AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 2(b) read with S. 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act
  • Regulation 1971 of F.C New Delhi. Rule 15
  • CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 2(b) read with S. 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act
  • Regulation 1971 of F.C New Delhi. Rule 15
  • CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Sri S.C. Pagaare filed a petition under S. 2(b) read with S. 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act seeking initiation of civil contempt proceedings against respondents for allegedly wilfully disobeying an interim injunction order passed by the Munsif, Jhansi on 31st August, 1985 (Suit No. 561 of 1985). The High Court issued notice only to respondent No. 2, Sri P.K. Vasudeva (Senior Regional Manager, Food Corporation of India), observing that no case of contempt was made out against respondents 1 and 3.

Background facts as stated in the opinion: Sri Pagaare joined the Food Corporation of India in 1958 and progressed through grades to be promoted as Deputy Manager in 1983 in the pay scale of Rs. 1100-50-1600 against a substantive post. His probation period (one year) is recorded to have expired on 23rd August, 1984, and the opinion states it was "not extended" so he stood automatically confirmed by operation of law and regulations. A reversion order (letter dated 26-8-1985) by the Manager (per Estt.) reverted him to Assistant Manager (G) with effect from 26th August, 1985 (afternoon). The petitioner is recorded to have become aware of the reversion order at Jhansi on 30th August (the text records the year as 1983 in one place). He filed a suit in the Munsif's court on 31st August, 1985 (the plaint is quoted in the opinion) claiming declarations and injunctive relief against the reversion.

On the same day the petitioner moved an interim application (11-C) under Order 39 CPC for a stay. The Munsif passed an interim order on 31st August, 1985 directing status quo and fixing 9-9-85 for objection and hearing. Separately, an earlier transfer order dated 23rd August, 1985 by the Zonal Manager (North) transferred the petitioner; subsequent communications (12-9-85 and 5-11-85) directed compliance with the transfer and relieved the petitioner to report for duty at Punjab, with a direction to hand over charge to a named officer failing which disciplinary action would follow. The petitioner contended that the 5-11-85 communication from Sri P.K. Vasudeva disobeyed the Munsif's injunction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether respondent No. 2 (Sri P.K. Vasudeva) wilfully disobeyed the interim injunction dated 31st August, 1985 passed by the Munsif, Jhansi such as to constitute civil contempt.
  2. Whether the order/communication of 5-11-85 directing compliance with an earlier transfer (and relieving the petitioner to report for duty) contravened the interim order of the Munsif and therefore amounted to contempt.
  3. Whether, given the availability of alternative remedies under Order 39, Rule 2-A CPC, it was appropriate for the High Court to exercise its contempt jurisdiction in the circumstances.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Contentions

  • The 5-11-85 order passed by Sri P.K. Vasudeva disobeyed the injunction order passed by the Munsif, Jhansi on 31-8-1985 and therefore constituted civil contempt deserving punishment.

Respondent's Contentions

  • The respondent (through counsel) argued that the stay/injunction purportedly granted by the court below attempted to stay the operation of an order reducing the petitioner in rank and that, by virtue of proviso (b) added by the U.P. State to Order 39, Rule 2 CPC, the court below was not competent to grant such an injunction; any injunction in contravention of the proviso would be void. (The opinion records this argument but observes it was unnecessary to decide it.)
  • Implicitly, the respondent maintained that the 5-11-85 communication only insisted on compliance with the earlier transfer order and did not purport to give effect to the reversion order; therefore it did not disobey the interim order of the Munsif.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Indu Tewari v. Ram Bahadur Choudhary, AIR 1981 All 309 Where an effective and alternative remedy is available, it is not a proper exercise of discretion for the High Court to invoke its jurisdiction under the Contempt of Courts Act. The court relied on this principle to observe that the petitioner had an effective alternative remedy under Order 39, Rule 2-A CPC and should not skip that remedy by initiating contempt proceedings; this supported dismissal of the petition.
Anis Ahmad Ahmad Khan v. State of U.P., 1985 All WC 25 : (1985 All LJ 30) The same view as in Indu Tewari — indicating that contempt jurisdiction should not be invoked where alternative remedies exist. The court noted that the same view had been taken in this authority and treated it as supporting the proposition that alternative remedies should be exhausted instead of initiating contempt proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a fact-driven analysis and applied the following reasoning steps (as stated in the opinion):

  1. Limitation of petition: The High Court had already determined that no case of contempt was made out against respondents 1 and 3; only respondent No. 2 remained before the court.
  2. Examination of the plaint: The court noted the plaint stated the cause of action arose on 30-8-85 when the petitioner heard of the reversion order. The plaint did not challenge the transfer order dated 23-8-85 because the petitioner had no knowledge of that transfer when he filed suit. Therefore the interim injunction order, which was granted on the basis of the plaint, related to the alleged reversion and not to the transfer.
  3. Interpretation of the interim order: The Munsif's direction to "maintain STATUS QUO" was construed as preventing giving effect to the reversion (if it had not already been given effect to) rather than affecting the earlier and separate transfer order which had not been challenged in the plaint or stay application.
  4. Analysis of respondent's 5-11-85 letter: The court observed that Sri P.K. Vasudeva's letter primarily insisted on compliance with the transfer order and directed the petitioner to hand over charge and report for duty in Punjab. The letter did not insist on giving effect to the reversion order; indeed, the respondent's letter continued to designate the petitioner as Deputy Manager (G) in forwarding a copy of the reversion order, which the court treated as evidence that the letter did not operate to give effect to reversion.
  5. Temporal and operative effect of the injunction: The interim injunction granted on 31-8-85 was operative only until the date fixed for hearing (9-9-85) unless extended. The court found the interim order was not extended on 9-9-85 and thus was not operative on 5-11-85 when respondent No. 2 issued his communication. Consequently, there was no disobedience of an operative injunction on 5-11-85.
  6. Withdrawal of underlying suit: The court recorded that the Munsif ultimately rejected the interim application and the petitioner later applied for return of the plaint and withdrew the suit (subject to costs). This further undercut the contention that an operative injunction continued to restrain the respondent when he issued the 5-11-85 communication.
  7. Alternative remedy and discretion: The court emphasized the availability of an effective alternative remedy under Order 39, Rule 2-A CPC and relied on authorities (Indu Tewari and Anis Ahmad Ahmad Khan) to state that it would be improper to exercise contempt jurisdiction where such remedies are available. The court therefore considered it inappropriate for the petitioner to invoke contempt proceedings in these circumstances.
  8. Proviso (b) to O.39, R.2 CPC: The court recorded the respondent's argument that U.P.'s proviso (b) barred injunctions staying reductions in rank and similar orders (rendering such injunctions void). The court stated this point was unnecessary to decide because no case of contempt was made out on the facts.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The contempt petition was dismissed. The court held that no case of civil contempt was made out against respondent No. 2, Sri P.K. Vasudeva, and discharged notices against him.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petition is dismissed and the notices against respondent No. 2 are discharged. The court's factual findings — that the 5-11-85 communication only insisted on compliance with a transfer order and that the interim injunction had ceased to be operative on 9-9-85 — meant there was no actionable contempt.
  • Procedural guidance: The court emphasized that where effective alternative remedies exist (e.g., remedies under Order 39 CPC), a litigant should not bypass those remedies by invoking contempt jurisdiction; the court cited precedent to that effect.
  • No new precedent: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle; it applies existing authorities and resolves the petition on its facts. The court expressly declined to decide the open question concerning the proviso to Order 39, Rule 2 CPC because it was unnecessary to the disposal.

Disposition: Petition dismissed.

    S.G Pagaare v. Zonal Manager, Food Corporation Of India, New Delhi And Others

    1. Sri S.C Pagaare has moved this petition under S. 2(b) read with S. 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act with the prayer that the proceedings for civil contempt be initiated against the respondents and they be punished for having wilfully disobeyed the interim injunction order passed by Munsif, Jhansi on 31st Aug. 1985 in Suit No. 561 of 1985.

    2. This Court on 5th of December, 1985 issued the notices to respondent No. 2 Sri P.K Vasudeva, Senior Regional Manager, Food Corporation of India to show cause why he not be punished for having committed civil contempt and observed that no case of civil contempt is made out against respondents 1 and 3 and as such rejected the petition against respondents 1 and 3. The present petition, therefore, survives only against respondent 2. The facts which have given rise to this petition are briefly put as below Sri S.C Pagaare, joined Food Corporation of India at Bombay in the year 1958 as Assistant Grade-III. Subsequently he was promoted as Assistant Grade-II and after completing five years as A.G-II he was selected and promoted as Assistant Manager (G) in the year 1969. He was elevated to the post of Deputy Manager in the year 1983 in the pay scale of Rs. 1100-50-1600 against a substantive posts. He was to be automatically confirmed as Deputy Manager after completing probation period of one year. His probation period expired on 23rd of Aug. 1984. It was not extended and so he stands automatically confirmed by the operation of law, statutes and circulars. The Manager (per Estt.) acting-for Managing Director reverted Sri Pagaare to the post of Assistant Manager (G) with effect from 26th August, 1985 afternoon in terms of regulation 15(3) of the F.C.I (Staff) Regulation, vide his letter No. PF/P-233.E.I.963 dt/- 26-8-1985. Sri Pagaare came to know about the order of his reversion at Jhansi on 30th August, 1983. He, therefore, on the aforesaid allegation filed Suit No. 4561 of 1985 in the court of Munsif Jhansi on 31st August, 1985 praying following four reliefs:—

    “1. That it be declared that the arbitrary reversion of the plaintiff from the present post of Deputy Manager (General) grade Rs. 1100-1600 to the lower post of Assistant Manager (General) Rs. 650-1200 is quite illegal and unwarranted, ultra vires and against the principle of natural justice.

    2. That a decree of permanent injunction be passed in favour of the plaintiff against the defendant restraining the latter from interfering in the working of the plaintiff as District Manager FCI, Jhansi or Deputy Manager (General) except after giving him sufficient opportunity of being heard and in accordance, with the F.C.I regulations and further the defendant should be restrained from acting and giving effect to the impugned order of reversion.

    3. That any other relief as deemed necessary in the hands of justice be also granted in favour of plaintiff against the defendant.”

    3. On the same day he moved an application (11-C) for stay obviously under O. 39, C.P.C to restrain the defendants from interfering in his working as District Manager (G), Jhansi or withdrawal of his salary as such or giving effect to the impugned order of reversion except otherwise than in accordance with the regulation of the Corporation. The learned Munsif was pleased to pass the following order on the same day:—

    “Since the papers on record reveal that the plaintiff has been working on the post of District Manager (G) since 24-8-1983 and two years have passed, according to Staff Regulation 1971 of F.C New Delhi. Rule 15 relates to the probation. In R. 15(4) it is laid down that an employee who has satisfactorily completed his probation in any post, shall, thereafter, be confirmed. In para 5 of the affidavit (12-C) the plaintiff has adopted the whole plaint on oath. In para 21 of the complaint he has stated that on 23rd August, 1985 he has completed 2 years of probation. Hence now he is protected by R. 15(4) of Staff Regulation. Prima facie case of the plaintiff is proved and balance of convenience is also in favour of the plaintiff.

    4. Issue notice to the defendants fixing 9-9-85 for objection and hearing of 11-C-2 application. Meanwhile the parties are directed to maintain STATUS QUO.”

    5. Sri S.K Sachdeva, Joint Manager (Personnel) acting for Zonal Manager (North) issued an order of transfer and posting of 7 Deputy Manager (G) with immediate effect on 23rd August, 1985, which includes the transfer of Sri Pagaare from U.P to Punjab (Annexure-B to the counter affidavit), Sri A.S Chhabra, Joint Manager (Personnel) vide this letter dt/- 12th Sept. 1985 (Annexure-C to the counter affidavit) relieved the petitioner 1 and four others with immediate effect in compliance to the aforesaid orders of the Zonal Office and advised him to hand over charge to the persons who are posted in their respective places of postings and join their new places of postings. Sri P.K Vasudeva, Senior Regional Manager vide his letter dated 5-11-85 (Annexure-1 to the contempt petition) viewed seriously the fact that Sri Pagaare did not comply with the order dated 23rd August, 1985 passed by the Zonal Manager (North) and order dated 12-9-1985 passed by Sri A.S Chhabra, and directed that Sri Pagaare stands relieved with effect from 8-11-1985 with further directions to report for duty to Senior Regional Manager, Punjab. He was directed to hand over charge to Sri K.K Unni on 8-11-85 positively failing which disciplinary, action will initiated against him.

    6. The petitioner's contention is that the order dt/- 5-11-1985 passed by Sri P.K Vasudeva disobeys the injunction order passed by the Munsif, Jhansi on 31st August, 1985. Hence this petition to punish him for having committed civil contempt by wilfully disobeying the injunction order passed by the learned Munsif.

    7. Annexure-2 is the copy of the plaint filed by Sri Pagaare in the court of Munsif, Jhansi. He has claimed four reliefs which I have extracted in the opening of this judgment. In para 31 of the plaint he says that the cause of action arose on 30-8-85 when he heard about the order of reversion which was not served upon him by that time. It is abundantly clear from the plaint that he simply heard about the order of reversion and rushed to the court of Munsif, Jhansi to seek his remedy against the order of reversion. Though the order of his transfer was passed on 23rd August, 1985 earlier than the order of reversion yet he had no knowledge of the same when he filed the suit. He therefore, could not and has not claimed any relief regarding the order of transfer passed on 23rd August, 1985. The plaint simply gives the grounds making the order of reversion without jurisdiction and illegal. The Munsif has while passing the interim injunction order applied his mind to the facts alleged by the plaintiff-petitioner and prima facie believed that the regulations protected the plaintiff's claim of having been automatically confirmed. It, therefore, leaves no room for doubt that when the learned Munsif directed the parties to maintain status quo he meant to say that the order of reversion alleged to have been passed against the plaintiff should not be given effect to if it had not been given effect to by that time and that the parties should henceforth maintain status quo meaning thereby that in case he has not actually been reverted in pursuance of the order of reversion then he should not be reverted. As there was no allegation either in the plaint or in the application for stay that the plaintiff-petitioner has been transferred and that the transfer order is also illegal and without jurisdiction so the order directing the maintenance of status quo cannot affect the transfer order.

    8. Sri P.K Vasudeva has vide his order (Annexure-1 to the contempt petition) simply insisted that the petitioner should comply with the orders of the Zonal Manager and took a serious view that the orders of transfer passed by Zonal Manager were not being complied with. He, therefore, directed that the petitioner stands relieved with effect from 8-11-86 and shall hand over charge to Sri K.K Unni on that date and report to duty at Punjab, otherwise disciplinary action will be taken against him. Sri Vasudeva, O.P 2, in this letter has Simply insisted that the order of transfer shall be complied with and in doing so he has in no way disobeyed the order passed by the learned Munsif. It is significant to find that though the order of reversion was passed on 26th August, 1985, yet in his letter dt/- 5-11-85 while forwarding the copy of the order, Sri Vasudeva has designated Sri Pagaare as Deputy Manager (General) F.C.I, District Jhansi. This conduct of the Opposite Party 2 shows that even up to 5th Nov. 85 Sri Pagaare was being treated as Deputy Manager (G) in spite of the fact that vide order dt/- 26th of August, 1985 he was reverted to the post of Assistant Manager (G) with effect from the afternoon of the same date. In the result the order dt/- 5-11-85 passed by the Opposite Party 2 simply insists the compliance of the transfer order. It does not in any way insist for the compliance of the reversion order and in no way goes to disobey the injunction order passed by the Munsif, Jhansi.

    9. The learned Munsif vide his order dt/- 31-8-85 issued notices to the defendants fixing 9-9-1985 for objections and hearing on injunction application and directed that meanwhile the parties shall maintain status quo. The interim injunction passed on 31st August, 1985 was not extended on 9-9-1985, fully agree with the learned counsel for the respondent that the interim order passed by the learned Munsif was operative only up to 9-9-1985. Therefore, the order was not operative on 5-11-1985, so the question of disobeying any such order does not arise. It will not be out of place to mention here that ultimately the learned Munsif finally rejected the application for interim injunction on 15-2-1986 and on 17-2-1986 the petitioner moved an application before the Munsif, Jhansi for return of the plaint because he was not willing to pursue the proceedings in that court (Annexure-H to the supplementary counter affidavit) and his prayer was allowed subject to payment of costs to the defendants vide Annexures-H and I to the supplementary counter affidavit. The plaintiff-petitioner has, thus, withdrawn the suit in which the order of interim injunction was passed.

    10. The contempt petition, therefore, deserves to be dismissed on facts for the reasons given above, but before taking leave of the matter I would like to observe that the petitioner had effective alternative remedy of the nature specified under O. 39, R. 2-A of the C.P.C and should not be permitted to skip over that remedy and take resort to initiate the proceedings under the Contempt of Courts Act. In “Smt. Indu Tewari v. Ram Bahadur Choudhary”, AIR 1981 All 309 it has been held that under such circumstances it would not be a proper exercise of discretion on the part of the High Court to exercise its jurisdiction under the Contempt of Courts Act when such an effective and alternative remedy is available to any person. Same view has been taken in “Anis Ahmad Ahmad Khan v. State of U.P,” 1985 All WC 25 : (1985 All LJ 30).

    11. It has been argued by the learned counsel for the respondent that the stay order passed by the court below goes to stay the operation of an order reducing the petitioner in rank and in view of proviso (b) added by the U.P State to O. 39, R. 2, C.P.C the Court below was not competent to pass the stay order and the order passed is without jurisdiction, hence void as clarified in the proviso itself. Proviso (b) added by the U.P State reads as below:—

    “Provided that no such injunction shall be granted—

    (b) to stay the operation of an order for transfer, suspension, reduction in rank, compulsory retirement, dismissal, removal or otherwise termination of service of, or taking charge from, any employee including any employee of the Government, or

    (c) ……………

    and any order for injunction granted in contravention of these provisions shall be void.”

    12. In the instant case no case for civil contempt is made out from the facts as discussed above. It is, therefore, not necessary to discuss in detail and adjudicate this point raised by the learned counsel for the respondent. In the result no case of civil contempt is made out against the respondent No. 2 Sri P.K Vasudeva. The petition is consequently dismissed and notices against O.P No. 2 are discharged.

    13. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.G Pagaare v. Zonal Manager, Food Corporation Of India, New Delhi And Others
    (Oct 23, 1986)