Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 236 read with Section 237
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • S. 236 read with Section 237

    Dastarali Accused v. Emperor Opposite Party.

    Suhrawardy, J.:— The accused Dastarali was tried with six others, charged under S. 467/34, 193/34 and 471, I.P.C The case for the prosecution was that the deed in question was fabricated by all these persons. It was executed in favour of the first three accused Dastarali, Wafiz Sheikh and Bhadurali and written and witnessed by the other accused. In the course of the trial the learned Judge found that nothing had been proved against accused 2 and 3, Wafiz Sheikh and Bhadurali, and directed the jury, under Section 289 of the Cr PC to return a verdict of acquittal in respect of them. As regards the remaining accused, the jury brought in a verdict of guilty under Ss. 467 and 193, Part. 2, I.P.C against the appellant Dastarali and acquitted the other accused persons. The learned Judge accepted the verdict and sentenced the accused to two years' rigorous imprisonment under each head, sentences to ran concurrently.

    2. The only point worth considering in this appeal is, whether the convictions under Ss. 467 and 193, I.P.C are correct in law in view of the fact that they were charged with offences under those sections read with S. 34.

    3. It has been argued that if a person is charged with an offence read with S. 34, he could not be convicted of the “substantive” offence. The view does not appear to be correct. By using the words “substantive offence” it is suggested that the offence under S. 34 is a constructive offence. Under S. 34, a person is charged with having committed the offence along with other persons.

    4. If it is proved that the other persons had no hand in committing the offence, but it was committed by the accused himself, or if the prosecution fails to prove that the other persons committed the offence, but succeeds in proving that one of the accused did it or had a part in committing it there does not seem to be any reason why he cannot be convicted for committing the offence himself. As has been observed in the case of Emperor v. Profulla Kumar Mazumdar* . A.I.R 1923 Cal. 453 S. 34 does cut create a new offence but is a rule of law and applies only when a criminal act is done by several persons of whom the accused charged thereunder was one. A person is charged with committing an offence read with S. 34, when he himself commits the offence along with others. In this particular case, the charge ran in these words:

    “That you, on or about the month of Pous 1333 B.S, forged a certain document purporting to be a valuable security, etc.”

    5. The charge of forgery was made against all the persons and S. 34 was added because the offence was said to have been committed by all of them jointly. If S. 34 creates a different offence, the accused may still be convicted of an offence when charged with that offence read with S. 34: vide S. 236 read with Section 237 of the Cr PC. In our opinion, this appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.

    Mallik, J.:— I agree.

    K.N/R.K

    6. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dastarali Accused v. Emperor Opposite Party.
    (Aug 25, 1930)