hear the parties, but also if it finds necessary after examining other evidence to pronounce the order, Thus, the powers of the Appellate Authority under the Act are not limited in terms of the provisions of Order 41 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Code. Where the Appellate Authority feels that in fairness and in the interest of justice and for proper adjudication of the main points in case it is necessary that documents of a party be put in the evidence, the order is in accordance with law. In the present case, as the evidence now proposed to be led by the appellant is necessary to enable the court to pronounce order and, therefore, in the interest of justice and fair play, application of the appellant for additional evidence is allowed. It is further ordered that report should be called from the learned Rent Controller in terms of the provisions contained in section 15(3) of the Act. Learned Rent Controller should record the additional evidence as mentioned in the application moved by the appellant and an opportunity should be given by the learned Rent Controller to the respondent. File of the trial court be sent back to the learned Rent Controller who should record the additional evidence of the appellant, rebuttal evidence of the respondent and make such further enquiry as it thinks fit and then submit a fresh report on the basis of evidence already recorded and the evidence now allowed to be recorded as to whether the appellant requires the disputed shop for his own use or not. This report should be submitted within a period of two months. Parties should appear before the learned Rent Controller on 2.6.2001”

    2. Shri K.S Dadwal, learned counsel for the tenant-petitioner has argued that under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code only such additional evidence could be permitted to be adduced which with due diligence and care could not have been adduced by the party. He has further argued that adducing of additional evidence could not be permitted in a case where ration card, electricity bills and other documents are sought to be tendered in evidence because all these documents were well within the knowledge of the landlord-respondent. He further submitted that it would amount to permitting the lacuna to be filled up which might have been left when the opportunity of adducing evidence was granted. He has referred to the provisions of Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code and has also relied upon a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Balbir Singh v. Balkiar Singh, 1993 (1) RCR (Rent) 1 (P&H) : 1983 (1) P.L.R 470.

    3. Shri P.K Gupta, learned counsel for the landlord-respondent has argued that the landlord-respondent had filed an application for adducing additional evidence before the Rent Controller which was dismissed. Against the order of dismissal, Civil Revision No. 5815 of 1999 (Ashok Kumar v. Harcharan Singh) was preferred in this Court by the landlord-respondent which was not pressed but permission was given to him to challenge the order rejecting his application for additional evidence in appeal. Photocopy of the order dated 29.11.1999 passed in Ashok Kumar's case (supra) has been placed on record as Annexure “A”. On the basis of the aforementioned submissions, the learned counsel states that no harm would be caused to the tenant-petitioner because the Appellate Authority felt adducing of additional evidence necessary for the purposes of pronouncing the order. The learned counsel has further argued that the provisions of Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code are not applicable stricto sensu to the Rent Tribunal. Therefore, similar limitations which are imposed by Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code cannot be imposed on the exercise of power on the Appellate Authority. According to the learned counsel there is ample power under sub-section (3) of Section 15 of the Act with the Appellate Authority to ask for the report of the Rent Control ler on any issue and then pronounce the order.

    4. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, I am of the considered view that the instant petition is devoid of merit and is thus liable to be dismissed because once the landlord-respondent has been permitted by this Court to challenge the order declining his application for adducing additional evidence then the right of the landlord-respondent cannot be further prejudiced especially when the Appellate Authority has felt the necessity of adducing additional evidence for the purposes of pronouncing the order. It is well settled that the provisions of the Code would not ipso facto apply to the statutory Tribunals which are creature of a statute. The Tribunal with the object of doing justice can always devise its own procedure. Moreover, under sub-section (3) of Section 15 of the Act there is ample power vested in the Appellate Authority to call for a report from the Rent Controller and make a reference which would of course be in the interest of justice. The question whether the Appellate Authority possesses jurisdiction to permit adducing of evidence fell for consideration of the Supreme Court in the case of Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar, 1987 (1) RCR (Rent) 225 (SC) : 1981 (1) SCC 204. There the provisions of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act. 1973 were considered and their Lordships upheld the order of the Appellate Authority whereby adducing of additional evidence was allowed. The observations of their Lordsh ips in this regard read as under :

    “The appellate authority, it must be mentioned, has normally the same jurisdiction to admit additional evidence as the trial Court if the facts and circumstances so warrant.

    Furthermore, in the instant case Section 15 of the Act deals with the powers of the appellate and revisional authorities under the Act. Sub-section (4) of the said section specifically provides that if necessary, after further enquiry as it thinks fit either personally or through the Collector, the appellate authority shall decide the appeal. Therefore, the appellate authority has by express provision jurisdiction to admit additional evidence. Indeed in this case from the written statement, it appears that the only contention that was sought to be raised was about the extent of the accommodation available to the landlord in the ancestral house of the landlord. The allegation about the alleged sale of the premises near Kabir Bhavan was not clearly spelled out. Therefore, if the interest of justice so demanded, the appellate authority was justified in admitting the additional evidence. The parties in this case had ample opportunity to test the veracity and to examine and submit on the value of such additional evidence. No prejudice could be said to have been caused by admission of such additional evidence. In State of Kerala v. K.M Charia Abdullah and Co., 1965 (1) SCR 601, this Court was dealing with similar power under Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939 and observed at page 610 of the report that but Sub-section (4) of Section 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 which is similar to Section 33(4) of the Income Tax Act, 1922, the Commissioner was authorised for disposing of the appeal to make such further enquiry or to direct the Income Tax Officer to make further enquiry as he thought fit and report upon them. This Court held that it could not be denied that the said sub-section conferred upon the appellate or revising authority power to make such enquiry as it thought fit for fair disposal of the appeal. We are, therefore, clearly of the opinion that in the facts and circumstances of a particular case, the appellate authority has jurisdiction under the Act in question to admit additional evidence. We are further of the opinion that in this case admission of such additional evidence was warranted by the facts and the pleadings in this case. We are satisfied that by such admission of evidence, no prejudice has been caused to the appellant. Indeed reading of the order of the appellate authority makes it abundantly clear that the appellate authority had adverted to all the facts recorded by the Rent Controller and further considered the additional evidence. It is true that in referring to the findings of the Rent Controller, the appellate authority in its order had not specifically referred to the paragraphs of the order of the Rent Controller but that does not mean nor does it indicate that the appellate authority had not considered evidence adduced before the Rent Controller. We are, therefore, unable to sustain the objection urged on behalf of the appellant by Shri Banerji, on admission and consideration of the additional evidence.”

    5. Similar view has been take by the Supreme Court in Gulabbai v. Nalin Narsi Vohra, 1991 (2) RCR (Rent) 453 (SC) : 1991 (3) SCC 483. Therefore, I do not find any legal infirmity in the impugned order of the Appellate Authority.

    6. For the reasons stated above, this petition fails and the same is dismissed. Parties through their counsel are directed to appear before the Rent Controller in accordance with the directions issued by the Appellate Authority on 28.2.2003

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harcharan Singh Petitioner v. Ashok Kumar
    (Feb 13, 2003)