Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 106, Sch. 1, Lim. Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Article 106, Sch. 1, Lim. Act.
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary — Allsop, J. (Partition; Partnership; Mortgages; Quarry Leases)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal concerns a partition suit instituted by Mt. Gulab Devi (the plaintiff) in the Subordinate Judge's Court at Aligarh claiming a share in various properties set out in Schedules A, B and C of the plaint. The plaintiff alleged that she had inherited a share in the properties from her deceased husband, Ram Chander (who died on 3 July 1921), under a will dated 19 November 1918. Defendants included Lachhman Das, Rameshwar Das, Nathu and several other transferees.

The properties in dispute included immovable properties, quarrying rights (leases), and interests created by three simple deeds of mortgage dated 19 February 1920 (item 1, Sch. B), 5 November 1919 (item 2, Sch. B) and 11 January 1921 (item 2, Sch. C). The defence in relation to the two mortgages in Sch. B was that those mortgages had been redeemed (with stated redemption dates in the record) and that recovery was barred by limitation.

The learned Subordinate Judge delivered judgment on 13 July 1932, dismissing the suit in so far as it related to certain mortgage interests and otherwise granting partition for remaining properties. Defendants Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das filed an appeal (instituted 26 July 1932). The plaintiff applied under Sections 151 and 152 CPC (application dated 15 July 1932) and filed a review application (21 July 1932) seeking correction regarding the treatment of the mortgage dated 11 January 1921 (Sch. C-2). The Subordinate Judge accepted the review application and passed an order on 5 September 1932, which itself prompted an appeal (No. 458 of 1932). The plaintiff also instituted appeal No. 379 of 1932 against dismissal in respect of the two mortgages in Sch. B. All three connected appeals were considered together by the Court hearing this opinion.

Background facts relevant to the legal analysis: Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das had been members of a joint Hindu family descended from Bagar Mal. They executed a partition-deed on 11 May 1913 (reciting an earlier practical separation) in which shares in family property were specified (Ram Chander 8 annas; Lachhman Das 4 annas; Rameshwar Das 4 annas). On 13 December of an indicated later year they executed a further deed described as a deed of partnership that set out differing shares in the partnership businesses. Business accounts were kept at two firms/places (Hathras and Katni Mundwara). The dispute centrally raises whether the properties in suit were partnership property or separate property held in the specified shares.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the immovable properties and quarrying rights enumerated in Schedules A, B and C were partnership property of firms carried on by Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das or were separate/joint family property held in defined shares after partition.
  2. Whether quarrying/lease interests granted by the Government of the Central Provinces after Ram Chander's death formed part of Ram Chander's estate (i.e., whether earlier leases had been renewed such that he had a share).
  3. Whether the plaintiff's claims in relation to the two mortgages described in Sch. B are barred by limitation because those mortgages were redeemed (and, relatedly, whether the mortgage discharges were valid so as to extinguish the security).
  4. What is the effect of the mortgage described in Sch. C (item 2) on the parties' shares, given related proceedings and payments made during Ram Chander's lifetime.
  5. The correctness and quantum of mesne profits awarded by the Subordinate Judge, and whether inclusion of quarry profits (to which the court later held the plaintiff had no claim) vitiated the mesne profits decree.
  6. Allocation of costs between the parties on appeals and as between the lower court and appellate proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff (Mt. Gulab Devi) — relevant content recorded in the opinion

  • The plaintiff claimed a share in the properties listed in Schedules A, B and C as heir under the will of Ram Chander.
  • She sought correction/review of the lower court's dismissal as to the mortgage dated 11 January 1921 (Sch. C-2) on the ground that the dismissal was made under a misapprehension.
  • The plaintiff contended that certain quarry leases (executed after Ram Chander's death) should be treated as renewals of earlier leases in which Ram Chander had a share, and therefore she should have rights in the interests created by those leases.
  • In relation to the mortgages the plaintiff (on appeal) argued that the mortgagees could not give a valid discharge (i.e., a challenge to the validity of the alleged redemption/discharge), seeking to avoid the limitation bar by asserting the mortgages still subsist.
  • The plaintiff sought mesne profits (the lower court awarded Rs. 2,100 for a three-year period, which was contested in part because it included quarry profits).

Defendants (Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das) — principal arguments recorded

  • The defendants' general defence was that the properties included in the plaint constituted partnership property of the two family firms (the business at Hathras and the firm at Katni Mundwara) and that the plaintiff could not obtain a partition decree without first instituting a suit for an account and a share of partnership profits.
  • They argued that, even if an account suit were brought, it would be barred by limitation (relying explicitly on Article 106, Schedule 1 of the Limitation Act).
  • With respect to the two mortgages in Sch. B, defendants asserted those mortgages had been redeemed and that any claim for a share of the monies paid would be time-barred.
  • In relation to quarrying leases, the defendants relied on the fact that the leases recorded on the record had been executed after Ram Chander's death and therefore Ram Chander could not have had a share in the interests created by them unless they were renewals of earlier leases (which the record did not prove).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds by addressing the core contractual question whether the properties in suit were partnership property (within the meaning of S. 253 of the Indian Contract Act, as quoted in the opinion) or separate/joint-family property held in specific shares following the 1913 partition deed. The court emphasised that partnership status of property depends on agreement and conduct, not merely on joint use by partners.

Key steps in the Court's reasoning:

  • Legal principle applied: The Court invoked the default rules in S. 253 (Contract Act) that define partnership property as property originally brought into partnership stock, bought with partnership money, or acquired for partnership purposes — but stressed that whether property falls within those categories depends on contract and the parties' conduct.
  • Documentary and accounts evidence: The Court examined the partition deed (11 May 1913), the partnership deed (13 December in a later year), ledger entries and the manner in which accounts were kept in the firms (Chunna Khudan Khata for the limestone/quarry business, Kharch Khata for shops and other property, and separate ledgers in the names of the three men). The Court observed:
    • The partition deed allocated shares in pre-existing properties (Ram Chander 8 annas; Lachhman Das 4 annas; Rameshwar Das 4 annas) and did not contain express terms converting those properties into partnership assets.
    • The accounts show immovable properties and their values being removed from the family ledger and credited to the individual partners' accounts rather than being shown as the firm's assets.
    • When property was purchased after partition (for example, property bought from Jagan Prasad on 13 December 1913 for Rs. 675/684-8-0), the purchase entry was debited to the Chunna Khudan Khata but the resulting account treatment led to the cost being included in the partners' separate accounts at year-end — consistent with the partners treating the property as passing to their separate ownership.
  • Inference from accounting practice: The Court found that the bookkeeping practice of this family did not treat the immovable properties in existence at partition as partnership assets. The separate ledgers, periodic balancing and transfers to individual accounts supported the inference that the partners regarded those properties as held by them in defined shares and not pooled into a partnership capital account.
  • Properties acquired after the formation of the partnership: For properties acquired post-partition (including certain zamindari property and the Nohra/enclosure at Hathras), the Court considered whether they were purchased out of partnership funds for partnership purposes. The Court found insufficient evidence to conclude they were partnership acquisitions; the ledger presentation and the absence of a clear nexus to the limestone business undermined the claim they were partnership property.
  • Quarrying/lease rights: The Court observed that the leases relied on by the plaintiff were executed after Ram Chander's death (leases dated 29 Sep 1923, 20 Nov 1923, 11 Jan 1924, 28 Jul 1927 and 17 Sep 1929). There was no evidence that these were renewals of earlier leases in which Ram Chander had an interest. On that basis the Court held Ram Chander could not have had rights in the interests arising under those leases, and the part of the lower court decree granting the plaintiff a share in those lease interests could not be sustained.
  • Mortgages (Sch. B and Sch. C): Regarding the two mortgages in Sch. B, the Court accepted that the mortgages had been redeemed (money paid to Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das). The Court noted a dilemma for the plaintiff:
    • If the plaintiff accepts the mortgages were extinguished by payment, then any claim to share in the money paid to the mortgagees would be barred by limitation.
    • If the plaintiff maintains the mortgages still subsist by asserting the discharges were invalid, then the appropriate remedy would be suits in which the mortgagors are parties — a remedy not encompassed by the present appeal record.
    The Court therefore held the plaintiff could not succeed on appeal in respect of those mortgages and dismissed her appeal on that point.
  • The mortgage in Sch. C (item 2): There had been separate proceedings brought upon that mortgage in which Mt. Gulab Devi was impleaded; the property was sold and purchased by the plaintiffs in that suit, and a direction was given that shares depend upon the decision in the present suit. The Court concluded that the sum secured by that mortgage had been paid out during Ram Chander's lifetime and found insufficient evidence that payments recorded in the family ledgers represented partnership capital. The Court held Mt. Gulab Devi had a one-third share in the interest created by that mortgage and would have that share in property acquired out of those interests.
  • Mesne profits: The Subordinate Judge had decreed Rs. 2,100 as mesne profits for three years, but in computing that figure he had included profits from the quarries — profits to which the Court concluded the plaintiff had no claim (because the quarry leases were not shown to give her an interest). The Court therefore set aside the figure as calculated and left the precise quantification of appropriate mesne profits to be determined in the final decree for partition, directing mesne profits for the three years immediately preceding the suit for those properties in which she was held to have a share.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core rulings):

  • The plaintiff's appeal No. 379 of 1932 is dismissed.
  • The defendants' appeal No. 458 of 1932 is dismissed.
  • In appeal No. 327 of 1932 the decree of the Court below is modified:
    • The plaintiff's share in properties Nos. 1–5 of Schedule A is held to be one-half, except that she shall not be entitled to any interest in the quarrying rights created by leases granted by the Government of the Central Provinces.
    • The plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits from defendants 1–3 for the period of three years next before the institution of the suit in relation to the properties in which she is held to have a share; the amount of mesne profits is to be calculated and included in the final decree for partition.
    • Mt. Gulab Devi is held to have a one-third share in the interest created by the mortgage identified as Item 2, Schedule C (and in any property acquired out of those interests).
    • That part of the lower-court decree granting the plaintiff a share in quarry lease interests (granted after Ram Chander's death) is set aside because there is no evidence they were renewals of earlier leases in which Ram Chander had a share.
    • Regarding the two mortgages in Sch. B, the plaintiff cannot obtain relief in this appeal: the mortgages have been shown to have been redeemed and any claim to share of monies paid is subject to limitation; alternatively, if discharges are challenged, the proper remedy is a suit involving the mortgagors.

Costs and other consequences:

  • The respondents (plaintiff-respondent) are awarded their costs in appeals Nos. 379 and 458 of 1932.
  • The defendant appellants are awarded one-third of their costs in appeal No. 327 of 1932; the plaintiff is awarded two-thirds of her costs in the lower Court as against defendants 1–3.
  • The order that defendants 4 to 10 should bear their own costs is left undisturbed.
  • The exact amount of mesne profits to be included in the final partition decree is left to be calculated on the basis directed by the Court (three years before suit for properties where she has a share) and excluding quarry profits to which the plaintiff had no claim.

Implication regarding precedent: The opinion resolves the disputes between the parties on the specific facts and documents before the Court (partition and partnership deeds, and ledger/accounts). The Court did not cite any prior judicial decisions as binding precedent in the opinion; the ruling applies to the parties and factual situation before it and does not purport to announce a broader novel legal principle beyond the application of established statutory rules (Contract Act s.253 and limitation principles).

Short Conclusion

Summarily, the Court found that the immovable properties in possession at the time of partition were not partnership property but were held by the three men in specific shares; leases executed after Ram Chander's death did not confer rights on him (and hence on his heir) absent evidence of renewal; the two mortgages in Sch. B were effectively dealt with by payment/redeem and the plaintiff's remedy was barred or otherwise required suits involving mortgagors; the mortgage in Sch. C gave rise to a one-third share for the plaintiff; mesne profits must be recomputed excluding quarry profits; and the decree below was modified accordingly with specific cost directions.

    Lachhman Das v. Mt. Gulab Devi

    Allsop, J.:— This appeal arises out of a ??? which was decided by the learned subordinate Judge of Aligarh. It was a ??? instituted by Mt. Gulab Devi for the partition of certain property of which the retails are set forth in Schs. A, B and C of the plaint. The plaintiff alleged that ??? had inherited a share in this property from her deceased husband, Ram Chandar, under a will executed by him ??? 19th November 1918. She impleaded ??? defendants Lachhman Das, Rameshwrar Das, Nathu and seven other persons. According to her Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das were joint owners of the property with her husband. She impleaded Nathu because he was Rameshwar's son and the other seven persons because they were transferees of parts of he property under deeds which were executed after the death of Ram Chandar. The property in suit included interests created by three simple deeds of mortgage respectively dated 19th February 1920, (item 1 of Sch. B), 5th November 1919, (item 2, Sch. B), and 11th January 1921, (item 2, Sch. C). The defence about the two first of these mortgages, namely those in Sch. B, was that they had been redeemed respectively on 27th May 1925 and 23rd May 1920. The learned Subordinate Judge held that the mortgages had been redeemed and that the suit for recovery of a share in the interests created by them was barred by limitation. He therefore dismissed the-suit in so far as it related to these items.

    2. It appears that he was under the misapprehension that the mortgage described in Sch. C had also been redeemed and that the same considerations applied to the interest created by it as applied to the interests created by the other two mortgages. He, therefore, dismissed the suit also in so far as it related to the interest created by this third mortgage. The general defence raised by Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das was that all the properties included in the plaint were partnership property and that the plaintiff was not entitled to get a decree without instituting a suit for an account and a share of the profits of the partnership. They further contended that such a suit, if it had been instituted, would have been barred by limitation under Article 106, Sch. 1, Lim. Act. This defence was not accepted by the learned Subordinate Judge and he gave the plaintiff in the first instance a decree for partition of all the properties except those to which I have already referred, namely the interests created by the three deeds of mortgage. The learned Subordinate Judge delivered judgment on 13th July 1932. The defendants, Lachman Das and Rameshwar Das, instituted the appeal with which I am dealing on 26th July 1932. Meanwhile, however on 15th July 1932, the plaintiff had made an application under Sections 151 and 152 of the CPC, asking, the Court to correct its judgment in so far as it related to the interests created by the mortgage deed of 11th January 1921, referred to as item 2, Sch. C of the plaint. This application was followed on 21st July 1932 by another application for review of judgment on the same grounds. The applicant, that is the plaintiff, pointed out that the learned Judge had dismissed the suit for partition of the interest created by that mortgage under a misapprehension.

    3. The learned Judge accepted this contention and he passed an order on 5th September 1932 accepting the application for review and directing that the suit should be decreed with respect to the interest created by the mortgage mentioned in Sch. C-2. This order led to another appeal 458 of 1932 instituted by Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das. Mt. Gulab Devi also on 21st October 1932 instituted an appeal No. 379 of 1932 against that part of the decree which dismissed her claim under the two mortgages mentioned as items 1 and 2, Sch. B of the plaint. There are therefore three connected appeals before us and I shall deal with all of them in this judgment. It is admitted that Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das were at one time members of a joint Hindu family. The common ancestor was Bagar Mal. He had two sons, Kanhaiya Lal and Lokman Das. Ram Chander was the son of Kanhaiya Lal and Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das are the sons of Lokman Das. The family remained joint till sometime towards the end of the year 1912. On 11th May 1913 Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das executed a deed in which they indicated that they had separated some time before and that the joint family was dissolved. They mentioned in this deed that there were two family firms, one carrying on business as traders in time at Hathras under the style of Bagar Mal Kanhaiya Lal and the other carrying on business as manufacturers of and traders in time at Katni Mundwara in the district of Jubbulpore in the Central Provinces under the style of Bagar Mal Lokman Das. They said that they were agreed that their shares in the joint family property were as follows, namely Ram Chander, 8 annas, Lachhman Das, 4 annas, and Rameshwar Das, 4 annas. The deed described how the partition had been effected. The household articles and ornaments had been distributed between the various branches of the family after the death of Kanhaiya Lal and Lokman Das. Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das confirmed this distribution and agreed that there was no further dispute between them about this property. They said that they had divided the cash in their hands by relevant entries in the books of the two firms. The firms were to remain joint but the three relations were to have definite shares in them in accordance with their shares in the whole of the family property. The moveable and immoveable property at Katni Mundwara was also to remain joint on the same condition. There were two houses which had been divided between the members of the family. One house worth Rs. 10,000 had been delivered to Ram Chander and the other worth Rs. 2, ??? to Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das. By way of adjustment Lachhman Das a Rameshwar Das had each been credit with Rs. 4,000 in the books of the firm Hathras. The houses were at Hathras and that is where the members of ??? family had their home. The business were carried on in accordance with ??? provisions of this deed till the year ???. On 13th December of that year Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das executed another deed which ??? described as a deed of partnership.

    4. According to this deed the shares the moveable and immoveable proper which they held jointly at that time we to remain as they had been before, ??? the three of them were to have ??? shares in any moveable or immovable property which they might acquire jointly after that date and the shares in ??? businesses of any kind which they carried on were to be varied, that is, Ram Chander was to have a share of 6 annas ??? the other two to have a share of 5 ??? each. According to the deed the businesses had been carried on, on these ??? since Katik Sudi 1, Sambat 1974, ??? since some date in October 1917. It position was not changed when Ram Chander died on 3rd July 1921. At the time he was credited with a large sum ??? money in the books of the firms. It obvious that the three persons had bee carrying on business as partners after the dissolution of the joint family to wards the end of the year 1912 and that the death of Ram Chander dissolved the partnership. Mt. Gulab Devi was admittedly the heir of Ram Chander under the will to which I have already referred. She did not institute any suit for an account and a share of the profits of the dissolved partnership, but eventually on 8th June 1931 she instituted the suit which has given rise to these appeals I have already mentioned that the ??? defence put forward by Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das was that the properties in suit were part of the partnership property of the two firms. That is a very important question in these appeals.

    5. Before I proceed to discuss it I think that it is necessary to describe the nature of the properties in suit. The property in item one of Schedule A is a ??? properties in items 2, 3, 4 and 5 ??? plots of land at or near Katni Mundwara. In items 2 and 3 it is mentioned ??? there are quarries in the plots. The ??? of this fact is that these ??? constitute a special kind of properly. It is not denied that agricultural ??? in the Central Provinces is held by ??? proprietors under grants by which ??? have only the surface rights in the property that is, they are entitled to use only ??? surface and the immediate subsoil for ??? poses of cultivation, whereas the ??? and quarrying rights in the deeper ??? remain the property of the Government. The Government deals with these its by issuing mining or quarrying ??? either to the proprietors or to other ??? sons. If the leases are given to ??? other than the proprietors, the properties are granted compensation for ??? interference with their rights in ??? surface of the soil. There are some ??? upon the record which show that is the usual practice to grant such ??? for periods of ten years with the ??? of renewal. The mention of ??? in the plaint is intended to indicate it the plaintiff is claiming a share in carrying rights which have been grant ??? Lachhman Das and Rameshwar ??? under certain leases. These quarrying rights constitute a special class of property with which I shall have to deal ??? due course.

    6. The property described in item 3, Sch. ??? is some zamindari property in Hathras ??? that described in item 1, Sch. C is an ??? closure in Hathras with a number of ??? in it. The other three items in ???. B and C are the interests created ??? the three mortgages to which I have already referred. I shall now proceed to ??? the question whether the properties mentioned in the plaint or any of ??? can be described as the partnership property of either of the two firms in which Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das were partners. Partnership is a matter of contract between the properties although there are provisions in ??? Contract Act that in the absence of ??? contract to the contrary certain ??? will be assumed to exist between ??? partners. I may refer particularly ??? some of the provisions of S. 253 of that Act. The first part of the section is as follows:

    In the absence of any contract to the contrary the relations of partners to each other are determined by the following rules:

    (1) All partners are joint owners of all property originally brought into the partnership stock or bought with money belonging to the partnership or acquired for the purposes of the partnership business. All such property is called partnership property. The share of each partner in the partnership property is the value of his original contribution, increased or diminished by his share of profit or loss…….

    7. The defendants contend that the property in suit was partnership property within the meaning of this section. What we have to decide is whether this property was originally brought into the partnership stock or was bought by money belonging to the partnership or was acquired for the purposes of the partnership, and if it was, whether there was any special contract varying the terms of the section. As this is a question of contract, we have to consider what conclusion we can reach from the express agreements in the two deeds of partition and partnership or from implicit agreements which can be inferred from the conduct of the parties. I may mention at this stage that the property in Sch. A was acquired before the partition with the exception of that part of the property in item 3 which is situated in village Mundwara and consists of plots 1236, 1237, 1254, 1255 and 1256. This latter property was purchased on 13th December 1913 from one Jagan Prasad. The property in list B was all purchased after the partition and so was the property in list C.

    8. The first question is whether it was the intention of Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das that the property in existence at the time of the partition should become partnership property or whether it was their intention that it should be regarded as their joint property apart from the partnership and should be used only so far as was necessary for the purposes of the partnership. It seems to me that it does not necessarily follow because certain partners jointly own immoveable property which they use for the purposes of the partnership business that property is partnership property. Whether it is or is not depends upon the agreement between the partners. If two brothers jointly inherited a house and thereafter at some time set, up a business in the house in partnership, I do not think that it could be inferred from that fact alone that they were intending to transfer their shares in the house to their partnership business. In the present case the partition deed of 1913 does not contain any stipulation that the property in Kunti Mundwara which was at that time the only joint family property should be regarded as the property of the partnership in the firm which was carrying on business in lime. It is true that was the only property which was not divided between the partners by metes and bounds, but there are possible explanations for this apart from the inference that the property was to be partnership property.

    9. One possible explanation is that the arrangement was made for convenience of management. Parts of the property were doubtless connected with the business because they were used for the purpose of quarrying limestone, but other parts of the property, notably the shops which were let to tenants, had no necessary connexion with the limestone business. I notice that in the deed of partition there is an express stipulation that the parties shall have no power to carry on any other trade except that of time without the consent of each other and that if any party carries on any other trade without obtaining the consent of the others the loss sustained in that separate business shall be borne by that party and that the profits accruing from that business shall be deposited in the shop, that is, shall be regarded as the profits of the partnership. It is suggested that the plots of land which were not used for quarrying were connected with the business because they were used for the purposes of the employees of the business, but it is not certain that was so. Then in the deed of 1917 the parties have stipulated that there shall be different shares in different properties. It is not inconceivable that partners might enter into a contract in respect of partnership property, that part of that property should be held in certain shares and the rest of it in certain other shares, but it is not what one would regard as an ordinary arrangement. The fact that the shares in the existing properties were not varied whereas the shares in the business itself were varied seems to me to convey a strong suggestion at least that Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das did not regard the existing properties as part of the assets of the firms.

    10. An inference also arises from ??? manner in which the accounts of ??? Katni firm were kept. At the time ??? the joint family was disrupted and ??? partnership business was begun cert ??? immoveable properties were shown in ??? books as the assets of the family. I ??? to an extract from the accounts ??? from Katik Badi 14th Sambat 1969 ??? Katik Sudi 15th Sambat 1969, that ??? from the 8th November 1912 to 24th November 1912. Although the partition deed was executed on 11th May 1913 appears that the partition took place November 1912, that is, at the ??? of the firm's financial year. In the ??? tract to which I refer there are certs sums of money which are shown to ??? account of land at Mundwara, Tikaria ??? other places. It appears from this ??? tract that at the time when the partition took place these sums of money we deducted from the capital account. ??? would appear that when the family ??? a joint family there was a ledger in ??? name of the family, that is, in the ??? of Kanhaiya Lal Lokman Das which ??? presented the capital invested or the property of the family. On Katik Badi 14 ??? Sambat 1969 the sum credited to the family was Rs. 51,118-2-6. Of the amount two sums of Rs. 28,934-11-3 ??? Rs. 13,222-7-3 were cash and the ??? was the value of the landed properties ??? which I have referred and the value ??? something which is described as a “bailat” and may mean a boiler. When the partition took place, the capital sum ??? Rs. 51,118-2-6 was taken away from the credit of the family. The sum of Rs. 28,934-11-3 was transferred to the account of the firm at Hathras and it has not been explained how this ??? dealt with in the books of that ???. The other sum of Rs. 13,222-7-3 was transferred to the credit of the ??? new partners according to their share i.e, a sum of Rs. 6,611-3-6 was credited to Ram Chander and sums ??? Rs. 3,305-9-6 were credited to each ??? the other two partners. The balance represented by the value of the properties including the “bailat” was remove from the account altogether, that is, the ledger in which the debits against the properties were shown were balance ??? there was a corresponding reduction the capital in the hands of the family. ??? ordinary meaning of this entry could be that the properties were no ??? regarded as the assets of the firm ??? that they were returned to the ??? to hold in their separate right according to their shares. It has been ??? on behalf of the appellants that ??? inference can be made against the appellants from these entries in the ??? books because it is the ordinary ??? of firms keeping their accounts the Indian fashion not to show as sets of the firm any properties acquired it of the moneys of the firm. It is said ??? the ordinary practice when money is ??? on acquiring property is immediate ??? to debit the money so spent against ??? capital account of the firm. There is ??? expert evidence on the record and consider therefore that we must take ??? entries as they stand. Whatever ??? usual practice may be, it is clear that ??? practice of this particular family was ??? debit money spent on acquired property against a ledger account in the ??? of that property: in other words, ??? show the property as an asset of the ???.

    11. Even if it is not advisable to lay ??? emphasis upon these items in the accounts it still must be admitted that the value of the property in existence ??? 1913 does not appear anywhere in the books of the firm as an asset of the firm. This is certainly an indication, of it is no more, that the property was regarded by the partners as existing apart from the partnership. After the partnership account was opened the system in accordance with which the books were kept was that there were three separate ledgers in the names of the three partners, a ledger called the Chunna Khudan Khata, in which the profits of the expenditure on the limestone business were included and a ledger called the Kharch Khata in which the profits of and the expenditure on the shops and other property were entered. It has been argued on behalf of the respondent that the books contained the joint accounts of Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das and that it was only the Chunna Khudan Khata which contained the accounts of the partnership business as such. It seems probable that the three men allowed the accounts to be continued in the same form in which they had been kept while the family was a joint family with this modification that the shares of the three of them were defined and that their assets were separately shown according to their shares. It appears that at the end of each year all the ledger accounts were balanced and the profits calculated and carried over to the ledgers of the three members of the family according to their shares.

    12. It is also probable that, when that was done the amount credited to the name of each of the three men was regarded as his separate property. There is a stipulation in the deed of 1917 that each of the three partners will be allowed interest at any time when his deposit is more than his share in the capital of the firms but we have not been shown on any occasion that any interest was paid to any of these persons on any credit in his separate account. It seems impossible that the three persons should always have withdrawn amounts exactly proportionate to their shares from their separate accounts either from the firm in Katni Mundwara or from the firm at Hathras. If they drew upon their accounts separately, as presumably they must have done, the balances to their credit could not always have been proportionate to their shares in the capital and, if the whole of those balances were regarded as parts of the capital, interest should have been paid to those whose balances were in excess of their shares. I may now refer again to the property which was purchased from Jagan Prasad on 15th December 1913. Before discussing the accounts in so far as they relate to that property it was necessary to mention the existence of the Kharch Khata and Chuna Khudan Khata. The price paid for the property was Rs. 675. There is a mention of this in an extract from the accounts which is published on p. 258 of our paper book.

    13. The payment of this sum is entered on Pus Badi 7th. At the same time there were certain expenses in connexion with the registration of the deed which brought the whole amount up to Rs. 684-8-0. This sum was debited to the Chuna Khudan Khata, that is, the limestone quarry account. It has been argued on behalf of the appellants that this property at least must be considered to have been purchased for the purposes of the business. The fact however is that the limestone quarry account was balanced every year and the profit was calculated and was credited to the partners. This sum of Rs. 684 therefore was included in the profit and loss for the year in which the entry was made and it was included therefore in the balance which was transferred to the partners in their separate accounts. The result is that this sum of Rs. 684 does not appear anywhere in the accounts as an asset of the firm and the property as such must therefore be considered to have passed to the partners in their separate right. In any case, in the year 1917 when the second agreement was entered into, this property with the rest of the property existing at that time was to be held by Ram Chander, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das in shares of 8 annas, 4 annas and 4 annas.

    14. The same argument applies to it as applies to the other property, namely that it is improbable that the partners if they had regarded this property as the property of the partnership would have agreed to hold it in shares different from the shares which they held in the business concerned. I now come to the property mentioned as item 3 of Sch. B. This was zamindari property with buildings thereon in the village of Dhunri in the Central Provinces. It was acquired by means of a sale deed dated 10th July 1920. Prom the extract of the accounts appearing at p. 293 of our paper book it seems that a sum of Rs. 3,122-14-0 was spent on the purchase of this property. Contrary to the practice which is set up on behalf of the appellants this sum was not debited immediately to any capital account but a ledger account was opened in the name of the village and in this account this sum was debited. This ledger account continued to be kept till the property was sold after the death of Ram Chander to one Ram Adhin in the year 1924. From an extract from the accounts at p. 291 of our paper book it appears that a sum of Rs. 4,000 was paid by Ram Adhin for the property.

    15. The entries show that this particular village was shown as an asset in the books kept at Katni Mundwara. But it must be remembered that Ram Chander died a year after the property was purchased and it may be that this property would have been absorbed in the accounts of the three persons concerned if his death had not taken place. Account were made up for that year three or for months after the property came into the hands of these people and before the ??? accounting Ram Chander had died. The is no reason for thinking that the parties intended to treat this property in manner different from the other immovable property in their possession. It do not appear to have been particularly connected with the business in time or ??? other business which might have ??? carried on by the partnership. Another possibility is that this property which belonged to all the three relations ??? being managed on their behalf by the same agency and that it was necessary ??? keep a separate account as there ??? profits from the property and money spent upon it. The fact that the share in this property were equal and ??? consequently different from the shares ??? the business would make it necessary the accounts of the two should not be amalgamated, and this seems to me to ??? an argument in favour of the contention of the plaintiff-respondent that the ac counts kept at Katni Mundwara were no taken as a whole, the accounts of the partnership, but the accounts of three joint owners. If that is so, this would have been an account entirely separate from the partnership account which was represented by the Chuna Khudan Khata or limestone quarry account.

    16. There remains the enclosure or Nohra at Hathras described in item 1, Sch. C This property was purchased on 31st January 1921. The arguments about this are the same as those about the property in Dhunri. The sums paid on account of the property are debited in the Nohra account in the Hathras books. The property has no connexion with any limestone business and the purchase took place only a few months before Ram Chander's death. Having considered the evidence I am satisfied that the immoveable properties, properly so called, in the possession of Ram Chandar, Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das were not partnership property. As soon as the joint family ceased to exist the members of it became owners in specific shares of the properties which were in existence at that time. They agreed to carry on certain businesses in partnership, but in order that the defendants' plea in this case should be accepted it would be necessary to hold that it is positively established that the three members of ??? family intended to pool those shares ??? hold the property not as co-owners it as members of a partnership. There no sufficient evidence to justify a finding of this kind. On the contrary, all ??? indications are that they regarded ??? properties as separate from the partnership, although some of them may have been used in part or in whole for ??? purpose of the business. As for the properties which were acquired after the partnership came into existence, that is, ??? property which was acquired from ??? Prasad and the two properties, ??? 3 of Sch. B and item 1 of Sch. C, in order that the defendants should succeed, would be necessary to hold that these properties were purchased from partnership funds for the purposes of the partnership business. It is true that the accounts of the partnership business, and he accounts of the members of the partnership were perhaps not very distinct, ??? on the whole it seems that the sums credited to the various members of the family in their separate accounts were regarded as their separate property and ??? as the joint capital of the partnership. If purchases were made jointly ??? of these funds, therefore, it cannot ??? said with any certainty that they were made out of the capital of the partnership. It appears, also, that none of ??? properties purchased had any real connection with the business in time which was at least the primary business of both the firms in which the members of the family were partners.

    17. I may now deal with the question of the quarries. According to the decree of the learned Subordinate Judge the plaintiff is to receive a share in the rights created by the leases granted to Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das by the Government of the Central Provinces. Now all these leases were executed after the death of Ram Chander. They the dated 29th September 1923, 20th November 1923, 11th January 1924, 28th July 1927 and 17th September 1929. Ram Chander could not have had any right in the interests created by the leases after he was dead. It is argued on behalf of the plaintiff-respondent that these leases were granted in renewal of previous leases which had been in favour of the two appellants and of Ram Chunder and consequently that it should be held that Ram Chunder had a share in the interests created by them. It has been admitted, however, that there is no evidence whatsoever to show that any of these leases were granted in renewal of previous leases. The plaintiff-respondent bases her argument only on the fact that the form in which the leases are drawn up show that they are capable of renewal. I am not prepared to hold in these circumstances that the leases were renewals of previous leases and it follows that there can be no doubt that Ram Chander had no right in the interests arising out of them. That part of the decree of the lower Court which provides that the plaintiff-respondent should get a share in these interests cannot be upheld.

    18. I now come to the mortgages. The two which are mentioned in Sch. B are the subject-matter of the plaintiff's appeal. It is admitted that these two mortgages have been redeemed in the sense that the money due has been paid to Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das. It is argued however on behalf of the plaintiff appellant in that appeal that two of the mortgagees could not give a valid discharge. It is unnecessary, I think, in this appeal to express any opinion upon that argument. The mortgagors were not parties to the case from which the appeal has arisen and are not represented before us. The plaintiff-appellant is on the horns of a dilemma. If she contends that the mortgages were extinguished by the payment of the money, there is no doubt that her claim for a share of that money against Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das would be barred by limitation. On the other hand, if she maintains, as it is suggested by arguments addressed to us that she does maintain, that the mortgages still subsist, because there has been no valid discharge, then her proper remedy is to institute suits to which the mortgagors are parties. In any case she cannot succeed in getting a decree in this appeal. Her appeal therefore must be dismissed with costs.

    19. As for the mortgage which is mentioned as Item 2, Sch. C, we are informed that a suit was instituted upon the basis of it by Lachhman Das and Rameshwar Das who impleaded Mt. Gulab Devi as a defendant. The lady made an application to the Court that she should be included in the array of plaintiff and that was done. A decree was passed on the basis of the mortgage. The property was sold and was purchased by the three plaintiffs in that suit. The direction we understand of the Court is that the question of the shares in the property shall depend upon the decision in the suit which we are considering. The sum of money which was secured by the mortgage was paid out during the life-time of Earn Chander. As I have already held, I am not satisfied that any payments made out of the credit of the three members of the family as shown in the books can be considered to be payments out of the partnership capital. It does not appear that this mortgage had anything to do with the partnership business. I am therefore of opinion that Mt. Gulab Devi had a share of one-third in the interest created by the mortgage and would have the same share in any property acquired out of those interests. There remains one other point. The plaintiff asked for a decree for mesne profits for a period of three years. The learned Subordinate Judge decreed a sum of Rs. 2,100 on this account. In arriving at that sum however he took into consideration the profit from the quarries to which I consider that the plaintiff respondent had no claim. The decree for mesne profits as it stands cannot be upheld. It seems unnecessary at this stage to go into the question of the amount which is properly due. I would therefore leave that question to be decided at the time when the final decree for partition is passed. As a result of my findings I would dismiss the plaintiff's appeal No. 379 of 1932 and the defendants' appeal No. 458 of 1932. In pursuance of the present appeal No. 327 of 1932 I would modify the decree of the Court below. Where the lower Court has said that the plaintiff's share in properties Nos. 1-5 of Sch. A is one-half, I should say that the plaintiff's share in properties Nos. 1-5 of Sch. A is one-half except that she shall not be entitled to any interests in the quarrying rights created by leases granted by the Government of the Central Provinces. Where the lower Court says that defendants 1-3 shall pay Rs. 2,100 as mesne profits to the plaintiff, I should say that the plaintiff shall be entitled to mesne profits from defendants 1-3 for a period of three years before the institution of the suit on the property in which she is held to have a share and that ??? amount of mesne profits should be calculated and included in the final decree of partition. I should give the respondent their costs in appeals Nos. 379 and 4 ??? of 1932. I should give the defendant appellants one-third of their costs in the appeal No. 327 of 1932, and the plaint two-thirds of her costs in the low Court from defendants 1 to 3. I would not interfere with the order of the low Court that defendants 4 to 10 should bear their own costs. The provision about future mesne profits should ???.

    Niamat Ullah, J.:— I agree and has nothing to add.

    20. By the Court.— We dismiss the plaintiff's appeal No. 379 of 1932 and the defendants' appeal No. 458 of 1932. ??? appeal No. 327 of 1932 we modify the decree of the Court below. Where the lower Court has said that the plaintiff share in properties Nos. 1 to 5 of Sch. ??? is one-half, we direct that the plaintiff share in properties Nos. 1 to 5 of Sch. shall be one-half, except that she ??? not be entitled to any interest in ??? quarry rights created by leases granted by the Government of the Central Provinces. Where the lower Court says, the defendants 1 to 3 shall pay Rs. 2,100 ??? mesne profits to the plaintiff, we direct that the plaintiff shall be entitled ??? mesne profits from defendants 1 to 3 ??? a period of three years next before the institution of the suit on the properties in which she is held to have a share and that the amount of mesne profits shall be calculated and included in the ??? decree for partition. We give the respondents their costs in appeals Nos. 37 and 458 of 1932. We give the defendant appellants one-third of their costs in appeal No. 327 of 1932, and the plaintiff two-third of her costs in the lower Court from defendants 1 to 3. We do not interfere with the order of the lower Court that defendants 4 to 10 shall ??? their own costs. The provisions in the decree of the Court below about future mesne profits shall stand.

    S.R/R.K

    21. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lachhman Das v. Mt. Gulab Devi
    (Oct 3, 1935)