Aftab H. Saikia, J.-
Heard Mr. J. Payeng learned counsel ap pearing for the petitioner (hereinafter referred to as 'the detenu'). Also heard Mr. P. S. Deka learned counsel representing the State of As sam/official respondent Nos. 2 to 6 and Mr. N. Baruah learned Central Government Counsel ('CGC'for short) on behalf of the Union of India/Respondent No. 1.
2. The legality and correctness of the or der dated 7.2.2008 issued by the District Magistrate, Nalbari in exercise of power un der Section 3 of National Security Act, 1980 (for short 'the Act') detaining the detenu Sri Dharmeswar Haloi @ Baity under the Act for his activities being detrimental to the mainte nance of public order and security of the country, have been assailed in this Habeas Corpus petition filed by the detenu himself.
3. The detenu has basically challenged the order on two grounds:
(1) The detaining authority by the im pugned detention order failed to inform the detenu as regards his right to file representa tion before the detaining authority and the same is evident from the impugned detention order itself as well as grounds of detention furnished to the detenu.
(2) There was an inordinate unexplained delay in disposing the representation dated 5.3.2008 of the detenu by the appropriate authorities namely, Government and Central Government inasmuch as the State Government rejected his representation on 31.3.2008 causing an unexplained delay of 26 days when Central Government rejected the representation dated 5.3.2008 on 7.4.2008 after one month.
4. It is a settled law that when a detenu is detained, he has a fundamental right under Article 22 (5) of the Constitution to make representation before the detaining authority in addition to his right to file representation before the Central Government or the appro priate Government. (See (i) Konsam Brojen Singh @ Basan @ Sekhar @ Suraj @ Sainthel @ Basanta @ Inaotomba Vs. State of Manipur & Ors. reported in 2006 (1) GLT 375 (Full Bench) (ii) Miss Dinali Langthasa Vs. Union of India & Ors. in Case W.P(Crl)No. 9/2008 disposed of on 2.6.2008 (iii) Sri Dilip Moran Vs. Union of India in case W. P. (Crl) No. 20 of 2008 disposed of on 27.8.2008.)
5. In the instant case, information as re gards the detenu's right to file representation before the detaining authority, has not been given to the detenu and the same is apparent in the impugned order itself.
For the sake of convenience, the portion relevant as discussed above reflected in "Copy forwarded to'" mentioned in the im pugned detention order may be quoted as under:
"1.........
2
3........
4..........
5........
6.......
7. Sri Dharmeswar Haloi @ Bhaity S/O Sri Bharat Haloi (Das) of village Bishnupur Khat, P. S. Nalbari in Nalbari District for information with a copy of the grounds of detention (both English & Assamese version) He has a right to make a representation to the State Government against the order of detention. He also has a right to claim personal appearance before the Advisory Board. He may make a representation to the Advisory Board, State Govt. & Central Govt. If he feels aggrieved by the above order through the Superintendent of District Jail, Nalbari or District Magistrate, Nalbari." In the grounds of detention the relevant portion in last paragraph may be extracted as under:
"The Subject may if he so desires submit representation against his detention to the Advisory Board, State Government & Central Government through the Superintendent of Dis trict Jail or District Magistrate, Nalbari."
6. Besides in their affidavit the State Gov ernment through respondent Nos. 2 and 3 in paragraph 9 and 12 emphatically admitted that the representation dated 5.3.08 so received by the State Government on 6.3.08 was re jected on 31.3.08 and delay in disposing such representation after 26 days was explained to the effect that the Government was await ing for the parawise comments from the de taining authority which the Government re ceived on 27.3.08. Such explanation pertain ing to non-receipt of parawise comments has been rejected as not tenable under the law and the said ground of delay for seeking and in getting parawise comments from the con cerned authority at a belated stage has already been negated by a catena of judicial pro nouncements; amongst those to cite one is the case of Subrata Paul Vs. Union of India & Ors., reported in 2007(2) GLOJO wherein this Court had the occasion to deal with such similarly situated issue of explaining the delay in disposal of the representation on the ground of non-receipt of parawise comments and in paragraphs 24 and 25 it was held as under:
"24. From the affidavit submitted by the Under Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt. of India, we find that the representation could not be considered for non-receipt of para wise comments from the detailing authority Strangely, the Central Government had to re mind the detaining authority for submitting its comments on 26.10.2006, we have given our anxious consideration whether this could have been a proper explanation for withholding the representation. In our considered opinion both the State Government and the Central Govern ment were at fault. We have already held earlier that the report from the State Government to the Central Government should be a complete one. It is true that in the present case, the detenu had submitted a representation, albeit only in the name of the detaining authority and the same was forwarded to the Central Government. However, the same could not be considered with prompt dispatch by the Central Government due to incomplete dossiers, that is, without com ments from the State. This procedural lacuna resulted in loss of 35 days in considering the representation by the Central Government. Ac cordingly, there was 66 days cumulative delay in disposal of the representation by the State and the Central Government. Having regard to the nature of detention and rigor of the law, we hold that there was disproportionate delay at both the ends.
25. Mrs. B. Goyal learned State Counsel ap pearing for the State submitted that in the case of Shetty Zuraina Begum Vs. Union of India & Ors. [(2002) 10 SCC 448] the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that if the delay is explained, the preventive detention need not be interfered with. In the said case only 20 days' time was taken for considering the representation. Even this delay took place to translate the represen tation from Tamil to English. However, in the case before us, the representation was submit ted in English and despite that both the State Government as well as the Central Government took long periods in considering the representation, above all both these authorities have failed to account for the time taken in disposing the representation."
7. It would be pertinent herein to quote those contentions made on behalf of the State Government narrated at para 9, 10, 11 and 12 in their affidavit and the same may be no ticed as under:
"9. That the humble deponent begs to state that the detenu submitted a representation addressed to the Chairman, Advisory Board, NSA with a copy to the Govt. which was forwarded by the Superintendent District Jail, Nalbari on 5.3.2008 and was received by the State Govern ment on 63.2008.
10. That the humble deponent begs to State that the detaining authority letter dated 25.3.08 forwarded its parawise comments to the State Government which was received by the State Government on 27.3.2008.
11. That the humble deponent begs to state that after receipt of the parawise comments on the representation dated 27.3.2008, the State Government vide its letter dated 27.3.2008 for warded the representation alongwith the para wise comments to the Central Government as well as the State Advisory Board. The State Government also asked the detaining authority vide letter dated 10.3.08 to furnish its parawise comments on the representation submitted by the detenu.
12. That the humble deponent begs to state that vide letter No. PLA. 64/08/64 dated 31.3.2008 the representation of the detenu was rejected by the State Government and the said fact was communicated immediately on the same day to the Central Government, State Advisory Board and to the Superintendent, District Jail, Nalbari to effect service of the order to the detenu. The detenu acknowledged receipt of the rejection order on 09.04.2008."
8. The representation filed by the detenu was also rejected by the Central Government on 7.4.2008 and the same is reflected from the paragraph-13 of the State Government's affidavit which may be quoted as under:
"13. That the humble deponent states that the Central Government rejected the represen tation of the detenu on 7.4.2008."
9. In the affidavit filed by the Central Gov ernment also single ground has been taken in case of such delay i.e. non receipt of parawise comments and receipt of the same at a be lated stage. As discussed above the ground of non-receipt of parawise comments has al ready been discarded by Apex Court as well as this Court.
10. In view of what has been stated dis cussed and observed above, we are of the considered opinion that the impugned deten tion order needs to be interfered with. Con sequently, the impugned detention order dated 7.2.2008 stands quashed and set aside.
11. The detenu Sri Dharmeswar Haloi @ Baity be set at liberty forthwith, if he is not connected with in any other case.
12. In the result this Habeas Corpus suc ceeds and stands allowed. However there shall be no order as to costs.
13. Send down the records forthwith.