Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Venkatasami Naidu (Petitioner). v. Gurusami Aiyar ().

    JUDGMENT

    Both the parties in this case attached the property of the same person before judgment in their respective suits against him, and both obtained decrees for money, one in the Court of the District Munsif of Tanjore and the other in that of Velangiman. Both parties applied in the Court of the District Munsif of Valangiman for execution of their respective decrees, but the first application of the respondent was dismissed. The appellant's application resulted in a Court sale in which he purchased the attached property.

    The respondent has now again applied for a sale of the same property in execution of his decree, and the appellant has applied in those proceedings for an order that the application may be dismissed on the ground that he has become the owner of the property.

    It is well established that an attachment confers no interest in the property, which is in custodia legis, and the effect of attachment is to render any private alienation void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment (See Civil Procedure Code Sect. 64 and Krishna Boi v. The Collector and Government Agent Tanjore The attachment does not prevent a transfer of the property under an order of Court, and therefore an order of adjudication in Insolvency which vests the property of the debtor in the Official Assignee is good as against an attaching, creditor (see Raghunath Das v. Sundar Das Khetri, and Errikuldappa Chetty v. The Official Assignee of Madras. This principle is implied in the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code Sect. 73 under which persons who have applied for execution of their decrees are entitled merely to share the assets realised; and it is clear that in the absence of fraud (see O. 21, R. 90) such persons cannot object to the sale of the property of their judgment-debtor by the Court.

    The ownership of the property passed to the appellant from the moment that the sale was knocked down to him, and the judgment-debtor retained no interest in it which can be attached or sold. (See Sect. 65 Civil Procedure Code). It has been stated that proceedings by way of suit are pending to set aside the decree of, and sale thereunder to, the appellant; if those proceedings are successful the respondent may be able to enforce his decree against any interest which thereby becomes vested again in his debtor, but he cannot now sell a merely speculative interest in these proceedings.

    It has been argued that the provisions of O. 21, Rr. 58 to 63, apply to this case, and the heading of the appellant's application referred to them; but we do not think that they apply, because the ground of an application under them is that the property in question is not liable to attachment. In the present case the respondent was originally entitled to attach the property of his debtor, but he is not entitled to proceed to sale because the Court has already disposed of the property.

    It was also objected that the appellant, not being the representative of any of the parties to the suit in which the decree was passed, had no locus standi to make this application under Sect. 47 Civil Procedure Code; but Mr. Jayarama Aiyar withdrew this objection in the course of the arguments, and after the recent Full Bench decision in Veyindramuthu Pillai v. Maya Nadan and we do not think it can be denied that the appellant having purchased the interests of the judgment-debtor is his representative for the purpose of Sect. 47.

    We think that the appeal should be allowed and that the respondent should not be permitted to proceed to the sale of the property in question unless or until the sale to the appellant has been set aside by an order or decree of Court and we order accordingly. The Execution Application is dismissed. Appellant will get his costs here and in the Lower Courts.

    The Civil Revision Petition follows Appeal Against Appellate Order No. 108 of 1918. No orders are necessary.

    S. S.Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Venkatasami Naidu (Petitioner). v. Gurusami Aiyar ().
    (Nov 14, 1919)