Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974) or and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (Central Act 49 of 1988)
  • provisions contained in Ss. 3 and 4 of the Police Act, 1861 and rules 1 and 2 of the Punjab Police Rules, 1934,
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1960,
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules.
  • rule 10(1) of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules.
  • rule 13 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • rule 11(i) of Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • Haryana Government (Allocation) Rules, 1974,
  • S. 3 of the All India Services Act, 1951,
  • rule 4 of the Business Rules
  • Cl. (a) of rule 2 of the Rules
  • Cl. (e) rule 2 of the Rules
  • ALL INDIA SERVICES ACT 1951
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 10
  • Rule 4 of the Rules
  • sub-rule (1) of rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974) or and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (Central Act 49 of 1988)
  • provisions contained in Ss. 3 and 4 of the Police Act, 1861 and rules 1 and 2 of the Punjab Police Rules, 1934,
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1960,
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules.
  • rule 10(1) of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules.
  • rule 13 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • rule 11(i) of Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules
  • Haryana Government (Allocation) Rules, 1974,
  • S. 3 of the All India Services Act, 1951,
  • rule 4 of the Business Rules
  • Cl. (a) of rule 2 of the Rules
  • Cl. (e) rule 2 of the Rules
  • ALL INDIA SERVICES ACT 1951
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 10
  • Rule 4 of the Rules
  • sub-rule (1) of rule
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are employees of the Public Works Department: the first petitioner an Executive Engineer and the second petitioner a Head Draftsman. During 1991–92 and 1992–93 they worked on the Integrated Tribunal Development Project (I.T.D.P.), being posted there because the project was undertaken by the Public Works Department. By order dated 21 October 1994 (Exhibit P1) the petitioners were placed under suspension with immediate effect, pending investigation and disciplinary action, on allegations that they abused their official position, committed grave irregularities and malpractices in execution of a road work and misappropriated Rs. 12,923 with the help of the convenor of the work. Exhibit P1 was issued by the Commissioner and Secretary to Government, Vigilance (the second respondent).

The petition is an original petition challenging Exhibit P1 principally on the ground that the second respondent lacked jurisdiction to issue the suspension order. The petitioners additionally contended that suspension did not serve public interest. The High Court heard the matter and delivered the judgment dismissing the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the second respondent (Commissioner and Secretary, Vigilance) had jurisdiction to issue the order of suspension (Exhibit P1) under rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules and related delegation/empowerment instruments.
  2. Whether placing the petitioners under suspension was justified in public interest given the allegations and pending investigation/disciplinary proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The second respondent had no jurisdiction to issue the suspension order because, under rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, suspension may be ordered only by the appointing authority, any authority to which it is subordinate, or any other authority empowered by the Government in that behalf; the petitioners contended the Secretary to Government, Vigilance Department, is none of these for them.
  • The appointing authority for the petitioners is the Government and, as they belong to the Public Works Department, the Secretary to the Public Works Department (the third respondent) is the proper authority to issue suspension orders; no notification under sub‑rule (1) of rule 10 had empowered the second respondent to issue suspension orders.
  • An amendment to the Rules of Business (Exhibit R2(a)) made under Clauses (2) and (3) of Article 166 cannot substitute for a notification made under rule 10(1) (rules framed under Article 309). Exhibit R2(a) therefore does not amount to the empowerment envisaged by rule 10.
  • Where rules are made under Article 309, they should prevail over rules of business framed under Article 166 if there is a conflict; reliance was placed on two prior decisions (including State of Haryana v. P.C. Wadhwa) to support this contention.
  • Separately, the petitioners argued that suspension would not serve public interest and therefore Exhibit P1 was invalid on that ground as well.

Respondent(s)' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments in the format of separate, itemised submissions. The judgment records the Government's allocation of business to the Vigilance Department (via Exhibit R2(a)) and proceeds to apply that allocation to justify the exercise of power by the second respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Original Petition No. 18372 of 1994 (High Court) Holds that a notification authorising an officer to impose certain penalties under rule 11 (items (i) and (iii)–(viii)) does not confer authority to pass an order of suspension under rule 10. The petitioners relied on this decision to argue that without a specific notification under rule 10 the second respondent could not issue a suspension order. The Court found this decision inapplicable to the present facts because the present case concerns allocation of business under the Rules of Business, not an attempt to substitute a rule 11 authorisation for rule 10 authority.
Original Petition No. 13372 of 1994 (High Court) Holds that a notification under rule 13 cannot substitute for a notification under rule 10(1) authorising suspension. The petitioners relied on this decision; the Court held it was not helpful because the basis for the Secretary (Public Works) issuing suspension orders in the present case is allocation of business under the Rules of Business, not an attempt to rely on rule 13 in place of rule 10(1).
State of Haryana v. P.C. Wadhwa, Inspector‑General of Police [1987 (2) L.L.N. 27] (Supreme Court) Consideration of whether Rules of Business (framed under Art. 166) can override statutory provisions or rules made under other statutory provisions (context: reporting authority for the Inspector‑General of Police). The case emphasises that Rules of Business cannot override statutory rules where the statute prescribes a different authority/arrangement. The petitioners relied on this Apex Court decision to contend that rules framed under Article 166 cannot override statutory rules made under Article 309. The Court distinguished the case and held it inapplicable: the present allocation of particular business to the Vigilance Department under the Rules of Business did not conflict with any statutory provision or statutory rules, and therefore Exhibit R2(a) legitimately allocated the matter of suspension to the Vigilance Department.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed the two main contentions of the petitioners sequentially:

  1. Jurisdictional challenge under rule 10:

    - The Court observed that the Government is the appointing authority for the first petitioner and, in respect of the second petitioner, the Government is a superior authority to the appointing authority. Therefore, an order of suspension issued by the Government (or an authority enabled by the Government) is not objectionable on the ground that it did not come from the Secretary to Public Works alone.

    - The Court relied on Rule 4 of the Rules of Business of the Government of Kerala (made under Clauses (2) and (3) of Article 166) which provides that business of the Government shall be transacted in departments specified in the First Schedule and shall be classified and distributed between those departments as laid down therein. The Secretary to the Public Works Department is enabled to pass suspension orders because the First Schedule allocates the relevant business to that Department.

    - Exhibit R2(a) is an amendment to the Rules of Business which specifically allocated to the Vigilance Department the business of issuing orders sanctioning prosecution under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and the Prevention of Corruption Act, placing a public servant under suspension and finalising disciplinary proceedings pursuant to vigilance enquiries. Because this allocation was made under the Rules of Business, the second respondent (Secretary, Vigilance) was empowered to issue Exhibit P1.

    - The Court distinguished the petitioners' relied decisions (including those dealing with the non‑substitutability of certain notifications under rule 10 and a Supreme Court decision about reporting authority in the police context), explaining that those authorities did not address or invalidate an allocation of business effected under the Rules of Business. Consequently, no separate notification under rule 10(1) was required to empower the Vigilance Secretary where the Rules of Business allocated that function to the Vigilance Department.

  2. Public interest justification for suspension:

    - On the substance of the allegations (abuse of official position, grave irregularities and misappropriation of Rs. 12,923), the Court held that public interest would be served by keeping the petitioners under suspension pending finalisation of investigation and disciplinary proceedings.

    - The Court concluded that the petitioners had not made out a case for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The original petition is dismissed; Exhibit P1 (the suspension order dated 21 October 1994 issued by the Commissioner and Secretary, Vigilance) is held not to be bad for want of jurisdiction, and the suspension is upheld as being in public interest.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the petitioners remain under suspension pending investigation and disciplinary proceedings; the High Court refused to interfere with the suspension order under Article 226.
  • The Court found no conflict between the amendment to the Rules of Business (Exhibit R2(a)) and statutory rules or enactments relied upon by the petitioners; therefore the allocation of the power to place public servants under suspension to the Vigilance Department was treated as valid in this factual and legal context.
  • No broader or novel legal principle creating a new precedent was announced beyond the application of existing principles: the decision resolves the present jurisdictional and public interest questions as they apply to the facts before the Court and declines relief to the petitioners.

    Nithyanandan v. State Of Kerala

    JUDGMENT

    1. Challenge in this original petition against an order of suspension issued by the second respondent, the Commissioner and Secretary to Vigilance (D) Department, against the petitioners is mainly on the ground that the second respondent has no jurisdiction to issue the order. The first petitioner is an Executive Engineer and second petitioner is a head draftsman in Public Works Department under the first respondent. During the period 1991–92 and 1992–93 respectively the petitioners were working in the Integrated Tribunal Development Project (I.T.D.P) They were posted to the project, as the project was undertaken by the Public Works Department. Under Exhibit P1 order, dated 21 October, 1994, which is under challenge in this original petition, petitioners were placed under suspension with immediate effect pending investigation and disciplinary action against them on the allegation that they abused their official position and committed grave irregularities and mal practices in the execution of second reach of Poduvayal-Ambannoor Road, Pudur Panchayat, and misappropriated an amount of Rs. 12,923 with the active help and connivance of the convenor of the work. Exhibit P1 order has been issued by the Commissioner and Secretary to Government, Vigilance Department.

    2. Petitioners would contend that the order of suspension is bad for two reasons, viz., the order has been issued by an authority, which has no jurisdiction to issue the order as per the provisions contained under rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules and that no public interest would be served by the suspension of the petitioners. Relevant portion of rule 10 reads as follows:

    “10. Suspension.— (1) The appointing authority or any authority to which it is subordinate or any other authority empowered by the Government in that behalf may at any time place a Government servant under suspension,—

    (a) where disciplinary proceeding against him is contemplated or is pending; or

    (b) where a case against him in respect of any criminal offence is under investigation or trial; or

    (c) where final orders are pending in the disciplinary proceeding.

    if the appropriate authority considers that in the then prevailing circumstances it is necessary in public interest, that the Government servant should be suspended from service.”

    Petitioners contend that the Secretary to Government, Vigilance (D) Department is neither the appointing authority nor an authority to which it is subordinate. The appointing authority is the Government and since the petitioners are members of service under the Public Works Department, orders are to be issued by the third respondent, the Secretary to Public Works Department, Government of Kerala. He is also not an authority empowered by the Government in that behalf as contemplated by rule 10. It is further contended that an amendment to the Rules of Business of the Government of Kerala under G.O(MS) No. 169/94.GAD, dated 23 April, 1994, produced as Exhibit R2(a) along with the counter-affidavit of the second respondent does not amount to empowerment as envisaged by rule 10. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners pointed out several notifications issued under sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1960, empowering officers other than those who comes under the first and second part of sub-rule (1) of rule 10. He contends that no such notification has been issued by the Government in exercise of its power under sub-rule (1) of rule 10 empowering the second respondent to issue an order of suspension against the petitioners. According to the petitioners, Exhibit R2(a) is no substitute for a notification to be issued in exercise of the powers under sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules. These rules are issued under Art. 309 of the Constitution of India, where as Exhibit R2(a) has been issued in exercise of the powers conferred by Cls. (2) and (3) of Art. 166 of the Constitution by the Governor of Kerala. He further contends that going by the provisions contained under rule 10 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules the second respondent cannot have any jurisdiction to issue Exhibit P2 order and that if there is a conflict between the rules issued under Art. 309 of the Constitution and Art. 166, then the rules issued under Art. 309 shall prevail. In support of the above contentions petitioners rely on two decisions.

    3. In Original Petition No. 18372 of 1994 the question arose whether an officer who was empowered under the proviso to rule 3 to impose certain penalties like censure, withholding of increments, recovery from pay, etc., can pass an order of suspension under sub-rule (1) of rule 10. A learned Judge of this Court took the view that a notification authorising an officer to impose penalties specified in (i) and (iii) to (viii) or rule 11(i) of Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules will not confer on him the authority to pass an order of suspension under rule 10. Petitioner relies on this decision in support of his contention that without a specific notification under rule 10 the second respondent cannot be authorised in any other manner to issue an order of suspension. A decision of the Apex Court in State of Haryana v. P.C Wadhwa, Inspector-General of Police [1987 (2) L.L.N 27], is relied on by the petitioners in support of their contentions that the Rules of Business framed under Art. 166 cannot override the provisions of statutory rules.

    4. I find no merit in the contention of the petitioners that the second respondent has no jurisdiction to issue Exhibit P1. Admittedly, the Government is the appointing authority in the case of the first petitioner. As far as the second petitioner is concerned Government is a superior authority to the appointing authority. Therefore, petitioners cannot have any complaint, if the order of suspension is issued by the Government. Rule 4 of the Rules of Business of the Government of Kerala issued by the Governor of Kerala in exercise of his powers under Cls. (2) and (3) of Art. 166 of the Constitution of India provides that the business of the Government shall be transacted in the departments specified in the First Schedule, and shall be classified and distributed between those departments as laid down therein. Petitioners concede that the order of suspension can be issued against them by the third respondent, Secretary to Government Public Works Department. The third respondent is thus enabled to pass such an order only because of the specific allocation of the business of the Government as per the First Schedule issued under Rule 4 of the Rules of Business of the Government of Kerala. Exhibit R2(a) is an amendment to the very same rules. By such amendment the following business of the Government, viz., issuance of orders sanctioning prosecution of a public servant under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974) or and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (Central Act 49 of 1988) placing him under suspension and finalising the disciplinary proceedings against him under the relevant rules and orders in pursuance of a vigilance enquiry contemplated/initiated against the public servant has been allocated to the Vigilance Department. Such allocation empowers the second respondent to issue the impugned order.

    5. The two decisions relied on by the petitioners cannot have any application in the present case. In Original Petition No. 13372 of 1994 this Court had held that a notification issued under rule 13 of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules cannot be a substitute for a notification under rule 10(1). The authorisation given under rule 13 was to impose certain penalties specified in items (i) and (iii) to (viii) of rule 11(1) on members of the State Services. It is, therefore, clear the notification does not and cannot authorise an officer to exercise the power of suspension under rule 10. This decision is of no help to the petitioners. In 1987 (2) L.L.N 27 (vide supra), the question which came up for consideration was whether the State Government was justified in specifically empowering the Home Secretary as the reporting authority for the purpose of writing a confidential report instead of Inspector-General of Police. Under the rules framed by the Central Government in exercise of its power under S. 3 of the All India Services Act, 1951, it was provided that the reporting authority means the authority who was during the period for which the confidential report was written immediately superior to the member of the service and such other authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government. The Supreme Court took the view that the expression “immediately superior” indicates that the reporting authority should be the immediate superior officer in the same service to which the member of service belongs. After interpreting the provisions contained in Ss. 3 and 4 of the Police Act, 1861 and rules 1 and 2 of the Punjab Police Rules, 1934, it was held that the administration of police throughout a general police-district shall be vested in the Inspector-General of Police who is the head of the Police Department. Therefore, there is no immediate superior officer to him in the police service. Then the question arose whether the State Government can specifically empower any authority to be the reporting authority of the Inspector-General of Police under the second part of Cl. (e) rule 2 of the Rules framed by the Central Government under All India Services Act, 1951. The Supreme Court took the view that State Government can specifically empower only such authority as the reporting authority as is superior in rank to the Inspector General of Police. Reliance was placed on the Business of the Haryana Government (Allocation) Rules, 1974, on behalf of State of Haryana in support of its action in empowering Home Secretary as the reporting authority in the case of Inspector-General of Police. It was contended that as per the rule the Home Secretary being the head of Home Department and as the Police Department has been be placed under the Home Department, the Home Secretary must necessarily be the head of the Police Department. The Supreme Court took the view that under rule 4 of the Business Rules Secretary of each department of the Secretariat is the head of the department and thus the Secretary of Home Department may be the head of Home Department enabling him to conduct the business of the Government in respect of Police Department. But he does not thereby become head of the Police Department. It was further held that the Rules of Business even though framed under Art. 166 cannot override the provision contained under the Police Act and the Rules framed therein in accordance with which Inspector-General of Police, Haryana, is the head of the Police Department. The immediate authority superior to the Inspector-General of Police is Minister-in-charge of the Police Department and the only authority who could be specifically empowered as the reporting authority in regard to the Inspector-General of Police under Cl. (a) of rule 2 of the Rules is the Minister-in-charge and the Chief Minister being superior to the Minister-in-charge. In acting as the reporting authority the Minister-in-charge may be assisted by the Home Secretary, but the confidential report relating to the performances of the Inspector-General of Police has to be written by the Minister-in-charge. The decision of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana quashing the confidential report of the I.G of Police written by the then Home Secretary was upheld by the Supreme Court. This decision also, I am afraid, is of no help to the petitioners. As mentioned earlier, according to the petitioners, it is the third respondent, viz., Secretary to Public Works Department who has the power to issue order of suspension representing the appointing authority, viz., Government. For third respondent is enabled to do so not by way of a notification under rule 10(1) of the Kerala Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules. The allocation of the business of the Government by which the Secretary, Departments of Public Works, was enabled to issue such an order is under the Rules of Business of the Government of Kerala and not under any other enactment or statutory rules. Thus, amendment to the Rules of Business of the Government of Kerala as evidenced by Exhibit R2(a) is not in conflict with any other statute or statutory rules. It is also not necessary to issue a notification under rule 10(1) authorising the second respondent. Therefore, I hold that Exhibit P1 is not bad for lack of jurisdiction.

    6. The second contention raised is that Exhibit P1 has not been issued in accordance with rule 10 as it was not issued in public interest. In the nature of the allegations put forward against the petitioners. I am of the view that public interest would be served in keeping them under suspension pending finalisation of investigation and disciplinary proceedings. The petitioners have not made out a case for interference by this Court under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India.

    7. In the result, the original petition fails and it stands dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nithyanandan v. State Of Kerala
    (Jul 19, 1995)