Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Kali Kumar Saha v. Kali Prasanna Majumdar

    1. This appeal arises out of a suit instituted by the plaintiff in pursuance of the provisions of R. 63, O. 21 of the CPC. The plaintiff had obtained a money-decree against defendant 2 and one other and proceeded to attach a money-decree that defendant 2 had obtained against defendant 3. The decree obtained by defendant 2 against defendant 3 had already been under attachment by two other decree-holders before the date of the plaintiff's money-decree. It appears that between the date of the attachment of the decree by the other decree-holders of defendant 2 and the date on which the plaintiff obtained his decree, defendant 2 had transferred his decree against defendant 3 to defendant 1, who has been the contesting defendant in the suit. On the plaintiff applying for attachment of the decree an objection was raised by defendant 1 on the ground that there had been a valid transfer in his favour by defendant 2. The objection of defendant 1 having been allowed the plaintiff was obliged to institute this suit. The relief sought in the plaint was that a declaration might be made that the plaintiff was entitled to attach the decree in question and that the alienation made by defendant 2 in favour of defendant 1 was inoperative as against the plaintiff. The Munsif, who tried the case, dismissed the suit and in appeal the plaintiff was equally unsuccessful. Hence this appeal to this Court.

    2. The only question that arises in this case is as to the applicability of the provisions of Section 64 of the CPC. On behalf of the respondent it is urged that the transfer by defendant 2 in his favour was made before the plaintiff obtained his decree, and therefore S. 64 of the Code does not apply inasmuch as the plaintiff's claim could not be enforceable for rateable distribution of assets, the decree not being then in existence. S. 64 of the present Code corresponds to S. 27c of the old Code with certain additions by way of explanation to that section, the additions being in view of the principle enunciated in the case of Sorabji Edulji Warden v. Gobind Ramji . 1892 16 Bom 91.. The object of the section is clearly to prevent fraud on decree-holders and to secure intact the rights of attaching creditors as well as of creditors who have obtained their decree and are entitled to satisfaction out of the assets of the judgment debtor.

    3. It is immaterial for the application of S. 64 of the Code whether the decree of the plaintiff had or had not been pissed before the time when the transfer was effected. Under S. 73 of the Cola on his obtaining a decree the plaintiff was entitled to apply for execution and there was no necessity for him to make any application for re-attachment inasmuch as under O. 38, R. 11, no further attachment was necessary. The claim of the plaintiff is clearly supported by the authority of the case of Sorabji Edulji Warden v. Gobind Ramji as well as by the language of S. 64 read with S. 73 and O. 38, R. 11. This appeal, therefore, is decreed with costs in all Courts.

    V.B/R.K

    4. Appeal decreed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kali Kumar Saha v. Kali Prasanna Majumdar
    (Jan 5, 1916)