Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Harekrishna Mallik And Others v. Narsingh Das And Others

    Fazl Ali, J.:— This miscellaneous appeal arises out of an appeal in a money suit which had been instituted by four persons in whose favour a decree was ultimately passed by the Court of first instance. The defendants thereupon appealed and while the appeal was pending, one of the plaintiffs who was respondent No. 4 in the appeal died on 17th August, 1930. As no step was taken within the time allowed by law for substituting the heir of the deceased respondent it was held by the Additional Subordinate Judge in whose Court the appeal was pending, on 17th January, 1931, that the appeal had abated as a whole. Subsequently an application was filed by the appellants asking the Court to set aside the abatement and this application was rejected by the learned Subordinate Judge on 2nd March, 1931. The defendants have now preferred an appeal against the decision of the Subordinate Judge refusing to set aside the abatement and a civil revision against the decision dated 17th January, 1931, by which he held that the whole appeal had abated. Now, it is clear that the civil revision does not lie because, the appeal having in effect been dismissed by the learned Subordinate Judge by reason of his decision that it had abated, a second appeal could have been preferred against his decision and it is clear that where it was possible for the defendants to 1 appeal against the decision of the Subordinate Judge and they have not appealed, they cannot agitate the matter which they might have agitated in appeal by preferring an application in revision. As to the miscellaneous appeal, the learned advocate for the appellants does not challenge the finding of the Subordinate Judge that if there has been an abatement no ground has been made out for setting aside such abatement. What he contends is that in fact there had been no abatement and he bases his contention upon the plaint in which it has been stated that the four plaintiffs “were carrying on business in the name of the firm Gurutoukh Roy Bisseswar Lal.” It is argued that the suit was virtually a suit by a number of partners in a firm and if one of the partners dies in the course of the litigation, the right to sue must be held to survive to the surviving partners. The learned advocate has in support of his contention relied upon the decisions in 21 IC 509(1) and 20 All 365(2). On the other hand reliance has been placed on behalf of the respondents on a decision by a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in 1918 Cal 160(3). The question which we are asked to decide is really as to whether O. 30, R. 4 ought to be construed in the wide manner as suggested in the decision by the Allahabad High Court in 20 All 365 and by the Calcutta High Court in 21 IC 509, or whether the construction placed upon it in the later case of the Calcutta High Court in 1918 Cal 160. Is the construction which should be adopted by us. In my opinion the question as to what should be the rule when several partners bring a suit and one of them dies in the course of the litigation does not arise, because upon reading para. 1 of the plaint it seems to be clear that there was no partnership in existence when the suit was brought. What appears from the plaint is that the four plaintiff's used to carry on business jointly at the time when the loan was taken by the defendants, but, it is conceded by all the parties concerned that there has since been a separation among the plaintiffs who were members of the old firm and that the firm no longer exists. As the learned Subordinate Judge has pointed out, the suit was not brought in the name of the firm but was brought by the plaintiffs in their individual capacity. It appears to me that the rule which would govern a suit brought by partners would not govern the present case. It is contended by the learned advocate for the appellants that under Section 263 of the Contract Act, such a rule would govern the present suit, but I am not prepared to accept this contention. O. 30, R. 4 clearly, provides that rule would apply where two or more persons may sue or be sued in the name of a firm.

    2. Here the firm being no longer in existence, the suit could not have been brought in the name of a firm and in fact was not so brought. It appears to me therefore that the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge was correct and I would dismiss this appeal with costs. The civil revision as dismissed with costs other than the hearing fee.

    3. Macpherson, J.:— I agree that the appeal be dismissed.

    4. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Harekrishna Mallik And Others v. Narsingh Das And Others
    (Dec 20, 1933)