Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • S. 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (for short the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Acts
  • S. 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (for short the Act
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — D.P. Wadhwa, J. (Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a petition under S. 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 seeking cancellation of a registered trade mark. The petitioner alleges long prior use of the trade mark "ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI" (claimed use since 1951 and elsewhere in the opinion as since 1954), with supporting documentary evidence including a packing-carton copyright registration (Registrar of Copyrights Registration No. A-1961/66), sales and advertising, and sales of over Rs. 1 lac. The trade mark complained of was registered in the name of Vaid Prem Sagar Aggarwal, proprietor of M/s. Hindustan Medicines, Aligarh (respondent No. 1). The impugned registration is described in the opinion variously as Registration No. 294966 (stated at the outset and in para 2) and later as No. 294699 (paras 27 and 16). The registration was granted on August 20, 1977, with a date of user given as March 16, 1974, in class 5 for Ayurvedic medical syrup for children for sale in the State of Uttar Pradesh; the registration record stated it gave no right to exclusive use of certain device elements.

Respondent No. 1 filed a written statement raising preliminary objections of res judicata, waiver and acquiescence, and lack of locus standi, relying in part on the fact that the petitioner's earlier application for registration was rejected on opposition by Revti Prasad (owner of an earlier mark "112 SAL KI BURHIA KI GHUTTI"). Issues were framed (see below). Both parties led evidence primarily by affidavit and produced documents. The court heard submissions and decided the framed issues, delivered findings on preliminary objections, additional issues under ss. 31 and 32, and finally allowed the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to have the registered trade mark No. 294966 (also referred to in the judgment at some places as No. 294699) of respondent struck off the register on the grounds mentioned in the amended petition?
  2. Whether the petition is not maintainable for the reasons stated in para 2 of the preliminary objections (waiver/acquiescence)?
  3. Whether the petition is barred by rule of res judicata for the reasons stated in para 4 of the preliminary objections?
  4. Relief.
  5. Additional issue 1: Is the application for rectification maintainable in view of section 31 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958?
  6. Additional issue 2: Is the trade mark of the respondent liable to be struck off in view of section 32 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The petitioner asserted prior and continuous use of the trade mark "ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI" since 1951/1954, with documentary support: bill books, order letters, a copyright registration for packaging (A-1961/66), advertisements (newspapers from 1971 onwards), declarations and other documents.
  • The petitioner claimed extensive sales and advertising and alleged that respondent's registered mark was obtained by concealing material facts and making false statements and that respondent's prior use began only on April 1, 1970 (as alleged by petitioner).
  • He contended respondent's registration was contrary to S.11 of the Act and likely to cause confusion and deception among the public.
  • In support of the petition, counsel for the petitioner relied on authorities discussing the locus standi of a "person aggrieved" and the public interest in the purity of the Register (quotation from Bowen, L.J. in re Powell's Trade Mark), and cited the Bombay High Court decision Kanshiram Surinderkumar v. Thakurdas Deoomal Rohire.

Respondent's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Respondent No. 1 raised preliminary objections that the petition was barred by res judicata and by waiver/acquiescence because the petitioner did not oppose respondent's application before the Registrar (publication in journal No. 660 alleged) and had earlier had his own registration application rejected on opposition by Revti Prasad.
  • Respondent contended the petitioner was not a "person aggrieved" and thus lacked locus standi, arguing that the petitioner's prior application was rejected (counsel referred to Charan Singh v. Ajit Singh).
  • Respondent further argued that the trademark had been in registered use for more than seven years and thus was valid under S.32 of the Act.
  • An objection of a technical nature was raised that the petitioner had not described respondent's mark correctly (dispute over the exact registered mark designation and number).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kanshiram Surinderkumar v. Thakurdas Deoomal Rohire, AIR 1982 Bombay 505 Where identical marks fall within S.11(a), the purity of the Register and public interest may predominate over acquiescence or delay unless substantial injury to the opposite party outweighs public interest. The court cited this decision as supporting the proposition that public interest/purity of the Register is a primary consideration when marks are identical; this supported the petitioner's position on priority and public interest.
Charan Singh v. Ajit Singh and another, (1970) C.L.J. 85 (Punjab & Haryana High Court) Addressed competence under S.56 where the petitioner had applied for registration of his own similar mark and that application had been rejected; discussed distinctiveness and competence of a petitioner to seek expungement. The respondent relied on this case to argue lack of locus standi; the court found the cited judgment not helpful to respondent's contention and did not accept it as barring the present petition.
re Powell's Trade Mark (quotation from Bowen, L.J.), (1983) 10 R.P.C. 195 (C.A.) (as quoted in a textbook) Explains locus standi of a person aggrieved: where an applicant is in the same trade and the registered mark on the Register would limit the applicant's legal rights, the applicant has locus standi; also emphasizes public interest and purity of the Register. The court relied on the proposition (as quoted in textbook of Dr. S. Venkateswarn) to conclude that the petitioner could be a "person aggrieved" and therefore had locus standi to maintain the petition under S.56.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded issue-by-issue and addressed preliminary objections and additional issues before the main issue of cancellation:

  1. Waiver and Acquiescence (Issue No. 2): The court held that failure to file opposition under section 21 of the Act before the Registrar does not bar the right to file a petition under S.56. The court found respondent's waiver/acquiescence argument had "no merit" and decided Issue No. 2 in favour of the petitioner.
  2. Res Judicata (Issue No. 3): The respondent relied on an earlier Assistant Registrar order dated July 5, 1976 rejecting the petitioner's registration application (on opposition by Revti Prasad). The court explained that to invoke res judicata the issues and parties must be the same and the issue must have been directly and substantially in issue earlier. The court found those conditions not satisfied and held Issue No. 3 in favour of the petitioner.
  3. Additional Issue No. 1 (S.31): Section 31 provides that registration is prima facie evidence of validity. The court observed this issue "does not arise" in the present case; counsel did not address it and the issue was struck off.
  4. Additional Issue No. 2 (S.32): Respondent contended that more than seven years of registration conferred protection. The court rejected the contention, noting pendency of the petition does not give the respondent a right under S.32; decided this issue in favour of the petitioner.
  5. Main Issue (Issue No. 1 — entitlement to have respondent's registered mark struck off): The court found on the evidence (bill books, order letters, copyright registration for packaging, advertisements, a declaration dated August 10, 1964, and other documents) that the petitioner had used the trade mark "ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI" well prior to respondent's claimed date of use. The court characterized the two marks as "quite identical." The court rejected respondent's hyper-technical objection concerning the description of the registered mark and observed that the earlier mark "112 SAL KI BURHIA KI GHUTI" of Revti Prasad had been in use since 1939 and was deceptively similar as well. Considering these facts and authorities on locus standi and public interest, the court concluded the petitioner was entitled to relief.

The court therefore allowed the petition, directing removal/cancellation of the impugned registration and explaining limited consequences (see holding).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition under S.56 was allowed and the court directed removal of the impugned registration. The opinion specifically directs that "the trade mark No. 294699 is directed to be removed from the Register of Trade Mark and respondent No. 2 will cancel this trade mark."

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The direct operative consequence ordered by the court is cancellation/removal of the specified registered trade mark from the Register (as cited in the judgment as No. 294699).
  • The court expressly stated that this order "will not in itself entitle the petitioner to ask for registration of his trade mark ASLI BURAIA KI GHUTTI if he is not otherwise entitled" — i.e., cancellation does not automatically confer a right to registration on the petitioner.
  • There was no order as to costs.
  • The opinion does not assert that it establishes a new binding precedent beyond application of existing principles (public interest/purity of the Register and locus standi of a person aggrieved); the court applied those principles to the facts to arrive at the decision.

Notes: The judgment text refers to the impugned registration by more than one registration number (No. 294966 in parts of the opinion and No. 294699 in the operative paragraph). The summary above reproduces the facts and the operative direction as stated in the provided opinion without reconciling those internal inconsistencies.

    Raghubhar Dayal v. Vaid Prem Sagar Aggarwal and Ors.

    JUDGMENT

    D.P. Wadhwa, J.

    1. This is a petition under S. 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (for short the Act for cancellation of the registered trade mark No. 294966 in the name of Vaid Prem Sagar Aggarwal, proprietor M/s. Hindustan Medicines, Aligarh, who is respondent No. 1 in the petition. The case of the petitioner is that he has been carryig on his business of manufacturing and selling an ayurvedic medicinal preparation for children (Ghutti) under the trade mark ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI since the year 1951 and that the packing carton bearing this trade mark was duly got registered by the petitioner with the Registrar of Copyrights under Registration No. A-1961/66. The petitioner then claims that he had sold this Chutti of the value of over Rs. 1 lac and also advertised the said Ghutti under the trade mark ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI through different media of advertising. The complaint of the petitioner is that respondent No. 1 got registered this trade mark by concealing the material facts and making false statements, which trade mark was registered under Registration No. 294966. It is stated that it was only on April 1, 1970, that the respondent started using this trade mark which the petitioner had used extensively and continuously for about 16 years. It is alleged that registration of the aforesaid trade mark in the name of respondent No. 1 is contrary to the provisions of S. 11 of the Act and the same is likely to cause confusion and deception among the public and the trade.

    2. The impugned trade mark was registered on August 20, 1977, in class 5 under No. 294966 as of the date March 16, 1974, in respect of Ayurvedic medical syrup for children for sale in the State of Uttar Pradesh. It was, however, mentioned in the trade mark that registration of the trade mark shall give no right to exclusive use of the device of women and child and device of medicine jar.

    3. The respondent No. 1 in his written statement took many preliminary objections. It was stated that the petition was barred by the principles of res judicata and also barred on the principles of waiver and acquiescence. It was stated that the trade mark 112 SAL KI BURHIA KI GHUTI had been used by Revti Prasad Ghuttiwala of Aligarh and that the petitioner dishonestly and with mala fide intentions and ulterior motives traded upon the goodwill of the 112 SAL KI BURHIA KI GHUTI and that when the petitioner applied for registration of his trade mark, his application was declined by the Registrar of Trade Marks on the Opposition made by Revti Prasad. It was alleged on this ground that the petitioner had no locus standi to file this petition and also that the petition was not maintainable. The Petitioner filed his rejoinder.

    4. On the pleas of the parties, the following issues were framed:

    1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to have the registered trade mark No. 294966 of respondent struck off the register on the grounds mentioned in the amended petition? OPP

    2. Whether the petition is not maintainable for the reasons stated in para 2 of the preliminary objections? OPD

    3. Whether the petition is barred by rule of res judicata for the reasons stated in para 4 of the preliminary objections? OPD

    4. Relief.

    Additional Issues:

    1. Is the application for rectification maintainable in view of section 31 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958?

    2. Is the trade mark of the respondent liable to be struck off in view of section 32 of the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, 1958?

    5. Parties led evidence by means of affidavits. Both the parties filed only their own affidavits apart from filing various documents.

    6. In para 2 of the preliminary objections, in the written statement, respondent No. 1 stated that the petitioner had already availed of the opportunity when the petitioner could file opposition to the application of the respondent for registration of the trade mark. It was stated that the trade mark of respondent No. 1 which was sought to be registered before the Registrar of Trade Marks was duly advertised in the journal and the petitioner was thus fully aware of the factum of the publication of the application of respondent No. 1 in journal No. 660. It was thus contended that the petition was barred under the principles of waiver and acquiescence. To me it appears that this contention has no merit. Failure to file opposition before the Registrar of Trade Marks under section 21 of the Act cannot bar the right of the petitioner to file a petition under S. 56 of the Act. Issue No. 2 is held in favour of the petitioner.

    7. Then, respondent No. 1 refers to an order dated July 5, 1976, passed by the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks on an application of the petitioner seeking registration of the trade mark ASLI BHURIA KI GHUTTI. By this order, the Assistant Registrar rejected the application of the petitioner. This was on the opposition filed by Revti Parsad owner of the trade mark 112 SAL KI BHURHIA KI GHUTTI. On this basis, it is contended that the present petition is barred res judicata. Again, I am afraid, this plea has no merit. To invoke the principles of res judicata the respondent No. 1 had to show that the issue in the present proceeding was directly and substantially in issue before the Assistant Registrar of the Trade Marks and that the parties were also the same in both the proceedings. This is certainly not so in the present case. Issue No. 3 is also held in favour of the petitioner.

    8. S. 31 of the Act says that registration of a trade mark is to be taken as prima facie evidence of the validity thereof. This issue, being additional issue No. 1 does not arise is the present case. Learned counsel for the parties also did not address any arguments on this issue. Accordingly, this issue is struck off.

    9. Mr. Gupta, learned counsel for respondent No. 1 contended that his trade mark has been in vogue for more than last seven years from the date of registration and it has to be taken as valid in all respects. This argument was advanced with reference to S. 32 of the Act. I am afraid, I cannot agree. In the present case, the petition was filed on October 6, 1977, and if it has been pending all this period it does not mean that respondent No. 1 gets any right under this section. I would, therefore, decide additional issue No. 2 in favour of the petitioner.

    10. With reference to issue No. 1, Mr. Aggarwal, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that his use of the trade mark ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTI was much earlier in time. He said that the petitioner was using this trade mark since 1954 and in support of his contention he referred to various documents like bill books, order letters, certificate of copyright, advertisements in news papers or otherwise and declarations from the Registrar of Assurances, Calcutta, which declaration is dated August 10, 1964. The newspapers containing advertisements of the trade mark ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI of the petitioner are from 1971 onwards. In view of all these documents, it could not be disputed that the petitioner was using the trade mark ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI much prior to the date of the user of the trade mark of respondent No. 1 Mr. Aggarwal said that use of the trade mark by respondent No. 1 was likely to cause deception or confusion in the minds of the public and respondent No. 1 was even otherwise disentitled to protection of the court and he, therefore, submitted that respondent No. 1 was not entitled to get his trade mark registered. In support of his contention, he referred to a decision of the Bombay High Court in Kanshiram Surinderkumar v. Thakurdas Deoomal Rohire AIR 1982 Bombay 505.

    11. It was, however, the contention of Mr. Gupta, learned counsel for respondent No. 1, that the petitioner had no locus stands to file the present petition under S. 56 of the Act in as much as, he said, that an application of the petitioner for registration of his trade mark was rejected by the Registrar of Trade Marks on opposition filed by Revti Prasad. Mr. Gupta referred to a decision of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Charan Singh v. Ajit Singh and another (1970 Current Law Journal 85). In this case, there was a petition under section 56 of the Act for cancellation of the trade mark 'Do Chiri' under No. 141359 on agricultural implements. The petitioner had himself applied for registration of his trade mark 'Do Kabutar' which, the court held, clearly implied that even according to the petitioner the use of the birds makes the trade mark distinctive which was entitled to be registered. The court also noticed that products of various manufacturers had come to be known by the bird or the animal which was used as the trade mark in those types of goods. The court, therefore, observed that,-

    It cannot, therefore, be said that the trade mark of respondent 1 was not distinctive in nature when it was got registered or has ceased to be so since its registration because some other manufacturers have started the name of some other bird as a trade mark on their products. The distinctiveness of the trade mark is not lost in this manner. When the petitioner has applied for the registration of his own trade mark in my opinion, he is not entitled to the relief of expunging or varying the entry with regard to the trade mark of respondent 1. This petition is, therefore, not competent under section 56 of the Act, and no other provision of the Act has been brought to my notice under which the petitioner is entitled to any relief.

    I do not think this judgment is of much help to Mr. Gupta in support of his contention that the petitioner in the present case has no locus standi to file the present petition.

    12. It was not disputed that the present petition under S. 56 of the Act was maintainable as such except that it was contended that the petitioner could not be a person aggrieved to bring the present petition. Mr. Aggarwal submitted that the expression person aggrieved is wide enough to include the petitioner in the present case. He said, the petitioner and respondent No. 1 were in the same line of trade and registration of the impugned trade mark was causing him immense damage. He said it was immaterial for the purpose of the present petition that his application for registration of his trade mark had earlier been rejected by the Registrar of Trade Marks which was principally on the ground that a similar trade mark was in use much prior to the date when the petitioner claimed to have started using his trade mark. Mr. Aggarwal also contended that the contest in the present case was not limed to the parties inter-se but the question involved was of public interest. Mr. Aggarwal referred to the following lines in the quotation from the judgment of Bowen, L.J., in re Powell's Tm. (1983) 10 R.P.C. 195 C.A. at page 201) as given in the book of Dr. S. Venkateswarn at page 627 of the Book entitled The Law of Trade and Merchandise Marks:

    Wherever it can be shown, as here, that the Applicant is in the same trade as the person who had registered the Trade Marks, and wherever the Trade Mark, if remaining on the Register, would, or might, limit the legal rights of the Applicant, so that by reason of the existence of the entry on the Register he could not lawfully do that which, but for the existence of the mark upon the Register, he could lawfully do, it appears to me he has a locus standi to be heard as a person aggrieved.

    He also referred to the following passage under the heading 'Public interest' from this book at page 629:

    It is to be remembered that the question is not merely one between the parties concerned, but is one of public interest. The purity of the Register is of much importance to the trade in general, and therefore, if the applicant is a person aggrieved, the fact that he is unmeritorious or fraudulent or had no mark to register will not disqualify him.

    13. In Kanshiram Surinderkumar (supra), the court held that in the case of identical marks falling within S. 11(a) of the Act the question of purity of Register in public interest was a primary consideration as against the question of acquiescence or delay unless the same had caused substantial injury to the opposite party so as to outweigh the question of public interest.

    14. I am of the opinion that the submissions made by Mr. Aggarwal are correct. The two marks, that of the petitioner which was in use earlier to that of respondent No. 1 and the mark of respondent No. 1, are quite identical. It was the contention of Mr. Gupta that in the whole body of the petition, the petitioner did not describe the trade mark of respondent No. 1 correctly. He said, the petitioner had described the trade mark of respondent No. 1 as ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI while in fact if reference is made to the registration of the trade mark of respondent No. 1, his trade mark is ASLI BURHIA KI GHUTTI No. 475. I think, this is a hyper technical objection. The petitioner has referred time and again to the registered trade mark No. 294699 and I do not think anyone was in doubt as to the description of the trade mark of respondent No. 1. This objection of Mr. Gupta is of no avail to him.

    15. I asked Mr. Gupta as to how respondent. No. 1 was able to get registration of his trade mark which admittedly he started using in 1974 when registration of the trade mark of the petitioner which he was using since 1954 was declined by the Registrar of Trade Marks. He submitted that no one filed opposition to his application. Be that as it may, respondent No. 1 has himself brought on record the fact that the trade 112 SAL KI BURHIA KI GHUTI of Revti Prasad was in use since 1939. This mark is certainly deceptively similar to that of respondent. No. 1 as well.

    16. On consideration of all these facts, I would decide issue No. 1 in favour of the petitioner. The petition is, therefore allowed. The trade mark No. 294699 is directed to be removed from the Register of Trade Mark and respondent No. 2 will cancel this trade mark. I may however, state that this order will not in itself entitle the petitioner to ask for registration of his trade mark ASLI BURAIA KI GHUTTI if he is not otherwise entitled. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raghubhar Dayal v. Vaid Prem Sagar Aggarwal and Ors.
    (Jul 22, 1985)