Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    Brij Lal v. Sohan Lal & Ors.

    S.C. Malte, J. - This appeal is preferred against the judgement and decree by which declaration was granted by the Courts below to the effect that the plaintiffs-respondents are the owners in possession of the suit property. The plaintiff have come to the Court with the contention that by registered sale deed dated 30.11.1959, they purchased the suit property for a consideration of Rs. 35,000/- and are in possession of it as owners. They further submit that, despite the purchase of the property, the revenue record was, however, not correctly shown. They, therefore, came to the Court for a declaration that they are the owners in possession of the property. 2. The defendant-appellant, by a written statement, contended that the plaintiffs were in unauthorised possession and that they were formerly the tenant on the suit property. It was further claimed that the plaintiffs had got executed a document of sale of the suit land without giving consideration for it. At the time of execution they simply assured that they would later on pay the consideration. It was contended that no such consideration ever was passed. The other point raised by him was the waiver of the right of ownership on the ground that the plaintiffs continued to be the tenants and accepted the defendants as the owner of the property. On this premises, it was contended that the plaintiffs are estopped from raising the claim that they were the owners of the property. It was further contended that the suit property was not the same which the plaintiffs were allotted in the course of consolidation of proceedings. In other words, certain question regarding the identity of the land had also been raised. 3. The trial Court held that the sale deed has been duly executed and there was nothing to show that the consideration had not passed. On the question regarding the identity of the property, the trial Court held that the identity of the property was properly established. On these main findings, the trial Court decreed the suit. 4. The matter was taken up before the first appellate Court. The question regarding the limitation to file the suit had also been raised and the first appellate Court held in favour of the plaintiffs. The next point raised before the first appellate Court pertains to the estoppee and that was also negatived. As regards the identity of the suit property, the first appellate Court referred to the admissions made by the defendant in the earlier proceedings wherein he had admitted that the suit property was the one which underwent change in number during the Consolidation proceedings. The first appellate Court also relied on Jamabandi Exhibit P-3 in which the possession of the suit land prior to and subsequent to the Consolidation proceedings was mentioned. Consequently, the first appellate Court dismissed the appeal by judgement and decree dated 28.3.1979. 5. In this Court it was submitted that the identity of the property was not correctly established. It was contended that the property which was covered by the so called sale-deed, had not remained the same after the Consolidation. 6. The question of limitation to file the suit has been properly dealt with by the lower appellate Court. The plaintiffs sought a declaration of ownership on the basis of the sale deed in their favour. The pleadings of the parties clearly indicate that the plaintiffs remained in possession from 1959, and, since prior to that as tenants. If any person raises a dispute regarding the ownership of the property in the set of circumstances mentioned above, the suit can be filed the moment he raises such questions. The matter does not depend upon as to what the revenue record in such cases shows regarding the ownership. The sale deed in such cases is the document of ownership and the revenue record only mentions a name of the person who would be primarily responsible for payment of revenue. In my opinion, therefore, the suit was rightly held to be within limitation. Such question is squarely covered by a Division Bench judgement reported as Ibrahim alias Dharam Vir v. Smt. Sharifan alias Shanti, 1979 P.L.J 469. It has been held therein that mere entry in the mutation record in the name of the defendant would not furnish a cause of action to the plaintiff to file the suit, and the cause of action arises when defendants actually threaten to take forcible possession. Article 58 of the Limitation Act would be applicable in this case. According to the plaintiffs, the cause of action had arisen two months prior to the filing of the suit. The suit was filed on 6.9.1975. It is, therefore, well within limitation. 7. There is also no question of any waiver of title or estoppel to file the suit for declaration of ownership. The question of estoppel would come to play only if due to the act of one party, the other party in belief has changed his position, and now the turn about would not be possible without detriment to the other party. There is no such question here. Section 116 of the Evidence Act is also not attracted because there is nothing to indicate that plaintiff paid rent to defendant and admitted ownership of the defendant even after the sale deed of the suit land. 8. The defendant-appellant has also raised the question regarding the lack of consideration of the sale. The sale deed in question is registered document, and the lower appellate Court has rightly observed that an element of presumption is in favour of passing consideration while executing the sale deed. Such endorsement are made by the Sub-Registrar while registering the document, and those endorsements carry the presumption of correctness unless contrary is proved. The sale deed in question has been executed long back in 1959. It is very difficult to accept that the defendant-appellant would keep quite till the suit was filed against him in 1975. I thus find no substance in the contention that no consideration had passed while executing the sale-deed. 9. The next question raised before me pertains to the identity of the suit property. In the year 1959 when the sale deed was executed, the property bore the revenue Khasra No. 1391/112. The defendant-appellant has raised the question as to the identity of the property after the consolidation proceedings. In my opinion, such question can very well be sorted out in the light of evidence on record. On executing the sale deed, the title in the property had already passed in favour of the purchases/plaintiffs, long back in 1959. The proceedings under the Consolidation Act were then not made applicable. While the title in the property had thus passed, it is of little significance as to what changes thereafter the property underwent. The defendant is not at all concerned with the subsequent changes. Moreover, in this case, the defendant was confronted with the admission in proceedings before the Assistant Collector, II Grade, Mandi Dabwali, vide Exhibit P-6, wherein he had admitted that Khasra No. 1391/112 was the old survey number. The said admission was made in 1975. Therefore, the identity of the property, as mentioned in Exhibit P-6, pertains to the property after the Consolidation proceedings were over. The lower appellate Court has considered the previous statement (Exhibit P-6) of the defendant. In addition to that, he has taken into consideration the copy of Jamabandi Exhibit P-3 which shows that Khasra No. 1391/112 was among the lands which underwent change after the Consolidation Proceedings. I thus find that there is nothing wrong in the approach of the lower appellate Court and the conclusion drawn on the point of fact does not deserve any further interference. 10. I thus find no substance in this appeal. It is dismissed with Costs. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Brij Lal v. Sohan Lal & Ors.
    (Aug 4, 1995)