Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judicial Opinion Summary — N. Kumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee obtained a site on settlement and constructed a three-storied building (ground plus two floors). The dispute concerns the transfer of the first and second floors together with the proportionate share in the land on which the building stands. It was undisputed that the building (the construction) had been held by the assessee for less than 36 months prior to transfer (thus treated as a short-term capital asset), while the land was a long-term capital asset. The assessing officer computed capital gains separately attributable to the building and to the land; that computation was not disputed. The assessee also satisfied the factual requirement of having constructed another residential house within the period stipulated under Section 54 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The sole controversy before the authorities and tribunals was whether the assessee could claim exemption under Section 54(1) in respect of the capital gains attributable to the land.

Procedurally, the Income Tax Officer denied the Section 54 benefit for the capital gains attributable to the land on the ground that the building component was a short-term capital asset. The assessee appealed; the first appellate authority dismissed the appeal. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (the Tribunal) likewise dismissed the second appeal, reading the words "buildings or lands appurtenant thereto" in Section 54 as requiring both building and appurtenant land to be long-term for relief to apply. The Tribunal relied on a Kerala High Court decision (Vasavan v. CIT). The assessee appealed to this court. The appeal was admitted to consider two substantial questions of law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in law under the facts and circumstances of the case in negating the appellant's claim under Section 54(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961?
  2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in law in holding that capital gains is chargeable under Section 45(1) on the facts and circumstances of the case?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • Section 54(1) applies to transfer of a long-term capital asset being "buildings or lands appurtenant thereto" which are residential houses chargeable as 'Income from House Property'. The phrasing should be read disjunctively ("or"), not conjunctively ("and").
  • The provision is beneficent and should be liberally and harmoniously interpreted to give relief in respect of land that is appurtenant to a residential house; applying the Tribunal's construction leads to an absurd result.
  • If land appurtenant to a residential house is entitled to exemption, then the land on which the residential house is constructed should equally be capable of attracting the benefit; otherwise the section would be incoherent.

Revenue's Arguments

  • The word "or" in the phrase "buildings or lands appurtenant thereto" should be read as "and" as held by the Tribunal (i.e., both components must be long-term for Section 54(1) relief to apply).
  • Accordingly, no interference with the impugned orders is warranted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vasavan v. CIT [1992] 197 ITR 163 / 60 Taxman 278 Relied upon by the Tribunal to support the proposition that the words "buildings or lands appurtenant thereto" in Section 54 should be read to require both building and appurtenant land to be long-term (i.e., reading "or" as "and"). The court recorded that the Tribunal relied on this Kerala High Court decision, but the court did not accept the Tribunal's approach and set aside the impugned orders that had followed that reasoning.
Smt. Azra Abdulla v. CIT (I.T.R.C. No. 146/1995, decided 09.04.1997) Considered whether land contiguous to or appurtenant to a residential house is entitled to benefit under Section 54(1); reasoned that where land and house form a contiguous whole the land may be treated as "land appurtenant to a residential house" and thus attract Section 54 relief. The court relied on and quoted this judgment extensively to support the view that "land appurtenant to a residential house" should be understood in a popular, non-technical sense and that contiguous land forming part of the residential unit is covered by Section 54(1).
CIT v. Zaibunniasa Begum, 151 ITR 320 (Andhra Pradesh High Court) Provided tests to determine whether a large extent of land was part of the residential unit and therefore "land appurtenant thereto"; factors included the needs of persons occupying the building and social/usage context. This case was referred to within the Azra Abdulla judgment; the court in the present opinion noted that Azra Abdulla relied on Zaibunniasa Begum for tests but distinguished the facts (Zaibunniasa Begum dealt with a very large area), using those authorities to show how "appurtenant" may be determined in context.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining the language of Section 54(1) and the context in which the word "or" appears in the statutory phrase "buildings or lands appurtenant thereto." It emphasized that the word "or" is properly understood disjunctively in this context and should not be judicially rewritten as "and." Replacing "or" with "and" would amount to substituting words the legislature chose, which is impermissible.

The court analysed the practical effect of recognizing land sold separately from the building. It observed that a person may use both a residential house and the land appurtenant to it exclusively for residential purposes; if such a person sells only the land (which has been used for residential purposes and qualifies as a long-term capital asset), Parliament has conferred the benefit under Section 54(1) for gains arising from that sale. The court found it difficult to accept an interpretation that would grant the benefit to contiguous appurtenant land but deny it to the land on which the residential building stands.

The court also noted the accepted assessment practice in the case: the assessing authority had apportioned the sale consideration between land (treated as long-term) and building (treated as short-term) for purposes of computing capital gains. The court reasoned that if tax law permits such a bifurcation for assessment, it is inconsistent to deny the Section 54(1) benefit in respect of the long-term component (the land) merely because the building component is short-term.

In support of its interpretive approach, the court relied on its earlier decision in Smt. Azra Abdulla v. CIT, which held that where land and a house form a contiguous whole and the land is used as part of the residential unit, that land may be regarded as "land appurtenant to a residential house" for Section 54(1) purposes. The court observed that the tests discussed in Zaibunniasa Begum were applied in Azra Abdulla to determine appurtenance but that the facts of Zaibunniasa Begum (very large area) were distinguishable. The court used these authorities to reinforce a contextual, non-technical understanding of "appurtenant."

Ultimately, the court concluded that the legislative intent does not support treating "or" as "and" in Section 54(1), and it is reasonable to extend the exemption to the capital gains attributable to the land component when that land qualifies as a long-term capital asset and the assessee has satisfied the other conditions of Section 54(1).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned orders passed by the authorities below are set aside and the appeal is allowed. The substantial questions of law in this appeal are answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the assessee is entitled to the benefit of Section 54(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, in respect of the land (and building) as applicable under the facts of this case — specifically, the capital gains attributable to the land component (a long-term capital asset) are eligible for exemption under Section 54(1) where the statutory conditions are otherwise satisfied.
  • The court declined to rewrite the statute by substituting "and" for "or"; it interpreted the provision disjunctively and applied prior judicial reasoning (notably Azra Abdulla) to treat land forming part of a residential unit as appurtenant in a popular, contextual sense.
  • No broader precedent beyond the direct holding was expressly framed by the court in terms of establishing a new rule; the decision resolves the parties' dispute and sets aside the orders below. (The opinion relied on prior authority and the court's reasoning as set out above.)

    C.N. Anantharam v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax

    N. Kumar, J.

    1. The assessee has preferred this appeal challenging the finding recorded by the authorities below where in they have held that the assessee is not entitled to benefit of Section 54(1) of the I.T.Act, 1961 in respect of the land sold by him.

    2. The Assessee obtained the site on settlement and constructed a three storied building i.e., ground plus two floors. The first and second floors of the building together with the proportionate share in the land on which the building stands is the subject matter of transaction in question. There is no dispute that the building as such was held by the assessee for a period of less than 36 months prior to the date of transfer. However the land was a long term capital asset. The computation of capital gains as is attributable to the building and the land as set out in the assessment order is not disputed. The land has been treated as long term capital asset and the capital gains treated accordingly. There is no dispute about the cost of ' construction of another residential house and such residential house has been constructed within the period stipulated under Section 54. The only dispute relates to the availability of Section 54.

    3. The Income Tax Officer is of the view that the capital gains as is attributable to long term capital asset viz land will not qualify for relief under section 54 even though it is a long term capital asset as the building which stood on the same and which was the subject matter of transfer was a short term capital asset.

    4. Aggrieved by the order, the assessee initially preferred an appeal which came to be dismissed. The second appeal preferred by the assessee also came to be dismissed by the tribunal holding that any used buildings or lands appurtenant thereto as mentioned in Section 54 is also appeared in Section 22 of the Act. Thus the meaning of the word building in Section 54 has to be construed in the same way as to be considered in the way considered for the purpose of Section 22. The rental income from the land is not taxable under Section 22.

    5. The Tribunal held as follows :

    The word 'or' in law relating to statutory interpretation need not be disjunctive, thought it is normally so. The word 'and' is normally used where the intention is not disjunctive but it is not unusual to use the word or' to mean 'and' in a statute. 'Or' can be disjunctive word. The clear intention elsewhere in the provision requires to be so understood as "and" in the context of section 54, the reasoning is that section does not contemplate two separate sales of building and appurtenant land. If appurtenant land can be sold independently, it ceases to be appurtenant which goes with the building. Hence the deduction under Section 54 will be admissible in case the capital asset is a residential house. Such capital asset must be a long term capital asset. A house consists of building and land appurtenant thereto. Hence building as well as appurtenant land should be long term capital asset. In the instant case, land is long term capital asset while the building constructed on it is a short term capital asset. Hence, the house, which was transferred, is not a long term capital asset because part of it is short term. Section 54 does not provide bifurcation of capital gain arising from the sale of land and building separately and to allow deduction in case any one of them-as long term capital asset.

    6. The tribunal relied on the judgment of the Kerala High Court in the case of Vasavan v. CIT [1992] 197 ITR 163/60 Taxman 278 to substantiate its contentions and thus the appeal filed by the assessee came to be dismissed. Aggrieved by the said order the assessee is in appeal.

    7. This appeal is admitted to consider the following substantial questions of law:

    "1. Whether the Tribunal is justified in law under the facts and circumstances of the case in negating the appellant claim under Section 54(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ?

    2. Whether the Tribunal is justified in law in holding that capital gains is chargeable under Section 45(1) on the facts and circumstances of the case?"

    8. Learned counsel for the assessee assailing the impugned order contends that it is clear from Section 54(1) of the Act, the benefit under the said provision is available to a transfer of long term capital asset being buildings or lands appurtenant thereto and being a residential house, the income of which is chargeable under the head 'Income from the House Property'. Therefore, the said section cannot be confined only to a residential house and cannot be interpreted to mean it has no application to the land appurtenant to a residential building when the legislature has confirmed the said benefit of an individual family or a Hindu Undivided Family in respect of the buildings or lands appurtenant thereto. The said provision being a beneficiary provision, should be liberally and harmoniously interpreted so as to give the benefit even in respect of land which is appurtenant to residential house. If a land appurtenant to a residential land is entitled to the said benefit, the land on which the residential house is put up is also should be gaining benefit. Otherwise section looks absurd.

    9. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the Revenue submitted the word "or" should be read as "and" as held by the Tribunal. The benefit is not available to sale of lands independent of the buildings, and therefore, he submits no cause for interference with the impugned orders is made out.

    10. In fact, it is useful to refer to a judgment of this court in the case of Smt. Azra Abdulla v. CIT in I.T.R.C.No. 146/1995 decided on 09.04.1997 where the questions which arose for consideration was whether land appurtenant thereto the sale of land appurtenant is entitled to the benefit of Section 54(1) of the Act?. This court after referring to - several judgments has held as under:

    "Section 54 of the Act deals with capital gain arising from transfer of a long term. capital asset being building or lands appurtenant thereto and being a residential house the income of which is chargeable under the head 'Income from House Property', in the present case, it is not in dispute that entire property held by the assessee prior to sale was subject matter of assessment under the Head 'Income from House Property'. What was sold was a part of that property now which is contiguous to the same. The test whether the sale is in relation to a residential house is satisfied. The sale is in relation to a residential house and what was sold was land contiguous thereto. If land is contiguous to the house, it cannot be taken to be separate and apart from the residential house. When land and house form one contiguous whole, the two cannot be separated for purpose of taxation. If that is so, a part of such property which is now sold, even though it may not be a residential house still it must be held it was a ' land appurtenant to a residential house. Understood in that manner we think the authorities below and the Tribunal were not justified in the view taken by them. We are fortified in our view by the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in CIT v. Zaibunniasa Begum 151 ITR 320. The land appurtenant thereto has not been defined under the Act and it is understood in popular non-technical sense The definition given to the same either under the Wealth Tax act or urban land (ceiling & regulation) act are not relevant. In that decision, however, certain tests were laid down to find out whether the vast extent of land sold therein was part of the residential unit so that it may be treated as land appurtenant thereto. Indeed, it was noticed there that in deciding as to whether any land is appurtenant thereto a residential house, the requirements of the persons occupying the building, consistent with their social standing etc., are relevant for the purpose. Thereafter, certain other tests were set out. In Bangalore City, years ago, the style of life was such that persons would purchase property with bungalows having sprawling ground around it and the bungalow and grounds thereto formed one unit. The land around it would not be put to any separate use for that would invade their privacy. If these aspects are borne in mind, we do not think any point is made out in this case to apply the tests laid down in the decision in Zaibunnisa Begum's case. In that case, the Andhra Pradesh High Court was dealing with a land spread over a vast area of about 13,029 sq. yards; whereas in the present case we are concerned with only 56,000 sq. feet i.e. 200' x 280' in which there is more than 56 squares house. AS stated earlier that house was situate in the centre of the property. Thus, the intention of the owner was to enjoy the entire land as appurtenant thereto."

    11. When the legislature has used the word 'or' which means the word buildings or lands appurtenant thereto to should be understood disjunctively having regard to the context in which it is used. It cannot be read as 'and'. If it is read as 'and', it amounts to court rewriting the section by substituting the word 'and' in place of the word "or" which is not permissible in law. A person may be residing in a residential house and the land pertinent thereto. That house he may be using it for his benefit. As long as the said land is not used for any commercial or non-residential purpose, the user of the land by the resident is for residential purpose only. If such a person chooses to sell only the land which he was using for residential purpose, the legislature has conferred the benefit in respect of/to the capital gains arising there from under Section 54(1) of the Act. If a land appurtenant to a residential house is entitled to the said benefit, we find it difficult to accept that the land on which the residential building is constructed is not entitled to the said benefit.

    12. When a property, residential house is sold, the sale consideration includes the value of the land and the value of the construction. Though there is no two sale transactions involved for the purpose of the Act, in order to calculate the capital gains as rightly done by the Assessing authority, he has treated the sale of land on which the residential house is constructed as a long term capital gain and he has treated the building as short term capital gain. If, for levying tax under the Act, such a distinction could be made, we fail to understand why that distinction should not be kept in mind in extending the benefit under Section 54(1) of the Act. If the land on which the building is constructed is a long term capital gain and the amount received towards the sale of such land when it is assessed as a long term capital gain and taxed. In view of Section 54(1) if that consideration from the sale of the land is utilized in acquiring a residential house, the benefit from exemption is to be extended. Otherwise, the section looks absurd. The land which is adjoining the residential house is entitled to benefit under Section 54(1) of the Act but the land on which the residential house would not be entitled to such benefit, we cannot impute any such intention to the legislature.

    13. On the contrary, the legislative intent is manifest. The assessee is entitled to the benefit of Section 54(1) of the Act in respect of land and building. That land may be the land on which the residential house is constructed or the land appurtenant to the residential house.

    In that view of the matter, the impugned orders passed by the authorities cannot be sustained. Accordingly they are hereby set aside. The appeal is allowed. The substantial questions of law in this appeal are answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C.N. Anantharam v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax
    (Oct 10, 2014)