Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 74 of the Indian evidence Act.9. Referring to section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • provisions contained in section 36 read with section 87 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • provisions contained in sections 36 and 83 of the Evidence Act.
  • provisions of section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • facts.7. Section 87 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • section 74(1)(i) of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • Evidence Act. read with section 151, C.P.C
  • sections 36 and 83 of the Evidence Act.
  • section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • Section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • Evidence Act (I of 1872), section 74].10.
  • SECTION 36 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 74 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 83 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 62 EVIDENCE ACT
  • S. Act and O.C.H & P.F.L Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 74 of the Indian evidence Act.9. Referring to section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • provisions contained in section 36 read with section 87 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • provisions contained in sections 36 and 83 of the Evidence Act.
  • provisions of section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act,
  • facts.7. Section 87 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • section 74(1)(i) of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • Evidence Act. read with section 151, C.P.C
  • sections 36 and 83 of the Evidence Act.
  • section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • Section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • Evidence Act (I of 1872), section 74].10.
  • SECTION 36 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 74 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 83 EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 62 EVIDENCE ACT
  • S. Act and O.C.H & P.F.L Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff-petitioner filed Title Suit No. 23/1995 before the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Rairangpur, seeking declaration of title over 0.1 decimal of land, delivery of possession by evicting defendant Nos. 1 to 3, recognition of easementary right of way, and permanent injunction against defendants interfering with possession. The suit was decreed on 24.11.2000. Some defendants appealed, and the Additional District Judge remanded the matter to the Trial Court with directions to appoint a Civil Court Commissioner for fresh measurement of the suit land and dispose of the suit within six months.

Post-remand, the plaintiff-petitioner obtained certified copies of original maps of mouza Bisoi from the Board of Revenue after depositing requisite fees. On 9.11.2006, the plaintiff filed 19 documents including the maps before the Trial Court. The Trial Court exhibited all documents except the village maps and rejected the application to mark the maps as exhibits on 29.11.2006, citing absence of signature with seal on the maps and the necessity of formal proof due to defendants disputing their genuineness.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the village maps purchased from the competent authority, lacking signature and seal, can be marked as exhibits in evidence under the Indian Evidence Act.
  2. Whether such maps constitute public documents within the meaning of Section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  3. Whether the Trial Court was justified in rejecting the application to exhibit the village maps on grounds of lack of formal proof and disputed genuineness.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The village maps were purchased in accordance with guidelines issued by the Board of Revenue and are public documents.
  • Under Sections 36 and 83 of the Indian Evidence Act, such maps should be admitted as exhibits without requiring further formal proof.
  • Reliance was placed on the judgment in Secretary of State v. Chimanlal Jamnadas AIR 1942 Bom. 161 to support admissibility.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The maps printed by the settlement authority typically contain date of publication and signature of the authority as required by the Orissa Survey and Settlement Act, 1962.
  • In the instant case, the maps lack such certificate and signature, justifying the Trial Court's rejection of their exhibition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Secretary of State v. Chimanlal Jamnadas AIR 1942 Bom. 161 Printed copy of the original map is a public document under Section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act. Supported the proposition that maps purchased from competent authority are admissible as public documents.
Manorama Srivastava v. Saroj Srivastava Definition and scope of public documents under Indian Evidence Act. Used to explain the nature of public documents and their admissibility.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Krishna Sharma AIR 1998 Del 386 Public documents contain statements made by authorized agents in discharge of official duties and are open to public scrutiny. Clarified the authoritative nature and public interest in such documents, supporting admissibility.
Sturla v. Freccia (per Lord Blackburn) Criteria for a document to be considered public: made by public officer, for public use, and kept accessible. Used to reinforce that maps published by government authorities are public documents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Sections 36, 74, 83, and 87 of the Indian Evidence Act to determine the admissibility of the village maps. Section 36 renders statements in published maps offered for public sale or made under government authority as relevant facts. Section 74 defines public documents, including those forming acts of sovereign authority or official bodies. Section 83 allows presumption of accuracy for such maps. The Court found that the maps supplied by the Board of Revenue, though lacking signature and seal, were printed copies of original official maps purchased after payment of requisite fees and thus constituted public documents.

The Court rejected the Trial Court's rationale that absence of formal certification and seal rendered the maps inadmissible, noting that no formal proof was necessary where the documents were obtained from competent government sources and no genuine dispute over authenticity existed. The Court emphasized that the maps were vital for proper adjudication and that their exclusion had vitiated the Civil Court Commissioner's report. Consequently, the Court directed the Trial Court to admit the Sabik and Hal maps as exhibits for effective resolution of the suit.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed.

The Court set aside the impugned order rejecting the application to mark the village maps as exhibits and directed the Trial Court to admit both the Sabik and Hal maps of mouza Bisoi submitted by the plaintiff-petitioner. This decision ensures that essential official maps are considered in evidence for just adjudication. No new precedent was established; the ruling affirms the applicability of existing provisions of the Indian Evidence Act concerning public documents and admissibility of official maps.

    Biseswar Dandpat v. Saraswati Dei And Others

    B.R Sarangi, J.:— The plaintiff-petitioner has filed this writ application assailing the order dated 29.11.2006 in Annexure-1 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Rairangpur in T.S No. 23/1995 rejecting the application to exhibit the village maps.

    2. The fact of the case in nut-shell is that the plaintiff-petitioner filed Title Suit No. 23/1995 before the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Rairangpur praying for declaration of title over Ac. 0.1 decimal of land as found by Civil Court Commissioner and delivering the possession of the same to him by evicting defendant Nos. 1 to 3 from the said area, his easementary right of way over path and injuncting defendants permanently not to interfere with his possession. The suit was decreed on 24.11.2000 Assailing the same, some of the defendants filed Title Appeal Nos. 1 of 2001 and 2 of 2001 before the Additional District Judge, Rairangpur. After hearing the parties, learned Lower Appellate Court remanded the matter to the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Rairangpur with a direction to appoint a Civil Court Commissioner for measurement of the suit land afresh at the cost of the parties and dispose of the suit within six months.

    3. After remand the plaintiff-petitioner filed an application before the Board of Revenue to obtain certified copy of-the original map of mouza Bisoi and the plaintiff was accordingly directed to deposit the requisite amount to-obtain the printed;copy available for public sale. In view of the notification issued by the Board of Revenue dated 6.12.2003 indicating, enhancement of cost of saleable maps with reference to the Gove Vnment in Revenue Department letter No. 57031/2011 dated 4.2;2013 under Clause (1) wherein it is stated that village maps finally published under O.S and S. Act and O.C.H & P.F.L Act, the present rate per sheet Rs. 10 has been revised rate per sheet to Rs. 25 and such notification has been issued by the Director of Land Records and Survey addressing to the various authorities of the Revenue Department. Accordingly, the plaintiff-petitioner deposited the requisite fees for supply of the printed copy of the maps which has been supplied to him in conformity with the provisions of law. On 9.11.2006 the plaintiff-petitioner filed 19 documents along-with the said, map before the Trial Court to prove his, case. Qn consideration of-the same, learned Trial Court by order dated 10.11.2006 exhibited other documents excluding the village maps in consequence thereof the plaintiff:petitioner filed a petition under sections 36 and 83 of. the. Evidence Act. read with section 151, C.P.C tinder Annexure-3 with a prayer to recall the order dated 10.11.2006 and to mark exhibit of both sabik and hal map of mouza Bisoi which has been rejected vide impugned order dated 29.11.2006 on the ground that maps produced by the plaintiff-petitioner do not contain signature with seal and the maps purchased from a competent authority cannot be suo motu exhibited without its formal proof when the defendants dispute the genuineness of the maps.

    4. Mrs. S. Mohanty, learned Counsel for the plaintiff-petitioner argued with vehemence that the map having been purchased in consonance with the guideline. Issued by the Board of Revenue issuing a public document the same should have been marked as exhibits as per the provisions contained in sections 36 and 83 of the Evidence Act. In support of her contention, she has relied upon the judgment in Secretary of State v. Chimanlal Jamnadas AIR 1942 Bom. 161..

    5. Mr. P.R Barik, learned Counsel for the defendant-opposite-party No. 1 stated that the maps printed by the settlement authority contain the date of publication and signature of the settlement authority as required by the Orissa Survey and Settlement Act, 1962. In the instant case, such certificate is not available in the map. Therefore, the orders passed by the learned Trial Court is justified.

    6. Considering, the rival contentions of the parties and on perusing the record, it is to be considered whether the map granted by the compe-tent authority can be marked as exhibits for just and proper adjudication of the suit in question. Section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act states as follows:

    “Relevancy of statements in maps, charts and plans.— Statements of facts in issue or relevant facts, made in published map or charts generally offered for public sale, or in maps or plans made under the authority of the. Central Government or any State Government, as to matters usually represented or stated in such maps, charts or plans, are themselves relevant facts.”

    7. Section 87 of the Indian Evidence Act reads as follows:

    “Presumption as to books, maps and charts.— The Court may presume that any book to which it may refer for information on matters of public or general interest and that any published map or chart, the statements of which are relevant facts, and which, is produced for its inspection, was written and published by the person, and at the time and place, by whom or at which it purports to have been written or published.”

    8. In view of the provisions contained in section 36 read with section 87 of the Indian Evidence Act it is to be considered whether the map is a public document within the meaning of section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act.

    9. Referring to Section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act, the map which has been granted by the competent authority in consonance with the notifications issued by the Board of Revenue in Annexure-5 can be termed an official map which means in zoning and land use, the authorized map for the determination of proper land use in the city or town, showing the zones and areas and their authorized uses'. Map or official maps can be taken into public document within the meaning of section 74 of. the Evidence Act. Therefore, which is of the documents are to be public documents has been mentioned in section 74 of the Evidence Act. The following documents are public documents (1) documents forming the acts or records of the acts:

    i. of the sovereign authority;

    ii. of official bodes and Tribunals and;

    iii. of public officers, legislative, judicial and executive, of any part of, or of the commonwealth other part of her Majesty's dominions, or of a foreign country.

    (2) public records kept in any state of private documents (Indian Evidence Act (I of 1872), section 74].

    10. What constitute public document has also been considered in see also Manorama Srivastava v. Saroj Sriuastava

    11. A public document is such a document contents of which are of public interest and the statements are made by authorized and competent agents of the public in the course of their official duty. Public are interested in such a document and entitle to see it, so that if there is anything wrong in if they would be entitled to object. In that sense it becomes a statement that would be open to the public to challenge or dispute and therefore, it has certain amount of authority. See New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Krishna Sharma AIR 1998 Del 386 at 388.

    12. With reference to the question of admissibility of a public document in evidence, the following observations were made by Lord BLACKBURN: There “should be a public inquiry, a public document, and made by a public officer. I do not think that, ‘public’ there, is to be taken in the sense of meaning of the whole world. I think an entry in the books of a Manor is ‘public’ in the sense that it concerns all the people interested in the manor and an entry, probably, in a corporation book concerning a matter or something in which all the corporation is concerned would be ‘public’ within that sense. But must be a ‘public document’ and it must be made by a Public Officer. I understand a ‘public document’, there to mean a document that is made for the purpose of the public making use of it and being able to refer to it. It is meant to be where there is a judicial or quasi judicial, duty to enquire. It should be made for the purpose of being kept public, so that the persons concerned in it may have access to it afterwards”. (per BLACKBURN J. Sturla v. Freccia

    13. On when the touch stone of the contention raised now it is to be considered whether the learned Trial Court is justified in rejecting the application on the ground stated earlier with reference to the ground No. 1 that the maps purchased by the plaintiff-petitioner which do not contain any certificate with seal and signature cannot be construed to be a public document to be marked as exhibit. The maps in question are prepared by the Revenue Department and the same are sold by the State Government pursuant to letter of Board of Revenue in Annexure-5 and more so the same is published by the Government and offered for sale. The maps in question are printed copy of the original purchased from the Government officers on payment of requisites fees. The said printed copy does not contain any certificate with seal and signature as it is not the certified copy. As per the provisions of Section 36 of the Indian Evidence Act, there are two types of maps, namely, published map or chars offered for public sale and maps and plans made under authority of Government. Therefore, section 36 of the Evidence Act mandates that the statement of the facts in issue made in published maps generally offered for public sale themselves constitute to be a public document and the element of public document as enshrined in section 74 of the Evidence Act is well founded. Therefore, under section 83 of the Evidence Act, the Court must presume the same maps to be accurate purporting to be made by the authority of any State Government. So far as rejection of the application on the ground that the maps purchased from competent authority cannot be suo motu exhibited without its formal proof when the defendants disputed genuineness of the map is concerned, the contention is that no formal proof is necessary as there is no dispute regarding genuineness of the documents, for the fact is that the document map has been purchased from the various sources of the State Government having competence over the same. The said documents are public document within the meaning of section 74(1)(i) of the Indian Evidence Act. As the said document forming the acts of the sovereign authority, the same should have been admitted without any objection as primary evidence under section 62 of the Evidence Act. When the competent authority has supplied the printed copy of the original on payment of requisite fees by virtue of letter under Annexure-5, it can be very well presumed to be accurate and the said printed maps are admissible in evidence as relevant under sections 36 and 83 of the Evidence Act. The printed copy of the original is the public document within the meaning of section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act. In Secretary of State (supra), the Bombay High Court held that the printed copy of the original is the public document within the meaning of section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act. In view of the aforesaid fact and law, the Trial Court should not have rejected the prayer of the plaintiff-petitioner to exhibit both the Sabik and Hal maps and other documents without appreciating the facts that the same are imperative for effective adjudication of issue involved in the case. Hence the Appellate Court remanded the case to the Trial Court with an observation that the report of the Civil Court Commissioner is vitiated due to non-supply of Sabik and Hal map and directed for appointment of a Civil Court Commissioner for measurement of the suit land afresh at the cost of the parties. Thus, the Sabik and Hal maps are most vital documents to be exhibited for adjudication of the dispute between the parties. Therefore, this Court set aside the impugned order dated 29.6.2011 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Rairangpur in T.S No. 23 of 1995 under Annexure-1 rejecting the application to mark the maps as exhibits and directs the Trial Court to exhibit both the Sabik and Hal maps of mouza Bisoi submitted by the plaintiff-petitioner for proper adjudication of the dispute in question.

    14. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. No order to cost.

    15. Petition Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Biseswar Dandpat v. Saraswati Dei And Others
    (Feb 11, 2014)