AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act, 1956 or the Societies Registration Act, 1963.
  • West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act, 1973 and/or Rules
  • West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act and/or Rules
  • West Bengal Co-operative Societies Rules, 1974.2.
  • ARTICLE 12 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act, 1956 or the Societies Registration Act, 1963.
  • West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act, 1973 and/or Rules
  • West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act and/or Rules
  • West Bengal Co-operative Societies Rules, 1974.2.
  • ARTICLE 12 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent No. 1, Midnapore Co-operative Land Development Bank Ltd. (the Bank) is a co-operative bank constituted under the West Bengal Co‑operative Societies Act, 1973 and the Rules framed thereunder. The Bank historically was managed by a Chairman and Board of Directors but, for several years before the litigation, was being run by an Executive Officer appointed by the Registrar of Co‑operative Societies and the Board had been superseded.

The petitioners are deed writers (Moharars), bond copyists and writers who have worked for the Bank since 1968, with between 8 and 18 years' service, and many are graduates. Prior to 13 January 1986 they were generally paid at piece rates (Rs. 10 per deed/bond), often paid by loan applicants or by the Bank in respect of bonds. Their work was described as perennial in nature (covering more than 240 days a year) but they had no employment security or benefits.

Government Memorandum No. 1700 Emp/3C-26/78 dated 3 August 1979 directed absorption of casual/perennial workers (engaged continuously for more than three years) into regular establishments of government agencies, in existing or newly created vacancies. That memo was forwarded to cooperative banks by a subsequent memo dated 27 January 1982. Some cooperative banks (e.g., Tamluk Co‑operative Land Development Bank) absorbed contract Moharars; the respondent Bank refused to implement the memo despite appeals.

On 13 January 1986 the respondent Bank offered the petitioners consolidated monthly remuneration of Rs. 350 plus Rs. 100 as travelling allowance (Annexure F). The petitioners accepted on a verbal understanding from the Executive Officer that the appointments (valid until June 1986) would lead to gradual absorption into the Bank's regular pay scales in implementation of Memo No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79. By memo dated 29 May 1986 the Executive Officer purported to discontinue the petitioners' employment with immediate effect (Annexure G). The petitioners challenged that order by filing the instant writ petition.

Respondents filed affidavits-in-opposition and raised, inter alia, a challenge to the maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that the Bank is not an "agency or instrumentality of the State" under Article 12 of the Constitution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Midnapore Co-operative Land Development Bank Ltd. is an "agency or instrumentality of the State" within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, thereby making the writ petition maintainable in public law.
  2. Assuming the writ petition is maintainable, whether the petitioners (deed writers and bond copyists) are entitled to the benefit of Government Memorandum No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 (absorption into regular establishment) or other reliefs claimed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented)

  • Mr. Lala, counsel for the petitioners, argued that because the State of West Bengal is the major contributor to the Bank's funds (holding 25,000 redeemable shares of Rs. 100 each) and because the State issues directives to the Bank, the Bank should be presumed to be an agency or instrumentality of the State under Article 12.
  • The petitioners relied on the forwarding of Government Memorandum No. 1700 Emp (3.8.79) to the Bank's Executive Officer and specifically noted that a copy was also sent to the Chairman of the Bank, as evidence of state control or a link justifying relief under the memo.
  • The petitioners contended they performed perennial work and sought absorption under the Government memo; they relied on the contractual appointments of January–June 1986 and the verbal assurance of eventual absorption to claim entitlement.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented)

  • The respondents contended that Memo No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 has no application to the respondent Bank because it is a cooperative-sector bank and not a government agency.
  • They argued the petitioners are outsiders/self‑employed persons who provided services to members and were not regular employees of the Bank; they were paid by loaners or from monies realised from members, not out of the public exchequer, and were not governed by West Bengal Service Rules.
  • The respondents maintained that the contractual appointments given in January 1986 (Rs. 350 + Rs. 100 TA) were temporary, contractual for the fixed term up to June 1986, with no appointment letters issued, and that services terminated on expiry of the contract; consequently the petition is not maintainable.
  • The respondents specifically challenged maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that the Bank is not an "agency or instrumentality of the State" under Article 12.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India, AIR 1979 SC 1628 Stated that a corporation may be an instrumentality of the State where it is wholly controlled by government in policy‑making and carrying out its functions; distinguishes corporations established by statute from those incorporated under general company/society law. The court invoked this authority as foundational guidance for assessing whether the Bank could be an instrumentality of the State. It used the principle that pervasive government control and statutory establishment point towards "agency" status as a starting point for analysis.
Tekraj Vasondi v. Union of India, (1988) 1 SCC 236 Set out specific tests/factors to determine whether a corporation is an instrumentality or agency of the State (e.g., ownership of entire share capital by government, extent of state financial assistance, monopoly status, deep and pervasive state control, functions being of public importance or transferred government departments). The court extracted the tests listed in Tekraj Vasondi and applied them point‑by‑point to the facts of the Bank (shareholding, funding, state control, functions). On application of these tests the court concluded that the Bank is not an instrumentality of the State within Article 12.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court structured its analysis in two stages: first, whether the writ petition was maintainable by determining if the Bank is an "agency or instrumentality of the State" under Article 12; and second, assuming maintainability, whether the petitioners are entitled to relief based on Government Memo No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79.

1. Tests applied to decide Article 12 status:

  1. The court relied on the tests culled from Tekraj Vasondi (which in turn relied on Ramana Shetty): ownership of share capital by the State, whether state financial assistance constituted the main source of funding, existence of monopoly status, existence of deep and pervasive state control, whether the functions are of public importance or akin to governmental functions, and whether a government department was effectively transferred to the corporation.
  2. Applying these tests, the court found: the entire share capital was not held by the State (though the State held a substantial block of shares); state funding did not meet the corporation's entire expenditure; there was no evidence of deep and pervasive State control; and the Bank's main function—advancing loans to members—was not a governmental function.
  3. The court noted that although the State issued memoranda and tried to exercise influence (for example forwarding Memo No. 1700 Emp), the Bank did not consider it necessary to comply with the Government Memo, demonstrating that government control, where attempted, was not effective or pervasive.
  4. The court also observed that the management was run by a Managing Committee and the Executive Officer did not exercise the Committee's powers; this tended to show the Bank's autonomy from direct governmental control.
  5. On this basis the court concluded the Bank was not an "agency or instrumentality of the State" within Article 12, and therefore the writ petition was not maintainable on that ground.

2. Even assuming maintainability — entitlement to Memo No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79:

  1. The court examined whether the petitioners were ever employed by the Bank in a capacity (e.g., casual workers) covered by the memo. The court found no dependable evidence that the petitioners were employed by the Bank prior to January 1986 as casual workers or that they were paid out of Bank funds/public exchequer.
  2. The court noted that the petitioners had historically been paid on a piece‑rate basis (Rs. 10 per deed/bond) often by the loan applicants or out of monies realised from members, which suggested they were self‑employed and not employees of the Bank.
  3. Festival advances given to the petitioners by the Bank were deemed insufficient to establish an employer‑employee relationship; the court considered such advances could be due to close links or sympathetic consideration rather than proof of employment.
  4. The contractual appointments of January 1986 (Annexure F) were expressly contractual and for a fixed term up to June 1986; no appointment letters were issued and the respondents' case was that services terminated on expiry of the contract. The Executive Officer's discontinuation on 29 May 1986 (Annexure G) was the order challenged.
  5. Given the lack of documentary proof that petitioners were casual employees prior to 1986 and given the explicit contractual character of the January 1986 appointments, the court concluded the petitioners failed to establish entitlement to absorption under the Government memo.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The court held that the Midnapore Co-operative Land Development Bank Ltd. is not an agency or instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, and, even on the assumption that the writ was maintainable, the petitioners failed to establish entitlement to the reliefs claimed under Government Memorandum No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79.

Direct Implications for the Parties:

  • The petitioners were not granted the reliefs sought and are not entitled to absorption or other reliefs as prayed in the petition.
  • The writ petition was dismissed without any order as to costs (the court expressly recorded "dismissed without any order for cost").

No broader legal doctrine or new precedent was declared beyond the application of existing tests (as extracted from cited precedents) to the specific facts of this Bank and these petitioners. The court confined itself to applying established authorities and to the documentary record.

Disposition: Petition dismissed.

    Muktaruddin Ahmed Khan & Ors. v. Midnapore Co-Operative Land Development Bank Ltd. & Ors.

    1. The respondent no. 1, the Midnapore Co-operative Land Development Bank Ltd. (in short, the respondent Bank) is a Bank in the Co-operative Sector constituted by and/or under the West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act, 1973 and/or Rules framed thereunder known as West Bengal Co-operative Societies Rules, 1974.

    2. The said Bank formerly used to be managed by its Chairman and the Board of Directors, but for the past several years. It is being managed by an Executive Officer, appointed by the respondent no. 2, the Registrar of Co-operative Societies, West Bengal and the Board of Directors of the said Bank has since been superseded.

    3. The respondent Bank inter alia advances long term loans to its members upon mortgage or creation of charge on immovable properties under several and different schemes envisaged by the said Bank, that is, rearing of ???, sinking of shallow tubewell with pumps for irrigation of agricultural land, for establishment of small village based Cottage Industries etc.

    4. For preparation of such mortgage or charge deeds, the Bank requires the services of Deed writers, Bond copyists and writers.

    5. The said Deed writers (Moharars), Bond Copyists and writers at aforesaid, require considerable experience regarding understanding of purchase of lands, J.L.R.O Certificates, prior mortgage deeds, if any, Rent Receipts possessory titles, economic viability of the Projects etc.

    6. The petitioners in the instant writ petition are working as Deed writers and Bond copyists and Writers for the respondent Bank since 1968 onwards and they have already put in 8 to 18 years of service. Most of them are Graduates of a recognised University of West Bengal and have acquired considerable efficiency and expertise in their work.

    7. Prior to January 13, 1986 the petitioners Deed writers (Moharars) used to be paid Rs. 10/- per deed at piece rate by the members of the said Bank seeking loan and the Bond copyists and writers used to be paid Rs. 10/- for each bond and/or deed at piece rate by the respondent Bank.

    8. Although the work done by the petitioners is perennial in nature covering a period of more than 240 days in a year, they have no security of employment or benefits available to the other employees of the Bank.

    9. The petitioners consequently, have been appealing to the concerned authorities of the Bank to absorb them in the employment of the said Bank so that the petitioners might have some security of an employment and consequential benefits as enjoyed by other employees of the Bank.

    10. By Memo no. 1700 Emp/3C-26/78 dated August 3, 1979, the Chief Secretary to the Government of West Bengal inter alia directed all Government Agencies and/or Departments including the respondent Bank that casual and such other categories of workers who have been engaged in a perennial type of work for a continuous period of more than three years may be absorbed in the regular establishments us on temporary basis in the existing vacancies and if suitable vacancies are not available, to create such vacancies for the purpose of absorption of such categories of workers in consultation with the Finance Department of the Government (Annexure ‘A’).

    11. By Memo no. 1114 dated January 27, 1982 the Special Officer end Ex Officio Additional Registrar of Co-operative Societies forwarded a copy of the said Memo no. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 to the Executive Officers of all the Co-operative Banks including the respondent Bank (Annexure ‘C’).

    12. Pursuant to the said Memo dated January 27, 1982 the Tamluk Co-operative Land Development Bank absorbed six Contract Moharars as Field Moharars in their regular establishment. However, the respondent Bank refused to implement the Memorandum no. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 In spite of numerous appeals and requests.

    13. But on January 13, 1986 the respondent Bank in partial implementation of the said Scheme decided to fix the monthly wages of the petitioners at Rs. 350/- (consolidated) with Rs. 100/- per month as travelling allowance (Annexure ‘F’).

    14. The petitioners accepted the said offer and joined their respective duties on the verbal understanding of the Executive Officer of the Bank that though the order appointing them would remain effective till June 1986, the petitioners will be gradually absorbed in the regular pay scale of the Bank with admissible allowances. In implementation of Memo no. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79

    15. However, in spite of such specific understanding, the Executive Officer of the Bank by a Memo dated 29.5.86 whimsically, most arbitrarily and unlawfully purported to discontinue the employment of the petitioners with immediate effect (Annexure ‘G’).

    16. It is the said order (Annexure ‘G’) which the petitioners have challenged in the instant writ petition.

    17. The claim of the petitioners has been seriously opposed by the respondents nos. 1 and 2 by filing two separate affidavits-in-opposition.

    18. According to the respondents, the Memo No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 has no manner of application to the respondent Bank since it is a Bank under the Co-operative Sector. It is the further case of the respondents that for sanction of loan the Bank does not require any help from outsiders including the petitioners. As a matter of fact, the petitioners are outsiders having no link or connection with the management of the Bank and the Executive Officer. They are neither regular employees of the Bank nor are they paid from the public exchequer and they are also not governed by the West Bengal Service Rules. They are paid by the loaners and are self-employed persons and consequently no question of their being absorbed in the regular establishment of the Bank actually arises.

    19. By a Memo/Order dated 31.1.86 the Deed writers and Bond writers were allotted jobs for indoor as well as outdoor work on a fixed remuneration of Rs. 350/- per month and Rs. 100/- as travelling allowance. Similar appointment was also also given to the Bond writers. But the said appointments were given purely on a contact basis and not on regular basis and was for a fixed term upto the month of June, 1986. As a matter of fact, no appointment letters were issued to the petitioners by the Bank. On the expiry of the period of contract the services of the petitioners were automatically terminated.

    20. The respondents have also challenged the maintainability of the instant writ petition on the ground that the respondent Bank is not an agency or an instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India.

    21. Now, since the question regarding the maintainability of the writ petition is a very vital question touching the root of the matter, it may be useful at the outset to consider whether the respondent Bank is an agency or instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. If the question is in the negative there will be no other alternative but to reject the writ petition on the ground that it is not maintainable in law.

    22. As already seen, the respondent Bank, namely the Midnepore Co-operative Land Development Bank Ltd. is a Bank in the Co-operative Sector constituted under the West Bengal Co-operative Societies Act and/or Rules framed thereunder. The object of the Bank as it will appear from the bye-laws is to create funds for lending out to its members against mortgage of their immovable properties and particularly agricultural lands. The State of West Bengal as one of the partners is the holder of 25,000 redeemable shares of the value of Rs. 100/- each. The nominal share capital of the Bank is Rs. 45,00,000/- (Forty five lac) divided into 99500 ordinary shares of the value of Rs. 20/- and 200 preference shares of the value of Rs. 50/- each.

    23. Mr. Lala, the learned Counsel representing the petitioners, contended that since the State of West Bengal is the major contributor of the fund of the Bank, it should be presumed that the respondent Bank is an agency or instrumentality of the State. He also contended that the State Government has a pervasive control over the functioning of the Bank. In support thereof he also referred to the Memorandum No. 1114(24) dated January 27, 1982 of the Special Officer and Ex-Officio Additional Registrar of Co-operative Societies, West Bengal addressed to the Executive Officer/Manager of the different Co-operative Land Development Banks forwarding a copy of the Memo No. 1700-Emp dated 3.8.79 and another Memo of the Labour Department, directing their implementation (Annexure ‘A’ to the petitioners affidavit-in-reply). Mr. Lala specially pointed out that a copy of the said Memo, was forwarded to the Chairman of the respondent Bank.

    24. In Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India, AIR 1979 SC 1628, it was pointed out by the Supreme Court that “a corporation may be created in one of two ways. It may be either established by statute or incorporated under a law such as the Companies Act, 1956 or the Societies Registration Act, 1963. Where a corporation is wholly controlled by government not only in its policy making but also in carrying out the function entrusted to it by the law establishing it or by the charter of its incorporation, there can be no doubt that it would be an instrumentality or agency of government”.

    25. The matter came up for further consideration before the Supreme Court in Tekraj Vasondi v. Union of India (1988) 1 SCC 236.

    26. In the said case the Supreme Court considered all the relevant decisions of the Court on the point Reliance was placed mainly upon the decision in the International Airport Authority's case (supra) and the relevant tests for determining whether a corporation is an agency or instrumentality of the State, were culled out from the said decision as follows:

    (1) One thing is clear that if the entire share capital of the corporation is held by government, it would go a long way towards indicating that the corporation is an instrumentality or agency of government.

    (2) Where the financial assistance of the State is so much as to meet almost entire expenditure of the corporation, it would afford some indication of the corporation being impregnated with governmental character.

    (3) It may also be a relevant factor …whether the corporation enjoys monopoly status which is State conferred or State protected.

    (4) Existence of deep and pervasive State control may afford an indication that the corporation is a State agency or instrumentality.

    (5) If the functions of the corporation are of public importance and closely related to governmental functions, it would be a relevant factor in classifying the corporation as an instrumentality or agency of government.

    (6) “Specifically, if a department of government is transferred to a corporation, it would be a strong factor supportive of this inference” of the corporation being an instrumentality or agency of government.

    27. Applying the aforesaid tests in the instant case, it is found that the entire share capital of the corporation (respondent Bank) is not held by the government though the Government holds the majority of the scares.

    28. It cannot also be said that the financial assistance tendered by the State is sufficient to meet the entire expenditure of the corporation. There also does not appear to be the existence of any deep and pervasive State control. The other conditions also are not fulfilled.

    29. Coming to the facts of Tekraj Vasandi's case (supra), the annual contribution from the Government was found to be substantial so much so, that it constituted the main source of funding. Regarding the pervasive control of the Government over the corporation (ICPS), It appeared that the Minister of Law tried to exercise his authority as the controlling Department of Government in the matter of making grants. There were also other relevant factors to which the attention of the Supreme Court was drawn on behalf of the appellants, namely, that the President of India had inaugurated the Society: the Speaker of the Loksabha was its first President and three Ministers, a former Chief Justice of India and the Former Attorney General joined as its Vice President; some public officers were also associated in the administrative set up of the Society, but even then it was held by the Supreme Court that the society/corporation was neither an agency or Instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution.

    30. In the instant case though the State funding is substantial, it cannot be said that the contribution made by the State is the main source of funding. As a matter of fact, substantial amount of money comes from other sources.

    31. As regards the alleged pervasive control of the Government, the simple fact that the Government from time to time have been issuing instructions to the Bank, does not establish the fact of such pervasive control. As a matter of fact the respondent Bank in spite of such communications did not consider it necessary to comply with the relevant Government Memo, no. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 This shows that though the Government has been trying to exercise control over the Bank, such control is not at all effective.

    32. It appears that the management of the Bank is run by the Managing Committee and the Executive Officer appointed by the Bank does not exercise any power of the said Managing Committee, as it will clearly appear from the letter of the Executive Officer dated 30.10.87 addressed to the Secretary of the Midnapore Co-operative Land Development Bank Employees Association (Annexure ‘A’ to the affidavit-in-reply of the petitioner).

    33. It also appears that the main function of the Bank is to advance loans to its members and it cannot be said that the Bank is thereby discharging governmental functions.

    34. Considering the facts and circumstances above, I am not inclined to hold in agreement with Mr. Lala, the learned Counsel for the petitioners, that the respondent Bank is an agency or instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and this makes the instant writ petition not maintainable in law.

    35. However, assuming for the time being that the writ petition is maintainable in law, it may be considered whether the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of the Government Memo. No. 1700 dated 3.8.79 By the said Memo (Annexure ‘A’ to the writ petition) the Deputy Secretary to the Government of West Bengal laid down the principles to be followed in the matter of absorption of casual and other categories of workers under the State Government. But significantly, there is nothing dependable to show that the petitioners were ever employed by the respondent Bank either as casual workers or in any other capacity barring isolated instance of contractual appointment for a period of six months from January to June, 1986.

    36. The petitioners are Deed writers (Moharars) and Bond writers and as stated in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the writ petition, the Deed writers (Moharars) used to be paid Rs. 10/- per deed at piece rate by the members of the respondent Bank seeking loan and the Bond Copyists and Writers used to be paid Rs. 10/- for each bond and/or deed at one piece rate by the said Bank.

    37. Evidence, however, is absolutely lacking as to whether the Bond Copyists and Writers used to be paid their remuneration out of the public exchequer. On the other hand, the case of the respondents is that they used to be paid Rs. 10/- for each Bond and/or Deed out of the money realised from the members.

    38. It seems that the services of the petitioners are utilised by the members of the Back for writing out deeds, bonds etc. for raising loans from the Bank and in that sense the petitioners appear to be nothing but self employed persons earning their living by writing out bonds, deeds etc. for the prospective loanee members of the Bank.

    39. In fact, the petitioners have not endeavoured to produce any document to show that they were ever employed as casual workers by the Bank prior to January, 1986 and were paid out of the funds of the Bank.

    40. Mr. Lala, the learned Counsel representing the petitioner, in this connection referred to certain correspondence for the purpose of showing that the petitioners are not total outsiders and self employed persons as sought to be proved by the respondents. But, unfortunately, from none of the said correspondence annexed so the affidavit-in-reply as well as the supplementary affidavit it can be ascertained whether the petitioners were ever employed by the respondent Bank even on casual basis.

    41. It is true that the petitioners were given festival advances from time to time recoverable in monthly instalments but from that alone it cannot be inferred that they were given such advances as employees of the Bank.

    42. It is quite likely that in view of the nature of the job performed by the petitioners they have established close links with the Bank authorities and possibly out of sympathetic consideration for them the Bank had been giving the festival advances to meet their demands during the festive occasions.

    43. It seems to be apparently clear that the petitioners in view of such close links with the respondent Bank, are now trying to take advantage of the Government Memo No. 1700 Emp dated 3.8.79 by trying to establish them as casual workers of the said Bank performing duties of a perennial nature.

    44. The Executive Officer of the Bank, as it appears, has been trying earnestly to create some opportunities for the petitioners so that they might be absorded in the regular establishment of the Bank and it was he who was instrumental in giving contractual appointments to the petitioners for a period of six months from January to June, 1986 (Annexure ‘F’ to the writ petition). It was, however made clear that the employment so given to the petitioners was purely contractual in nature and not regular employment. The petitioners having agreed to accept the terms contained in Annexure ‘F’ they were given such employments which were discontinued with effect from 29.5.86 (Vide Annexure ‘G’ to the writ petition).

    45. Thus, firstly, the instant writ position is not maintainable since the respondent Bank is neither an agency nor instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. And then even assuming that the writ petition is maintainable, the petitioners have failed to establish that they are entitled to the benefit of the Government Memo. No. 1700-Emp dated 3.8.99

    46. In the above view of the matter, the petitioners are not entitled to the reliefs as prayed for.

    47. The writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed without any order for cost.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Muktaruddin Ahmed Khan & Ors. v. Midnapore Co-Operative Land Development Bank Ltd. & Ors.
    (Mar 17, 1988)