AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts

    Man Singh Decree-Holder v. Amantaka Prasad Judgment-Debtor .

    1. This is a first appeal by a decree-holder in an execution case. A preliminary decree for sale under O. XXXIV, R. 4 of the CPC, was obtained on the 31st of May 1913 against one Jai Kishore. Several properties ware involved in this decree. One of these properties was put up for sale on the 21st July 1913 in execution of a simple money decree and-was purchased by the respondent, Amantaka Prasad. The final decree for sale under Order XXXIV, Rule 5 of the CPC, was passed on the 6th of January 1914. In applying for execution of this decree the decree-holder named Amantaka Prasad as one of the parsons against whom relief was sought and notice was issued to Amantaka Prasad accordingly. The latter appeared in Court) presenting a petition of objections, in the course of which he did not content himself with alleging that he had been wrongly impleaded in the execution proceedings but claimed further that, by reason of certain events, his purchase was in some way or other binding on the decree-holder, so that the property purchased by him ought not to have been put up for sale. In dealing with this matter the Court below has contented itself with saying that the decree-holder might have impleaded Amantaka Prasad in the interval between the preliminary decree for sale and the decree absolute. As he has not done so, he was not justified in trying to bring Amantaka Prasad on the record as the legal representative of the judgment-debtor in subsequent execution proceedings. The formal order which followed was to the effect that Amantaka Prasad's objection is allowed, and his name be struck, off the application for execution and the execution proceedings. As it stands, this order appears to be one that the property in Mouza Yahiapur involved in Amantaka Prasad's objection should not be put up for sale in execution of the decree. If this be the effect of the order, it seems to us that it was clearly wrong; but we are informed that it has not been interpreted in this sense and the property has actually been sold.

    2. Whether this be so or not, we think it advisable to amend the formal order lest it should give rise to difficulty hereafter. In our view Amantaka Prasad was a purchaser pendente lite pure and simple. Be was liable to the provisions of Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act (IV of 1882) and his purchase could not in any way affect the rights obtained by the present appellant under the preliminary decree for sale. A case in many respects similar to the present, though somewhat stronger, decided by their Lordships of the Privy Council, is that of Faiyaz Husain Khan v. Prag Narain (1). If the appellant now before us has made any mistake, it has been in seeking to implead Amantaka Prasad at all in the execution proceedings. He does not admit that Amantaka Prasad acquired any title under his auction-purchase, and consequently should not have attempted to treat him as the legal reprasantative of the judgment-dabtor. If Amantaka Prasad has chosen of his own accord to come into Court, as a person in possession of property which was in danger of being sold in execution of a decree, and asked the Court to adjudicate on the matter, he might have been entitled to a hearing. As the case stands, ws think that portion of the lower Court's order which simply directed the name of the appellant to be struck off the his of the execution proceedings was correct. We so far allow the appeal that we amend the formal order of the Court by directing that the first few words of that order shall run thus, namely, “that the objections be so far allowed that the name of Amantaka Prasad be struck off, et cetera, et cetera.” In other respects the appeal is dismissed. We leave the parties in this Court to pay their own costs.

    3. Appeal partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Man Singh Decree-Holder v. Amantaka Prasad Judgment-Debtor .
    (Dec 15, 1914)