Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 33(a) Part I of the Kerala Service Rules
  • Rule 9(a)(v)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 33(a) Part I of the Kerala Service Rules
  • Rule 9(a)(v)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns two original petitions challenging administrative orders that refixed pay by excluding periods of provisional service when granting increments.

In OP No. 5702 of 1995 the petitioner, appointed as Pharmacist Grade II on a provisional basis during three spells (30 March 1987 to 23 March 1988; 12 July 1988 to 6 July 1989; 19 September 1989 to 18 August 1990), obtained regular appointment in the same category with effect from 1 January 1991. Initially, annual increments were granted taking into account the three provisional spells under Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R. Later, that fixation was undone by Exhibit P2 which excluded the first provisional spell (30 March 1987 to 23 March 1988) because the scale attached to the post in that earlier period was different.

In OP No. 6844 of 1997 the petitioner, a staff nurse, had provisional service from 4 January 1988 to 14 August 1992 and obtained regular appointment on 15 August 1992. Her pay was initially fixed by reckoning the provisional appointment pursuant to Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R (Exhibit P3). The respondents thereafter issued Exhibit P4 excluding the entire provisional service and refixed pay in the revised scale applicable on 15 August 1992. The petitioners challenge the respective impugned orders (Exhibit P2 and Exhibit P4).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether provisional service rendered by the petitioners can be reckoned for the purpose of granting increments after they were appointed to regular service (i.e., whether provisional service is to be treated as officiating service ab initio for limited purpose of increment under Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R).
  2. Whether a change in the scale of pay (by intervening pay revision) excludes earlier provisional service from being treated as service in the "same category" for the limited purpose of granting increments.
  3. Whether non-regularised provisional service (i.e., provisional service not regularised) can be counted towards increments when followed by regular appointment with or without break.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • They relied on Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R which provided that provisional service on regularisation or when followed by regular appointment with or without break in the same category of post be treated as officiating service ab initio for the limited purpose of granting increments.
  • Government decision No. 2 was in force at the time of their first increment after regular appointment and was deleted only with effect from 1 October 1994 (G.O.(P) No. 540/94 Fin., dated 30 September 1994), whereas their regular appointments predated that deletion.
  • Therefore, their provisional service (whether followed by regular appointment with a break or without a break) should be reckoned for the purpose of increments and treated as officiating service ab initio.

Government's Arguments (Government Pleader)

  • Under rule 9(a)(i) provisional appointees are paid only the minimum of the relevant time scale, and since at the time of regular appointment such persons were receiving only minimum basic pay, they cannot count provisional service for increments.
  • The provisional services to the credit of the petitioners were not regularised; so long as such service is not regularised, the petitioners cannot claim benefits under Government decision No. 2.
  • In the case of OP No. 5702 of 1995 (and similarly OP No. 6844 of 1997) the scale of pay attached to the post during the provisional appointment period was different (because of pay revision) from the scale at the time of regular appointment; that change in scale prevents treating the earlier provisional service as being in the “same category” for the purpose of fixation of pay/increments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Satyapalan v. Deputy Director Of Education [1998 (2) L.L.N 297] Held that provisional service should have been regularised for one limb of Government decision No. 2 (i.e., provisional service "on regularisation" is to be treated as officiating service ab initio). The court relied on this decision to acknowledge that one limb of Government decision No. 2 requires regularisation; but the court distinguished that limb from the separate limb which treats provisional service followed by regular appointment (with or without break) as officiiating service ab initio even without regularisation.
Vijayan Warrier v. Director Of Technical Education [1989 (2) K.L.T 221] Principle that intervening revision of pay-scale does not deprive an employee of his right to increment accrued on completion of qualifying period; pay revision for which employee not responsible cannot have effect of depriving his right to increment. The court applied this principle to hold that change in scale of pay due to pay revisions does not remove the incumbent from the definition of "same category" and cannot be a ground to deny benefit of Government decision No. 2.
Hussain v. Kerala Water Authority [1996 (2) K.L.T 555] Held that revision of pay-scales does not destroy the identity of the scale for the purpose of treating provisional service as officiating service; provisional service should be treated as officiating service for increments despite pay revision. The court followed this authority to reinforce that quinquennial or intervening pay revisions do not disentitle provisional/regularised hands from increments attributable to provisional service; it supported quashing of the impugned orders that excluded provisional service on grounds of pay revision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded to analyze the legal effect of Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R and the relevant statutory rules (including rule 9(a)(v) and rule 9(a)(i)). The key steps in the court's reasoning are summarized below.

  1. The court observed that rule 9(a)(v) is applicable only to temporary appointees and so long as one continues as a temporary appointee. The petitioners, however, had been appointed on regular basis (1 January 1991 and 15 August 1992 respectively), and the entitlement to increments arises on their regular appointments. Thus rule 9(a)(v) (which addresses temporary appointees) could not be used to deny increments due upon regular appointment.
  2. The court set out the operative wording of Government decision No. 2: it treats "provisional service on regularisation" or "provisional service followed by regular appointment with or without break in the same category of post" as officiating service ab initio for the limited purpose of granting increment. The court emphasized that the decision contains two alternative limbs; the first explicitly requires regularisation, while the second does not mention regularisation and applies where provisional service is followed by regular appointment (with or without break).
  3. On that textual basis the court held the two conditions in Government decision No. 2 are disjunctive (alternative) and not conjunctive. Therefore, the Government Pleader's argument that provisional service not regularised cannot be counted is untenable where the provisional service is followed by regular appointment (with or without break) — because the second limb requires no separate regularisation.
  4. As an additional factual point supporting petitioners, the court noted that Exhibit P2 (the impugned order in OP No. 5702 of 1995) itself had reckoned two spells of provisional service (12 July 1988 to 6 July 1989 and 19 September 1989 to 18 August 1990) for grant of increment. That showed the respondents already accepted in that order that provisional service in the same scale of pay can be reckoned for increments even absent formal regularisation.
  5. On the issue of pay revision and differing scales, the court held that although there had been intervening pay revisions producing changes in the scale of pay, that fact does not remove the incumbent from the meaning of "same category" as used in Government decision No. 2. The court relied on precedents (Vijayan Warrier and Hussain) to support the proposition that pay revision for which the employee is not responsible cannot deprive him of his right to increment; revision does not destroy the identity of the scale for purposes of reckoning provisional service.
  6. Applying those principles, the court concluded that the respondents' reasons for excluding the provisional periods (non-regularisation and change of pay scale) were not legally tenable in these cases where the petitioners had regular appointments in the same category and where Government decision No. 2 was in force at the relevant time.
  7. Accordingly, the court quashed Exhibit P2 and Exhibit P4, restored Exhibit P1 (in OP No. 5702 of 1995) and Exhibit P3 (in OP No. 6844 of 1997), and ordered that any recovery effected be refunded to the petitioners.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling:

Original petitions are allowed; Exhibits P2 and P4 are quashed, and Exhibits P1 and P3 are revived.

Implications

  • Direct consequence for the parties: The impugned orders that excluded provisional service for the purpose of increments (Exhibit P2 in OP No. 5702 of 1995 and Exhibit P4 in OP No. 6844 of 1997) are set aside, and the earlier orders granting fixation/reckoning of provisional service (Exhibit P1 and Exhibit P3) are revived.
  • If any recovery from the petitioners was effected pursuant to Exhibit P2 or Exhibit P4, such recovery shall be refunded to the petitioners.
  • No costs were awarded against the petitioners (the court expressly noted "No costs").
  • On broader precedent implications: the court applied and reinforced existing authorities holding (a) that the two limbs of Government decision No. 2 operate disjunctively so that provisional service followed by regular appointment can be treated as officiating service ab initio even without separate regularisation, and (b) that intervening pay revisions do not, by themselves, defeat entitlement to increments accrued while provisional service was rendered in the same category.

This summary is prepared solely from the provided opinion text and does not introduce information not contained therein.

    Jose Jacob v. State Of Kerala

    1. The petitioner in OP No. 5702 of 1995 was appointed as Pharmacist Grade II on provisional basis under rule 9(a)(i) of the K.S & S.S.R during the period from 30 March, 1987 to 23 March, 1988, 12 July, 1988 to 6 July, 1989 and 19 September, 1989 to 18 August, 1990. Therefore he got regular appointment in the same category of Pharmacist Grade II in the same scale or pay with effect from 1 January, 1991. In terms of Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R governing grant of increment, the petitioner was granted annual increments in the scale of pay of the post taking into account the aforesaid three spells of provisional service. Later, that fixation was undone by Exhibit P2. The period of temporary appointment from 30 March, 1987 to 23 March, 1988 is taken out of that and is excluded for the purpose of granting increment and a refixation is effected as per Exhibit P2, resulting in drop in emoluments. Thus, the petitioner challenges Exhibit P2. The factum of having three spells of provisional service is admitted by the respondents. It is also admitted that the said three spells of provisional service were in the same category as Pharmacist Grade II to which the petitioner got regular appointment with effect from 1 January, 1991.

    2. The petitioner in O.P No. 6844 of 1997 is a staff nurse. She had to her credit temporary service under rule 9(a)(i) from 4 January, 1988 to 14 August, 1992. This was followed by regular appointment on 15 August, 1992. In her case also, her pay was fixed granting increment reckoning the spell of aforesaid provisional appointment, applying Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R Exhibit P3 is that order. In Exhibit P4, the entire period of provisional service is excluded and her pay is fixed in the revised scale of pay applicable to staff nurse as on 15 August, 1992. The petitioner challenges Exhibit P4 order.

    3. The question that arises for consideration in these two cases is whether the provisional service rendered by the petitioners can be reckoned for the purpose of granting increments after they being appointed into regular service. Admittedly, in the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 5702 of 1995, two spells of provisional service namely 12 July, 1988 to 6 May, 1989 and 19 September, 1989 to 18 August, 1990 are reckoned for the purpose of granting increment even as per the impugned order Exhibit P2. Only the provisional spell of appointment from 30 March, 1987 to 23 March, 1988 is excluded. The reason discernible from Exhibit P2 to exclude that period is that during the said period the scale attached to the post was a different one to that existed in the subsequent two periods of provisional appointments and at me time of regular appointment. But, all these appointments including the regular appointment were in the same category, is not disputed by the respondents. In the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 6844 of 1997, the entire provisional service is excluded even though during the period from 1 March, 1992 to 14 August, 1992 she had been in the same scale of pay attached to the post at the time of regular appointment on 15 August, 1992. The reason stated in Exhibit P4 is that “as per existing orders she is not eligible for such fixation.”

    4. Attacking Exhibit P2 in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 and Exhibit P4 in O.P No. 6844 of 1997, the petitioners submit that they are entitled to reckon the provisional service to their credit for the purpose of increments on the basis of Government decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R It was deleted only with effect from 1 October, 1994 as per G.O (P) No. 540/94./Fin., dated 30 September, 1994. Regular appointment of the petitioner was before the said date and when Government decision No. 2 was in force. Their provisional service was followed by regular appointment with break in the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 and without break in the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 6844 of 1997. Therefore, the entire service shall be treated as officiating service ab initio for the purpose of granting increments.

    5. It is contended by the Government Pleader that in terms of rule 9(a)(i), the provisional appointees shall be paid only the minimum pay in the time scale applicable to the respective category. So, even at the time of regular appointment, such persons were receiving minimum of the basic pay. In such circumstances, they cannot count the provisional service to their credit for the purpose of increment. It is also contended that the provisional services to the credit of the petitioners were not regularised at any point of time. So long as such service is not regularised, the petitioner cannot claim the benefit of Government decision No. 2.

    6. It is also contended in the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 that during the period from 30 March, 1987 to 23 March, 1988 when that petitioner had a provisional appointment, scale of pay attached to the post was a different one to that at the time when he got regular appointment on 1 January, 1991. This difference is because of the pay revision effected. Same is the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 6844 of 1997.

    7. All these contentions raised by the Government Pleader cannot be accepted. Rule 9(a)(v) is applicable only in the case of temporary appointees and so long as one continued as a temporary appointee. The petitioners in these cases are not temporary appointees. They were respectively appointed on regular basis with effect from 1 January, 1991 and 15 August, 1992. It is on their regular appointments that they are entitled for increments. It is at that point of time that they claimed that their provisional service shall also be reckoned for the purpose of increment. When they were thus entitled for the first increment after their regular appointment, Government decision No. 2 was on the statute book and it was deleted only with effect from 1 October, 1994 as per G.O (P) No. 540/94.Fin., dated 30 September, 1994. The said Government decision provides that “provisional service on regularisation or followed by regular appointment with or without break in the same category of post will be treated as officiating service ab initio for the limited purpose of granting of increment”. For this purpose, it is true that provisional service should have been regularised as held by me in the decision reported in Satyapalan v. Deputy Director Of Education [1998 (2) L.L.N 297]. But the said Government decision also provides that “provisional service followed by regular appointment with or without break in the same category of post will also be treated as officiating service ab initio for the limited purpose of granting increment”. In this clause, regularisation is not referred to at all. Therefore, even non-regularised provisional service also can be reckoned for the purpose of granting increment treating the service as officiating service ab initio. Even such service involving break as in the case of the petitioner in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 can also be taken note of. The aforesaid two conditions contained in the Government Decision No. 2 are not conjunctive but disjunctive. So, contention of the Government Pleader that the petitioners' provisional service had not been regularised and therefore, they cannot be granted increment taking into account their provisional service cannot be accepted in the light of the second limb of the Government Decision No. 2.

    8. Moreover, it cannot be accepted on another reason also. Admittedly in Exhibit P2, the impugned order in O.P No. 5702 of 1995, the respondents have reckoned the provisional service to the credit of the petitioner in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 during the period from 12 July, 1988 to 6 July, 1989 and 19 September, 1989 to 18 August, 1990. So, it is an admitted case even in Exhibit P2 that provisional service in the same scale of pay can be reckoned for the purpose of granting increment even without such regularisation.

    9. Another contention put forth by the Government Pleader is with reference to the scale of pay. It is not disputed by the respondents that the respective petitioners got appointment in the same category of post which they did hold as provisional appointees. In other words, they were appointed later, on regular basis in the same category of posts to which the qualification and method of appointment were one and the same. Because or an intervening pay revision or revisions, there was change in the scale of pay. This is admitted by the petitioners also. Such charge of pay will not take the incumbent concerned from out of the definition to the term “same category” as contained in the Government Decision No. 2 under rule 33 Part I K.S.R Because of such change in the scale of pay due to the pay revision, the incumbents cannot be denied of the benefits as are applicable in terms of the statutory rules. This aspect has been considered by this Court in more than one occasion. In Vijayan Warrier v. Director Of Technical Education [1989 (2) K.L.T 221], it was held as follows:

    “The only question is whether the respondents are right in contending that the petitioner will not get the benefit of increment because the Government had, in the meantime, revised his salary scale disabling the petitioner from drawing salary on the same time scale of pay. It is agreed that but for the revision of salary, the petitioner would have been entitled for increment on completion of the qualifying period of duty. I am of the opinion that the revision of the pay-scale for which the petitioner was not in any manner responsible cannot have the effect of depriving the petitioner of his normal right to increment on completion of the qualifying period of service. I do not understand the ruling in rule 33(a) Part I of the Kerala Service Rules to have any such effect. If it does have any such effect, that may not bind the Government employee concerned.”

    A Division Bench in Hussain v. Kerala Water Authority [1996 (2) K.L.T 555], held as follows:

    “By the revision of pay-scales it cannot be said that the identity of the scale of pay was lost. If the interpretation given in the clarification is accepted, it will lead to a situation where no regularised hands would be able to enjoy the benefits of increments accrued to them while working as provisional hands, as there would be quinquennial pay revision for employees. Only the effect for pay revision was given and that is quite normal under any service. All the overseers were on identical pay-scales and so long as there was no change in their pay-scales they are entitled to the benefit of the Government. Decision No. 2 and their entire provisional service should be treated as officiating services and they are entitled to treat this period for the purpose of increments.”

    The said two decisions squarely apply in the case of the petitioners. Merely because there was a change in the scales of pay because of pay revisions, the petitioners who got regular appointments in the same category in which they held provisional appointment cannot be denied of increments reckoning the provisional service as at the material time Government decision No. 2 was applicable in their case. Accordingly, Exhibit P2 in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 and Exhibit P4 in O.P No. 6844 of 1997 are quashed. Consequence is that Exhibit P1 in O.P No. 5702 of 1995 and Exhibit P3 in O.P No. 6844 of 1997 will get revived. If any recovery had been effected, the same shall be refunded to the petitioners.

    10. Original petitions are allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jose Jacob v. State Of Kerala
    (Sep 8, 1998)