Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: W.P. No. 20852 of 2011 (Decided September 19, 2011)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a registered dealer under the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, manufacturing and selling rolling-shutter parts, iron gates and grills locally and outside the State. The petitioner failed to file returns from March 2010. A show-cause notice dated February 25, 2011 was served directing the petitioner to show cause why his registration certificate should not be cancelled. The petitioner did not reply to that notice. On March 31, 2011 the respondent passed the impugned order cancelling the petitioner's registration certificate. The petitioner initially contended that no notice was issued; the respondent produced the file at a subsequent hearing evidencing service of the February 25, 2011 notice. The petitioner challenged the cancellation by filing the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a registration certificate can be cancelled for non-filing of returns under the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006.
  2. Whether issuance of a show-cause notice suffices as the "opportunity of being heard" required by sub-section (15) of section 39, or whether a personal hearing is required.
  3. Whether the impugned cancellation order dated March 31, 2011 complied with the procedure mandated by the Act and applicable precedent.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner's counsel initially denied that any notice was issued; that denial was later undermined by the respondent's production of the file showing the February 25, 2011 notice.
  • The counsel argued that cancellation of a registration certificate is a "capital punishment" and registration cannot be cancelled merely for non-filing of returns. In support, reliance was placed on section 71(3)(e), section 72(b) and sub-sections (14) and (15) of section 39 of the Act, contending that the Act provides for criminal action, fines and compounding fees for non-filing, but not cancellation of registration for that reason.
  • The petitioner contended that no opportunity of being heard (a personal hearing) was given before cancellation, contrary to sub-section (15) of section 39.

Respondent's Arguments (Special Government Pleader)

  • The respondent produced the departmental file to show that the show-cause notice dated February 25, 2011 was served on the petitioner.
  • Relying on sub-sections (14) and (15) of section 39 of the Act, the respondent contended that the authority which grants registration also has power to cancel, modify or amend a certificate of registration for good and sufficient reasons.
  • As a show-cause notice had been issued and the petitioner did not respond, the respondent maintained that the requirement of opportunity to be heard had been satisfied and the impugned cancellation was justified.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Meera Sahni v. Lieutenant Governor of Delhi (2008) 9 SCC 177 Where an Act prescribes a method or mode to issue an order, that mode must be followed; paragraph 35 addressed the mandatory nature of prescribed procedure. The court applied this precedent to conclude that sub-section (15) of section 39 contemplates a personal hearing distinct from a show-cause notice, and therefore the show-cause notice issued did not satisfy the statutory requirement of being heard.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two principal analytical steps.

  1. Interpretation of statutory power to cancel: The court accepted the respondent's construction of sub-section (14) of section 39, noting the clear wording that "the authority granting the certificate of registration may, by order, for good and sufficient reasons, cancel, modify or amend any certificate of registration granted by it." On that basis the court held that the authority that issues the registration certificate also has the power to cancel it for good and sufficient reasons; the petitioner's contention that cancellation cannot be imposed for non-filing of returns was therefore not accepted as a general prohibition on cancellation.
  2. Procedural requirement of hearing: The court examined sub-section (15) of section 39, which provides that no order under sub-section (14) shall be made unless the dealer has been given an opportunity of being heard. Relying on paragraph 35 of Meera Sahni v. Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, the court emphasized that where the statute prescribes a mode or method for issuing an order, that method must be followed. The court distinguished a show-cause notice from a personal hearing, holding that issuance of a show-cause notice did not amount to the "opportunity of being heard" contemplated by sub-section (15). Because the impugned cancellation order was passed without affording a personal hearing, the court found the statutory condition unsatisfied.

On these bases the court set aside the impugned order dated March 31, 2011 for non-compliance with sub-section (15) of section 39 and remitted the matter to the Assistant Commissioner for fresh consideration in accordance with the procedure required by the Act and Rules.

Holding and Implications

Writ petition disposed in part: the impugned order dated March 31, 2011 cancelling the petitioner's registration certificate is set aside and the matter is remitted to the Assistant Commissioner for fresh consideration after affording the petitioner a personal hearing.

Direct consequences and directions contained in the opinion:

  • The petitioner is granted liberty, within ten days from receipt of a copy of the order, to file his returns from March 2010.
  • Thereafter, the respondent (Assistant Commissioner) is directed to pass orders within four weeks, following the procedure contemplated under the relevant Act and Rules (including providing the personal hearing required by sub-section (15) of section 39).
  • The court directed the petitioner to pay costs of Rs. 2,000 to the Chief Justice Relief Fund within one week; the opinion also states that in the event of the petitioner's failure to pay costs within the stipulated time, the respondent need not re-do the exercise and may proceed further based on the impugned order dated March 31, 2011.
  • The final paragraph of the opinion records that "With the above direction, this writ petition in disposed of No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed." (Both the directions as stated in the text are recorded above without any inference as to reconciliation of the two statements.)

    Indo Germa Products Limited v. Assistant Commissioner (Ct), Thiruvottiyur Assessment Circle, Chennai

    W.P No. 20852 of 2011 and M.P No. 1 of 2011

    Decided on September 19, 2011

    K. Suguna, J.:— This writ petition is filed challenging the order dated March 31, 2011 passed by the respondent herein by which the petitioner's registration certificate has been cancelled.

    2. The case of the petitioner is that he is a registered dealer under the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 (“the Act”, for short) and also under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956; he is a dealer manufacturing rolling shutter parts, iron gates and grills and selling the same, both locally and also outside the State; however, he had not filed the returns from March, 2010 and based on the non-filing of returns, a notice was served on him by proceedings dated February 25, 2011 directing him to show cause as to why his, registration certificate should not be cancelled; but, he had not submitted his reply to the show-cause notice; subsequently, the impugned order cancelling his registration certificate was passed. Initially, a stand was taken by the learned counsel for the petitioner that no notice was issued to the petitioner. But, by producing the relevant file in the last hearing, the learned Special Government Pleader is able to establish that a notice dated February 25, 2011 was served on the petitioner. The said notice is also referred to in the “reference” column of the impugned order dated March 31, 2011 also. Consequently, I am not able to accept this stand of the learned counsel for the petitioner.

    3. The other stand taken by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that as far as cancellation of registration certificate is concerned, it is a capital punishment and registration certificate cannot be cancelled for non-filing of returns. In support of this contention, the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on section 71(3)(e), section 72(b) and also sub-sections. (14) and (15) of section 39 of the Act, 2006, i.e, according to him, as per section 71 of the Act, criminal action can be initiated for non-filing of returns and also fine may be collected; apart from this, as per section 72 of the Act, compounding fee also can be imposed; but, the question of imposing punishment of cancellation of registration for non filing of returns does not arise.

    4. In reply to the above stand of the learned counsel for the petitioner, the stand of the learned Special Government Pleader is that under sub-sections (14) and (15) of section 39 of the Act which reads as follows:

    “(14) The authority granting the certificate of registration may, by order, for good and sufficient reasons to cancel modify or amend any certificate of registration granted by it.

    (15) No application for registration or for a copy or duplicate of the certificate under this section shall be refused and no order under subsection (14) shall be made, unless the dealer concerned has been given an opportunity of being heard.

    for any good reason, registration can be cancelled and according to him the authority having the power to issue certificate of registration, has got the power to cancel the same.

    5. I am inclined to accept this stand of the learned Special Government Pleader since the wordings used in the said section are “the authority granting the certificate of registration may, any order for good and sufficient reasons to cancel, ‘modify’ or amend any certificate of registration granted by it”. As per this, the authority who has got the power to issue, the certificate of registration has also got the power to cancel or modify or amend the certificate of registration. When the wordings in sub-section (14) of section 39 of the Act are very clear to that effect, the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner cannot be accepted.

    6. The other stand of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that as per sub-sections (14) and (15) of section 39 of the Act, an opportunity of being heard should be given, but, no such an opportunity of being heard was given to the petitioner.

    7. But, according to the learned Special Government Pleader, under sub-sections (14) and (15) of section 39 of the Act, an opportunity has to, be given and in the case of the petitioner, already, a show-cause notice dated February 25, 2011 had been issued.; since the petitioner had not responded to the said show-cause notice, the impugned order had been passed. Besides, it is the specific stand of the learned Special Government Pleader that since show-cause notice had been issued to the petitioner directing him to show cause as to why his registration certificate should not be cancelled, the petitioner has to make his submission with regard to the proposed cancellation of registration certificate and the question of again providing an opportunity of being heard does not arise.

    8. I am not able, to accept this stand of the learned Special Government Pleader for the reason that even as per paragraph No. 35 of the judgment of the honourable apex court reported in Meera Sahni v. Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, (2008) 9 SCC 177, when the Act prescribes a method or mode to issue an order, that has to be followed while passing that order. It is an admitted fact that a show-cause notice was issued to the petitioner. But, under sub-section (15) of section 39 of the Act, what is contemplated is a personal hearing. Personal hearing is totally different from show-cause notice. Consequently, though the Department has issued a show-cause notice, that will not amount to granting an opportunity of being heard. Consequently, it has to be held that before passing the impugned order, the condition imposed under sub-section (15) of section 39 of the Act has not been complied with. Hence, on the ground that the condition imposed under sub-section (15) of section 39 of the Act has not been complied with, the impugned order is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the Assistant Commissioner, the respondent herein, who has passed the impugned order.

    9. However, it is ah admitted fact that for the show-cause notice also, the petitioner had not at all responded and he had not even filed his returns also, that too, from March, 2010. But, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner is willing to file his returns and comply with other formalities also. In view of this submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner, within a period of ten days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, the petitioner is at liberty to file his returns from March, 2010 and thereafter, within a period of four weeks, the respondent is directed to pass orders following the procedure contemplated under the relevant Act and Rules. However, in spite of the show-cause notice issued to the petitioner, the petitioner had not responded and besides, a stand has been taken by the petitioner that no opportunity was given to him which is also a false stand even as per the documents enclosed in the typed set of papers. Hence, the petitioner is directed to pay costs of Rs. 2,000 to the Chief Justice Relief Fund within a period of one Week. In the event of the petitioner's failure to pay costs within the stipulated time, the respondent need not re-do the exercise and the respondent is at liberty to proceed further based on the impugned order dated March 31, 2011.

    10. With the above direction, this writ petition in disposed of No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Indo Germa Products ... v. Assistant Commission...
    (Sep 19, 2011)