AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India as a public interest litigation. The petitioner sought writs, including mandamus, directing respondents to construct and repair roads within the Ranchi Municipal Corporation area (wards no. 1 to 37) using hot mix plant construction methods. The prayer identifies several specific stretches, including Sujata Chowk to Kadru, Ashok Nagar Daladali Road to Argora Chowk, the road near Lohardaga railway line at Debadih, Argora Chowk to Harmu Road up to the burning ghat (both sides excluding bypass road), Chutiya road, and other badly damaged municipal roads, and also sought construction of drains (nali) alongside those roads.

The Court reviewed the nature and limits of public interest litigation (PIL) and referred to guidelines from a Supreme Court decision on the restraint required in entertaining PILs. Counter-affidavits were filed by several respondents (specifically respondent nos. 5, 7, 8 and 9). After hearing counsel for the petitioner and respondents, the Court disposed of the petition by directing certain respondents to prepare estimates and approach the appropriate governmental authority to secure funds for the construction and repair work.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the grievances about municipal and other public roads, as presented in this petition, are maintainable by way of public interest litigation.
  2. Whether the respondents responsible for road construction and maintenance have the obligation and capacity (in law and in practice) to undertake the construction/repair, and whether lack of funds excuses non-performance.
  3. What remedial directions, if any, the Court should grant to secure action on estimates and funding for the repair and construction of the roads identified in the petition.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner

  • The petitioner's pleadings (in the form of a public interest litigation) sought directions for construction and repair of multiple specified roads within the Ranchi Municipal Corporation area and also sought construction of accompanying drainage.

Respondents' Contentions (as stated in counter-affidavits)

  • Respondent No. 5 (Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi):
    • Construction/repair of roads and drains in Ranchi town primarily fall within P.W.D (Roads), R.R.D.A., and Ranchi Municipal Corporation.
    • Under RRDA workings, a Board chaired by the Chairman, RRDA decides road/drain schemes and execution follows Board recommendations.
    • Ranchi Municipal Corporation independently selects and executes development schemes for the town.
    • Funds received by the Deputy Commissioner for urban development come through the Planning Department for the District Plan; only limited funds (Rs. 47.68 lacs over last two years) were received and only 15% of District Plan funds may be spent on urban areas for certain schemes.
  • Respondent No. 7 (Vice Chairman, Ranchi Regional Development Authority - R.R.D.A):
    • All roads within Ranchi Municipal Corporation jurisdiction do not belong to RRDA; they belong either to Ranchi Municipal Corporation or PWD; RRDA can act only if funds are provided by the government or other agencies.
    • The road from Sujata Chowk to Kadru belongs to PWD (Road Construction Department).
    • Some roads (e.g., Ashok Nagar Daladili road to Argora Chowk) were previously constructed by the authority and repaired by Municipal Corporation; due to paucity of funds the authority has not worked for four years.
    • Work on certain roads (e.g., Argora Chowk to Harmu Chowk) awaits funds requested from Regional Development Commissioner; other roads similarly await availability of funds.
  • Respondent Nos. 8 and 9 (Executive Engineer, Road Division (P.W.D), Ranchi, and Chief Engineer, Road Division (P.W.D), Ranchi):
    • Daladili road from Kadru to Argora is within Ranchi Municipal Corporation jurisdiction and not within P.W.D's jurisdiction; P.W.D. cannot carry out repairs on that road.
    • Certain major roads falling within P.W.D jurisdiction were constructed/ repaired in 1993-1995 using Hot Mix Plant; the Department decided that entire roads within its jurisdiction in the municipal limit will be constructed by Hot Mix Plant.
    • Several specified roads will be constructed by Hot Mix Plant on a priority basis depending on availability of funds; however, no funds had been sanctioned for 1995-1996, so no works could be undertaken in that financial year.
    • Respondents have marked roads on a priority basis and intend to undertake works when funds become available.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri Sachidanand Pandey v. The State of West Bengal ((1987) 2 SCC 295; A.I.R. 1987 (SC) 1109) The need for restraint in public interest litigation; guidelines that PIL should be entertained in rarest of rare cases involving gross violation of fundamental/human rights or where acts shock the judicial conscience; courts should avoid assuming administrative/executive functions and restrict frivolous PILs. The Court referred to paras 58–60 of this decision to emphasize restraint in entertaining PILs and concluded there was "very little scope" to espouse the petitioner's grievances by PIL. Nevertheless, the Court did not dismiss the petition on maintainability grounds at this belated stage and proceeded to give directions concerning estimates and funding.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by recognizing the utility and permanence of public interest litigation but stressed the need for restraint when such petitions are filed. The opinion expressly relied on the Supreme Court's observations (paras 58–60 of Shri Sachidanand Pandey) that PILs should be reserved for rare and serious violations affecting fundamental or human rights or matters that shock the judicial conscience, and that courts must avoid becoming administrative or executive bodies.

Applying these principles, the Court examined the writ petition's grievances about road repair and construction. It concluded there was "very little scope" to entertain the petition as a PIL because the grievances concerned routine administrative/municipal works rather than gross violations of fundamental rights. However, the Court observed that counter-affidavits had been filed by respondents nos. 5, 7, 8 and 9 and, given the procedural posture ("at this belated stage"), the petitioner would not be reproached on the question of maintainability.

The Court analysed the respondents' affidavits and found a consistent explanation: the construction and repair of the roads in question had not been carried out for want of necessary funds. The respondents delineated jurisdictional responsibilities among PWD, RRDA and Ranchi Municipal Corporation and indicated that works depended on availability of sanctioned funds and internal prioritization.

Given these factual admissions regarding funds and jurisdiction, the Court chose a remedial but narrow course. Rather than dismissing the petition as non-PIL or compelling immediate execution, the Court directed respondents nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 to prepare estimates (for works for which they are responsible) within one month of receiving a copy of the order and to approach the appropriate government authority to seek release of funds so that construction and repair could be carried out expeditiously.

Holding and Implications

Holding: DISPOSED OF — The petition was disposed of by directing respondents nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 to prepare estimates for the construction and repair of the roads for which they are responsible within one month from receipt of the order and to approach the appropriate government authority to obtain necessary funds for prompt execution of the works.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The specified respondents have an immediate ministerial obligation to prepare estimates within the one-month period and to approach the appropriate departments/authority to secure funds, after which construction and repair work should proceed on a priority basis as funds become available.
  • The opinion does not purport to set a new legal precedent on the substantive obligations of municipal or state bodies beyond reiterating and applying established guidance on the limited scope of PILs; the Court specifically emphasized restraint in entertaining PILs and limited its intervention to directions aimed at facilitating estimates and funding.

    Ram Kishore Prasad, Advocate, High Court, Ranchi v. The State Of Bihar & Ors. .

    1. In this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India the petitioner has approached this Court by way of a public interest litigation with the following prayer:—

    “For issuance of appropriate writs, order(s) and direction(s) by way of Mandamus or any other writs to the respondents to construct the road within Ranchi Municipal Corporation area ward no. 1 to 37 by hot mix plant specially in the area of Sujata Chowk to Kadru, Ashok Nagar Daladali Road to Argora Chowk, to Dibdi Near Lohardaga Railway Line, Argora Chowk to Harmu Road upto burning ghat both side road excluding the by pass road, Chutiya road and all the roads on Municipal Corporation area which are badly damaged since last so many years and also construct the Nali (drainage) side the road.”

    2. Public interest litigation has come to stay. Each and every failure and/or omission to discharge the public duty/obligation on the part of the public servant, public body or public authority, no doubt affects the interest of the public adversely in this way or that way.

    3. But all grievances arising out of omission and/or commission on the part of the public servant, public body or public authority cannot be espoused in a court by way of public interest litigation. There should be restraint on the part of the public interest litigants. We are of the view that public interest may be espoused by way of public interest litigation in the rarest of the rare cases where omission or commission on the part of the public servant or public authority entails gross violation of fundamental rights of the citizens and/or invades the human rights, which shocks the judicial conscience, in this connection, it is appropriate to refer to the paras 58, 59 and 60 of the judgment of the Hon'ble the Supreme Court passed in the case of Shri Sachidanand Pandey v. The State of West Bengal (reported in (1987) 2 SCC 295 : A.I.R 1987 (SC) 1109) wherein in paras 58, 59 and 60 the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as follows:—

    “58. My purpose in adding these few line of my own is to highlight the need for restraint on the part of the public interest litigants when they move courts. Public interest litigation has now come to stay. But one is led to think that it poses a threat to Courts and public alike. Such cases are now filed without any rhyme or reason. It is, therefore, necessary to lay down clear guidelines and to outline the correct parameters for entertainment of such petitions. If Courts do not restrict the free flow of such cases in the name of Public interest Litigations, the traditional litigation will suffer and the Courts of law, instead of dispensing justice, will have to take upon themselves administrative and executive functions.”

    “59. I should not be understood to say that traditional litigation should stay put. They have to be tackled by other effective methods, like decentralising the judicial system and entrusting majority of traditional litigation to village Courts and Lok Adalats without the usual populist stance and by a complete restructuring of the procedural law which is the villain in delaying disposal of cases.”

    “60. It is only when Courts are apprised of gross violation of fundamental rights by a group or a class action or when basic human rights are invaded or when there are complaints of such acts as shock the judicial conscience that the Courts, especially this Court., should leave aside procedural shackles and hear such petitions and extend its jurisdiction under all avaliable provisions for remedying the hardships and miseries of the needy, the underdog and the neglected, I will be second to none in extending help when such help is required. But this does not mean that the doors of this Court are always open for anyone to walk in. It is necessary to have some self imposed restraint on public interest litigants.”

    4. On perusal of the complaints made in this petition, we find that there is very little scope to espouse the grievances narrated in the writ petition by way of public interest litigation. However, in view of the fact that counter-affidavit filed by respondent nos. 5, 7, 8 and 9 we are of the view that at this belated stage, the petitioner may not be told off on the question of maintainability of the petition.

    5. Respondent no. 5, Dy. Commissioner, Ranchi, in paras 5, 6 and 8 of the counter-affidavit has contended as follows:—

    “5. That it is submitted that the construction/repair of roads and drains in Ranchi town are primarily the outlook of P.W.D (Roads), R.R.D.A and Ranchi Municipal Corporation. Under the present system of working in R.R.D.A there exists a Board under the Chairmanship of Chairman, R.R.D.A which takes ultimate decisions about the construction/repair of roads and drains in Ranchi town. It is only on the basis of the recommendation of this Board that the roads and drain schemes are executed in the town by the Chairman, R.R.D.A”

    “6. That the Ranchi Municipal Corporation is also independent in the selection of development schemes pertaining to Ranchi town. Road construction/repair schemes are selected by the Ranchi Municipal Corporation as per its own decision and priorities and executed accordingly.”

    “8. That it is respectfully submitted that as far as funds received by the Deputy Commissioner from Government for Urban development is concerned, it is received only through Planning Department for implementation of the District Plan. For last two years only Rs. 47.68 lacs have been received from the Planning Department. Of the total fund received under District Plan, only 15% be spent in Urban areas on certain development schemes.”

    6. Respondent no. 7, Vice Chairman, Ranchi Regional Development Authority (R.R.D.A) in paras 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 in the counter-affidavit has contended as follows:—

    “7. That with regard to the reliefs claimed in para-1 of the writ application, I say and submit that the petitioner is not entitled to get any relief as against the answering respondent. At the very outset, I say and submit that all the roads falling within the jurisdiction of Ranchi Municipal Corporation does not belong to the answering respondent, R.R.D.A All the roads either belong to Ranchi Municipal Corporation or PWD (Road Construction Department). In any view of the matter, the answering respondent can construct roads only if funds are provided by the government or any other agencies.”

    “8. That I say and submit that the road from Sujata Chowk to Kadru Chowk belongs to Road Construction Department, P.W.D So far the roads of Ashok Nagar Daladili Road to Argora Chowk is concerned, this road was constructed by the respondent-authority four years back. Thereafter the Municipal Corporation had done repair work in 1994. Due to paucity of fund, the Authority has not done any work since last four years.”

    “9. That I submit that the road beside Lohardaga line in village, Debadih, the work was completed by the respondent no. 4 in March, 1995.”

    “10. That I further say and submit that so far construction of road of Argora Chowk to Harmu Chowk is concerned, estimate was made by the respondent no. 4 and letter has been sent to Regional Development Commissioner for fund. As soon as the fund is received the work will be started. So far other roads are concerned, as stated above, no funds for improving of the roads have been made available to the respondent Authority who is to keep all the road in motorable condition.”

    “11. That with regard to the statements made in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the writ application, I say and submit that the responsibility of the respondent Authority for the construction or repair of roads depend only if funds are made available to the authority either by the Government or by other agencies.”

    7. Respondent nos. 8 and 9, Executive Engineer, Road Division (P.W.D), Ranchi, and Chief Engineer, (Road Division) P.W.D, Ranchi, in paras 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14 and 15 of the counter-affidavit have contended as follows:—

    “5. That it is respectfully stated and submitted that the road in question i.e to say Daladili road from Kadru to Argora is not within the jurisdiction of the answering respondents and the same fails within the jurisdiction of the Ranchi Municipal Corporation and as such the answering respondents are not in a position to carry out any repair/construction over the said road.”

    “6. That it is respectfully stated and submitted that the Road commonly known as Main Road (Ranchi Chaibasa road) stretching to 8 Kilometers from office of the Divisional Commissioner, South Chhotanagpur Division to Birsa Chowk falls under the jurisdiction of answering respondents and as such for the years 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 the said road falling within the Ranchi Municipal Area was constructed by Hot Mix Plant.”

    “7. That it is respectfully stated and submitted that the entire road falling within the jurisdiction of Road Construction Department within the Municipal limit of Ranchi Municipal Corporation will be constructed by Hot Mix Plant and a decision to this effect has been taken by the answering respondents.”

    “8. That apart from the above roads, the Roads known as Ranchi-Chaibasa Road via Rajendra Chowk to Mecon office has also been repaired by Mini Hot Mix Plant.”

    “9. That Ranchi-Daltonganj road, Ranchi-Bariatu Road, Ranchi-Patratu Road and approaching road to Government House, Radium Road, Namkum-Doranda Road, Ranchi Hazaribagh road from Jamuar bridge to Firayalal Chowk via Koker Chowk, Namkum Cantonment Road, Old Hazaribagh Road from Bihar State Road Transport Corporation Depot to Kokar Chowk via Kanta Toli Chowk will be constructed by Hot Mix Plant on prioritiy basis depending upon the availability of the fund.”

    “10. That Ranchi, Purulia Road from Dangra Toli to Namkum stretching upto 1.5 kilometers have been constructed by” the Hot Mix Plant.”

    “12. That it is respectfully stated and submitted that no fund has been sanctioned for the construction of the roads in the year 1995-1996 and as such no repair or construction of the roads could be taken in the current financial year.”

    “13. That the answering respondents respectfully state and submit that they have marked the roads mentioned hereinabove in the priority basis and as soon as the fund will be made available, the construction work will be taken up on the priority basis.”

    “14. That the answering respondents respectfully state and submit that as stated earlier, the Road stretching between from Kadru to Argora known as Daladili Road is not within the jurisdiction of the answering respondent and the same falls within the jurisdiction of Ranchi Municipal Corporation and as such the answering respondents are not in a position to carry out any repair/construction over the said road.”

    “15. That as stated above, it is not out of place to mention here that no fund has been sanctioned for the construction of the roads in the year 1995-1996 and hence no repair or construction of the roads could be taken in the current financial year. As soon as the fund is made available, the roads earlier, which have already been marked in the priority list, will be taken up on the priority basis.”

    8. From the contentions made in the counter-affidavits by the respondents, it becomes apparent that for want of necessary fund, the construction and repair of the roads in question were not carried out.

    9. Upon hearing the learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel for the respondents, we dispose of this petition with the direction that respondents nos 6, 7, 8 and 9 will make estimates of the construction and repair of the roads in question, for construction and maintenance which they are responsible for, within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and shall approach the appropriate authority of the concerned department of the Government to release necessary fund for carrying out the construction and repair of the roads in question expeditiously.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Kishore Prasad, Advocate, High Court, Ranchi v. The State Of Bihar & Ors. .
    (Feb 2, 1996)