Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 2(2) of the Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules.4.
  • rule 2(12) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules.
  • rule 2(2) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules
  • rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules,
  • rule 2(3) of the Chap. XXIII of Kerala Education Rules,
  • rule 2(3) of the Chap. XXII of Kerala Education Rules,
  • rules 2(2) and 6-B(i) of Chap. XXIII
  • XXIII rule 2(2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rule 2(2) of the Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules.4.
  • rule 2(12) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules.
  • rule 2(2) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules
  • rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules,
  • rule 2(3) of the Chap. XXIII of Kerala Education Rules,
  • rule 2(3) of the Chap. XXII of Kerala Education Rules,
  • rules 2(2) and 6-B(i) of Chap. XXIII
  • XXIII rule 2(2)

    Govinda Pillai v. State Of Kerala

    Balasubramanyan, J.:— The original petition giving rise to this appeal was filed by the Manager of an aided school and a sewing mistress appointed in the lower primary school of which he was the Manager. In terms of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules sewing mistress is a specialised teacher. Appointment of petitioner 2 was on 1 June 1987. The post was earlier occupied by one K. Indiramma. Indiramma had continuous service in the school as a sewing mistress from 3 June, 1967 onwards. Indiramma retired on 31 March 1987. The educational authority refused to approve the appointment of petitioner 2 on the ground that under rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules, no post of specialised teacher could be treated in any lower primary school and what was saved by the proviso to that rule was only the person who was holding the post of a specialised teacher in a lower primary school before the commencement of the academic year 1969–70. According to the petitioners, what was saved by the proviso to rule 2(3) of the Chap. XXIII of Kerala Education Rules, was a post of specialised teacher that existed prior to the academic year 1969–70 and not merely the incumbent and the post continues to exist notwithstanding the retirement or death of the prior incumbent of the post. This contention raised on behalf of the petitioners was not accepted by this Court originally and this Court following the decision in Krishnankutty v. Commissioner and Secretary to Government [1988 (1) K.L.T 913], dismissed the original petition. The writ appeal filed by the petitioners against the said judgment was dismissed by the Division Bench by holding that in the light of the decision in Krishnankutty which was binding on the Single Judge there was no scope for interference in appeal. The petitioners challenged the decision of the Division Bench in Civil Appeal No. 10409 of 1995 before the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and accepted the contention of the petitioners that what was saved by the proviso to rule 2(3) of the Chap. XXII of Kerala Education Rules, was the post of specialised teacher that existed prior to the academic year 1969–70 and not merely the incumbent occupying such a post. After disagreeing with the view taken by this Court earlier and holding that the post will continue to exist, the Supreme Court remanded the writ appeal to this Court for considering whether there were any other Government orders abolishing such posts. The Supreme Court indicated the scope of enquiry by this Court as follows:

    “……It is, therefore, not possible without a probe into the matter to decide whether or not at the date of appointment of appellant 2 the post was in fact abolished. That is a question of fact which the High Court will have to consider. We have merely explained the import of the relevant rules and the factual aspect will have to be considered in the light thereof by the High Court.”

    2. Though the Supreme Court gave the parties opportunities to file additional pleadings neither of the parties have filed any additional pleadings before us.

    3. Learned counsel for the appellants. Manager and the teacher submitted that there were no subsequent Government orders which abolished such posts and on the interpretation placed on rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules by the Supreme Court in the order of remand, post continues to subsist and no long as the conditions of Chap. XXIII rule 2(2) are satisfied, the post can be filled by the competent teacher and in this case by petitioner 2. Counsel therefore submitted that the authorities were bound to approve the appointment of petitioner 2 for the concerned academic years. Learned Government Pleader submitted that Exhibit P12 order, dated 22 August 1989, marked in the original petition was a subsequent order abolishing the post. The learned Government Pleader in particular referred to the operative portion of the order reading:

    “In view of the Government decision, dated 27 January 1989, the position is that the posts of specialist teachers in LP and UP Schools which were being continued under the proviso to rules 2(2) and 6-B(i) of Chap. XXIII will terminate with the vacation of the posts by the specialist teacher by retirement, resignation, death and like reasons. No request for approval of fresh appointments against such post will be entertained or allowed by Government or by any educational authority. All the requests received or appeal or revision, etc., pending with the educational authorities should be dealt with and disposed of accordingly.”

    It is also submitted that even otherwise, the existence or otherwise of the post for a particular academic year will depend upon the staff fixation order in terms of the Kerala Education Rules and will also be subject to rule 2(2) of the Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules.

    4. We must observe that even when the Supreme Court made the order of remand after setting aside the interpretation placed by this Court on proviso to rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules, the order Exhibit P12 was available before that Court. That Court did not take note of Exhibit P12 as an order deciding to do away with the posts themselves on the death or retirement of the incumbent at the commencement of the academic year 1969–70. It cannot therefore be said that Exhibit P12 order can now be relied upon to contend that the post no more survives. It is also clear that Exhibit P12 order was passed on the basis of the interpretation placed by this Court on the scope of the proviso to rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules which interpretation has not been accepted by the Supreme Court. We are of the view that since no subsequent order abolishing the posts that were saved by the proviso to rule 2(3) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules as interpreted by the Supreme Court is brought to our notice, it has necessarily be held that the petitioners appellants are entitled to relief in the original petition. But there is merit in the submission that the existence or otherwise of the post for a particular academic year will depend upon the staff fixation order in terms of the Kerala Education Rules and will also be subject to rule 2(12) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules. Hence the only clarification needed is to make it clear that the continuation of the post occupied by petitioner 2 appellant 2 will be subject to the conditions laid down in rule 2(2) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules and will depend upon the staff fixation orders for the respective academic years. We may also notice that in view of the clear pronouncement by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 10409 of 1995, the decision of the Division Bench in Mary Thomas v. State Of Kerala [1991 (2) K.L.T 129], relied on by the learned Government Pleader cannot be considered any longer to be good law.

    5. In the light of our conclusion as above, the orders Exhibits P2, P3, P5, P7, P12 and P15 are quashed and the authorities are directed to approve the appointment of petitioner 2 to the post of sewing mistress in the lower primary school subject to rule 2(2) of Chap. XXIII of the Kerala Education Rules. The parties are directed to suffer their respective costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Govinda Pillai v. State Of Kerala
    (Mar 31, 1999)