Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Madan B. Lokur, CJ

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises under section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The substantial question of law framed for consideration was whether the National Calamity Contingent (NCC) duty is exempted under Notification No.32/99-CE dated 8.7.1999 and, if not, whether CENVAT credit under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 can be utilized towards payment of such duty.

At the adjudicatory stage the Commissioner of Central Excise at Dibrugarh held that CENVAT credit of duty paid on inputs could be utilized only for payment of duty on the final product (per the second proviso to Rule 3(4)), and that CENVAT credit on any other duty could not be utilized for payment of NCC duty. The Commissioner accordingly confirmed a demand (recorded in the opinion as Rs. 82,07,1257) and ordered recovery of NCC duty from the assessee.

The assessee appealed to the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata (Excise Appeal EDM 648/2006). The CESTAT examined Rule 3(4) and Rule 3(7) of the CENVAT Credit Rules and held that while credit of NCC duty could be utilized only for paying NCC duty, that restriction did not extend to utilization of credit of duties not specifically listed in Rule 3(7); consequently, credit on basic excise duty could be used to pay NCC duty. The Supreme Court (Madan B. Lokur, CJ) heard the reference and rendered the present opinion. A preliminary objection as to maintainability of the appeal was raised but the Court did not decide that issue in view of its findings on the substantive questions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether NCC Duty (National Calamity Contingent duty) is a duty exempted under Notification No.32/99-CE dated 8.7.1999.
  2. If NCC Duty is not exempted under the Notification, whether CENVAT credit under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, can be utilized towards payment of such duty.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty can be utilized only for payment of NCC duty (i.e., credit attributable to NCC duty must be used to pay NCC duty).
  • The above limitation, however, does not mean that CENVAT credit on basic excise duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty. In other words, payment of NCC duty through utilization of CENVAT credit that was originally taken on basic excise duty is not prohibited.

Revenue's Arguments

  • CENVAT credit on NCC duty can be utilized only for paying NCC duty and CENVAT credit on basic excise duty cannot be utilized for paying NCC duty.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds in ordered steps based on the text of the concerned statutes, notifications and rules:

  1. Nature and source of NCC duty:
    • The Court notes that NCC duty is leviable under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001, and that sub-section (1) of section 136 makes clear that NCC duty is a surcharge and is a duty of excise. NCC duty is charged in addition to any other duties of excise chargeable under the Central Excise Act.
    • Section 136(3) of the Finance Act makes the provisions of the Excise Act and its Rules relating to refunds and exemptions applicable in relation to levy and collection of NCC duty.
  2. Interpretation of Notification No.32/99-CE:
    • Notification No.32/99-CE grants exemptions to certain goods (First and Second Schedules to the Central Excise Tariff Act) under the exercise of powers from specified provisions of the Excise Act and additional duties Acts (Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and Additional Duties of Excise (Textile and Textile Articles) Act, 1978).
    • The Notification exempts goods from so much of the duty of excise or additional duty of excise leviable under those Acts as is equivalent to the amount of duty paid by the manufacturer other than amounts paid by utilization of CENVAT credit.
    • The Court emphasizes that the Notification's exemptions are limited to duties leviable under the listed Acts (the Central Excise Act and the two Additional Duties Acts) and do not refer to NCC duty, which is levied as a surcharge under the Finance Act, 2001.
    • Conclusion on the first question: NCC duty, although a duty of excise, is not exempted under Notification No.32/99-CE. The Court answers the first part of the substantial question in the negative.
  3. Examination of the CENVAT Credit Rules:
    • Rule 3(1): A manufacturer or producer of a final product is allowed to take CENVAT credit of NCC duty leviable under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001. The parties do not dispute this point.
    • Rule 3(4): Provides that CENVAT credit may be utilized for payment of (a) any duty of excise on any final product; (b) amounts equating to credit on inputs removed as such; (c) amounts equating to credit on capital goods removed as such; (d) amounts under sub-rule (2) of rule 16 Central Excise Rules, 2002; or (e) service tax on any output service. The Rule contains two provisos: the first limits utilization to the extent credit is available on the last day of the relevant period; the second proviso restricts CENVAT credit of duty paid on inputs used in manufacture of final products cleared after availing exemption under specified Notifications (including No.32/99-CE) to be used only for payment of duty on the final product in respect of which the exemption is availed.
    • Rule 3(7): "Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4)," contains specific sub-items (including NCC duty under section 136) and provides that CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty shall be utilized only towards payment of the NCC duty leviable under section 136 on any final products manufactured by the manufacturer. The Court highlights that Rule 3(7) limits utilization of credit in respect of listed duties to payment of duties under the respective statutes.
  4. Resolution of the second question (utilization of other CENVAT credit to pay NCC duty):
    • The Court accepts the CESTAT's interpretation that Rule 3(7)'s restriction (that credit in respect of NCC duty can be used only for payment of NCC duty) does not imply the converse prohibition that credit in respect of other duties cannot be used to pay NCC duty.
    • The Court reasons that the use of the word "respectively" in Rule 3(7) confines utilization of the CENVAT credit obtained in respect of a particular duty to payment of duty under that particular statute. However, this one-way confinement does not prevent credits obtained otherwise (for example, credit of basic excise duty) from being used to pay the NCC duty.
    • Because Rule 3(4) allows utilization of CENVAT credit for payment of any duty of excise on a final product, subject to the limitations in Rule 3(7), and because Rule 3(7) does not list basic excise duty as a duty whose credit is restricted from being used to pay NCC duty, the Court finds that CENVAT credit of duties other than NCC duty may be utilized to pay NCC duty.
    • The Court concludes that the Commissioner's ruling that CENVAT credit of basic excise duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty was erroneous.
  5. Administrative history and outcome:
    • The Commissioner confirmed a demand and ordered recovery. The CESTAT allowed the appeal in part, holding that credit on basic excise duty could be used to pay NCC duty. The Supreme Court agrees with the CESTAT's view and answers the second part of the reference in the affirmative.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court answered the two-part substantial question as follows:

  • First part: Answered in the negative — NCC duty is not exempted under Notification No.32/99-CE dated 8.7.1999.
  • Second part: Answered in the affirmative — while CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty may be utilized only for payment of NCC duty (per Rule 3(7)), CENVAT credit obtained from other sources (for example, credit of basic excise duty) can be utilized for payment of NCC duty on the final product in terms of the CENVAT Credit Rules (notably Rule 3(4)), subject to the limitations expressed in the Rules.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The consequence for the parties is that the Commissioner's finding — that CENVAT credit of basic excise duty could not be used to pay NCC duty — was incorrect. The CESTAT's view allowing utilization of other CENVAT credits to pay NCC duty is endorsed by the Court.
  • The ruling clarifies the interplay between Rule 3(4) and Rule 3(7) of the CENVAT Credit Rules: Rule 3(7) restricts usage of credit taken in respect of certain duties (including NCC duty) to payment of the corresponding duty, but does not by implication prevent the use of credits arising under other duties to satisfy NCC duty liabilities.
  • No broader precedent beyond the decision's direct application to the dispute is discussed in the opinion; the Court does not purport to establish an expansive new principle beyond the resolution of the reference framed. The opinion notes that a preliminary objection on maintainability was raised but declines to decide it in view of the substantive determination.

Disposition: The reference is answered accordingly in the manner set out above.

    Commissioner Of Central Excise v. Pragbosimi Synthetics Ltd.

    Madan B. Lokur, CJ;-

    1. In this appeal under section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 the following substantial question of law has been framed for consideration :

    "Whether NCC Duty (National Calamity Contingent duty) is a duty exempted under Notification No.32/99-CE dated 8.7.1999 and, if not, whether CENVAT Credit under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, can be utilized, towards payment of such duty, which is not exempted under the said Notification."

    2. The substantial question of law is really in two parts: The first part being whether NCC duty is exempted under Notification No.32/99-CE. If the answer to the first part is in the negative, then the second part is, whether CENVAT credit under the CENVAT Credit Rules can be utilized towards payment of NCC duty. Our answer to the first part of the question is in the negative and our answer to the second part of the question is in the affirmative.

    3. NCC duty is leviable under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001. Sub-section (1) of section 136 of the Finance Act makes it clear that NCC duty is by way of a surcharge and is a duty of excise. NCC duty is chargeable on goods specified in 7th Schedule of the Finance Act and is in addition to any other duties of excise chargeable on such goods under the Central Excise Act, 1944 ('the Excise Act'). In terms of section 136(3) of the Finance Act the provisions of the Excise Act and the Rules made thereunder relating to refunds and exemptions from duties, etc., apply in relation to the levy and collection of NCC duty.

    4. From the above, it is quite clear that NCC duty is nothing but a duty of excise and on this, learned counsel for both parties are ad idem.

    5. Notification No.32/99-CE relates to exemption to North East States from excise duty and additional excise duty on goods cleared from certain units. This Notification has been issued in exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 5Aof the Excise Act read with sub-section (3) of section 3 of the Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and sub-section (3) of section 3 of the Additional Duties of Excise (Textile and Textile Articles) Act, 1978. By virtue of this Notification the Central Government has exempted goods specified in the First and Second Schedules to the Central Excise Tariff Act from so much of the duty of excise or additional duty of excise, as the case may be, leviable thereon under any of the said Acts as is equivalent to the amount of duty paid by the manufacturer of goods other than the amount of duty paid by utilization of CENVAT credit under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

    6. It is clear from the above that the general exemption is only in respect of the duty of excise or additional duty of excise under any of the above Acts, namely, the Central Excise Act, 1944, the Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and the Additional Duties of Excise (Textile and Textile Articles) Act, 1978.

    The general exemption has absolutely no reference to NCC duty which is levied as a surcharge under the provisions of the Finance Act, 2001.

    7. Consequently, insofar as the first part of the substantial question of law framed above is concerned, it must be answered in the negative which is to say that NCC duty, even though it is a duty of excise, is not exempted under Notification No-32/99-CE. The operation of this Notification is limited.

    8. The second part of the substantial question of law would now arise, namely, whether CENVAT credit can be utilized towards payment of NCC duty under the CENVAT Credit Rules.

    9. In this regard it is necessary to go through the CENVAT Credit Rules, particularly Rule 3(4) and Rule 3(7) thereof.

    10. Rule 3( 1) provides that a manufacturer or producer of a final product shall be allowed to take CENVAT credit of the NCC duty leviable under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001. To this extent there is no dispute between the parties.

    11. Rule 3(4) of the CENVAT Credit Rules is important and this reads as follows :

    (4) The CENVAT credit may be utilized for payment of-

    (a) any duty of excise on any final product; or

    (b) an amount equal to CENVAT credit taken on inputs if such inputs are removed as such or after being partially processed; or

    (c) an amount equal to the CENVAT credit taken on capital goods if such capital goods are removed as such; or

    (d) an amount under sub-rule (2) of rule 16 of Central Excise Rules, 2002 ; or

    (e) service tax on any output service :

    Provided that while paying duty of excise or service tax, as the case may be, the CENVAT credit shall be utilized only to the extent such credit is available on the last day of the month or quarter, as the case may be, for payment of duty or tax relating to that month or the quarter, as the case may be :

    Provided further that the CENVAT credit of the duty, or service tax, paid on the inputs, or input services, used in the manufacture of final products cleared after availing of the exemption under the following Notifications of Government of India in the Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue), -

    (i) No. 32/99-Central Excise, dated the 8th July, 1999 [GSR 508(E), dated 8th July, 1999];

    (ii) No. 33/99-Central Excise, dated the 8th July, 1999 [GSR 509(E), dated 8th July, 1999];

    (iii) No. 39/2001-Central Excise, dated the 31st July, 2001 [GSR 565(E), dated the 31st July, 2001];

    (iv) No. 56/2002-Central Excise, dated the 14th November, 2002 [GSR 764(E), dated the 14th November, 2002];

    (v) No. 57/2002-Central Excise, dated 14th November, 2002 [GSR 765XE), dated the 14th November, 2002];

    (vi) No. 56/2003-Central Excise, dated the 25th June, 2003 [GSR 513(E), dated the 25th June, 2003]; and

    (vii) No. 71/2003-Central Excise, dated the 9th September, 2003 [GSR 717(E), dated the 9th September, 2003], shall, respectively, be utilized only for payment of duty on final products, in respect of which exemption under the said respective Notifications is availed of.

    Rule 3(4) provides that CENVAT credit may be utilized, inter alia, for payment of any duty of excise on any final product. To this extent also there is no dispute between the parties. However, what is of importance is the second proviso to Rule 3(4) of the CENVAT Credit Rules. This provides that the CENVAT credit of duty paid on inputs used in the manufacture of a final product cleared after availing of the exemption under Notification No-32/99-CE shall be utilized only for payment of duty on the final product in respect of which exemption under the said Notification is availed of. It is clear from this -that CENVAT credit of duty paid on inputs shall be utilized only for payment of duty on the final product for which exemption is availed.

    12. Rule 3(7) is equally important and this reads as follows :

    "(7) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4), -

    (a) .

    (b) CENVAT credit in. respect of, -

    (c) .............................................................................................

    (ii) the National Calamity Contingent duty leviable under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001 (14 of 2001);

    (iv) .............................................................................................

    (v).............................................................................................

    (vi) .............................................................................................

    shall be utilized only towards payment of.......the National Calamity Contingent duty leviable under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001, ....... respectively, on any final products manufactured by the manufacturer........." (words not necessary are deleted)

    Rule 3(7) provides that notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4), CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty shall be utilized only towards payment of the NCC duty under section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001 on any final product manufactured by the manufacturer.

    13. Insofar as the assessee is concerned the contention urged was that CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty can be utilized only for payment of NCC duty. But this does not mean that CENVAT credit on basic excise duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty on the final product. Simply put, the contention is that payment of NCC duty through utilization of CENVAT credit on basic excise duty is not prohibited. The question is whether this is permissible or not. According to the Revenue, CENVAT credit on NCC duty can be utilized only for paying NCC duty and CENVAT credit on basic excise duty cannot be utilized for paying NCC duty.

    14. On the above broad facts, the matter was adjudicated before the Commissioner of Central Excise at Dibrugarh and he came to the conclusion that CENVAT credit of duty paid on inputs can be utilized only for payment of duty on the final product as per the second proviso to Rule 3(4) but CENVAT credit on any other duty could not be utilized for payment of NCC duty. Accordingly, the said Commissioner confirmed the demand of Rs, 82,07,1257, and passed an order for recovery of NCC duty from the assessee.

    15. Feeling aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal before the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal at Kolkata. The appeal filed by the assessee was registered as Excise Appeal EDM 648/2006. The CESTAT noticed the provisions of Rule 3(4) as well as the provisions of Rule 3(7) of the CENVAT Credit Rules and held that though credit of NCC duty could be utilized for paying NCC duty only, the restriction would not extend to utilization of credit of duty which is not specifically listed in Rule 3(7). The corollary to this argument is that since credit on basic excise duty is not mentioned in Rule 3(7), CENVAT credit on basic excise duty could be utilized for payment of NCC duty.

    16. We are in agreement with the view expressed by the CESTAT. In terms of rule 3(1) a manufacturer or producer of a final product is allowed to take CENVAT credit of NCC duty. Since NCC duty is admittedly a duty of excise, Rule 3(4) provides that CENVAT credit may be utilized for payment of any duty of excise on any final product. Therefore, CENVAT credit of NCC duty may also be utilized for payment of any duty of excise on any final product in terms of Rule 3(4) subject to Rule 3(7).

    17. Rule 3(7) limits the utilization of CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty as also other duties mentioned in Rule 3(7)(b). It provides that CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty and other duties shall be utilized towards payment of duty of excise leviable under various statutes respectively. The use of the word "respectively" in this regard is important inasmuch as it confines the utilization of CENVAT credit obtained to a particular statute and for utilization for payment of duty under that statute only. The converse, however, does not follow. That is to say that merely because CENVAT credit in respect of NCC duty can be utilized only for payment of NCC duty, it does not follow that any other credit of duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty.

    18. This being the position, in our opinion the Commissioner of Central Excise at Dibrugarh was in error in coming to the conclusion that CENVAT credit of basic excise duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty on the final product.

    19. Under the circumstances the second part of the substantial question of law must be answered in the affirmative and it must be held that while CENVAT credit of NCC duty can be utilized under the CENVAT Credit Rules only towards payment of such NCC duty, CENVAT credit obtained from other sources can be utilized for payment of NCC duty on the final product.

    20. The reference is answered accordingly.

    21. We may note that a preliminary objection was raised about the maintainability of the appeal, but in the view that we have taken, it is not necessary to decide that issue.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Central Excise v. Pragbosimi Synthetics Ltd.
    (Jun 29, 2011)