Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • English Act, the Patents and Designs Act of 1907. Under Act 2 of 1911,
  • Rule 39, Indian Patents and Designs Rules, 1933,
  • Section 53(2) of the Patents and Designs Act
  • Act. Section 43(4)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • English Act, the Patents and Designs Act of 1907. Under Act 2 of 1911,
  • Rule 39, Indian Patents and Designs Rules, 1933,
  • Section 53(2) of the Patents and Designs Act
  • Act. Section 43(4)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from a suit brought by the plaintiffs who claim to be the registered proprietors of a design registered under the Patents and Designs Act (2 of 1911), for use on textile goods. The plaintiffs sued the defendants seeking injunctions to restrain infringement of the design, accounts, damages, costs and other reliefs.

In their written statement the defendants pleaded that prior to registration the design had been published in British India by the plaintiffs themselves and by other merchants, that the design was not new or original at the date of registration, and that the registration was therefore invalid and did not confer exclusive rights on the plaintiffs. To substantiate these defences the defendants obtained a chamber summons seeking discovery and inspection of specified documents from the plaintiffs.

The documents sought for inspection (as listed in the summons) were:

  1. The first shipment samples of the goods in dispute received by the plaintiffs from Japan.
  2. Copy of the first order placed by the plaintiffs in respect of the said goods.
  3. Correspondence between the plaintiffs and the Japanese firms from whom the plaintiffs imported the goods prior to and up to first importation.
  4. The original invoices and papers in respect of the first importation together with covering letters with the invoices.
  5. Entries in the plaintiffs' books of account as to when they received the first lot of such goods.
  6. Counterparts or copies of the contracts made by the plaintiffs with merchants in India regarding the sale of the goods in dispute.

The procedural posture: the chamber summons for discovery was heard and the Court made an order (the summons was made absolute), directing the plaintiffs to file a supplemental affidavit of documents and to allow inspection, and the suit was to be placed on the board for hearing as part heard on 13 January 1941.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the certificate of registration (and the register entry) for a design under the Patents and Designs Act, 1911, is final and conclusive proof that the person registered is the proprietor of a new or original design, or whether that presumption is rebuttable in a suit for infringement under Section 53(2).
  2. Whether a defendant in a suit for infringement of a registered design can, by way of defence, raise plea(s) of previous publication or lack of novelty/originality (i.e., that the design was not new or original at the date of registration), instead of or in addition to seeking cancellation/rectification under Sections 51-A or 64.
  3. Whether the documents sought by the defendants in the chamber summons are relevant and ought to be ordered for inspection (i.e., whether they are in the plaintiffs' possession, power or control and relevant to the pleaded defences).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The plaintiffs relied on the register and the certificate of registration under the Act and contended that the defendants are not entitled to "go behind" the certificate; thus the documents sought are not relevant to the issues in dispute.
  • Plaintiffs' counsel argued that an interested person has a statutory remedy under Section 51-A (petition to the High Court for cancellation on ground of previous publication or lack of novelty/originality) and under Section 64 (application for rectification), and in the absence of such cancellation/rectification the register should be treated as conclusive on the point of proprietorship.
  • Plaintiffs' counsel further argued that the discovery sought amounted to a fishing expedition, based on general defences pleaded on information and belief rather than particularized facts.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants pleaded that before registration the design had been published in British India by the plaintiffs and other merchants, and that the design was not new or original at the date of registration; consequently the registration was invalid and conferred no exclusive right on the plaintiffs.
  • To support these defences, the defendants sought discovery and inspection of documents (the six categories enumerated above) to show prior publication, earlier foreign sources, dates of first importation and related correspondence and commercial records.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
56 ALL 10321 Cited to support the proposition that nothing in the Act prevents a defendant in a suit under Section 53 from raising the defence that the design was previously published and was not new or original. The Court referred to this authority as supporting the availability of such defences in infringement proceedings and used it in rejecting the plaintiffs' contention that the register is conclusive.
56 ALL 1032 (Allahabad High Court) Held that the defendant to a suit under Section 53(2) is not confined to remedies under Sections 51-A and 64 and may raise the pleaded points as defences in the suit. The Court agreed with the conclusion of the learned Judges of the Allahabad High Court in this reported decision and adopted that view in holding that the defendants may raise the pleas in their written statement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by close reference to the statutory scheme of the Patents and Designs Act of 1911 (which is based upon the English Patents and Designs Act, 1907) and the associated Rules (Indian Patents and Designs Rules, 1933). The court identified the relevant statutory provisions and considered their language and purpose:

  • Section 43 (Part II) defines the criteria for registration: the applicant must claim to be proprietor of a new or original design not previously published in British India. Section 43(4) permits the Controller to refuse registration (with an appeal available).
  • Rule 39 of the 1933 Rules contemplates the Controller's consideration of applications and permits acceptance unless there is objection.
  • Section 45(1) authorises the grant of a certificate of registration when a design is registered; Section 46(1) mandates a register of designs and Section 46(3) provides that the register is prima facie evidence of matters directed to be entered therein (e.g., name and address of proprietor).

The crucial interpretive question was the legal effect of the register entry/certificate under Section 46(3): whether it is conclusive proof that the registered person is the proprietor of a new or original design, or merely prima facie evidence permitting rebuttal.

The Court reasoned that the phrase "prima facie evidence" in Section 46(3) creates a rebuttable presumption — i.e., it establishes a presumption that the registered proprietor is the proprietor of a new or original design until contrary evidence is adduced. The court found nothing in the Act expressly making the certificate conclusive, and observed that if the legislature had intended conclusiveness it would likely have made such an important point explicit rather than leaving it to implication.

The Court addressed and rejected the plaintiffs' submission that defendants are limited to statutory remedies of cancellation under Section 51-A or rectification under Section 64 and that no defence in an infringement suit could be founded on prior publication or want of novelty. The court noted:

  • There is no provision in the designs part of the Act corresponding to Section 29(2) (patents) which expressly allows revocation grounds to be pleaded as defences in infringement suits; however the absence of such an express provision does not, in the Court's view, imply that the Act prevents defendants from pleading those points in defence.
  • The Court relied upon the reasoning of the Allahabad High Court (56 ALL 1032) and other cited authority to conclude that defendants may raise pleas of prior publication and lack of novelty as a defence in a suit under Section 53(2).

On the specific chamber summons for discovery, the Court applied the ordinary test for relevance and possession/power/control: whether the documents sought are relevant to the pleaded defences and whether they appear to be within the plaintiffs' possession or control. The Court found the documents relevant, noted that nothing definitely showed they were not in the plaintiffs' possession (and the correspondence annexed to the affidavit in support of the summons suggested they were), and observed that if any document was not in the plaintiffs' possession the plaintiffs could so state on oath.

Consequently, the Court ordered discovery and inspection: the summons was made absolute with costs; plaintiffs were directed to file a supplemental affidavit of documents within a week disclosing the documents (or those in their possession) and to allow inspection forthwith; the suit was to be placed back on the board for further hearing as part heard on 13 January 1941.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court held that the register of designs and the certificate of registration under Section 46(3) is prima facie evidence only and is not conclusive proof that the registered person is the proprietor of a new or original design. Accordingly, a defendant in a suit for infringement under Section 53(2) may raise the defence that the design was previously published or was not new or original at the date of registration. The chamber summons for further discovery was made absolute: the plaintiffs were ordered to make a supplemental affidavit of documents within a week and to permit inspection of the documents in their possession; costs were awarded (to be taxed); the suit was to be placed on the board for hearing as part heard on 13 January 1941.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The plaintiffs must disclose and allow inspection of the specified documents (or say on oath if any are not in their possession). The defendants are permitted to rely on their pleaded defences (prior publication and lack of novelty) in the infringement suit.
  • On legal principle: The opinion affirms that a registration under the Act creates a rebuttable presumption of proprietorship/newness (prima facie), placing the ordinary onus on defendants to rebut it with evidence. The Court did not treat the certificate as irrebuttable.
  • On precedent-setting: The Court did not purport to lay down a novel or sweeping new rule of law beyond its interpretation of the statutory provisions and its agreement with earlier authority (notably the Allahabad High Court decision cited). The decision applies existing interpretive principles to permit defences of prior publication and lack of novelty in infringement proceedings and to permit relevant discovery to test those defences.

Order summary from the opinion: Summons made absolute; plaintiffs to file supplemental affidavit of documents within one week and to give inspection forthwith; suit to be placed on board for hearing as part heard on 13th January, 1941. Costs to be taxed.

    Dwarkadas Dhanji Sha v. Chhotalal Ravicarandas & Co.

    1. This is a chamber summons taken out by the defendants for further discovery. The plaintiffs claim to be the registered proprietors of a certain design for being printed on textile goods registered under the Patents and Designs Act (2 of 1911), and have filed this suit against the defendants for restraining them from in fringing the design under the circumstances mentioned in the plaint, and for accounts, damages, costs and other reliefs. In their written statement the defendants allege that prior to the registration of the design it was published in British India by the plaintiffs themselves as well as by other merchants. They also contend that the design was not new or original at the date of the registration and that the registration is invalid and does not confer any specific right upon the plaintiffs to exclusively use the same. In order to substantiate these defences the defendants pray for an order for discovery and inspection of the documents mentioned in the summons, viz., (1) the first shipment samples of the goods in dispute received by the plaintiffs from Japan, (2) copy of the first order placed by the plaintiffs in respect of the said goods, (3) correspondence between the plaintiffs and the Japanese firms from whom the plaintiffs imported the said goods prior to and up to first importation of the goods by plaintiffs, (4) the original invoices and papers in respect of the first importation of the said goods by the plaintiffs together with the covering letters with the invoices, (5) entries in the plaintiffs' books of account as to when they received the first lot of such goods, and (6) counterparts or copies of the contracts made by the plaintiffs with merchants in India regarding the sale of the goods in dispute.

    2. The suit is brought under Section 53(2) of the Patents and Designs Act of 1911. This Act is based upon the English Act, the Patents and Designs Act of 1907. Under Act 2 of 1911, Part I up to S. 42 refers to patents, Part II from S. 43 to S. 54 refers to designs, and Part III is general. The design in dispute has been registered under the provisions of the Act of 1911 and the Indian Patents and Designs Rules of 1933. Section 43(1) provides that the Controller may, on the application of any person claiming to be the proprietor of any new or original design not previously published in British India, register the design under part II of the Act. Section 43(4) provides that the Controller may, if he thinks fit, refuse to register any design presented to him for registration, but that any person aggrieved by any such refusal may appeal to the Central Government. Rule 39, Indian Patents and Designs Rules, 1933, which came into force on 1st April 1933, also provides that the Controller shall consider the application for registration and may accept it if he considers that there is no objection to the design being registered. Section 45(1) enables the Controller to grant a certificate of registration to the proprietor of the design when registered. Under S. 46(1) a book called the register of designs is kept at the Patent Office,

    wherein shall be entered the names and addresses of proprietors of registered designs, notifications of assignments and of transmissions of registered designs, and such other matters as may be prescribed.

    3. Section 46(3) provides that the register of designs shall be prima facie evidence of any matters by the Act directed or authorised to be entered therein. The plaintiffs contend that the defendants are not entitled to go behind the certificate of registration, and that therefore the documents of which inspection is asked for are not relevant to the matters in dispute between the parties. The important question therefore for consideration is whether the certificate of registration is final and conclusive, or whether it is open to the defence to raise the pleas that the design had been previously published and was not new or original at the date of the application for registration and that the plaintiffs are therefore not the proprietors thereof. Under Section 2(14) of the a proprietor means a proprietor of a new or original design. Formerly the words were “new and original,” but by act 7 of 1930 the words “new or original” have been substituted. From the words of the sections which I have referred to before it will be seen that the only person who can have a design registered under the Act is the proprietor for the time being of the design and that the design must be a new or original design and must not have been previously published in British India.

    4. Plaintiffs' counsel argued that it was open to any interested person under S. 51-A at any time after the registration to present a petition to the High Court for cancellation of the registration of the design on the ground of previous publication or also on the ground that it was not a new or original design. Such a petition could also within one year from the date of the petition be presented to the Controller subject to an appeal to the High Court. Section 64 of the general portion of the Act also provides for any person making an application for rectification of the register of patents or designs on the ground that any entry was wrongly made in the register. Counsel farther argued that in the absence of any such cancellation the register of designs which contains the name of the proprietor of the registered design was conclusive on the point that the person registered as proprietor was the proprietor of a new or original design.

    5. The words of Section 46(3) of the however are that the entry with regard to the name and address of the proprietor or proprietors of the registered design is prima facie evidence to that effect. That means in my opinion that there is a prima facie presumption that the person whose name is registered as the proprietor is the proprietor of a new or original design, but the entry in the register is not conclusive proof thereof, and the presumption can be rebutted. It is true that under S. 43 no registration can be effective unless the design sought to be protected is new or original and not of a pre-existing common type. But the certificate is not conclusive, and there is nothing in the Act which prevents the defendant in a suit for damages for infringement of a registered design under S. 53 from raising in defence the plea that the design was previously published and was neither new or original see, 56 ALL 10321. It was pointed out that unless it was final and conclusive there was no advantage in having a certificate of registration. The advantage is that if no evidence is led by the defendants to the contrary, the certificate is sufficient evidence that the plaintiffs are the proprietors, that is proprietors of a new or original design. If evidence is led, it is for the Court to come to its finding on the question. A further advantage is that as the register is prima facie evidence of the matters contained in it, the onus ordinarily will be on the defendants to show that the plaintiffs are not the proprietors of the registered design in question.

    6. Counsel for the plaintiffs also drew the attention of the Court to the several corresponding sections of the part of the Act dealing with patents. It is provided under Section 20(3) of the that the register of patents shall also be prima facie evidence of any matters by the Act directed or authorized to be inserted therein. Section 26 provides for the revocation of a patent on any of the grounds stated therein. Section 29(1) provides for the institution of suits for infringement of patents. It is provided by Section 29(2) of the that every ground on which a patent may be revoked under the Act shall be available by way of defence to a suit for infringement. Counsel pointed out that there was no corresponding section in the portion of the Act dealing with designs, nor was S. 29(2) made applicable in the matter of designs under Section 54 of the Act. It was therefore argued that as there was no section in regard to designs corresponding to S. 29(2) in regard to patents, the Act did not contemplate such a defence in the case of registered designs. I do not accept that argument. It might be that the reason for not making a specific provision in S. 53 similar to the provision in S. 29(2) was as is pointed out in 56 ALL 1032 at pp. 1936–1937.

    7. But what is really significant is that the Legislature has not definitely provided anywhere in the Act that the certificate of registration until cancellation is conclusive proof of the fact that the grantee of the certificate is the proprietor of the design, that is to say, the proprietor of a new or original design. I do not think that the Legislature would have left such an important point merely for inference. Nor is it provided in the Act that the only remedy of an aggrieved party is under Section 51-A and Section 64 of the Act, and that if no such application is made the aggrieved party cannot urge his grounds of defence in a suit brought by the registered proprietor under Section 53(2) of the Act. My attention was drawn to the observations of Halsbury, Hailsham's Edn., Vol. XXXII, p. 696, para. 1006, in which it is stated that it seems to be doubtful whether the validity of the registration can properly be raised by way of defence in a suit for infringement of a design, and whether it should not rather be sought by means of a motion for rectification of the register. It is however also pointed out that the former course has often been adopted, though it may be by consent of the parties. I, however, agree with the conclusion arrived at by the learned Judges of the Allahabad High Court in 56 ALL 1032 that the defendant to a suit under S. 53(2) is not confined to his remedy laid down by those particular sections of the Act, and that the points pleaded in the written statement by the defendants are points which can be raised in a suit like the present.

    8. Plaintiffs' counsel lastly urged that no order should be made on the chamber summons for inspection as the inspection asked for was on a fishing enquiry, not based on any particulars, but merely on defences which are taken up as general defences to the suit. Those defences may have been based on information and belief. The only question is whether the documents are relevant and whether they are in the plaintiffs' possession, power or control. In my opinion they are relevant, and it is nowhere definitely stated that they are not in the plaintiffs' possession. The correspondence annexed to the affidavit in support of the summons seems to indicate that they are. If any of these documents are not in the plaintiffs' possession, the plaintiffs can say so on oath. In the result, the summons is made absolute with costs. Costs to be taxed. Counsel certified.

    9. The plaintiffs to make the supplemental affidavit of documents disclosing the documents referred to in the summons or such of them as are in their possession within a week and to give inspection to the defendants forthwith thereafter. Suit to be placed on board for hearing as part heard on 13th January, 1941.

    D.S/R.K

    10. Summons made absolute.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dwarkadas Dhanji Sha v. Chhotalal Ravicarandas & Co.
    (Dec 5, 1940)