Ashok Bhan, J. - The present revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, has been filed by the defendant-judgment debtors (hereinafter referred to as, the J.D.). The facts giving rise to the revision petition are as under : Plaintiff-decree holder (hereinafter referred to as the DH) filed a suit for the recovery of the Rs. 5500/- as arrears of rent. The suit was decreed on 1st November, 1984. Decree holder filed an execution application to which the judgment debtors filed their objections. The objection petition filed by the J.Ds was decided on 12th January, 1987, a copy of which is attached with the petition as Annexure P.1. In the objection petition it was stated that the decree dated Ist November, 1984 was not binding on the judgment debtors as the same was null and void and incapable of execution. The other objections taken were that the impugned decree was passed in contravention of mandatory provisions of section 10 of the Code of the Civil Procedure. 2. On the pleadings of the parties, the following four issues were framed by the executing Court: (1) Whether the impugned decree is null and void and incapable of execution ? OPJD (2) Whether the impugned decree was passed in contravention of the mandatory provisions of section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If so, to what effect ? OPJD. (3) Whether the impugned decree was passed in contravention of the provisions of section 11, Code of Civil Procedure ? If so to what effect ? OPJD. (4) Relief. 3. After a detailed discussion, the executing Court recorded a finding that the decree was not executable as the same stood satisfied which was apparent from the very acts of the decree holder who had accepted Rs. 20,000/- vide two receipt as full and final settlement. Issue No. 1 was decided in favour of the judgment debtor and against the decree holder. Under issue No. 2 and 3, it was held that the executing Court could not go into the question as to whether there has been any contravention of sections 10 and 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Both these issues were negatived against the judgment debtor. Consequent upon the finding recorded on issue No. 1, the executing Court should have held that objections filed by the J. D. are upheld and the execution application filed by the decree holder is dismissed but instead it seems due to some typographical mistake, the following order was passed:
"As a result of foregoing discussion and findings, the present execution petition succeeds and the same is hereby accepted and consequently, the present execution application is hereby dismissed as not maintainable because the impugned decree is not executable. In the peculiar circumstances of the case, there is no order as to costs."
4. Since there was a confusion in the order of the trial Court while recording the finding under the issue regarding relief, decree holder filed an appeal before the Additional District Judge, Faridabad. Evidently, after the amendment of definition of 'decree' under
section 2(2) of the Civil Procedure Code as amended in 1976, an order passed by the executing Court under
section 47 of the code could not be treated as a decree and consequently the order passed under
section 47 of the code, dismissing the execution petition was no longer appealable. No such objection was taken before the appellate Court and the appellate Court proceeded to decide the appeal on merits. It was held by the Additional District Judge,. vide his order dated 3rd February, 1988 (Annexure P-2) that the matter had been confused by the trial Court and under the circumstance instead of deciding the appeal on merits, set aside the order, of the trial Court and remanded the same to the executing court for fresh decision. The parties were directed to appear before the executing Court on 9th February, 1988. 5. On appearance before the executing Court, an application was filed on behalf of the decree holder under
Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure for leading Additional evidence. Judgment debtor took an objection that, no appeal was competent against the order passed by the executing Court under
Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure as the order passed under
Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure was not a decree within the meaning of
section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure after its amendment in 1976. Executing Court held that it was not competent to go into the question of appeal being maintainable or not because the Senior Sub Judge who was the executing Court was subordinate to the Court of Additional District Judge and it could not sit in judgment over the superior Court. If there 'was any objection regard the order of remand passed by the Additional District Judge then the judgment debtor should have challenged the same in the appropriate forum. Application under
Order 47, Rule 27 of the Code of -Civil Procedure was allowed and the decree holder was permitted to lead additional evidence. This order was passed by the executing, Court on 29th September; 1989. 6. Petitioner has filed the present petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, challenging the order (Annexure P-2). passed by the Additional District Judge and the subsequent order passed by the executing Court on 29th September, 1989 (Annexure P-3). 7. I have heard the Learned counsel for the petitioner at length. 8. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner at the outset submitted that the order of Additional District Judge, is without jurisdiction as no appeal was competent before it because no appeal was maintainable against an order passed by the execution Court under
Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure because section 47 had been taken out of the purview of the word decree as given in
section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure. For this proposition, he relied upon
Jagar Ram and others v. Jagjit Singh,
AIR 1984 Pb. & Hr. 281, wherein it has been held that with change in the definition of 'decree' under
section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure as amended in 1976, an order passed by the executing Court under
Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure is not to be treated as a decree and consequently the order passed under section 47 dismissing the objection is no longer appealable. I find force in this submission of the counsel of the petitioner. 9. Counsel appearing for the respondent contended that the present revision petition is clearly time barred. To this counsel appearing for the petitioner replied that strictly the
Indian Limitation Act, does not apply to the proceedings under
Article 227 of the Constitution; he further stated that he has no objection to the setting aside of the order of Additional District Judge passed on 3rd February, 1988 (Annexure P-2) is well as to the setting aside of the order dated 12th January, 1987 (Annexure P-1) passed by Senior Sub Judge as some confusion has been created in the order of the executing Court while deciding issue No. 4 regarding relief. Since the order of Additional District Judge dated 3rd February, 1988 (Annexure P-2 is without jurisdiction and since no appeal was competent against the order of the executing Court passed under Section 47, I deem it appropriate to set aside the said order. The order of the executing Court dated 12th January, 1987, is also set aside as there is some confusion in the same while disposing of issue No. 4. Accordingly, the order dated 12th January, 1987 is also set aside. The order dated 29th September,
1989 (P-3) which was passed by the executing Court after remand of the case to it by the Additional District Judge is also set aside. 10. Since I have set aside the order of the executing Court passed on 12th January 1987 the case is remanded to the executing court for re-decision on issue No. 4. Under issue No. 1 the trial Court had recorded a clear finding after an elaborate discussion that the impugned decree dated 1st November 1984 was not executable as it stood satisfied. As a consequence of the finding on issue No. 4 the executing Court should have accepted the objection petition and dismissed the execution application but it seems due to some typographical mistake or otherwise contradictory orders have been passed in para 10 of the order which has been reproduced in the earlier part of the judgment by the executing Court. The executing Court shall now re-write its clear finding under issue No. 4 keeping in view the findings recorded by it on issue No. 1 to 3. No costs. 11. Parties through their counsel are directed to appear before the executing Court on 20th July 1992. Orders accordingly.