Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 41 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act
  • Section 5 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act (Act VI of 1908)
  • Section 5 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Section 6(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 41 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act
  • Section 5 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act (Act VI of 1908)
  • Section 5 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Section 6(1)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was brought by the plaintiffs in an ejectment suit. The plaintiffs' ancestor, Alam Mian, obtained a jalsasam patta (Ex. 1) from the landlord of village Damudih on 9th Fagun, 1230 B.S. After preparing a bandh and taking possession of the reclaimed land, he gave the land to defendant No. 1 in khaikhalasi (usufructuary) mortgage for a term of fifteen years ending in 1327. The mortgage was redeemed and, in 1328, when the plaintiffs sought to take possession, defendants Nos. 2 and 3 resisted and claimed to be tenants under defendant No. 1. Defendant No. 1 asserted he had purchased the land in 1292 B.S. under a kabala from the plaintiffs' ancestor and had leased it to defendants Nos. 2 and 3 under a patta dated 11th January, 1906 (Ex. A).

Both lower Courts held that defendant No. 1 was a mortgagee (not a purchaser), that upon redemption the plaintiffs held the jalsasam right, and that defendants Nos. 2 and 3 were non-occupancy raiyats who could only be ejected under Section 41 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act—which had not been complied with—leading to dismissal of the plaintiffs' suit. The plaintiffs appealed, disputing the lower Courts' classification of defendants Nos. 2 and 3 as non-occupancy raiyats.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenancy in question (a jalsasam patta) conferred upon the plaintiffs' ancestor an occupancy right (occupancy raiyat) or created a tenure-holder status leading to non-occupancy raiyat rights for defendants.
  2. Whether a mortgagee in possession (defendant No. 1) had the power to create a lease or tenancy which would endure beyond the term of his mortgage and bind the mortgagor or his successors after redemption.
  3. If the lease to defendants Nos. 2 and 3 was valid, whether the plaintiffs were required to give any statutory notice before seeking khas possession after redemption of the mortgage.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (Plaintiffs)

  • The plaintiffs appealed the dismissal of their ejectment suit and disputed the lower Courts' finding that defendants Nos. 2 and 3 were non-occupancy raiyats.
  • The plaintiffs asserted that upon redemption of the mortgage they held the jalsasam right and were entitled to khas possession of the land.

Respondents (Defendants)

  • Mr. Bose appearing for the respondents contended that the plaintiffs were tenure-holders in respect of the lands in suit (invoking definitions in the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act).
  • Mr. Bose further contended (as recorded) that Section 67 would apply only where a person had been previously a raiyat and later cultivated or held land by korkar.
  • The defendants (Nos. 2 and 3) pleaded that the plaintiffs had no right to the land and that redemption did not confer upon the plaintiffs the position of jalsasam tenancy-holder—effectively repudiating the plaintiffs' title and the landlord-tenant relationship alleged by the plaintiffs.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pareshram Deogharia v. Pratap Udai Nath Sahi Deo Authority supporting that a jalsasam tenancy (korkar/jalsasam) may result in an occupancy right (occupancy raiyat) under the relevant statutory provisions. The Court treated this decision as supporting the conclusion that a jalsasam tenancy cultivated or held by a raiyat can amount to an occupancy holding and relied on it in concluding that the plaintiffs' ancestor acquired an occupancy right.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by analysing legal definitions and the nature of the jalsasam patta and the conduct of the parties.

1. Statutory definitions and approach:

  • The Court referenced the definitions in the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act: a "tenure-holder" per Section 5 and a "raiyat" per Section 6(1). Clause (3) of the relevant section requires regard to local custom and the original purpose of the tenancy when determining whether a tenant is a tenure-holder or a raiyat.
  • The Court observed that unlike the Bengal Tenancy Act (Section 5 thereof), the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act contains no statutory presumption based on area; therefore, area is immaterial except as evidentiary of purpose or use.

2. Evidence and the jalsasam patta (Ex. 1):

  • The jalsasam patta conferred a right to prepare a bandh and to receive as much reclaimed land "as will yield 4 maunds (of crop)" to be possessed by the lessee, heirs and successors; the land was not demarcated by rigid boundaries but allocated from a specified tract.
  • Under the patta and subsequent conduct, the land was reclaimed and cultivated in khas (direct cultivation) by the original holder and later by the mortgagee in possession; there was no evidence the land had been settled with tenants for purposes of collecting rents or establishing tenants.
  • Given the purpose of reclamation and cultivation and the small area (sufficient to yield four maunds), the Court concluded the object was to bring the land into khas cultivation, not to create a tenure for rent collection or tenant-establishment.

3. Application to the parties' statuses:

  • On the foregoing, the Court concluded the plaintiffs' ancestor, as holder of the jalsasam patta, acquired an occupancy right (occupancy raiyat) rather than tenure-holder status; therefore the defendants could not be non-occupancy raiyats created by an occupancy raiyat.
  • The Court relied on Section 3 (definition of korkar/jalsasam) read with Section 67 to support that a jalsasam tenure cultivated/held by a raiyat yields an occupancy holding.
  • The Court rejected Mr. Bose's contention that Section 67 would only apply if the person had earlier been a raiyat and later cultivated by korkar; the point had not been raised in lower Courts and, on the evidence, it did not assist the respondents.

4. Effect of mortgagee's actions and leases (Ex. A):

  • Defendant No. 1 was a mortgagee in possession with a limited interest (term expiring in 1327). While a mortgagee in possession can settle land in management, he cannot create rights that extend beyond his term (i.e., bind the mortgagor or successors after redemption).
  • The patta (Ex. A) under which defendants Nos. 2 and 3 claimed tenancy imposed a fixed annual rent (Rs. 7) and a salami/premium (Rs. 110), and on its face suggested a permanent character. The Court held such a permanent lease would be beyond the mortgagee's power and thus invalid as against the mortgagor's successors; possession of defendants Nos. 2 and 3 would become trespass after redemption.
  • Alternatively, if Ex. A were to be interpreted as creating a tenancy from year to year (an indefinite periodic tenancy), the Court reasoned that such a tenancy created by a mortgagee in possession still could not extend the occupier's right beyond the mortgagee's term by the mortgagee's unilateral act. Moreover, under the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act, leases by a raiyat for more than five years are not recognised (Section 46).
  • The Transfer of Property Act was ruled inapplicable by reason of Section 117 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act, so its presumptions and notices do not govern here.

5. Notice and timing:

  • Paragraph 26 of the plaint alleged the defendants were asked to give up the land before the commencement of 13th Fasli (1921), and the suit was instituted on 10th September, 1922. The defendants did not deny this or raise a notice defence in their written statement; accordingly, even if notice were required, the Court found sufficient notice had been given.
  • Separately, because the defendants repudiated the plaintiffs' title (pleading that the plaintiffs had no right), the Court held that no notice was necessary in that factual context to justify the plaintiffs' claim to possession after redemption.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed. The Court set aside the judgment of the lower Court and decreed the plaintiffs' suit for possession and mesne profits with costs.

DISPOSITION: The plaintiffs are entitled to khas possession; the decree in their favour was granted and the lower Courts' judgments were set aside.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The plaintiffs obtain khas possession and mesne profits; costs were assessed such that all defendants are liable for the costs of the Courts below, and defendants Nos. 2 and 3 alone are liable for the costs of this Court (defendant No. 1 did not enter appearance in this Court).
  • On legal principles, the decision affirms that (on the facts found) a jalsasam patta conferring rights to reclaim and cultivate a small area may create an occupancy right rather than a tenure-holder status; a mortgagee in possession cannot create rights that substantively outlast his limited term such as a permanent lease binding the mortgagor or his successors after redemption.
  • No broader new precedent was explicitly framed by the Court beyond application of existing statutory provisions and the cited authority; the ruling is applied to the facts of this case as described in the opinion.

This summary is confined strictly to the matters and reasoning expressly recorded in the provided opinion. No additional facts, inferences or outside materials have been introduced.

    Jhagru Mian And Ors. v. Raghunath Singh And Ors.

    1. This is an appeal by the plaintiffs in a suit for ejectment. The ancestor of the plaintiffs Alam Mian obtained a jalsasam patta from the landlord of village Damudih on the 9th Fagun, 1230 B.S. (Ex. 1). After preparing a bandh and taking possession of the land granted to him by the aforesaid patta he gave the land to defendant No. 1 in Khaikhalasi (usufructuary) mortgage for a term of fifteen years ending with 1327. The mortgage was redeemed, and in 1328 the plaintiffs went to take possession but were resisted by defendants Nos. 2 and 3 who claimed to be the tenants of the land under defendant No 1. The plaintiffs then asked defendant No. 1 to give them khas possession. He claimed to have purchased the land in 1292 B.S. under a kabala, from the ancestor of the plaintiffs and that be had settled the same with the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 under a patta dated the 11th January, 1906 (Ex. A).

    2. Both the Courts below concurrently held that the defendant No. 1 was not a purchaser of the land in dispute but was merely a mortgagee and after redemption the plaintiffs came to be the holders of the jalsasam right, holding that the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 were non-occupancy raiyats in respect of the lands in dispute. They could not be ejected except under the provisions of Section 41 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act which not having been complied with the plaintiffs are entitled to no relief. Accordingly, the Courts below dismissed the plaintiffs' suit, but they have come up to this Court in appeal and dispute the correctness of the findings of the Courts below as to the status of the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 being that of a non-occupancy raiyat. We have been taken through the provisions of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act and the Settlement Report of Chota Nagpur by Mr. Sifton and of Manbhum by Mr. Gokhale.

    3. Mr. Bose appearing on behalf of the respondents contends that the plaintiffs were tenure-holders in respect of the lands in suit. Now a "tenure-holder" has been denned in Section 5 of the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act (Act VI of 1908) as meaning: "primarily a person who has acquired from the proprietor, or from another tenure-holder, a right to hold land for the purpose of collecting rents or bringin g it under cultivation by establishing tenants on it", and a "raiyat" has been denned in Section 6(1) as meaning "primarily a person who has acquired a right to hold land for the purpose of cultivating it by himself, or by members of his family, or by hired servants, etc".

    4. Clause (3) of that section says

    "In determining whether a tenant is a tenure-holder or a raiyat, the Court shall have regard to--(a) local custom, and (b) the purpose for which the right of tenancy was originally acquired."

    5. In Section 5 of the Bengal Tenancy Act over and above the above considerations for determining whether a tenant sis a tenure-holder or a raiyat the statutory presumption has been raised in favour of a tenant holding land in excess of 100 standard bighas. No such presumption having been provided for in the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act, the question of area becomes immaterial. In the present case the area of the lands in dispute is a small one. No proof of custom has been given as to the tenancy in question being that of a tenure-holder or of a raiyat. The only basis upon which the nature of the tenancy can be determined in this case is the purpose for which the tenancy was created. The use of the land by direct cultivation or by settlement of tenants or collection of rents from them as well as the area of the land, the position of the tenants and other circumstances might be taken into consideration. To my mind, the jalsasam patta (Ex. 1) affords in this case a firm, basis for determining the nature of the tenancy. By this patta right was conferred upon the lessee to prepare a bandh in the mauza in question in a certain tract of land known as sapahigara lying in the southern portion of Mama Damudih out of the lands thus rendered fit for cultivation. The lessee was given as much land "as will yield 4 maunds (of crop)", so that the lessee, his heirs and successors might possess and enjoy the same. The land was not specified by boundaries, but was directed to be given out of the northern portion of that area. In accordance with this lease the plaintiffs' ancestor came into possession of the specific portion of the reclaimed land. This land was given in usufructuary mortgage to defendant No. 1 who, as stated above, leased a portion of it to defendants Nos. 2 and 3. The patta (Ex. A) states that the lessor was in khas possession of the land in dispute and that the land was leased on receipt of salami of Rs. 10 and at a fixed rent of Rs. 7. At the time when the patta was executed the mortgagee was in khas possession of the land, that is to say, was cultivating it himself and presumably the mortgagor was also cultivating it himself. There is nothing to show that the land was ever settled with tenants. The use of the land, therefore, by the original jalsasam holder, the mortgagee and the lessee of the mortgagee, that is, by all the parties concerned, indicates that the object of taking the lease of this land was to bring it in khas cultivation and not for the purpose of establishing tenants thereon. The area of the land being only such a quantity as would yield four maunds would also indicate the same. There is not a single word in the jalsasam patta (Ex. 1) indicating that the land was primarily let out for the purpose of establishing tenants on it. It could not be for the purpose of collecting rents, as at that time the land was not fit for cultivation, and the object of the patta was to have the lands reclaimed and rendered fit for cultivation. The defendants have failed to prove it, and the onus of it undoubtedly lay upon them, that the land in question was let out for such purposes as would create a tenure. The Settlement Reports referred to above do not say that all korkar or jalsasam lands are necessarily tenures and the holder thereof is a tenure-holder. It seems to me that the nature of the tenancy has to be determined according to the evidence in each case, and in the absence of anything to show that the tenancy created was in the nature of a tenure, the definition of the word "korkar" including jalsasam given in Section 3, Clause (xiii) read with the statutory provision in Section 67, would inevitably lead to the conclusion that a jalsasam tenure cultivated or held by a raiyat comes to be an occupancy holding. The tenancy in the present case was admittedly a jalsasam tenancy and consequently the plaintiffs' ancestor acquired a right of occupancy therein. The view is supported by the decision in the case of Pareshram Deogharia v. Pratap Udai Nath Sahi Deo (1). The contention of Mr. Bose that Section 67 would apply only to the case of one who was previously a raiyat and cultivated or held the land by korkar subsequently, does not seem to be substantial. The question was not raised in the Courts below nor was any issue framed as to whether the plaintiffs' ancestor, who acquired the jalsasam right, was not a raiyat at all. Therefore, in no case the contention of Mr. Bose can have any force. The plaintiffs being occupancy raiyats of the land in dispute, the defendants could not be non-occupancy raiyats at all. An occupancy raiyat cannot create a non-occupancy raiyat. Both occupancy and non-occupancy rights are held directly under the landlord or a tenure-holder. The view taken by the Courts below, therefore, that the defendants-respondents were non-occupancy raiyats in respect of the land in dispute, is erroneous and must be set aside.

    6. Now the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 were inducted on the land by defendant No. 1, who had a limited interest therein, namely, that of a mortgagee in possession liable to be redeemed in 1327. As mortgagee in possession no doubt the defendant No. 1 had a right to settle the land in the ordinary course of management, but he could not create any right beyond his own term, that is to say, he could not give a lease either in perpetuity or for a period lasting beyond 1327 when the term of the mortgage expired and the plaintiffs redeemed the mortgage. The patta (Ex. A) does not purport in any way to limit the term of occupancy of the land by the lessees defendants Nos. 2 and 3. The lease was granted on payment of salami or premium of Rs. 110 as a consideration for the lease. The annual rental fixed for ever was Rs. 7 and it was not at all liable to be varied in any circumstance. This would indicate that the lease granted was of a permanent character. That was in excess of the power of the mortgagee to do, and a permanent lessee does not acquire any right to hold the land except under the lease, and the lease is invalid and inoperative so far as the lessor mortgagor is concerned. The possession of the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 was that of a mere trespasser after the redemption of the mortgage. If, on the other hand, the patta (Ex. 1) in this case is capable of an interpretation in such a way as not to be a permanent lease but only for an indefinite period, in such a case the defendants having been brought on the land as tenants in the ordinary course of management by the mortgagee in possession they would not be liable to be objected by the plaintiffs if under any law they acquired the right to remain on the land against the will of the mortgagor. The land was an agricultural one, and the lease granted was for agricultural purposes. The defendants in that case would become under-raiyats under the plaintiffs. But the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act does not require, as the Bengal Tenancy Act does, that an under-raiyat cannot be ejected by a raiyat except by serving him with a notice prior to the termination of the agricultural year. All leases are terminable either by an express agreement between the parties by fixing a term or period of the lease, or if no term is fixed it terminates every year, such as in the case of a tenant from year to year. In the former case, that is, in the case of a fixed term, the lease terminates on the expiry of the term. In the case of a tenant from year to year where no term is fixed, the lessee not having got any intimation of the termination of the lease, the principles of law require that it must be expressly terminated before the expiry of any one year. Giving of notice is not expressly provided for by the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act which governs the present case, and the Transfer of Property Act does not apply to it by reason of Section 117. Therefore, want of notice in the present case will not in itself deprive the right of the plaintiffs after redemption of the mortgage to take khas possession of the land. Although it might be a lease from year to year, the mortgagee had no right to create such a lease as would have the effect of extending the occupation of one brought by him, without the consent of the mortgagor, on to the land. It must be construed to be a lease expiring with the term of the mortgage in 1327, because the Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act in itself does not contemplate of creating an under-raiyat a tenant from year to year. This is expressly forbidden by Section 46 of the Act, which does not recognize the lease by a raiyat for a period exceeding five years.

    7. According to para. 26 of the plaint the defendants were asked by the plaintiffs to give up the land from before the commencement of the year 13th Fasli, that is, 1921 and the suit was brought, a year after on the 10th September, 1922. This is not denied by the defendants, and in fact the defendants do not raise the question of notice in their written statement. Therefore, even if notice was required, the defendants had sufficient notice in the present case.

    8. The defendants in the present case pleaded that the plaintiffs had no right at all to the land in question and did not by redemption acquire the position of the holder of the jalsasam tenancy. In other words, the defendants repudiated the title of the plaintiffs and pleaded non-existence of relationship of landlord and tenant between themselves and the plaintiffs. In this circumstance also no notice was necessary.

    9. The result is that the plaintiffs are entitled to khas possession. The appeal is allowed, and the judgment of the Court below is set aside and the plaintiffs' suit for possession and mesne profits decreed with costs. There will be one set of costs of the Courts below. All the defendants will be liable to the plaintiffs for costs of both the Courts below. As regards the costs of this Court, defendants Nos. 2 and 3 only would be liable, the defendant No. 1 not having entered appearance Wort, J.

    10. I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jhagru Mian And Ors. v. Raghunath Singh And Ors.
    (May 6, 1929)