Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • s. 76, cl. (1) of the Transfer of Property Act
  • s. 76, cl. (a) of the Transfer of Property Act
  • s. 52 of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • s. 8 of the Transfer of Property Act
  • s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act
  • s. 76, cl. (1) of the Transfer of Property Act
  • s. 76, cl. (a) of the Transfer of Property Act
  • s. 52 of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • s. 8 of the Transfer of Property Act
  • s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act

    Pramatha Nath Bhattacharjya v. Sashi Bhooshan Banerji

    Nasim Ali, J.:— This is an appeal by defendant No. 1 arising out of a suit for khâs possession of about 15 bighâs of land lying in mouzyâ Damra in the district of Bankura. The late Tara Prasanna Basu, the father of defendant No. 5 in the suit, held this mouzâ along with several other mouzâs in patni right. He mortgaged by conditional sale the entire patni to Bipin Bihari Banerji and Jagan Nath Marwari on May 2, 1912. The defendant No. 5 was adjudicated an insolvent on February 21, 1914. Bipin and Jagan Nath instituted a suit for foreclosure on the basis of the mortgage in their favour by Tara Prasanna in the year 1915. During the pendency of the suit Tara Prasanna died, leaving defendant No. 5 as his only legal representative. The latter was substituted in place of the original mortgagor but the receiver of the estate of defendant No. 5 appointed in the insolvency proceeding was not made a party in the mortgage suit. On September 19, 1919, the mortgagees took possession of the mortgage properties on the basis of the final foreclosure decree obtained by them in the suit on the basis of the mortgage. Thereafter the interest of Jagan Nath passed by transfer to Bipin. In 1919, the receiver in insolvency brought a suit for redemption of the mortgage properties. This suit was decreed by the first Court on February 5, 1923. An appeal was taken by Bipin against the decree of the trial Court to this Court and this Court ultimately dismissed the redemption suit on February 26, 1924. The receiver applied for leave to appeal to His Majesty in Council on January 15, 1925, and leave was granted by this Court on February 16 of that year. On May 4, 1926, Bipin granted a mokarari râiyati lease of the disputed lands to the defendant appellant. Their Lordships of the Judicial Committee allowed the receiver's appeal and restored the decree of the first Court on March 3, 1927. Thereafter the receiver deposited the mortgage money in Court and obtained possession of the mortgage properties on February 21, 1928, and realised rent from the tenants including the defendant appellant after taking certain directions, from the Court. The receiver conducted all these litigations with the fund supplied by the plaintiff. On January 30, 1929, he sold 12 annas share of the patni and granted darpatni settlement lease of the remaining four annas share to the plaintiff. On August 21, 1930, the present suit for ejectment was raised by the plaintiff.

    The defence of the defendant appellant, so far as it is relevant for the purposes of the present appeal, is two-fold: (1) that he is a settled râiyat of mouzâ Damra and consequently he has acquired occupancy right in the disputed lands and cannot be ejected, and (2) that the receiver from whom the plaintiff has derived his title having recognised him as a râiyat by receipt of rent, the plaintiff is bound to recognise him as a râiyat and cannot eject him.

    The trial Court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for khâs possession. The plaintiff appealed to the lower appellate Court. The learned District Judge has allowed the appeal and has passed a decree for ejectment against the appellant. Hence this Second Appeal.

    The only point for determination in this appeal is whether the defendant appellant is liable to be ejected from the disputed lands. It is an admitted fact that the appellant is a settled râiyat of mouzâ Damra. Under s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act every person who is a settled râiyat of a village within the meaning of s. 20 has a right of occupancy in all lands for the time being held by him as a râiyat of that village. The question then is whether the appellant was in possession of these lands as a râiyat after obtaining lease of these lands from Bipin in the year 1926. The lease which was granted by Bipin in favour of the appellant was a lease in perpetuity at a fixed rate. The finding of the lower appellate Court is that the transaction is not an act of prudent management as the mortgagee in possession received a large amount, as selâmi and reduced the rent which would be ordinarily payable for the lands of this class by cultivating râiyats. Again this mokarari lease was granted during the pendency of the redemption suit. It is, therefore, hit by s. 52 of the Transfer of Property Act. But this section does not take away the rights of mortgagees in possession under s. 76, cl. (1) of the Transfer of Property Act after the redemption suit is instituted. Bipin therefore had the right to lease the lands in ordinary râiyati right for the period of his possession after the suit for redemption was instituted. It is true that he granted a mokarari lease and it cannot be operative as a mokarari lease. But by s. 8 of the Transfer of Property Act this transfer conferred upon the defendant such right as the mortgagee in possession was then capable of conferring. The appellant therefore acquired a right to cultivate these lands as a râiyat from Bipin in the year 1926 at least for the period during which the latter would continue in possession as mortgagee. He was in fact in possession as a râiyat till the mortgage was redeemed. He is, therefore, not liable to be ejected as he has acquired occupancy right in the lands under s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. This view is supported by the decision of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Mt. Aziz Fatma v. Mukund Lal. Much reliance was placed by the learned advocate for the respondents on a decision of this Court in the case of Madan Mohan Singh v. Rajkishori, Kumari. That case is an authority for the proposition that a lessee from the mortgagor pending the mortgage suit is not entitled to resist the claim for possession of the auction-purchaser in execution of the mortgage decree. In that case, however, the rights of a mortgage in possession under s. 76, cl. (a) of the Transfer of Property Act to execute ordinary râiyati lease on usual terms in the ordinary course of management during the pendency of a redemption suit did not arise for consideration. Further the question of the effect of the provisions of s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act was neither raised nor decided in the case. Again it appears that after the receiver obtained possession of the property through Court and after he received directions from the Court to realise rent from the tenants of the patni mehâl, he actually realised rent from the defendant appellant stating in the rent receipts that the defendant was a tenant in the disputed lands. It is true that in the rent receipts he noted that he was not aware of the real state of affairs so far as the area of the tenancy and the amount of rent payable for the tenancy are concerned. But these remarks do not indicate that he was not receiving the money payable by the defendant as anything but rent for the lands in suit, inasmuch as in the receipt it is clearly indicated that the amount received was rent payable for the jote and the person who was paying the rent was the tenant in respect of that jote. The defendant appellant is, therefore, entitled to remain on the lands as a tenant not only by virtue of s. 21 of the Bengal Tenancy Act but also on account of the recognition of his tenancy by the receiver after he obtained possession through Court. But the plaintiff will be entitled to get fair and equitable rent settled for these disputed lands in an appropriate proceeding on the footing that the appellant is an ordinary occupancy râiyat in respect of the disputed lands.

    The result, therefore, is that this appeal is allowed in the judgments and decrees of the Courts below are set aside. Plaintiff's title to the disputed lands is declared. His prayer for Khâs possession is disallowed. The plaintiff will get a decree for rent for the lands in suit at the rate of Rs. 15 per year for two years, namely, 1335 and 1336 B.S, but this will not preclude the plaintiff from having fair and equitable rent settled for these disputed lands on the footing that the defendant is an occupancy râiyat in respect of these lands for subsequent periods subject to the law of limitation.

    The defendant appellant will get his costs in the Courts below but the parties will bear their own costs in this Court.

    Mitter, J.:— I agree.

    Appeal allowed.
    A.K.D

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pramatha Nath Bhattacharjya v. Sashi Bhooshan Banerji
    (Jan 26, 1937)