Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These Civil Revision Petitions arise from Rent Control Petitions filed by the respondent (landlord) for eviction of tenants from scheduled premises under Sections 11(2) and 11(4)(iv) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 ("the Act"). All Rent Control Petitions were tried jointly and the Rent Control Court rendered a common judgment allowing eviction under both Section 11(2) and Section 11(4)(iv). The tenants' appeals were dismissed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority, which confirmed the Rent Control Court's orders. The tenants filed these revision petitions.

Both lower authorities found (1) default in payment of rent by the tenants and (2) that the building required reconstruction and that the landlord bona fide required it. After the orders were obtained, the municipal licence period for reconstruction expired and, by a Municipal Commissioner order dated 29-12-1990, the Commissioner declined to renew the licence. That municipal order was produced with the revision petitions and prompted the tenants to contend that eviction under Section 11(4)(iv) must be set aside because a current licence no longer exists.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the expiry of, or refusal to renew, a municipal licence for reconstruction during the pendency of eviction proceedings under Section 11(4)(iv) of the Act requires dismissal of the landlord's petition for eviction on the ground of bona fide requirement for reconstruction.
  2. Whether, and to what extent, a court may condition enforcement of an eviction order based on reconstruction on the landlord's production of a renewed or new licence from the local authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioners (Tenants)

  • Contended that the concurrent findings below were unsupported by legal evidence (argued forcefully but court found evidence adequate).
  • Relied on a new municipal order (Order No. PW 2-C.A. 337/82-83 dated 29-12-1990) declining renewal of the licence for reconstruction and argued that under Section 11(4)(iv) the landlord must have a current licence and approved plan; hence eviction for reconstruction should be set aside.

Respondent (Landlord)

  • Argued the point about licence renewal was not raised before the Appellate Authority and therefore should not be permitted for the first time in revision.
  • Pointed out that an original petition was filed against the Municipal Commissioner’s order and this Court had stayed the operation of that municipal order; but acknowledged that the stay does not itself produce a current licence enabling immediate reconstruction.
  • Emphasized that at the time of filing the Rent Control Petitions the landlord had obtained a licence and approved plan but could not start reconstruction because tenants would not voluntarily surrender possession.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul Khader v. Abdularahiman Master [1987 (2) K.L.T 945] When the Rent Control or Revisional Authority is satisfied that the landlord has a plan and licence to reconstruct, petition need not be dismissed merely because the licence period expired during proceedings; court may impose safeguards such as requiring production of renewed licence before delivery of possession. The court relied on this decision to hold that expiry of the licence during proceedings does not mandate dismissal and that the court can condition enforcement on production of a renewed or new licence to protect tenants' rights.
Sukumaran v. Additional District Judge (1988 (1) K.L.T (S.N) 30) The section requires only a plan and a licence; if licence is not approved by a relevant authority (e.g., G.C.D.A.), the court may direct production of approval before execution. The court cited this decision to support the approach that production of necessary municipal/authority approvals can be required before execution of eviction for reconstruction.
Kochuvavakunju v. Kathemkunju (I.L.R 1991 (3) Kerala 353) Held that under Section 11(4)(iv) the landlord must satisfy the court that he has the plan and licence, and that requirement cannot be dispensed with by relying on decisions under different enactments. The court noted this decision but stated it was of no assistance in deciding the specific question here (i.e., whether expiry of licence during pendency requires dismissal).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook the following analytical steps:

  1. Affirmed the concurrent factual findings of the Rent Control Court and the Appellate Authority that the tenants had defaulted in payment of rent and that the landlord bona fide required reconstruction; the court found those findings supported by evidence and free of infirmity.
  2. Identified the central statutory provision at issue—Section 11(4)(iv) of the Act—which requires that a landlord seeking eviction for bona fide reconstruction must satisfy the court that he has the plan and licence (if any) required.
  3. Considered the tenants' contention that expiry or non-renewal of the municipal licence during the pendency of proceedings renders eviction orders invalid; weighed the practical consequences of accepting that interpretation (i.e., automatic dismissal whenever a licence period expires), noting that in contested cases licence periods will commonly expire before final disposal.
  4. Applied the established canon of interpretation that statutes should be interpreted to effectuate their purpose and avoid constructions that defeat the object of the legislation; concluded the tenants' suggested interpretation would defeat Section 11(4)(iv)'s purpose.
  5. Reviewed relevant precedents. In particular, relied on Abdul Khader to hold that expiry of licence during pendency does not require dismissal and that the court has the power to impose safeguards (for example, a condition that actual delivery be made only upon production of a renewed licence). Sukumaran was cited to support conditioning execution on production of requisite approvals. Kochuvavakunju was noted but found unhelpful to the narrow question.
  6. Arrived at a remedial solution balancing the landlord's right to relief and the tenant's protection: affirmed the eviction orders but directed that they shall not be enforced until the landlord produces either a renewed licence or a new licence from the local authority, thereby guaranteeing tenants' rights (including the right of first option to reconstructed accommodation at fair rent) until such proof is produced.
  7. Noted ancillary matters: the Rent Control Court had also ordered eviction under Section 11(2) for rent default and the Appellate Authority had upheld that ground; the court observed that tenants had deposited arrears in court but declined to decide that question in this revision proceeding because the focus was on maintainability of eviction under Section 11(4)(iv).

Holding and Implications

Final Ruling:

The revision petitions are disposed of: the orders of eviction on the ground of bona fide requirement for reconstruction under Section 11(4)(iv) are affirmed, but those orders will not be enforced unless and until the landlord produces either a renewed licence or a new licence granted by the local authority.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The eviction orders stand, but execution is conditionally stayed until documentary proof of a renewed or fresh municipal/local authority licence is produced by the landlord. This condition is intended to protect the tenants' statutory right of first option to reconstructed accommodation at fair rent.
  • Procedure for execution: The court may require production of renewed/new licence (or approvals where applicable) before actual delivery of possession is effected in execution.
  • Costs: The parties were ordered to bear their respective costs.
  • Precedential outcome: The court applied existing authority to interpret Section 11(4)(iv) in a way that avoids defeating the statute's object; it did not purport to lay down a novel principle beyond applying and endorsing the remedial approach taken in earlier decisions (notably Abdul Khader).

    C.T Jose And Others v. T.K Thomas

    Shamsuddin, J.:— These Civil Revision Petitions arise out of Rent Control Petitions filed by the respondent herein for eviction of the tenants from the respective petition scheduled premises under Sections 11(2) and 11(4)(iv) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act 1965, which is hereinafter, referred to as the ‘Act’ for short all the Rent Control Petitions were tried jointly and a common judgment was rendered by the Rent Control Court allowing eviction both under Section 11(2) and Section 11(4)(iv) of the Act. The appeals filed by the respective tenants were dismissed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority confirming the orders passed by the Rent Control Court. These revision petitions have been filed by the respective tenants.

    2. Both the Rent Control Court and the Appellate Authority found that the tenants have committed default in payment of rent and that the building needs reconstruction and the landlord bona fide required to reconstruct the same. In view of the concurrent findings of the authorities below, the counsel for the petitioners strained very much to convince us that the findings of the courts below are not supported by any legal evidence, but we are satisfied that the above findings are supported by evidence and that the orders do not suffer from any infirmity. We, therefore, affirm the said findings. Relying on a new document, which is produced along with the revision petitions (Order No. PW 2-C.A. 337/82-83 dated 29-12-1990 of Municipal Commissioner, Thodupuzha), learned counsel for petitioners contended that the impugned orders are liable to be set aside in view of the provisions contained in Section 11(4)(iv) of the Act. By the aforesaid order, the Commissioner of Thodupuzha Municipality declined to renew the licence; granted to the landlord to reconstruct the building.

    3. Clause (4) of Sub-section (iv) of Section 11 lays down that an order of eviction on the ground of bona fide requirement to reconstruct the building can be ordered, if only that the landlord has the plan and licence and ability to rebuild. The contention of the learned counsel is that though initially the petitioner had licence from the Municipality and an approved plan, as the period of licence granted by the Municipality expired and by order of the Municipal Commissioner dated 29-12-1990 the Commissioner declined to renew the licence, the impugned orders allowing eviction for reconstruction are liable to be set aside.

    4. Shri M.V Joseph, who appeard for the landlord, on the other hand, contended that this ground has not been raised by the landlord before the Appellate Authority, and in the circumstances, the petitioners should not be permitted to raise such a contention for the first time in revision. He also submitted that against the order passed by the Commissioner, the landlord has filed an original petition and this court has stayed the operation of the impugned order. The stay granted by this court will not enable the landlord to start the construction as there is no current licence issued by the Municipal Commissioner to start construction.

    5. It is not disputed that at the time when the Rent Control Petitions were filed, the landlord had obtained the licence for reconstruction and an approved plan. However, the landlord could not start reconstruction, since the tenants did not voluntarily surrender the premises for enabling the landlord to start reconstruction, and the landlord had to resort to proceedings under Section 11 of the Act for eviction of the tenants for the purpose of reconstruction. In the course of proceedings, the tenants raised various objections. Those objections were overruled by the Rent Control Court which was upheld by the Appellate Authority. By the time, the landlord obtained orders from Rent Control Court and the Appellate Authority, the time granted by the Municipality for reconstruction expired. The landlord applied for renewal of licence, but the Commissioner of Municipality passed the above order declining renewal of licence. The question to be considered in such circumstances, in these revision petitions is whether the orders passed by the Rent Control Court and the Appellate. Authority ordering eviction for reconstruction are liable to be set aside.

    6. Learned counsel for the revision petitioners relied on Section 11(4)(iv) of the Act which lays down that the landlord should satisfy the court that he has plan and licence, if any, required and submitted that the existence of a current licence and approved plan is a condition precedent for ordering eviction on the ground of bona fide need for reconstruction and that since the period granted by the municipality expired and renewal of licence was declined, the petitions for eviction on the ground of reconstruction are liable to be dismissed.

    7. If the argument advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners-tenants is accepted, it would mean that in all cases where the period granted by the Municipality for reconstruction expires, the petition for eviction has to be dismissed unless the landlord was able to get the licence renewed before the expiry of the period even if the Municipality delays the renewal of licence or rejects the application even on unsustainable grounds. In our view, the interpretation suggested by the counsel, if accepted, would defeat the very purpose for which Section 11(4)(iv) is enacted. In almost all cases wherein the tenants contest the claim for eviction, the period originally granted by the local authority for construction of building would expire before final disposal of the petition. It is a well known canon of interpretation that the court should adopt an interpretation which would give effect to the purpose of the act and avoid an interpretation which would defeat its object.

    8. A similar question arose before one of us (Thomas J.) in Abdul Khader v. Abdularahiman Master [1987 (2) K.L.T 945]. It was held therein that when the Rent Control or Revisional Authority is satisfied that the landlord has a plan and licence to reconstruct the building, his petition is not to be dismissed on a finding that the period of licence expired during the pendency of proceedings under the Act. The possibility of a contumacious or recalcitrant landlord adopting dilatory tactics and also trying to take advantage of the expiry of the period of licence by refusing to reconstruct the building was noticed by the court, but it was pointed out that the court was not helpless as it has ample power to provide necessary safeguards in the order for protecting the tenant's right of first option to have the building reconstructed allotted to him and that one such safeguard is the power to impose a condition in the order that actual delivery be given to the landlord only if the landlord produces a renewed licence granted by the local authority for the purpose of reconstruction of the building. The law has been correctly stated in the said decision.

    9. In Sukumaran v. Additional District Judge (1988 (1) K.L.T (S.N) 30), the landlord had not obtained an order for construction from Greater Cochin Development Authority. Paripoornan, J. held that strictly speaking the section requires only a plan and a licence, that if licence does not happen to be approved by the Greater Cochin Development Authority, the building cannot be reconstructed and therefore it is sufficient to direct that before execution is taken out, the landlord must produce the approval from G.C.D.A

    10. Learned counsel for the revision petitioner brought to our notice a decision of K.A Nayar, J. in Kochuvavakunju v. Kathemkunju (I.L.R 1991 (3) Kerala 353). It was held therein that in view of provisions contained in Section 11(4)(iv), the landlord must satisfy the court that he has the plan and licence, and that requirement cannot be dispensed with based on decisions a rendered under different enactments which do not contain such provision. The above decision is of no help in deciding the question in issue in this case.

    11. Having regard to the scheme of the Act and the object of Section 11(4)(iv), we have no doubt in our mind that the Act does not contemplate rejection of the petition on the ground that the period of licence granted by the Municipality expired during the pendency of the proceedings. In order to safeguard and protect the interest of the tenant in such cases, the court may incorporate a direction in the order of eviction that actual delivery of possession will be given only when landlord satisfies the execution court that the licence has been renewed or a new licence has been granted by the local authority concerned.

    12. For the reasons stated above, we hold that orders for eviction on the ground of reconstruction do not call for interference. However, the orders passed by the courts below under Section 11(4)(iv) will not be enforced unless and until the landlord produces either a renewed licence or a new licence granted by the local authority. This would guarantee the right of first option of the tenants to have the rooms in the building reconstructed allotted to them with liability to pay fair rent. The counsel for the respondent-landlord pointed out that the Rent Control Court has ordered eviction in all these cases under Section 11(2) of the Act also on the ground that the tenants committed default in payment of rent and the Appellate Authority has upheld the, order of eviction on that ground also. Learned Counsel for the revision petitioners pointed out that the arrears of rent has already been deposited in the court. It is not necessary for us to decide that question in this revision petition. We have only considered the maintainability of order of eviction, under Section 11(4)(iv).

    13. The Revision Petitions are disposed of as above. We order that the parties will bear their respective costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C.T Jose And Others v. T.K Thomas
    (Dec 9, 1991)