AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A suit for partition was filed by Moh'd Sidiq Dareel in the Court of Sub-Judge, Srinagar, claiming ownership of 7 shares purchased from Mst. Zooni, part of joint ancestral property. The first defendant contended that Mst. Zooni had already gifted her entire interest in the property to her brother Ghulam Ahmad Sofi, leaving no title to transfer to the plaintiff. The trial court accepted the defendant's plea regarding the oral gift and dismissed the suit. On appeal, the District Judge reversed this decision, ruling that a valid gift requires a registered instrument under the Transfer of Property Act, thereby decreeing the plaintiff's suit. The defendant further appealed to this Court, challenging the necessity of registration for gifts under Muslim Law and asserting the validity of the oral gift. The case was referred to the Full Bench due to the significant legal question concerning the applicability of the Transfer of Property Act provisions to Muslim oral gifts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Sections 123 and 129 of the Transfer of Property Act supersede the Muhamandan Law on the question of gifts.
  2. Whether it is necessary to have a registered instrument as required by Sections 123 and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act for gifts made under Muhamandan Law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Under Muslim Law, a gift is valid upon declaration by the donor, acceptance by the donee, and delivery of possession, without the necessity of a written instrument.
  • Sections 123 and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act do not apply to gifts made under Muslim Law, as saved by Section 129 of the Act.
  • The parties should be governed by their personal law in matters of gifts, consistent with Section 4 of the Sri Pratap Consolidation of Laws of 1974.
  • The oral gift made by Mst. Zooni was valid and not invalidated by the absence of a registered instrument.
  • The transaction was a pure and simple gift, even if made in consideration of services, and not a sale or Hiba-Bil-Iwaz.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act makes Section 123 applicable to all gifts, including those by Muslims.
  • Section 123 requires a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by two witnesses for a valid gift.
  • Section 138 mandates that transfer of immovable property must be in writing and registered.
  • Reliance on Section 17 of the Jammu and Kashmir Registration Act reinforces the requirement of registration.
  • The alleged gift was not proven factually and, if accepted, was only relinquishment, not a pure gift.
  • If the transaction occurred, it involved consideration, thus detracting from the nature of a gift.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1934 Oudh 163 Validity of oral gifts under Muslim Law; Section 129 saves Muslim Law from Chapter VII of Transfer of Property Act Confirmed that oral gifts are valid under Muslim Law notwithstanding Transfer of Property Act provisions.
AIR 1927 Cal 199 Essentials of a valid gift under Muslim Law: declaration, acceptance, and delivery of possession without requirement of written instrument Supported the principle that a written instrument is not necessary for a valid Muslim gift.
AIR 1937 All 25 Distinction between Hiba and Hiba-Bil-Iwaz; gift by consideration of love and affection or services is a pure gift Used to reject the argument that consideration converts the gift into sale or Hiba-Bil-Iwaz.
35 Ind Cas 14 (AIR 1916 All 351) Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act does not apply to gifts made by Muslims Confirmed inapplicability of Section 123 to Muslim gifts.
AIR 1936 All 600 Court looks to Muslim Law to determine validity of gift, not Section 122 of Transfer of Property Act Reinforced that Muslim Law governs validity of gifts among Muslims, overriding Section 122.
AIR 1929 Pat 417 Rule that Muslim Law applies to gifts made by Muslims even to non-Muslims; oral gift perfected by delivery is valid Applied Muslim Law principles to uphold validity of oral gift despite Transfer of Property Act provisions.
(1888) ILR 11 All 1 Explanation of Hiba-Bil-Iwaz distinguishing it from pure gift Used to clarify that gift made out of affection or services is a pure gift, not Hiba-Bil-Iwaz.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions of Sections 123, 129, and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act in relation to gifts under Muslim Law. Section 129 explicitly excludes the operation of Chapter VII of the Act on gifts made under Muslim Law, thereby preserving Muslim Law's rules on gifts. The Court analyzed the legislative history, noting that prior to the 2003 Bikrami amendment, Section 129 applied Section 123 to all religions, but the amendment deliberately excluded Muslim Law from such application. The essential conditions for a valid gift under Muslim Law—donor's declaration, donee's acceptance, and delivery of possession—do not require a registered written instrument. The Court relied on authoritative precedents affirming that oral gifts under Muslim Law are valid and that Section 123 does not apply to Muslim gifts. Furthermore, the Court rejected the argument that the transaction was a relinquishment or a sale disguised as a gift (Hiba-Bil-Iwaz), holding that gifts made out of affection or in recognition of services remain pure gifts without consideration. The Court clarified that if a registered instrument is executed contemporaneously with the gift, registration is required; however, if the instrument is merely evidentiary and executed after the gift, registration is not necessary.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that Sections 123 and 129 of the Transfer of Property Act do not supersede Muslim Law regarding oral gifts, and it is not necessary to have a registered instrument as required by Sections 123 and 138 of the Act for such gifts.

The direct effect of this decision is to validate oral gifts made under Muslim Law without the requirement of registration, provided the essential conditions of Muslim Law are met. The case was remitted to the learned Single Judge for determination of factual issues. No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming the non-application of certain Transfer of Property Act provisions to Muslim oral gifts.

    Ghulam Ahmad Sofi v. Mohd. Sidiq Dareel And Others

    M. Jalal-Ud-Din, J.:— The following proposition of law has been referred to Page: 60the Full Bench for an authoritative pronouncement.

    (1) Whether in view of the provisions of Sections 123 and 129 of the Transfer of Property Act the Muhamandan Law on the question of gifts stands superseded; and whether it is necessary that there should be a registered instrument as required by Sections 123 and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act in the case of gifts made under that law.

    2. The facts leading to this reference are as follows:

    A suit for partition was brought by Moh'd Sidiq Dareel in the Court of Sub-Judge (Judge Small Causes Court) Srinagar on the ground that he had purchased 7 shares from Mst. Zooni out of the joint property left by Mohd Son her ancestor. It was pleaded on behalf of the first defendant that Mst. Zooni had already relinquished her entire title in favour of her brother Ghulam Ahmad Sofi the defendant therefore she had no title left to transfer it to the vendee plaintiff. The trial Court held that the plea raised by the defendant as regards the oral gift made by Mst. Zooni in favour of her brother was established. It therefore dismissed the suit of the plaintiff. On appeal before the District Judge the legal character of the transaction of the oral gift was challenged on behalf of the plaintiff. The learned District Judge discountenanced the proposition or the oral gift. He found that in order to constitute a valid gift there must be a registered instrument for this purpose. Transfer of property without such an instrument was invalid. He therefore decreed the suit of the plaintiff. A further appeal was taken by Ghulam Ahmad Sofi the defendant before this Court. An argument was advanced that the oral gift was valid in the instant case, and that Sections 123 and 129 of the Transfer of Property Act did not supersede the Mohammadan Law on the subject. As Mst. Zooni had already gifted away the suit property in favour of her brother, therefore, there was no title or interest left in her to transfer it by sale to the plaintiff.

    3. It was also argued that even if Mst. Zooni had gifted the property in consideration of some services that would not make the transaction as Hiba-Bil-Iwaz or clothe it with sale, but it would nevertheless be a pure and simple gift. The proposition of law was, however, controverted at the bar. It was argued on behalf of the plaintiff respondent that the view of the mandatory provisions of Sections 123 and 129 and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act no oral gift of the property could be validly made. It was a sham transaction. Chapter VII of the Transfer of Property Act superseded the rule of Muslim Law relating to making of gifts. The learned single Judge who heard the appeal found the question involved of considerable importance. He, therefore, referred it to the Full Bench. This is how the case has coma before us. We have heard the elaborate arguments of the learned counsel for the parties. Appearing for the appellants Mr. S.T Hussain has submitted that the position under the Muslim Law in regard to making of gifts is that a gift in order to be valid must be made in accordance with the forms prescribed by that law. There is no necessity that there should be an instrument in writing for this purpose. Gift under the Muslim law is complete as soon as a declaration to this effect is made by the donor and it is accepted by the donee and its possession is given by the donor to the donee. When these essential conditions are satisfied the gift becomes complete and valid. Sections 123 and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act have on application to the gifts made under the Muslim Law. Our attention has also been invited to Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act which saves the gifts made under the Muslim Law from the operation of Chapter VII of Transfer of Property Act. He has further canvassed the proposition that in matters relating to gifts the parties are to be guided by their personal law and this is in accordance with Section 4 of the Sri Pratap Consolidation of Laws of 1974. In the instant case it is submitted that there was an oral sift made by Mst. Zooni in favour of her brother. All the conditions required by Muslim law relating to making of gift are satisfied, therefore, the gift was valid. The first appellate Court, it is submitted has proceeded on an erroneous assumption of law and has committed legal error in construing the law on the subject. The gift in the present case was valid notwithstanding the fact that there was no instrument in writing. The transaction partook of a pure and simple gift although it was made in consideration of some services rendered. The transaction could neither be termed as Hiba-Bil-Iwaz nor sale.

    4. Mr. J.N Bhan learned counsel for the respondents has on the other hand seriously disputed the correctness of this proposition of law. He has argued that Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act clearly made Section 123 applicable to all gifts made by Hindus, Budhists or Muslims alike. According to Section 123 a gift could only be made by effecting a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by atleast two witnesses. Attention is also invited to Section 138 of the Transfer of Property Act according to which no transfer of inmovable property is valid unless and until it is in writing and registered according to the law relating to registration of deeds. Reliance is also placed on Section 17 of the Jammu and Kashnir Registration Act. It is also submitted Page: 61that the allegation of transaction of gift was not established on facts and that assuming that there was any such transaction the same was only relinquishment and not gift. Even if the story of the defendants were accepted the act of Mst. Zooni would not constitute a pure and simple gift but the transaction would be in exchange for something which therefore detracted it from the attributes of a gift.

    5. In order to appreciate the legal position it is necessary to refer to Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act which reads as under:

    “Nothing in this Chapter relates to gifts of movable property made in contemplation of death, or shall be ‘deemed to affect, save as provided by’ Section 123, any rule of Hindu or Buddhist law, or to affect any rule of Mohammedan Law.”

    6. According to this section nothing in Chapter VII i.e from Section 122 to 128 (inclusive) relating to gifts is to affect any rule of Mohammedan law. This section, therefore, clearly saves all gifts made under the Mohammedan law from the operation of this Chapter. The scheme of the aforesaid section is that whereas gifts made under Hindu or Budhist law must be made in accordance with Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, this is not so as far as gifts made under the Mohammedan law are concerned. The words “or to affect any rule of Mohammedan law” occurring last of all in Section 129 are independent of the preceding line of the Section. The word's “save as provided by Section 123 any rule of Hindu or Budhist law” do not control the last words of the Section. It will be useful to draw a comparison between Section 129 as it stood before amendment of 2003 Bikrami and the words now engrafted in the present section. Before Samvat 2003 Bikrami the Section was as under:—

    “Nothing in this, chapter relates to gifts of movable property made in contemplation of death, or shall be deemed to affect save as provided by Section 123 any rule of Hindu, Mohammedan or Buddhist law.”

    7. According to the pre-amended law Section 123 affected the mode of making of the gifts under the Hindu, Buddhists and Muslim law alike. In other words Section 123 abrogated the rule relating to gifts made under Hindu, Muslim and Buddhists law. That this section was interpreted so appears from the decision of a Division Bench of this Court reported as J and K Law Reporter volume II, 2000 Bikrami. After 2003 Section 129 was substituted by the present section as reproduced above. It seems that the words “or to affect any rule of Mohammadan Law” have been deliberately substituted in order to exclude the operation of Chapter VII in regard to gifts made by persons professing Muslim faith and made under that law. This has indeed made all the difference in the case of gifts made under any rule of Mbhammadan law and under any other law. Thus if all the formalities as prescribed by the Mohammadan law relating to making of gifts are satisfied i.e there is a declaration by the donor of his intention to make a gift, there is acceptance of the gift by the donee, and delivery of possession of the property is complete, the gift is valid notwithstanding the fact that it is made orally without any instrument. In this view of mine I am fortified by the observations made in AIR 1934 Oudh 163 at p. 165; AIR 1927 Cal 199; AIR 1937 All 25 : 35 Ind Cas 14 : (AIR 1916 All 351); AIR 1936 All 600.

    8. A Division Bench of the Oudh Chief Court in AIR 1934 Oudh 163 (Supra) observed as follows:—

    “One of the rules of Mohammadan law is that an oral gift is valid. Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act provides that nothing in Ch. 7 of that Act which relates to gifts shall be deemed to affect any rule of Mohammadan Law. The gift in question (oral) must therefore be held to be valid unless it can be treated as a sale under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act.”

    9. Again in AIR 1936 All 600 (Supra) a Division Bench consisting of Niamat Ullah and Rachhpal Singh JJ. laid down that the Courts in deciding as to whether or not a particular transaction is a gift according to Mohammadan law would look not to the provisions of Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act but to the rule of Mohammadan law on the point i.e to say they will consider whether the transaction is a valid gift according to Mohammadan law and if it is so then it will be treated as a gift Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act notwithstanding.

    10. Suhrawardy J. in AIR 1927 Cal 199 (Supra) while dealing with the question relating to an oral gift observed that the essentials of a gift under the Mohammadan law are a declaration of he be by the donor, on acceptance, express or implied of the gift by the donee, and delivery of possession of the property according to its nature. A simple gift could only be made by going through the above formalities and no written instrument is required. A gift under the Mohammandan law in order to be valid must be made in accordance with the forms stated above and if it is evidenced by writing unless all the essential forms are observed, it is not valid according to law. That being so, a deed of gift executed by a Mohammandan is not the instrument, effecting, creating or making the gift but a mere piece of evidence, and does not require registration under Section 17 of the Registration Act.

    11. In 35 Ind Cas 14 : (AIR 1916 All 351) (Supra) Sir Henry Richards Chief Justice Allahabad High Court speaking for the Division Bench ruled that the provisions of Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act are inapplicable to gifts made by Monammadans. They are valid according to Mohammadan law.

    12. Again in AIR 1929 Pat 417, a Division Bench of the Court had an occasion to interpret Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act with reference to gifts made under the Mohammadan law. That was a case where a gift was made by a Muslim to a Hindu. Wort J. speaking for the Bench observed that Rule of Mohammadan law would apply to such a gift. Under that law a person governed by that law could make a valid gift by an oral transaction perfected by delivery of possession. To apply the provisions of Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act would render invalid a gift made under Muslim law and have the effect of making the section abrogate a rule of Mohammandan law, in spite of the express provisions of Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act.

    13. In this context it is appropriate to mention here that before the Amending Act XX of 1929 Section 129 of the Indian Transfer of Property Act had the following clause:

    “Or shall be deemed to affect any rule of Mohammadan Law or save as provided by Section 123, any rule of Hindu or Buddhist law.”

    14. After the amendment Section 129 of the Indian Transfer of Property Act stands as under:—

    “Nothing in this chapter relates to gifts of movable property made in contemplation of death, or shall be deemed to affect any rule of Mohammadan Law.”

    15. From this Section as reproduced above it is clear that nothing in this Chapter applies to gifts made under Mohammadan Law. This is reinforced by the summary of the decisions given above.

    16. The ratio of the above cited authorities is therefore in favour of the proposition that an oral gift made under the Muslim law would not be affected by Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act and the gift if it has otherwise all the attributes of a valid gift under the Muslim Law would not become invalid because there is no instrument in writing and registered. Therefore the answer to the question formulated would be in the negative i.e that Sections 123 and 129 of the Transfer of Property Act do not supersedes the Muslim law on matters relating to making of oral gifts, that it is not essential that there should be a registered instrument as required by Sections 123 and 138 of the Transfer of Property Act in such cases. But if there is executed an instrument and its execution is contemporaneous with the making of the gift then in that case the instrument must be registered as provided under Section 17 of the Registration Act. If, however, the making of the gift is an antecedent act and a deed is executed afterwards as evidencing the said transaction that does not require registration as it is an instrument made after the gift is made and does not therefore create, make or complete the gift thereby transferring the ownership of the property from the executant to the person in whose favour it is executed.

    17. The next argument of the plaintiff is with regard to the nature of the transaction, that it was not a gift but only relinquishment, and that even if such a transaction be construed as a gift it would nevertheless be Hiba-Bil-Iwaz which was tantamount to a sale. Our attention has been invited to the pleadings of the second defendant where he has used the word family arrangement. But this contention in our opinion is devoid of any merit in as much as such an intention cannot be gathered from the averments used in the written statement. The word family arrangement has been used as an idiomatic expression. The substance of the defendants case is that the entire property had been gifted by his sister to him. The issue raised in the case is also quite clear. The evidence led also speaks of gift. It is the case of the defendant that his sister had gifted the suit property to him in token of love and affection and also for the fact that he had brought about her marriage. This would not make it a relinquishment nor could this transaction in my opinion be termed as sale or even Hiba-Bil-Iwaz but only a pure and simple gift. It is true that the Chief characteristic of gift is that it is a transfer of a right and interest in the property by the donor without consideration.

    18. But as pointed out by Tyabji in his treatise on Mohammadan law (40th Edition) that Hiba-Bil-Iwaz consists of two separate distinct acts i.e of mutual or reciprocal gift of the properties between the two persons each of whom is deliberately a donor and donee. That indeed is not the case before us. There was no reciprocal or mutual distinct act of donation on either side. It may be that a person who receives a present in most instances feels under social obligation to give gift in return on a suitable occasion. That donation may be said to be Hiba-Bil-Iwaz But gift made out of affection or out of regard for services rendered would not make it a Hiba-bil-Iwaz. Justice Mohmud in (1888) ILR 11 All 1 has elaborately explained the implications of Hiba-Bil-Iwaz distmguishing it from that of Hiba which is by one of the parties in consideration of illusory return such as love and affection and service rendered and thus a pure and simple Hiba. Page: 63These observations of Mohmud J. were quoted with approval in AIR 1937 All 25. These were taken as an authority for the proposition that a gift in lieu of natural love and affection or services cannot in their nature be the subject of gift. Therefore in view of what has been stated above the transaction in the instant case cannot be termed as Hiba-bil-Iwaz but only a pure and simple gift.

    19. These are the legal aspects of the case that we have been called upon to consider and decide.

    20. Having answered the propositions as above the case will now go to the learned Single Judge for deciding the other questions of facts raised in the appeal.

    21. S.M.F Ali, C.J:— I agree.

    22. S. Wasi-Ud-Din, J.:— I agree.

    23. Answer accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ghulam Ahmad Sofi v. Mohd. Sidiq Dareel And Others
    (Oct 23, 1973)