AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal from a decision of the First Class Subordinate Judge of Dharwar. The plaintiff claims as the adopted son of one Parappa. Parappa and his brother (the father of defendant 3) were descendants of Basappa and members of a joint family with the descendants of Yeerappa (Basappa's brother). Parappa died in 1923, leaving a widow (defendant 6). In 1932 there was a partition between defendant 3 (who represented Basappa's branch) and the descendants of Yeerappa; defendant 3 took half the property and Yeerappa's descendants took the other half. In 1933 Parappa's widow adopted the plaintiff.

The learned trial Judge held that the plaintiff was entitled to one-fourth of the whole of the property which had been partitioned, except the houses; he held the partition of the houses to be fair but considered the partition of the remainder unfair and ordered a fresh partition of that part. The present appeal challenges aspects of that decree. The appellate court varied the decree to direct that the plaintiff recover one-half of the share of the joint family property taken by defendant 3 on the partition; otherwise the appeal failed. The court also made an order as to costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What share, if any, in the family property is the plaintiff (adopted son of Parappa) entitled to?
  2. Whether the plaintiff can challenge a partition effected before he was adopted.
  3. Whether the share taken by defendant 3 on the 1932 partition became his absolute property (severalty) or remained subject to joint family (coparcenary) rights, such that an adopted son of Parappa's widow could claim a portion.
  4. Whether the rule in the Full Bench decision reported at 39 Bom LR 382 applies to bar the plaintiff's claim.
  5. Whether, on the evidence, the partition's terms (particularly as to lands versus houses) are sufficiently shown to be unequal or fraudulent to warrant reopening.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants / Defendants' Arguments (as presented)

  • Defendant 3 contended that the share he took on the partition was his absolute property in severalty and that the adopted son of his father's brother (the plaintiff) takes no interest in that share.
  • Mr. Murdeshwar (for the appellants-defendants) relied on the Full Bench decision reported at 39 Bom LR 382 to argue that, even if the adoption is valid, the adopted son would not acquire an interest in the joint family property — specifically where the coparcenary has terminated such that property has vested in an heir.
  • The appellants argued that the adopted son could not challenge the validity or terms of the partition effected prior to his adoption between the surviving coparceners (i.e., defendant 3 and his cousins).

Plaintiff / Respondent's Allegations and Contentions (as presented)

  • The plaintiff claimed rights as the adopted son of Parappa and sought a share in family property, asserting a right to reopen or question the partition because it was unequal and unfair (the trial court awarded one-fourth of the whole property except houses).
  • The plaintiff alleged possible unfairness or fraud in the partition as regards lands and the appropriation of realizations in respect of certain family advances secured by mortgages allotted to shares of defendants 1, 2 and 4.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
39 Bom LR 382 The Full Bench rule: where adoption takes place after the termination of the coparcenary by the death (actually or fictionally) of the last surviving coparcener and the family property has vested in his heir, the widow's adoption does not revive the coparcenary and does not divest property from the heir or those claiming through him (quoted at p.414 in the judgment). The court held the case distinguishable: in the present case the coparcenary had not come to an end by death of the last surviving coparcener and the 1932 disruption was by partition/agreement. The court refused to apply 39 Bom LR 382 to bar the plaintiff's claim and limited its scope.
37 Bom LR 692 Authority distinguishing joint Hindu family and coparcenary and relevant observations on the distinction (referred to in the judgment). The court relied on the distinction to support the view that disruption by agreement (partition) is different from termination by death and does not necessarily prevent revival of coparcenary rights on adoption or birth.
14 Bom 463 (Chandra's case) Principle drawn: an adopted son cannot divest an estate already vested in another; adoption by a widow of a deceased coparcener, though valid, cannot divest property which has vested in an heir (subject to discussion in the opinion). The Full Bench (39 Bom LR 382) approved this ruling; the court acknowledged the principle but limited its application and declined to extend it to defeat the plaintiff's claim in these facts.
46 IA 97; 48 IA 513; 60 IA 256; 60 IA 242 Privy Council decisions referenced in relation to the continued validity of Chandra's case and related principles on adoption and succession (cited as not expressly disapproving the earlier ruling). These authorities were noted as not having expressly disapproved Chandra's case; the court used the cluster of decisions to situate the limits of the Full Bench's rule and to caution against over-extending that rule to the facts before it.
3 IA 1548 at p. 193 Ruling relied upon (as recorded) to support the observation that if the question arose between an adopted son and his uncle, the adopted son might be entitled to succeed; referenced as foundation for certain obiter remarks. The court referred to this ruling as underpinning observations in Chandra's case and as part of the authorities that inform how far the adopted son's rights can affect property vested in collaterals; used to explain limits of divestiture by adoption.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded through two judgments (Beaumont, C.J., and Wassoodew, J.) which converge on the result while emphasizing complementary legal points.

Beaumont, C.J.

  • Begins by framing the narrow factual question: what share in the family property the plaintiff (adopted in 1933) is entitled to, given the 1932 partition.
  • Notes the trial Judge's finding that the plaintiff was entitled to one-fourth of the whole property except houses, and that the partition of the remainder was unfair requiring redivision.
  • States the general proposition that a plaintiff cannot challenge a partition effected before he was adopted; however, he qualifies that in the present facts the plaintiff's challenge cannot extend to upsetting the partition in its entirety because defendant 3 had accepted the partition at the time.
  • Analyses the nature of the share taken by defendant 3: because defendant 3's share on partition was made liable for maintenance of Parappa's widow and because Veerappa's descendants remained joint among themselves, the proper inference is that defendant 3 took the half-share as joint family property (i.e., the coparcenary had not come to an end).
  • Concludes that the adoption did not divest any estate from a person who already possessed it; rather, the adoption admits the adopted son into the existing coparcenary. Therefore the plaintiff may claim a proportionate right in the share held by defendant 3 — specifically, one-half of the share defendant 3 took on the partition — and directs variation of the lower court's order accordingly.

Wassoodew, J.

  • Summarizes the appellants' two principal grounds: application of 39 Bom LR 382 and that an adopted son could not challenge a pre-adoption partition between surviving coparceners.
  • Distinguishes 39 Bom LR 382 on the facts: that case involved termination of the coparcenary by death of the last surviving coparcener and vesting of property in his heir; the present case involves disruption by agreement (partition), which creates several distinct estates but does not necessarily destroy the possibility of reviving the coparcenary.
  • Emphasizes the legal distinction between joint Hindu family and coparcenary; notes that a widow of a coparcener remains a member of the joint family and that the existence of a widow entitled to adopt means the family status continues in a relevant sense.
  • Holds that defendant 3 (Nishimappa's son) remained a member of the joint family even after the partition and that the adoption by Parappa's widow could, in the circumstances, admit the adopted son into the coparcenary as would the birth of a son to defendant 3.
  • Considers authorities limiting the adopted son's power to divest property already vested in another, but finds those authorities distinguishable and not sufficient to defeat the plaintiff's claim here.
  • On the factual question whether the partition was unfair or fraudulent, finds that the plaintiff had not discharged the onus of proving inequality or fraud: area differences were compensated by quality of land; defendant 3 was represented by a guardian who did not appear negligent; alleged appropriation of realisations on mortgage security lacked sufficient evidence; the minor had received certain moveables as advantages.
  • Accordingly, agrees that the decree of the lower court should be affirmed except that the plaintiff is entitled to one-half of the share allotted to Nishimappa (defendant 3) on partition.

The court thus blends legal analysis (distinguishing partition by agreement from termination of coparcenary by death; examining the status of the widow and the continuity of coparcenary rights) with an evaluation of the evidence (insufficient proof of unfairness or fraud), reaching a mixed legal-factual conclusion.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The decree is varied so that the plaintiff is entitled to recover one-half of the share of the joint family property taken by defendant 3 (Nishimappa's son) on the 1932 partition; in all other respects the lower court's decree is affirmed. The court further ordered costs: the plaintiff must pay the costs of the suit and the appeal to defendants 1, 2 and 4, and shall recover his costs of the suit from defendant 3. The final notation in the opinion records: "Decree varied."

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the plaintiff gains a specific entitlement (one-half of defendant 3's allotted share) rather than the broader relief originally awarded by the trial judge; the partition is not reopened generally because the plaintiff failed to prove unfairness or fraud to the requisite standard.
  • On legal principle: the court limits the application of the Full Bench rule in 39 Bom LR 382 to its facts (termination of the coparcenary by death and vesting in an heir). The court held that a partition by agreement creating severalty does not necessarily preclude an adopted son's claim where the coparcenary has not been terminated by death and where the adopted son is admitted into the continuing coparcenary status of the family. The court did not purport to lay down a wholly new precedent beyond the confines of the facts adjudicated.
  • No sweeping rule was laid down to overrule or broadly extend prior authorities; the court explicitly distinguished earlier decisions and confined its holding to the factual matrix before it.

Per Curiam notation in the opinion: the costs order and the variation to the decree were expressly recorded by the court.

    Chanbasappa Virappa Bolagondar v. Huchappa Parappa Bolagondar

    Beaumont, C.J:— This is an appeal from a decision of the First Class Sub ordinate Judge of Dharwar. The facts are simple. The plaintiff claims as the adopted son of one Parappa. Parappa had a brother who was defendant 3's father, and they, as descendants of Basappa, were members of a joint family with the descendants of Basappa's brother Yeerappa. Parappa died in 1923, leaving a widow who is defendant 6. In 1932 there was a partition between defendant 3 and the other branch of the family that is Veerappa's descendants. Defendant 3 took half the property, and, Yeerappa's descendants took the other half. In 1933 Parappa's widow adopted the plaintiff.

    2. The question is what share (if any) in the family property the plaintiff is entitled to. The learned Judge held that he was entitled to one-fourth of the whole of the property which had been partitioned, except the houses. He held that the partition of the houses was fair, but that the partition of the rest of the property was not fair, and that although the fact of the partition was admitted, there ought to be a fresh partition of that part of the property in respect of which the partition was unfair. But, in my opinion the plaintiff cannot challenge a partition effected before he was adopted. Defendant 3 at the time of the partition represented the branch of Basappa, and as he was and is satisfied with the partition, in my opinion the plaintiff cannot challenge it. I think therefore that the utmost which the plaintiff can claim is a share in the half share of the family property which defendant 3 took, and the question is whether a claim to that share is good.

    3. Defendant 3 contends that the share which he took on partition is his absolute-property, and that the adopted son of his, father's brother takes no interest therein. Now, if on the partition, defendant 3 took a half-share in his own right absolutely, I agree that the subsequently adopted son of his father's brother would not be entitled to share. But, from the fact that the descendants of Veerappa remained joint as between themselves, and from the fact that defendant 3's share was on the partition made liable for the maintenance of Parappa's widow, I think the proper inference to be drawn is that defendant 3 took this half share as joint family property. He and the widow of Parappa were the only members; of the joint family, and no doubt he was the sole coparcener. But in my opinion it is not accurate to say that the coparcenary had come to an end. I think the coparcenary still exists in respect of the share which he took on the partition and that on the birth of a son to him, that son would have a share in the coparcenary and on the adoption of a son by his father's brother's widow, that adopted son is also entitled to share.

    4. Mr. Murdeshwar relied on the decision of this Court in 39 Bom LR 3821 as showing that, although the adoption of the plaintiff might be valid, he would not acquire any interest in the joint family property. But in that case the coparcenary had come to an end by the death of the last surviving coparcener and this Court held that in that event the adoption although valid could not divest the property from the heir of the last coparcener. The actual proposition dealing with this subject, which the majority of the Court laid down, is (p. 414):

    That where the adoption takes place after the termination of the coparcenary by the death, actually or fictionally, of the last surviving coparcener, the adoption by a widow of a deceased coparcener has not the effect of reviving the coparcenary, and does not divest property from the heir of the last Surviving coparcener (other than the widow) or those claiming through him or her.

    5. The distinction between that case and the present one is that there the coparcenary had not come to an end by the death of the last surviving coparcener. The last surviving corparcener was still alive and, in my opinion, the coparcenary must be taken as still alive, although there was only one coparcener. The adoption therefore of the plaintiff does not divest the estate from anybody. It merely lets him in as a member of the coparcenary. That being so, I think that the order of the lower Court must be varied by directing that the plaintiff do recover one-half of the share of the joint family property taken by defendant 3 on the partition. Subject to that variation the appeal fails.

    Wassoodew, J.:— The facts of this case have been fully stated in the judgment just delivered. Mr. Murdeshwar for the appellants-defendants has challenged the decree of the lower Court on two principal grounds First, that the case falls within the principle of the Full Bench ruling in 39 Bom LR 382 and secondly, that assuming that the adoption is valid, the adopted son could not question the validity or the terms of the partition effected between his deceased father's nephew and his coparceners, namely his cousins. With regard to the first ground, it seems to me that the case in 39 Bom LR 382 is distinguishable on the facts. The decision of the majority of the Full Bench was to the effect that where the adoption takes place after the termination of a Hindu coparcenary by the death, actually or fictionally, of the last surviving coparcener, and the family property has vested in his heir, the adoption by a widow of a predeceased coparcener, though valid, has not the effect of reviving the coparcenary and does not divest property from the heir of the last surviving coparcener (other than the widow) or those claiming through him or her. For the application of the rule in 39 Bom LR 382 not only has it to be established that the coparcenary has come to an end, but also that it has come to an end in a particular manner, that is, by the death of the only surviving coparcener with the result that the property has vested in the heir of the latter. The result cannot be the same where there is disruption of the joint family by agreement. In that event the family property is held in severalty by the different members of the joint family. The interest remains vested in the same individuals but only in the parcels allotted to their shares so that several distinct estates are created of a different quantity. The result contemplated in 39 Bom LR 382 upon termination of the coparcenary by the death of the last surviving coparcener cannot be said to have been attained upon disruption by agreement. The possibility of reviving the coparcenary is not destroyed in the latter event. Upon authority there is a distinction between joint Hindu family and coparcenary. In that connexion I would refer to the remarks of this Court in 37 Bom LR 692.2

    6. It does not, I think, follow from the fact of the partition that Basappa's grandson, defendant 3, ceased to be, along with the widow of his uncle, a member of a joint Hindu family. As Parappa was dead at the time of partition, Nishimappa's son, defendant 3, took the estate subject to the rights of the widow of Parappa to residence and maintenance out of the share which Parappa would have got if he were alive at the date of the partition. That right is referable to her being a widow of a deceased coparcener. A wife of a coparcener is a member of the joint family. She does not cease to be a member by the death of her husband. In that view Nishimappa's son, I think, continued to be a member of the joint family, notwithstanding the disruption of the coparcenary of which he was a member along with his cousins, so long as there was a widow in that family entitled to adopt: see observations in Mulla's Hindu Law under III. (c) to S. 506, p. 557, Edn. 8. It is therefore in my opinion wrong to draw an analogy from 39 Bom LR 382, for here there is no question of reviving the coparcenary after devolution of the estate held by the last surviving coparcener upon his death on his heir. In the present case the birth of a son to defendant 3 would have revived the coparcenary in the same way as the adoption of the plaintiff.

    7. It may be noted that the Full Bench approved of the ruling in 14 Bom 463,3 which they held was still good law, it not having been expressly disapproved by the Privy Council decisions, such as 46 IA 97, 4 48 IA 513,5 60 IA 256 and 60 IA 242.7 The principle deducible from Chandra's case is that an adopted son cannot divest an estate which is already vested in another, that is, he cannot exclude the heir of the last holder other than the widow herself. There, it was remarked that if the question had arisen between an adopted son and his uncle, if he were alive, the adopted son would have been entitled to succeed. Although those remarks were obiter, they were founded upon the ruling in 3 IA 1548 at p. 193, and recognize the principle that the adopted son cannot divest property vested in a collateral relation of the husband in succession to some other person who had himself been the sole owner in the meantime. I am in doubt whether that is consistent with the rule laid down in 60 IA 242, although the latter was a case of inheritance and not coparcenary. Although 39 Bom LR 382 has to a certain extent restricted the rights of the adopted son, particularly upon an argument ab inconvenienti, the analogy of that ruling cannot be extended further to the prejudice of the adopted son.

    8. Here however the case is entirely different. Nishimappa's son was the nephew of the adopted son's father Parappa. There is no question of divesting the property which was already vested in him and in his possession as a member of the coparcenary. The interest of Nishimappa's son which was defined upon a division among the coparceners was vested in him at the time of the partition. That partition merely transformed the entirety of interest in the joint family property into severalty. It is idle to contend that the adopted son was divesting him of that estate. There would be upon adoption of the plaintiff a protanto reduction of the quantum of the interest acquired by him at the time of the partition. But that is entirely a different matter. If it were held that a division among the surviving coparceners could effectively bar the adopted son of a deceased coparcener from claiming a share in the family property, the right of adoption of a widow of a deceased coparcener would be easily frustrated. It is therefore reasonable and proper to conclude that, merely because there was disruption of the coparcenary upon partition between defendant 3 and his cousins, the rule in 39 Bom LR 382 will not affect the plaintiff's adoption. It seems to me following the recent decisions of the Privy Council and this Court that the adoption of the plaintiff Huchappa by Parappa's widow is valid. The question of the right of the adopted son to re-open the partition, or rather to question the fairness of its terms, is not free from difficulty. There is no doubt that the rights of the adopted son arise for the first time upon his adoption, and, although the authorities are not clear as to whether his rights relate back to the date of the death of the adoptive father, I am not prepared to say that under all conditions and circumstances the adopted son cannot challenge a partition of this kind effected prior to his adoption among the coparceners of his father. There is considerable body of authority to the effect that an adopted son cannot challenge alienations or arrangements made by his adoptive father on the ground that the rights of the adopted son arise from the moment of his adoption, and they do not displace the rights created by the father or adoptive mother prior to the adoption. Consequently it has been urged that as Nishimappa's son, defendant 3 had dealt with his property by agreement entered into by him, or rather by his guardian, with his coparceners, that agreement could not be questioned by the adopted son. On the other hand, there is authority for the view that an agreement by the adoptive mother with the natural father of the adopted son can be questioned by the latter, if it is to his prejudice: see, 37 Bom 251.9 It is urged that an adopted son could therefore call in question a partition effected prior to his adoption between the surviving coparceners of his father if it is to his prejudice. That eminent scholar, Mr. Golapchandra Sarkar Sastri, in his Treatise on Hindu Law of Adoption (Edition 1916, p. 416 at p. 419), has dealt with the adopted son's powers to question the alienations of his mother. But he has expressed no opinion on the rights of the adopted son to question a partition effected prior to his adoption. The matter has not been very fully argued before us, and I think it is not proper to express any definite view on the point raised, as on the merits and the evidence I am satisfied that the plaintiff has not made out a case for reopening the partition.

    9. The learned trial Judge has held that the division of the houses is not unequal. But, with regard to the lands he was in doubt, because there was divergence in the area and assessment which might possibly lead to the suspicion of inequality of division. It seems to me that the inequality in the area has been compensated by the quality of the land. It is difficult to say, in view of the fact that defendant 3 was properly represented by his guardian who, it is not shown, was negligent with regard to the interest of her minor son, that the division accepted by her should now be set aside merely upon the statement in the pleadings that it was unequal and unfair. The other circumstance alluded to is that there was possibly a fraud on the minor by reason of the appropriation of the realizations in respect of certain family advances, on the security of mortgages allotted to the share of defendants 1, 2 and 4. There is no sufficient evidence for accepting that statement. There were certain other advantages which the minor received in the shape of moveables. It is sufficient to say that the onus which lay on the plaintiff of proving the alleged inequality of the division has not been satisfactorily discharged. I therefore agree with my Lord the Chief Justice that the lower Court's decree should be affirmed, subject to the variation that the-plaintiff shall be entitled to one-half of the share allotted to Nishimappa on partition.

    10. Per Curiam:— The plaintiff must pay the costs of the suit and the appeal to defendants 1, 2 and 4, and must recover his costs of the suit from defendant 3.

    D.S/R.K

    11. Decree varied.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chanbasappa Virappa Bolagondar v. Huchappa Parappa Bolagondar
    (Jan 26, 1938)