Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 227 of the High Court O.S Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 227 of the High Court O.S Rules,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit was filed on 30 October 1995. A writ of summons was stated to have been served on 16 December 1995. Summons for Judgment, however, were taken out only on 30 December 1996 — i.e., well beyond six months from service. The late issuance of Summons for Judgment engaged Rule 227 of the High Court O.S. Rules, which provides that where summons for judgment are not taken out within six months the suit ought to be placed on the Board for dismissal.

The plaintiff's counsel (Mr. Sanglikar) acknowledged an error in the calculation of interest in the plaint and asked for permission to withdraw the Summons for Judgment and to take out fresh Summons for Judgment after amending the plaint. The defendants' counsel (Mr. Madan) contended that the gross delay entitled the defendants to unconditional leave to defend and relied on prior authority to support that submission.

The Court considered competing authorities and the scope of its discretion under Rule 227, and ultimately determined the appropriate consequences for the parties. The Summons for Judgment was disposed of by the Court's order described below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the late taking out of Summons for Judgment (after the six-month period) requires dismissal of the suit, or whether the Court has discretion to grant unconditional leave to the defendants or to permit the plaintiffs to withdraw and refile after amending the plaint.
  2. Whether a plaint that includes a claim for interest not warranted by statute or contract renders the suit unsuitable for summary procedure and, if so, what the appropriate remedy is (unconditional leave to defend or permission to withdraw and amend).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments (Mr. Sanglikar)

  • The plaint contains a mistake in the calculation of interest; consequently the present Summons for Judgment should be withdrawn so that the plaint can be amended and fresh Summons for Judgment taken out.
  • There was an argument (advanced in reliance on an earlier single-judge judgment of Justice N.D. Vyas) that Rule 227 gives the Court a wider discretion (including the discretion to decree ex parte) even where Summons for Judgment are taken out after six months, particularly if defences are frivolous or merely technical.

Defendant's Arguments (Mr. Madan)

  • The gross delay in taking out the Summons for Judgment entitles the defendants to unconditional leave to defend the suit.
  • Reliance was placed on a judgment of this Court in Central Bank of India v. Femme Pharma Ltd., AIR 1982 Bom. 67, which the defendant contended supports granting unconditional leave where Summons for Judgment are taken out after delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Central Bank of India v. Femme Pharma Ltd., AIR 1982 Bom. 67 Held (per paragraph 4 reproduced) that where Summons for Judgment are taken out after such delay, unconditional leave to defend should be granted; suit transferred to long-list; written statement within 8 weeks; usual orders for discovery and inspection. The defendants relied on this authority. The Court found Justice Mody's view in that case to be consonant with later Division Bench authority and treated it as supportive of the defendants' entitlement to leave in appropriate circumstances.
Judgment of Justice N.D. Vyas dated 26 Feb 1994 (Summons for Judgment No. 731 of 1991 in Suit No. 2684 of 1990) Interpreted Rule 227 as giving a wider discretion under which the Court may decree the suit ex parte even if Summons for Judgment were taken out after six months, where defences are frivolous or technical. The Court noted this view but held it to be contrary to later Division Bench authority; the Court rejected Justice Vyas's interpretation as inconsistent with the binding Division Bench decisions subsequently discussed.
Randerian & Singh (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Indian Overseas Bank, Appeal No. 1060 of 1986 (Division Bench: S.K. Desai & N.K. Parekh, JJ.) Held that if the plaint makes a claim for interest not warranted by statute or contract, the suit cannot be accepted as a summary suit; consequences are either (a) grant unconditional leave to defend and transfer to appropriate cause list, or (b) permit plaintiffs to withdraw Summons for Judgment with liberty to take out fresh Summons for Judgment after amending the plaint. The Court treated this Division Bench judgment as authoritative to resolve the apparent conflict between single-judge decisions and followed its rule as laying down the correct approach.
Hydraulic and General Engg. Ltd. v. UCO Bank, 1998 (1) LJ 793 (Division Bench) Applied and followed the principle in Randerian & Singh: where a plaint contains claim(s) not suitable for summary suit, the plaintiffs should be permitted to amend and refile within a time frame or else defendants are to be granted unconditional leave to defend. The Court observed that this Division Bench followed Appeal No. 1060 of 1986 and confirmed that the correct course is to require amendment or to grant unconditional leave; the present Court relied on this confirmation in reaching its decision.
Order of Justice Deshpande dated 6 Oct 1998 (Summons for Judgment No. 385 of 1997 in Summary Suit No. 1584 of 1995) Applied the view consistent with Justice Mody’s approach as reflected in Central Bank (single-judge) and followed the result reached therein. The Court noted that Justice Deshpande followed Justice Mody's view; this was cited as one among the authorities consistent with the Division Bench position and supportive of granting defendants leave in appropriate circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in the following analytical steps, based solely on the materials and authority placed before it:

  1. Factual threshold: The Court observed that Summons for Judgment were taken out more than six months after service of the writ of summons — a fact that, under Rule 227 of the High Court O.S. Rules, requires the suit to be placed on the Board for dismissal. The Court also noted an asserted mistake in the plaint's calculation of interest.
  2. Review of competing authorities: The Court examined two conflicting single-judge approaches. Justice N.D. Vyas had held that Rule 227 allows the Court to exercise a wide discretion and possibly decree the suit ex parte even when Summons for Judgment are taken out after six months (particularly where defences are frivolous). Justice Mody (in Central Bank) had taken a different view that the present rule gives the Court a wider discretion than under the old rules and that the Court is not bound to dismiss the suit.
  3. Reliance on Division Bench authority to resolve conflict: The Court found the conflict between single-judge decisions resolved by a Division Bench in Randerian & Singh (Appeal No. 1060 of 1986). That Division Bench held that where plaintiffs have made claims (for example, interest) not warranted by statute or contract — rendering the plaint unsuitable for summary procedure — two consequences are available: either grant the defendants unconditional leave to defend and transfer the suit to an appropriate cause list, or permit the plaintiffs to withdraw the Summons for Judgment and refile after amending the plaint. The Court noted that another Division Bench in Hydraulic & General Engg. Ltd. v. UCO Bank confirmed this approach.
  4. Application to present facts: The Court recorded that Mr. Sanglikar (plaintiff's counsel) admitted the plaint in its present form could not be entertained as a summary suit. Given that admission and in light of the Division Bench authority, the Court concluded that the defendants were entitled to unconditional leave to defend rather than permitting the plaintiffs to withdraw their Summons for Judgment in the circumstances before the Court.
  5. Rejection of the request for a reference to a larger Bench: The Court observed that two Division Benches had already laid down the law; accordingly, the submission that the conflict between Justice Vyas and Justice Mody required reference to a larger Bench was rejected.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court granted unconditional leave to defend to the defendants. The plaintiff's request to withdraw the Summons for Judgment was declined.

Direct consequences and directions given by the Court:

  • The plaintiff is at liberty to take out any necessary amendments to the plaint, if so advised.
  • The suit was transferred to the list of Commercial causes.
  • The defendants must file their written statement within 12 weeks from the date of the order.
  • An affidavit of documents must be filed within eight weeks after the written statement.
  • The usual orders as to discovery and inspection were made.
  • The Summons for Judgment was disposed of accordingly; there was no order as to costs.
  • Miscellaneous administrative directions: the Prothonotary to act on the copy of the order certified by the Chamber Registrar; certified copy expedited.

Implications regarding precedent: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; rather, it follows and applies the law as laid down by earlier Division Bench decisions (notably Randerian & Singh and Hydraulic & General Engg.). The immediate effect is procedural and binding on the parties in this suit (grant of unconditional leave and the timetable set out above).

    United Western Bank Ltd. v. Marmago Steel Ltd.

    1. The present suit was filed on 30th October, 1995. Summons for Judgment was taken out on 30th December, 1996. Writ of summons was also stated to be served on 16th December, 1995. Clearly thus Summons for Judgment have not been taken out within six months. Thus under Rule 227 of the High Court O.S Rules, the suit ought to have been placed on Board for dismissal. Furthermore, Mr. Sanglikar very fairly points out that there is a mistake about the calculation of interest. In view of the above he points out that it would be necessary to withdraw the present Summons for Judgment and to take out fresh Summons for Judgment after making the necessary amendment in the plaint.

    2. Mr. Madan, learned Counsel appearing for the Defendants, on the other hand points out that in view of the gross delay in taking out the Summons for Judgment, the Defendants are entitled to unconditional leave. In support of this proposition he cites a judgment of this Court in the case of Central Bank of India v. Femme Pharma Ltd., AIR 1982 Bom. 67. In the aforesaid judgment in paragraph 4 it is held as follows:—

    “In view of the fact that the summons for judgment has been taken out after such delay, unconditional leave to defend. Suit transferred to the list of long causes. Written statement within 8 weeks. Usual orders for discovery and inspection.”

    This judgment has also been followed by Justice Deshpande in his order dated October 6, 1998 in Summons for Judgment No. 385 of 1997 in Summary Suit No. 1584 of 1995. Mr. Sanglikar, however, relies on a judgment of Justice N.D Vyas dated 26th February, 1994 in Summons for Judgment No. 731 of 1991 in Suit No. 2684 of 1990. In this judgment, it is noticed that the first defence which was canvassed was that the summons for judgment not having been taken out within six months unconditional leave should be granted. Justice Vyas held that Rule 227 of the High Court O.S Rules gives wider discretion to the Court especially in view of the fact that there is no defence on merits. Mr. Sanglikar submits that the aforesaid observation of Justice Vyas is in conflict with the view taken by Justice Mody. In paragraph 2 of the order in the case of Central Bank of India (supra) Justice Mody has held as under:—

    “2. Under the old rules, the Court's discretion was limited to sufficient cause being shown and if it was not shown the suit had to be dismissed. As against this the present rule only provides that the suit shall be placed on board for dismissal but it does not provide as to what is to happen thereafter. In my view the Court will, therefore, have a wider discretion now than before and the Court is not bound to dismiss the suit.”

    3. A perusal of the passages reproduced above shows that Justice Vyas has held that the Court has a discretion to decree the suit ex parte even if the Summons for Judgment is taken out after six months, if the Court on examination of the defences find the same to be frivolous or of technical nature. Mr. Justice Mody, however, held that Rule 227 does not provide as to what is to happen when the suit is placed on Board for dismissal. It was held that the Court will have a wider discretion now than before and the Court is not bound to dismiss the same. The submissions made by Mr. Sanglikar with regard to the conflict in the view expressed by the two learned Judges do not survive in view of the decision given by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Randerian & Singh (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Indian Overseas Bank, Appeal No. 1060 of 1986 in Summons for Judgment No. 307 of 1986 in Summary Suit No. 3212 of 1985 (S.K Desai and N.K Parekh, JJ). The Division Bench held as follows:—

    “Under the Rules of this Court strict conditions are imposed on the defendants in a summary suit. They must file their appearance in Court within a very short specified period and failure to do so entitles the Plaintiffs to obtain an ex parte decree against them. It must logically follow that there must be equally stringent requirements postulated on the Plaintiffs. One of these requirements would be that they must not in the suit make a claim not warranted by the contract or under a statutory provision. If it can be demonstrated, as it can be in the instant case, that the Plaintiffs have in the Plaint made a claim for interest not warranted by the statutory provision or by the contractual document, then the suit must be one which cannot be accepted as a summary suit. Once this is demonstrated, one of two consequences must follow. The first and the more obvious is to grant to defendants unconditional leave to defend the suit and transfer the same to the appropriate cause list-long cause, short cause or commercial cause. The present case would fall in the last category. There is another way open and that is for the Plaintiffs who are faced with such defence in the affidavits made on the Summons for Judgment to apply for permission to withdraw their Summons for Judgment with liberty to take out a fresh Summons for Judgment after amending the Plaint and putting their house in order. Recording of a statement to give up or accept reduced interest is not sufficient.”

    A perusal of the aforesaid observations of the Division Bench shows that if a claim is made by the Plaintiffs in the plaint for interest not warranted by the statutory provision or by the contractual document, then the suit must be one which cannot be accepted as a summary suit. Once this is demonstrated, one of the two consequences must follow. The first and the more obvious is to grant the defendants unconditional leave to defend the suit. The second is to permit the plaintiffs to withdraw the Summons for Judgment with liberty to take out a fresh Summons for Judgment after amending the plaint and putting their house in order.

    4. The aforesaid Division Bench Judgment has been followed by another Division Bench in the case of Hydraulic and General Engg. Ltd. v. UCO Bank, 1998 (1) LJ 793. In that case the learned single Judge had accepted the statement made by the Counsel for the plaintiff to the effect that the plaintiffs shall restrict their claim only to the amount of Rs. 44,91,631.94 and seek decree only in the said sum which was the amount of guarantee. Earlier, however, the learned Single Judge had accepted the defence of the defendants therein that the claim towards interest as made by way of Exh. 88 to the plaint could not have been included in a summary suit. Counsel appearing for the plaintiff before the learned single Judge, on instructions, stated that in case the order of conditional deposit is passed and non-compliance therewith will entitle the plaintiffs to get the suit set down for ex parte then in that event the Plaintiff shall restrict their claim as mentioned above. The learned Judge accepted the statement and recorded the same. Thereafter conditional leave was granted to the defendants to defend the suit on deposit of Rs. 25 lakhs within ten weeks from the date of the order. This order of the learned single Judge was challenged in the appeal. The Division Bench allowed the appeal. In para 6 of the said judgment, the submission made by the Counsel for the defendants is noticed. In paragraph 7 of the judgment, the Division Bench accepted the aforesaid contentions. It was held that the observations made by the Division Bench in Appeal No. 1060 of 1986 as reproduced in para 3 above covers the controversy before the Division Bench in favour of the Appellants. The Summons for judgment was, therefore, dismissed. It was further directed that it would be open to the plaintiffs to amend the plaint and then take out Summons for Judgment after putting their house in order. The plaintiffs were granted four weeks time to complete the exercise. It was further directed that if not, unconditional leave to defend is granted to the defendants.

    5. Keeping the aforesaid observations in view, I am of the considered opinion that the Court has a discretion as to whether to permit the Summons for Judgment to be withdrawn and enable the Plaintiffs to take out fresh Summons for Judgment after amending the plaint or to grant unconditional leave. As noticed above, Justice Vyas has refused to exercise discretion and decreed the suit.

    6. In my view, the interpretation placed by Justice Vyas on Rule 227 of the High Court, O.S Rules, is contrary to the law laid down by the Division Bench in Appeal No. 1060 of 1986 (supra). The aforesaid Division Bench judgment was given on 24th February, 1987 whereas Justice Vyas has given the judgment on 28th February, 1994. The aforesaid judgment of the Division Bench was not brought to the notice of Justice Vyas. On the other hand the view taken by Justice Mody seems to be in consonance with the view taken by the Division Bench in Appeal No. 1060 of 1986 which has been confirmed subsequently by another Division Bench in the case of Hydraulic and General Engg. (supra). The view taken by Justice Mody has also been followed by Justice Deshpande in order dated 6th October, 1998 in Summons for Judgment No. 385 of 1997 in Summary suit No. 1584 of 1995. In the present case Mr. Sanglikar has himself admitted that the plaint in the present form could not be entertained as a summary suit. He had submitted that since there is a conflict between the views taken by Justice Vyas and Justice Mody the matter deserves to be referred to a larger Bench. In view of the fact that two Division Benches have already laid down the law, the submission made by Mr. Sanglikar has to be rejected.

    7. In view of the above, I am of the considered opinion that the defendants are entitled to unconditional leave to defend the suit. The Plaintiff will be at liberty to take out any necessary amendments, if so advised. In view of the above, the request for withdrawal of the Summons for Judgment is declined.

    8. Unconditional leave to defend the suit is granted to the defendants. Suit transferred to the list of Commercial causes. Written statement to be filed within 12 weeks from today. Affidavit of documents within eight weeks thereafter. Usual order as to discovery and inspection. Suit to come up on Board in usual course.

    Summons for judgment is disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs. Prothonotary to act on the copy of the order certified by the Chamber Registrar of this Court.

    Certified copy expedited.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    United Western Bank Ltd. v. Marmago Steel Ltd.
    (Dec 11, 1998)