Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns title, shares and partition of a house purchased by Kunjabihari but placed in the name of his father, Poornachandra (Poorna), because Kunjabihari served in the police and did not wish acquisition to be known in the district where he served. Kunjabihari predeceased his father (he died in 1912; Poorna died in 1919). In 1925 a deed of partition was executed between the sons of Kunjabihari (on one side) and their uncles Matilal and Biharilal (on the other), which stated that possession of the plaintiff Hemchandra Ganguli and his brother was in respect of a one-third share of the property. The plaintiff instituted a suit in 1928 for partition and possession, asserting that the 1925 partition deed was not registered and that he and his brother were entitled to two-thirds of the property (i.e., that the property was self-acquired by Kunjabihari or otherwise not ancestral to the defendants). Defendants 1 and 2 (the paternal uncles) pleaded that the family was a Hindu joint family and that the property was ancestral, acquired from a common fund.

At trial the subordinate judge found that the disputed land was ancestral and acquired out of the common fund, giving defined shares (the plaintiff and defendant 3 having one-sixth share each). On appeal the District Judge (Court of appeal below) disagreed with some trial findings, held there was a presumption the property was acquired for the family (placing onus on plaintiff to displace that presumption), and upheld the trial decree as to shares, dismissing the plaintiff's appeal on that issue. The present court (the court issuing the opinion summarized here) reviews those conclusions, the factual findings, and the applicable law, and enters final directions including setting aside the decisions and decrees of the courts below and allowing the plaintiff's claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disputed property is ancestral property of the parties, and whether it was acquired out of a common fund (expressed in the record as issue 4: "Is the disputed property ancestral property of the parties? Has it been acquired out of common fund?").
  2. Whether, under the Dayabhaga school of Hindu law, there is a legal presumption that property purchased in the name of the father but funded by a son (where no nucleus of joint family property is proved) is joint family property, placing onus on the son/plaintiff to show it was self-acquired.
  3. Whether certain specified items (a chowchala tin-roofed hut in the outer house and a table mentioned in the plaint) are the plaintiff's self-acquired property and should be excluded from partition.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff (Appellant) / Sons of Kunjabihari

  • The plaintiff pleaded that the 1925 partition deed was not registered and that the agreement was not to come into force before registration; therefore the plaintiff asserted his legal rights afresh in 1928.
  • The plaintiff's case included the position that the family was not a joint Hindu family under the Dayabhaga law but rather a community of persons (father and sons) living jointly and governed by Dayabhaga; implicitly, this supported a claim that the property was self-acquired by Kunjabihari (or at least not ancestral to the defendants) and that the plaintiff and his brother were entitled to two-thirds share.
  • The plaintiff asserted that certain chattels—specifically a chowchala tin-roofed hut and a table—were his self-acquired property and should be kept outside partition.

Defendants 1 and 2 (Paternal Uncles)

  • Defendants 1 and 2 pleaded that the family was a Hindu joint family, that the property in suit had been acquired from common fund contributed by Poorna and his three sons, and that on the father's death each son inherited a one-third share, entitling the uncles to shares claimed as ancestral property.
  • They resisted the plaintiff's claim that the property was self-acquired by Kunjabihari and alleged that the property was ancestral and part of the joint family's assets.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gouranqa Sundar v. Mohendra Narayan, AIR 1927 Cal 776 Under Dayabhaga law, a father-and-sons grouping does not constitute a joint family in the same sense; brothers living in commensality are not treated as members of a joint family for the purpose of treating one brother's acquisitions as joint unless the other brothers contributed to the acquisition. The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that there was no presumption that the property became joint family property merely because funds were supplied by Kunjabihari to Poorna; brothers who did not contribute cannot automatically claim a brother's self-acquisition as joint family property.
Lal Bahadur v. Kanhaiya Lal, 1907 29 All 244 Self-acquired property may become joint property if voluntarily thrown into the joint stock with clear intention of abandoning separate claims; the question of abandonment is one of fact and requires clear intention. Quoted to emphasise that a clear intention to waive separate rights is necessary before treating self-acquired property as joint; the court reiterates that such an intention cannot be lightly inferred.
Suraj Narain v. Batan Lal, AIR 1917 PC 12 Supports the principle that voluntary incorporation of self-acquired property into joint stock requires clear intention and is a factual question. Applied to stress that the finding of abandonment of separate rights must be based on evidence of intention, not mere inference.
Muddun Gopal Lal v. Khihhinda Koer, 1890 18 Cal 341 Affirms that originally self-acquired property may become joint family property if clearly thrown into the common stock. Used to underline the factual nature of proving abandonment of separate title and to caution against inferring jointness without clear evidence.
C. Ethirajulu Naidu v. Govindarajulu Naidu, 1915 32 IC 12 Where there is no nucleus of joint property, property acquired by a member of a joint family is presumed to be his separate property; burden lies on those who assert that it was thrown into the common stock to prove it. The court invoked this authority to conclude there was no presumption in favour of defendants that the property was for the benefit of a joint family, since no nucleus of joint family property was shown.
Abrath v. N.E Ry. Co., 1883 11 QBD 440 General evidentiary principle: where a claim or defence rests upon a negative allegation, the party asserting that negative must prove it; parties are not relieved of the burden by the inconvenient form of the allegation. The court cited this rule to clarify that where a defence or claim involves negative averments, the party asserting the negative bears the burden; used to explain allocation of onus in the present dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining (i) the factual findings at trial, (ii) the reasoning and conclusions of the Court of appeal below (the District Judge), and (iii) established legal propositions under the Dayabhaga school as supported by authorities. The analytical steps were:

  1. Review of trial findings: The trial Court found on the evidence that the disputed land was ancestral and acquired out of the common fund, and also found indications that Kunja (Kunjabihari) intended the property to be family property rather than his separate property.
  2. Review of appellate findings: The District Judge (Court of appeal below) expressed disagreement with some trial findings, adopted the view that there was a presumption favouring defendants 1 and 2 (that the property was acquired for the family despite funds being supplied by Kunja), and placed the onus on the plaintiff to show that Kunja had treated the property as his self-acquired property. The District Judge also characterized distinctions between types of family arrangements under Dayabhaga in a manner the present court found objectionable.
  3. Legal framework under Dayabhaga and evidentiary burdens: The court surveyed authority and treatises showing that under Dayabhaga law (prevalent in Bengal) there cannot be a joint family consisting solely of father and sons in the sense that would automatically convert a son's self-acquisition into joint family property. Brothers living together are not automatically entitled to treat one brother's self-acquisitions as joint property unless they prove contribution. The court emphasised that self-acquired property can become joint only if there is voluntary transfer into the common stock with clear intention to abandon separate rights — a question of fact requiring clear proof.
  4. Application of authorities to the facts: Applying the above legal principles (and specifically citing Gouranqa Sundar and C. Ethirajulu Naidu), the court concluded that where no nucleus of joint property is shown, there is no presumption that property funded by one son but appearing in the father's name is joint property. Consequently, the Court of appeal below was incorrect to place the burden on the plaintiff to disprove jointness. Instead, defendants 1 and 2 (who asserted the property was ancestral and acquired from common fund) bore the onus to prove their defence, which they failed to discharge.
  5. Resolution on shares and partition: On the facts and the court's acceptance of the trial court's core findings (that Kunja intended the property for the family but with evidentiary nuances considered), the court determined that the plaintiff and defendant 3 (the sons of Kunjabihari) are each entitled to a one-third share and to possession on partition; defendants 1 and 2 failed to establish an entitlement to the shares they claimed on the ground of ancestral property.
  6. Specific movable/immovable items: The Court reviewed the cross-objection allowed by the District Judge concerning a chowchala tin-roofed hut and a table. The trial Court had found these to be the plaintiff's separate self-acquired property and excluded them from partition. Because the District Judge provided no reason to reverse those findings and no argument was made before the present court to support that reversal, the court accepted the trial Court's decision and held those items outside partition. The chowchala tin-roofed hut was declared the plaintiff's separate property irrespective of the ground on which it stands (the ground being part of the property to be partitioned under the court's shares decision).
  7. Relief and directions: The court set aside the decisions and decrees passed by the courts below on the principal question of shares, allowed the plaintiff's claim in full, directed that a self-contained decree be drawn incorporating the court's decision, ordered that partition be effected after appointing a Commissioner by the trial Court, and directed that parties bear their own costs up to date (including the costs of this appeal).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL ALLOWED. The court set aside the decisions and decrees of the Courts below on the question of shares and partition. The plaintiff and defendant 3 (sons of Kunjabihari) are each entitled to a one-third share of the property in suit and to possession on partition. The chowchala tin-roofed hut and the table mentioned in the plaint are to be treated as the plaintiff's separate (self-acquired) property and are excluded from partition. A self-contained decree is to be drawn incorporating these directions and a Commissioner is to be appointed by the trial Court to effect partition. The parties are directed to bear their own costs up to the present stage, including the costs of this appeal.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiff's claim is allowed in full; entitlement to one-third share and possession is granted to the plaintiff and his brother (defendant 3). The uncles (defendants 1 and 2) failed to prove entitlement to shares on the basis of ancestral property and thus lose the relief they sought on that ground. Specific items found to be the plaintiff's separate property remain outside the partition.
  • Broader legal implications discussed in the opinion: The court applied established Dayabhaga principles (as cited) to hold that, where there is no nucleus of joint family property shown, there is no presumption that property funded by one son but standing in the father's name is joint family property; the burden to prove that self-acquired property was thrown into the common stock rests on those who assert it. The opinion articulates and applies these legal rules to the facts of this case. The opinion does not state any pronouncement that it is creating a new rule beyond the application of the cited authorities to the facts before the court.

This summary is strictly based on the content of the provided opinion. No additional facts or external inferences have been introduced.

    Hemchandra Ganguli v. Matilal Ganguli .

    1. The facts giving rise to the litigation, in which this appeal has arisen, as accepted by the Court of appeal below, may be briefly enumerated, in view of the matters in controversy between the parties. One Poornachandra Ganguli had three sons, Kunjabihari, Matilal and Biharilal. Poorna, it would appear, was not at all well off, so far as his pecuniary circumstances were concerned, and had to spend a part of his life in his father-in-law's house. Kunja-behari, the eldest son, served in the police department of the Government, and had a decent income; out of his own money he acquired property, which is the subject matter of the present litigation, in the name of his father Poorna, the name of the father having been used for the reason that Kunja's superior officers in the department would have raised objection, had it been known that he was acquiring property within the district in which he was serving. Kunjabihari predeceased his father; Kunja died in the year 1912, while his father Poorna's death took place in the year 1919. The father was dealing with the property as his own, in the sense that he was living in the same, which is a house, till the time of his death; there is lack of evidence to show that Kunjabihari treated the property as his own self-acquired property, and, in point of fact, after the death of Poorna, there was, in the year 1925, a deed of partition between the sons of Kunjabihari on one side and their uncles Matilal and Biharilal on the other, in which it was stated that the possession of the plaintiff, Hemchandra Ganguli, in the suit, out of which this appeal has arisen, and that of his brother was in respect of one-third share of the property. This suit as instituted by the plaintiff in 1928 for partition and possession of the property, to which reference has been made above, was on the footing that the partition deed, drawn up in 1925 mentioned above, was not registered, and the agreement between the parties was that it should not come into force before registration; the plaintiff averred that he subsequently came to realise his own legal position in respect of the property, and was suing in assertion of his and his brother's legal rights in respect of two-thirds share of the property, defendants 1 and 2 being entitled to get the remaining one-third share. The learned District Judge in the Court of appeal below has quoted the plaintiff's own words, in which his case was put before the Court:

    “The family was not a joint Hindu family under the Dayabhaga law, but was a family of persons, father and sons, living jointly, and governed by Dayabhaga law.”

    2. In other words, the family was not a Hindu family under the Dayabhaga school of Hindu law, but it was a community of persons living jointly and governed by the Dayabhaga. On the pleadings of the parties, defendants 1 and 2 in the suit—the paternal uncles of the family—having pleaded that the family was a Hindu joint family, that the property in suit was acquired from common fund of the joint family contributed by Poorna and his three sons, and that, on their father's death, they had inherited a one-third share each in the property, the plaintiff and his brother—the sons of Kunjabihari—being entitled to the remaining one-third share, the material issue raised for trial in the suit was issue 4:

    “Is the disputed property ancestral property of the parties? Has it been acquired out of common fund?”

    3. It would appear that the trial Court was of opinion, on the evidence in the case, that

    “The property in dispute was acquired by Poorna, though in all probability the money was got by Poorna from his son Kunja. The evidence on the plaintiff's side shows that Kunja intended to make his property, property of the family and not his separate property.”

    4. The trial Court, on consideration of the evidence before it, held that

    “The disputed land was ancestral property of the parties, and was acquired out of what is called by the defendants the common fund.”

    5. The shares of the parties were, accordingly, determined; the plaintiff and defendant 3 having a one-sixth share each in the property in suit. On appeal by the plaintiff, the learned District Judge has held, as has already been mentioned, that the property in suit was purchased by Kunjabihari in the name of Poorna. The learned Judge observed that, with regard to actual treatment of the property after its acquisition, there was a great dearth of evidence. He has stated definitely that evidence on the side of defendants 1 and 2 did not prove that the property was not joint family property. The learned Judge has then proceeded to observe that on the side of the plaintiff however there is lack of evidence to show that Kunja ever treated the property as his own self-acquired property. According to the learned District Judge there was a presumption in favour of defendants 1 and 2 that the property was acquired for the benefit of the family, although the money actually was subscribed by Kunja; the onus lay on the plaintiff's side to show that Kunja treated the property as his self acquired property and that onus had not been discharged. In the above view of the case, the decree passed by the learned Subordinate Judge in the trial Court was upheld by the Court of appeal below, and the plaintiff's appeal was dismissed, so far as the question of determination of shares and partition as between the plaintiff and defendant 3 on one side and defendants 1 and 2 on the other was concerned. It requires notice, in the first place, that the learned District Judge's observation, regarding the distinction between a joint family under the Dayabhaga school of Hindu law and a community of persons governed by the Dayabhaga living jointly and his characterisation of the distinction between the two, as drawn before him, as a thing which savoured of “sophistry” does not commend itself to us. It is now well recognized that, under the Dayabhaga school of Hindu law prevalent in Bengal, there cannot be a joint family consisting of the father and the sons. The sons may acquire separate property having no concern with the joint family property, if any property can be called joint family property during the lifetime of the father. It must also be taken to be well established that brothers living in commensality are not members of joint Hindu family governed by the Dayabhaga, so as to enable the brothers to claim the self-acquisition of a brother in more affluent circumstances as acquisition of a joint family, unless these other brothers proved that they had also contributed to the acquisition of the property claimed by them as acquisition by the joint family: see in this connexion the case of Gouranqa Sundar v. Mohendra Narayan . AIR 1927 Cal 776. It is to be noticed further that there cannot be any doubt that property, which was originally self-acquired, may become joint property, if it has been voluntarily thrown into the joint stock with the intention of abandoning all separate claims upon it. The question, whether there was abandonment of separate claim or not, is entirely one of fact, to be decided in the light of all the circumstances of the case; a clear intention to waive separate rights must however be established and will not be inferred from acts attributable to various causes; see Mayne on Hindu Law and Usage, 9th Edn., para. 278, pp. 360 to 361; Lal Bahadur v. Kanhaiya Lal . 1907 29 All 244, Suraj Narain v. Batan Lal . AIR 1917 PC 12 and Muddun Gopal Lal v. Khihhinda Koer . 1890 18 Cal 341. It requires notice also that where no nucleus of joint property is admitted or proved, and there is, in the case before us, nothing to indicate that there was any nucleus of the joint family, to which the parties concerned belonged, the onus is upon the party asserting that property was not the self acquired property of an individual member of the family: see Gopalchandra Sarliar's Treatise on Hindu Law, 7th Edn., by Mr. Bishindraaath Sarkar, p. 549, and the case referred to there. Reference may also be made to the decision of a Full Bench of the Madras High Court in the case of C. Ethirajulu Naidu v. Govindarajulu Naidu . 1915 32 IC 12., in which it has been held that property acquired by a member of a joint Hindu family, when there is no nucleus of joint property, is presumed to be his separate property, and the burden of proving that he threw it into the common stock is upon those who assert it.

    6. In the light of the above position in law, the decision of the Court of appeal below, which was arrived at after expressing disagreement with the findings arrived at by the trial Court that the property was acquired by Poorna, that Kunja, by whom the fund was supplied to Poorna, intended to make his property the property of the family and not his separate property, cannot be accepted as one sound in law. There was under the law no presumption in the case before us in favour of defendants 1 and 2 that the property was acquired for the benefit of the joint family, although money was actually subscribed by Kunja, there having been no joint family, in the strict sense of the expression applicable to persons governed by the Dayabhag's school of Hindu law, owning property. The Court below, in our judgment, is not right in law in laying down the proposition that the onus lay on the plaintiff's side to show that Kunja had not treated the property as his own self-acquired property. In view of the propositions of law, to which reference has been made, with which we are in entire agreement, the plaintiff had no burden on himself to discharge in the matter of proof of the fact that his father had no intention to treat the property acquired by him with his own funds, as his separate property. It was not for the plaintiff to prove a negative regard being had specially to the defence of defendants 1 and 2 in the suit, to which reference has been made already. The general rule of evidence is that, if, in order to make out a title, it is necessary to prove a negative, the party who avers it must prove the title.

    7. In some cases this allegation, negative in form, is made by the plaintiff, in others by way of defence: the rule applicable to all such cases is that, where a claim or defence rests upon a negative allegation, the one asserting such claim or defence is not relieved of the onus probandi by reason of the form of the allegation or the inconvenience of proving a negative: see Abrath v. N.E Ry. Co. . 1883 11 QBD 440. The plaintiff's claim before the Court, on the basis that the property in suit was the self-acquired property of his father, Kunjabihari, was resisted by defendants 1 and 2 on the ground that the property was acquired by Poorna, that it was the property of the joint family, having been acquired from the common funds of the joint family, and that it was ancestral property. The defence so raised was not accepted by the Court of appeal below. It was held that the evidence on the side of defendants 1 and 2 to which reference has been made by the Court below in detail, did not prove that the property was joint family property. In the case before us, therefore, regard being had to the cases set up by the respective parties, it was not for the plaintiff to prove a negative; but it was for defendants 1 and 2 to prove their defence before the Court, which they had failed to do so.

    8. The conclusion of the learned Judge in the Court below based upon propositions laid down by him that there was a joint Hindu family comprising the father and the sons, that there was a presumption in favour of defendants 1 and 2 that the property was acquired for the benefit of the joint family, although the fund was actually supplied by Kunjabihari, and the onus was on the plaintiff to prove the negative; that the property was not treated as the separate self-acquired property of Kunjabihari, has not been discharged, is not supportable in law; and we are wholly unable to give effect to the conclusion so arrived at by him. We have no hesitation in coming to the decision that, upon the findings of fact arrived at by the learned Judge, the plaintiff was entitled to the share claimed by him so far as the property in suit was concerned and that defendants 1 and 2 have failed to establish the case, which would have entitled them to the shares claimed by them on the score of the property being ancestral, their defence having failed on the findings arrived at by the final Court of fact. According to our decision, the plaintiff and defendant 3 in the suit, the sons of Kunjabihari, are entitled to get a one-third share each, in the property in suit, and are entitled also to get possession of the same on partition. This disposes of the case decided by the Court of appeal below on appeal by the plaintiff.

    9. The question requiring consideration next is this: The learned District Judge in the Court of appeal below allowed the cross-objection preferred by defendants 1 and 2 in regard to a chowchala tin-roofed but in the outer house within the ambit of the property in suit, and in regard to a table mentioned in the plaint, as the plaintiff's self-acquired property. The trial Court, on the evidence in the case held that the two items of property mentioned above were the self-acquired separate properties of the plaintiff and were, therefore, to be kept outside partition. The learned Judge, in the Court of appeal below, has not assigned any season whatsoever for reversing the decision of the trial Court, and no attempt was made before us to support the learned Judge's decision in this behalf. We accept the decision of the trial Court with reference to the chowchala tin-roofed hut, and the table mentioned above, and they are to be kept outside the partition, as the self-acquired properties of the plaintiff in the suit. It may be mentioned that the chowchala tin-roofed but mentioned in the plaint is to be treated as the plaintiff's separate property, irrespective of the ground on which the hut stands, which is to be partitioned in accordance with the shares of the parties concerned, in view of our decision, in supercession of the decision arrived at by the Courts below, on the question of shares. In the result the decisions and decrees passed by the Courts below are set aside and the plaintiff's claim is allowed in full. A self-contained decree is to be drawn up in this Court incorporating our decision in favour of the plaintiff in the suit, entitling him to possession on partition, after a Commissioner for effecting partition has been appointed by the trial Court. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case, we direct that the parties do bear their own costs in the litigation up to the present stage including the costs of this appeal.

    R.K

    10. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hemchandra Ganguli v. Matilal Ganguli .
    (May 15, 1933)