A. S. No. 291 of 1920: Appellants' Vakil has no instructions. The appeal is dismissed with costs of respondents Nos. 2 to 6 (Costs of papers in A. S. No. 279 of 1920, to be included).
A. S. Nos. 279 and 280 of 1920. Respondent's Vakil reports no instructions and withdraws from the case, which is therefore heard exparte.
The question of limitation is first argued and on that, we think appellant must succeed.
The suit is to set aside a revenue sale and limitation is governed by Art. 12 (b) of Sch. I of the Limitation Act. This allows one year from the time when the sale is confirmed, or would otherwise have become final and conclusive. There is no provision in the Estates Land Act, similar to the one in the Civil Procedure Code, O. 21, R. 92, for confirmation of sale and for the sale thereupon becoming absolute, and consequently the second clause of Art. 12 (b) of the Limitation Act must be applied.
Sect. 124 (2) of the Madras Estates Land Act provides that on payment of the purchase money and, on the expiration of thirty days, the Court shall, if no application has been made to set aside the sale, under Sect. 131, or if such application has been made and rejected, grant a certificate of sale to the purchaser, stating the property sold, the name of the purchaser and the date of sale. From this, it is clear that such a sale would become final, in the absence of any application under Sect. 131, Estates Land Act, thirty days after the date of sale. This suit was brought more than one year after such date in the present case and is therefore barred by limitation. We are supported in this conclusion by the decision in Karuppa v. Vasudeva. This was under the Madras Act, II of 1864, in which Sect. 38 provides that the Collector shall make an order confirming the sale. The absence of this provision in the Estates Land Act makes the present case, so much the stronger.
We may also refer to Bhuban Mohan Maitra v. Girish Narain Moonshi, where a similar view prevailed. In Appeal No. 280 of 1920, there is an allegation in the plaint that a petition was put in by plaintiff to set aside the sale; but Ex. F, shows that this application was really a suit under Sect. 131. The Appeals are accordingly allowed and plaintiff's suits dismissed with costs throughout.
S. S.Appeals allowed.