AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section of the Code of 1882, S. 243
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section of the Code of 1882, S. 243
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revisional application challenges an order of the lower Court (Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Ahmedabad) which declined to grant injunction under Order XXXIX, Rules 1 & 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) and instead passed an order under Order XXI, Rule 29 staying execution of a decree. The applicant, Narsidas Nathubhii, had been Karbhari (estate steward) of the Gamph talukdari estate. A pension agreement dated 6 January 1915 provided a pension of Rs. 100 per month to the applicant during his lifetime and Rs. 50 per month to his heirs for one generation. The applicant left service on 1 October 1918 and received pension payments until 31 May 1921.

The applicant sued in October 1925 (Suit No. 1232 of 1925) to recover arrears of pension (Rs. 5,800 claimed for the period 1 June 1921 to 30 September 1925) and obtained a decree; no appeal was filed. In June 1927 the applicant filed darkhast No. 525 of 1927 for Rs. 7,000. The talukdar's heir (the present opponent), who had been a minor at his father's death (15 June 1923), attained majority on 16 October 1927 and in November 1928 filed Suit No. 1453 of 1928 seeking to set aside the decree obtained in Suit No. 1232 of 1925.

While execution proceedings on the earlier decree were pending before the First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Jhaveri, the suit to set aside the decree was pending in the Court of the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Yajnik. The opponent applied on 8 November 1928 for an interim injunction under O. 39, Rr. 1 & 2 and for any other order the Court deemed fit. On 21 October 1929 Mr. Yajnik held the injunction application under O. 39 Rr. 1 & 2 not maintainable but issued a stay of execution under O. 21, R. 29 until the suit filed by the opponent was finally decided. The present revisional application challenges that O. 21, R. 29 order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge (in whose Court the suit to set aside the decree was pending) had jurisdiction to pass an order under Order XXI, Rule 29 staying execution of the decree, when execution proceedings were pending before another Judge of the same Court.
  2. Whether the learned Judge acted illegally or with material irregularity in exercising his jurisdiction by granting the stay under O. 21, R. 29 (including whether he was bound to demand security for the whole amount claimed in darkhast No. 525 of 1927).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's (Revisionist) Arguments

  • The Joint First Class Subordinate Judge (Mr. Yajnik) had no jurisdiction to pass an order under O. 21, R. 29 because the execution proceedings were pending before another Judge (Mr. Jhaveri) of the same First Class Subordinate Judge's Court; therefore the application should have been heard by the Judge before whom the execution proceedings were pending.
  • Precedents were relied upon to show that an application for stay under the corresponding provision in the old Code (S. 243) had been treated as an order in execution, and that an order granting a stay was an order in execution (arguing for the necessity of making the application in the execution proceedings).
  • The learned Judge acted illegally or with material irregularity in not demanding security for the entire amount of Rs. 7,000 covered by darkhast No. 525 of 1927; it was argued that the wording of the present rule required imposition of terms (including security) and that security for the whole amount should have been required.

Opponent's (Respondent / Talukdar) Arguments and Contentions Supporting the Order

  • The application made seeking injunction was broadly framed and asked for "any other order the Honourable Court deems proper," which could legitimately include an order under O. 21, R. 29; therefore it was open to the learned Judge to grant a stay under that rule rather than an injunction under O. 39.
  • It was pointed out in support of not demanding full security that the pension amount was made a charge on two properties belonging to the opponent — a circumstance relied upon by the lower Court as a sufficient reason not to require security for the full amount of Rs. 7,000.
  • The terms imposed by the Judge (including that future payments be made monthly into Court) were adequate and within the Court's discretion to protect the decree-holder's interests pending the outcome of the suit to set aside the decree.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Steel & Co. v. Iachamoyi Chowdhrain Reliance on earlier decisions where applications were made to the Court in execution and an appeal lay against an order granting stay under the corresponding older provision (S. 243). The Court observed that although these decisions involved applications in execution and appeals under the older section, the specific present point (jurisdiction where a Court has more than one Judge) was not considered in those cases; they were therefore distinguished rather than treated as directly controlling.
Lingum Krishnabhupati Devu v. Kandula Sivaramayya Same line as above — cited among cases where stay applications related to execution proceedings under the old Code provision. The Court noted these authorities but held that they did not decide the present point as to which Judge of a multi-judge Court must hear an application under O.21, R.29.
Mahesh Chandra Sadhu v. Jogendra Lal Sarkar Cited with other cases addressing stay in execution under the older Code provision. The Court treated these decisions as not resolving the precise jurisdictional question presented in the instant revision, and thus not decisive against the Joint Judge's power to act.
Janardan v. Martand (also cited as Janardan v. Martani) Interpreted omission of the word “stay” in earlier enactments and held that an order under O.21, R.29 did not fall under section 47 of the CPC and was not a "decree" under section 2; therefore an appeal would not lie. The Court relied on this decision to note that orders under O.21, R.29 are not appealable under section 47 and to justify that an order under O.21, R.29 can be regarded as distinct from orders in execution (supporting the view that jurisdiction lies in the Court where the suit is pending).
Tribhuwandas Kalliandas Gajjar v. Jivanchand An application under O.21, R.29 was made to the Court in which the suit was pending; the specific jurisdictional question was not raised; the decision turned on whether an arbitration award was a decree. The Court observed that this case did not address the present jurisdictional issue and therefore did not control the outcome; it was cited and noted as inapposite on the point under consideration.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The opinion contains parallel reasoning by Patkar, J. and Broomfield, J., reaching the same result. The Court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps:

  1. Interpretation of O. 21, R. 29: The Court emphasized that the rule refers to "the Court in which a suit is pending against the holder of a decree of such Court." The judges construed this to refer to the Court as an institutional entity rather than to the individual Judge by name. Accordingly, when a Court consists of two or more Judges, it is sufficient that the suit is pending in any Court (i.e., before any Judge of that Court) against the holder of the decree of that Court.
  2. Jurisdiction where multiple Judges preside: Applying that interpretation, the Court held that it was not necessary for the execution proceedings to be pending before the same Judge who was seised of the suit to enable the Judge before whom the suit was pending to make an order under O. 21, R. 29. Thus, Mr. Yajnik, who presided over the suit to set aside the decree, had jurisdiction to stay execution even though execution proceedings were before another Judge (Mr. Jhaveri) of the same First Class Subordinate Judge's Court.
  3. Consideration of authorities: The Court reviewed earlier decisions relied upon by the applicant (cases where applications were made in execution and where appeals lay under the older S. 243) and found that those decisions did not consider the precise point arising in this case. Janardan v. Martand was noted as authority for the proposition that an order under O.21, R.29 does not fall under section 47 and is not a decree — supporting the distinct character of O.21, R.29 orders and limiting the applicability of prior execution-focused authorities.
  4. Discretion as to terms and security: The Court carefully examined the wording of O. 21, R. 29 — "the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution..." — and concluded that the rule confers broad discretion on the Court to impose such terms as it thinks fit. It is not mandatory to demand security for the full amount claimed; taking security is not a condition precedent to granting a stay. The Court accepted the learned Subordinate Judge's explanation that the phrase in the rule demonstrates that taking security is optional and within judicial discretion.
  5. Application of discretion in the present facts: The Court considered the factual circumstance relied on by the opponent — that the pension amount was charged on two properties of the opponent — as a valid ground for the learned Judge to decline to require security for the whole Rs. 7,000. Further, the Judge imposed terms (monthly payments by the opponent into Court) designed to maintain status quo and secure the applicant's interest. The Court found no conscious or willful disregard of the Code, nor material irregularity in exercising discretion.
  6. Procedural sufficiency of the application: Broomfield, J. accepted that the application filed by the opponent was broadly framed (it sought injunction "and any other order the Honourable Court deems proper"), which was sufficient to permit the learned Judge to treat the application as inclusive of a prayer for a stay under O.21, R.29.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revisional application is DISMISSED WITH COSTS.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The order of the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge (Mr. Yajnik) under Order XXI, Rule 29 staying execution of the decree until the pending suit (Suit No. 1453 of 1928) is upheld by this revisional Court.
  • The revisional Court found that the Joint Judge had jurisdiction to pass the O.21, R.29 order even though execution proceedings were pending before another Judge of the same Court, and that there was no illegality or material irregularity in the exercise of discretion (including the decision not to demand security for the full Rs. 7,000).
  • The lower Court's requirement that future payments be made monthly into Court was treated as an adequate term to protect the decree-holder's interest pending determination of the suit to set aside the decree.
  • The Court directed that Suit No. 1453 of 1928 (the suit to set aside the prior decree) "should be disposed of with all possible despatch." This is a direct procedural instruction addressed to expedite the pending litigation.

The opinion does not state that it establishes a broader binding precedent beyond its legal conclusions; the decision affirms the application of O.21, R.29 and the discretionary nature of terms of stay in the facts of this case.

    Narsidas Nathubhai Vohra v. Manharsingh Agarsing Thakor Opposite Party.

    Patkar, J.:— This is a revisional application against the order of the lower Court declining to take action under O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2, and passing an order under O. 21, R. 29 of the CPC.

    2. The applicant Narsidas Nathubhii was the Karbhari of the talukdari estate of Gamph in the Dhandhuka Taluka in the Ahmedabad District. The opponent's father Agarsinghji passed a document of pension, dated 6th January 1915, in favour of the applicant with the approval of the Talukdari Settlement Officer by which a pension of Rs. 100 per month was agreed to be paid to him during his lifetime, and Rs. 50 per month to his heirs for one generation. On 1st October 1918 the applicant retired, or, as is stated on the other side, his services were dispensed with. The applicant received the amount of the pension up to 31st May 1921. The father of the opponent. Thakor Agarsingji, died on 15th June 1923, and was succeeded by his minor son, the opponent Manharsingji. On 7th October 1925, the applicant brought a suit. No. 1232 of 1925, in the Court of the First Class Subordinate Judge at Ahmedabad against the Talukdari Settlement Officer as guardian of the present opponent to recover Rs. 5,800 as arrears of pension and for a declaration that he was entitled to recover Rs. 100 per month till his death, and his heirs Rs. 50 per month for one generation. The amount claimed in the suit was for fifty-two months from 1st June 1921 to 30th September 1925. The applicant obtained a decree. No appeal was filed against the decree, and on 30th June 1927 the applicant filed darkhast No. 525 of 1927 for Rs. 7,000. On 16th October 1927, the present opponent attained majority and the estate was handed over to him. The opponent on 7th November 1928, brought Suit No. 1453 of 1928 for setting aside the decree in Suit No. 1232 of 1925 in the First Class Subordinate Judge's Court at Ahmedabad. That suit came on for trial before the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge at Ahmedabad, Mr. Yajnik. The execution proceedings referred to above were pending in the Court of the First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Jhaveri. On 8th November 1928 the opponent made an application for an interim injunction under O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2, and also prayed for any other order which the Court might deem fit to pass under the circumstances.

    3. On 21st October 1929 the learned Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Yajnik, passed a final order under O. 21, R. 29, staying the execution of the decree till the suit filed by the opponent was finally decided. The learned Judge held that the application for injunction was not maintainable under O. 39, Rr. 1 and 2, and did not think it proper to pass any order under section 151 of the cpc but thought that an order under O. 21, R. 29 would meet the ends of justice in the present case, and passed an order staying the execution of the decree till the final decision of the suit. This application has been filed to revise the order of Mr. Yajnik passed under O. 21, R. 29. The only questions arising in the present application are whether the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. ??? had jurisdiction to pass an order under O. 21, R. 29, and whether he acted ??? gaily or with material irregularity in the exercise of his jurisdiction. It is urged on behalf of the applicant that the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. ??? had no jurisdiction to pass an order under O. 21, R. 29, as the execution proceeding were not pending before him, but were pending before the First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Jhaveri. O. 21, R. 29 refers to the Court in which a suit is pending against the holder of a decree of such Court, and has no reference to the personality of the Judge presiding over such Court. There is no distinction made in that rule between the Judge presiding over the Court and the Court as provided for in O. 47, R. 5 of the CPC. Ordinarily when there is a single Judge attached to a Court, no difficulty arises. When there are two or more Judges attached to a Court, it would be sufficient if the suit is pending in any Court against the holder of the decree of such Court, and the fact that the execution proceeding were pending before the First Class Subordinate Judge, whereas the suit was pending in the Court of the Joint Firs Glass Subordinate Judge would make ??? difference. Under R. 29, O. 21, where ??? suit is pending in any Court against the holder of a decree of such Court, the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution of the decree until the pending suit has been decided. The present suit was pending in the Court of the First Class Subordinate Judge though it was presided over by Mr. Yajnik, and that suit was against the holder of a decree of suit Court, that is, the First Class Subordinate Judge's Court, though the execution proceedings may have been pending before another Judge of the same Court We think therefore that the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, in whose Court the suit is pending, had jurisdiction to pass the order under O. 21, R. 29. It is not necessary that the execution proceedings should be pending before the same Judge in whose Court the suit is pending. If the execution of a decree is transferred for execution to another Court, and a suit is brought in the Court in which the execution proceedings were first started against the holder of a decree of that Court, the Court in which the suit is brought would have jurisdiction to pass in order under O. 21, R. 29, though the execution proceedings may be actually pending before another Judge to whom;he execution proceedings may have been ??? by the Court. It is not therefore necessary, in our opinion, that she execution proceedings must be pending before the same Judge before whom the suit is pending. It is sufficient if the suit is pending in any Court against the holder of a decree of such Court. The Point First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Yajnik, had therefore jurisdiction to pass in order under O. 21, R. 29.

    4. It is next urged on behalf of the applicant that the application ought to have been made not to the Court in which the suit is pending, but ought to have been made to the Court in which the execution proceedings are pending, and reliance has been placed on the decisions in the cases of O. Steel & Co. v. Iachamoyi Chowdhrain (1), Lingum Krishnabhupati Devu v. Kandula Sivaramayya (2) and Mahesh Chandra Sadhu v. Jogendra Lal Sarkar (3). Though in the ??? two cases cited on behalf of the applicant an application was made to the Court in execution and it was held that an appeal lay against the order granting stay under S. 243, corresponding to O. 21, R. 29, the present point was not considered in those cases. It was recently held in the case of Janardan v. Martand (4) that the word “stay” occurring in section 214 of the old cpc having been omitted in the present section 47 of the cpc, an order passed under O. 21, R. 29, was an order which did not fall under section 47 of the cpc, and was not a decree under section 2 of the cpc, and therefore an appeal would not lie. On the other hind, in the case of Tribhuwandas Kalliandas Gajjar v. Jivanchand (5) an application under O. 21, R. 29 was made to the Court in which the suit was pending but the point was not raised and decided, and the only decision in the case turned upon the question whether an award under the Arbitration Act was a decree. The terms of O. 21, R. 29, indicate that the Court in which at suit is pending is the Court which has jurisdiction to pass an order under O. 21, R. 29. There is no indication in the rule that the application must be made to the Court in the execution proceedings. On the other hand, the wording of the rule is quite clear that the Court in which a suit is pending has jurisdiction to pass an order under that rule. We think therefore that the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Mr. Yajnik, had jurisdiction to pass the order under O. 21, R. 29.

    5. Next it is urged that in passing the order Mr. Yajnik, the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, acted illegally or with material irregularity in not demanding security for the whole amount of Rs. 7,000 covered by darkhast No. 525 of 1927. It is urged that the words “either absolutely or on such terms as it thinks fit,” occurring in the corresponding section of the old Code, have been changed in the present rule. The phraseology of O. 21, R. 29, would indicate that it is not necessary that the Court should pass an order for security for the whole amount of Rs. 7,000. The wording of O. 21, R. 29, is that the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution of the decree until the pending suit has been decided. We think that the Court had ample discretion in passing an order as to the terms on which the execution of the decree could be stayed until the pending suit had been decided. In the present case the learned Subordinate Judge did not consider that he had no jurisdiction to take security as to the whole amount of Rs. 7,000, but observed as follows:

    “The words on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit in the said rule are Sufficient in themselves to show that the taking of the security is not a condition precedent to the granting of a stay order and that the Court need not take security if it thinks fit not to do so in the circumstances of the case.”

    6. We think therefore that the learned Subordinate Judge exercised his discretion in the imposition of the terms on which the execution of the decree was stayed, and one of the grounds suggested on behalf of the opponent in support of the order of the lower Court, is that the amount of the pension is made a charge on two properties belonging to the opponent. That in itself can be considered a sufficient reason for not exercising the discretion in demanding security as to the whole amount of Rs. 7,000 in the present case. One of the terms imposed by the learned Judge in desiring to maintain the status quo was that future payments should be made by the opponent every month in Court. We do not think, in view of the circumstances of this case, that there was any conscious or wilful disregard of any section of the Code, and therefore it cannot be said that the lower Court had acted illegally or with material irregularity in the exercise of its discretion.

    7. On these grounds we think that this application must be dismissed with costs.

    8. We desire to add that Suit No. 1453 of 1928 brought by the present Thakor for setting aside the previous decree should be disposed of with all possible despatch.

    Broomfield, J.:— This is an application for revision of the order of the Joint First Class Subordinate Judge, Ahmedabad, staying execution of the decree in Suit No. 1232 of 1925 under O. 21, R. 29. Suit No. 1232 of 1925 was filed by the present applicant Narsidas to recover arrears of his pension as Karbhari of the Gamph estate on the strength of an agreement made by the late talukdar. A decree against the present talukdar, then a minor, was passed on 1st November 1926. A suit No. 1453 of 1928, has been filed by the present talukdar to set aside that decree, and stay of execution of that decree has been granted on an application made by the present talukdar as the plaintiff in Suit No. 1453. The date of the Joint Subordinate Judge's order staying execution is 21st October 1929. The first point taken by Mr. Divatia on behalf of the applicant, was that the application having been made under O. 39 for an injunction, it was not legal for the Subordinate Judge, in dealing with that application to make an order under O. 21, R. 29. It appears to me however that the application, which did not specify any particular order or rule, was wide enough to cover, an order for stay under O. 21, R. 29. The application ended with these words:

    “The Court will be pleased to issue injunction order in the darkhast matter and write a yad for staying the proceedings of this darkhast and piss any other order the Honourable Court deems proper in this case.”

    9. It is admitted that the order passed by the Joint Subordinate Judge was passed under O. 21, R. 29. I can see nothing illegal in that.

    10. The second point taken by Mr. Divatia arises from the fact that the Court of the First Class Subordinate Judge, Ahmedabad, has two Judges, the First Class Subordinate Judge and the Joint Judge. It so happened that at the material time the execution proceedings in connexion with the decree obtained by Narsidas were pending before the First Class Subordinate Judge himself, whereas the Joint Judge was in charge of the suit filed by the minor talukdar. Mr. Divatia his quoted a number of cases: O. Steel & Co. v. Ichchamoyi Chowdhrain , Lingum Krishnabliupati Devu v. Kandula Sivaramayya, and others, in which the application for stay happened to be or was ??? as an application in execution proceedings. The argument is that these cases and also the position of R. 29 in the Code show that the order contemplated is an order in execution proceedings and not an order in the suit, whereas in the present case it is contended that the application was not made in the execution proceedings but in the suit, i.e the second suit filed be the talukdar. The particular point however did not arise in the cases cited before us. Mr. Divatii's contention would really require us to imply a proviso or exception to the rule in question:

    “Provided that where a Court consists of two or more Judges, the application under this rule shall be made to the Judge before whom the execution proceedings are pending.”

    11. In my opinion, there is no necessity to imply any such proviso, nor indeed can I see any good reason why it should be done. It was urged before us that the Judge in charge of the execution proceedings is in a better position to decide whether those proceedings should be stayed. There can be very little in it either way. The Judges are Judges of the same Court and information in the possession of either could, no doubt, be readily made available to the other; but it would seem that generally speaking he Judges in charge of the suit would ??? in a better position to say whether execution of the previous decree should be stayed in consequence of it, than the judge who is merely concerned with carrying out the execution. As my learned brother has pointed out, the wording of the rule is clearly against Mr. Divatia's argument, because it provides that the application is to be made of the Court in which the suit is pending, may also say that if it is necessary that the order in question should be ??? as an order made in execution proceedings, I can see no good reason why the order here made should not be of regarded. It may be an order made a execution although it is not an order ??? under S. 47, as held by this Court in Janardan v. Martani . For these ??? I hold that the Joint Subordinate Judge had jurisdiction to make the order in question. Mr. Divatia next contended that the Subordinate Judge was bound to consider whether a prima facie case had been made out for the grant of stay, that ??? not so considered and that he had ??? the stay of execution simply because another suit had been filed, as if it ??? followed from that circumstance that the parties should be kept ??? statu quo. That however appears to me to be a misrepresentation of the order of he learned Subordinate Judge. He says: “On a careful consideration of the facts of the case, I aril of opinion that the ends of justice will under the circumstances be met by keeping he parties in status quo,”

    12. And I think it is evident from a perusal of the order as a whole that the Subordinate Judge stayed execution not because he considered that he was bound ??? do so, but because in the view which ??? took of the circumstances, he thought that it was the most equitable thing to lo. It was also contended that the order made is not in accordance with the provisions of O. 21, S. 29. The corresponding section of the Code of 1882, S. 243 allowed the Court to stay execution either “absolutely” or on terms. In the present rule the words are:

    “the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution….”

    13. Under the present rule, Mr. Divatia contends, it is essential that terms of some kind should be imposed, and he urges that with regard to the particular darkhast No. 525 no terms have been imposed at all. But the order contemplated by this rule is an order staying execution of the decree and not an order staying execution of a particular darkhast. It may be that according to the proper construction of this rule execution of the decree should not be stayed without the imposition of terms of some kind, but in this case the execution of the decree has been stayed upon terms. The terms imposed by the Court were that the plaintiff in the new suit should deposit month by month the sums accruing due under the pension agreement. The Subordinate Judge having stayed the execution of the decree upon terms, that, in my opinion, is all the rule requires. Thus in the view was take of the case no question of jurisdiction really arises at all. There has been no irregularity in the exercise of jurisdiction, nor I think can it be said that there has been any irregularity at all whether affecting jurisdiction or otherwise. The nature of the terms to be imposed by the Subordinate Judge in his order staying execution of the decree was a matter within his discretion. It is arguable perhaps that the terms as to security might have been made stricter in view of the fact that no appeal had been filed against the decree obtained by Narsidas but whether that be so or not, it is not a matter which will justify this Court in interfering in revision. The ultimate security appears to be sufficient, and the order made by the Subordinate Judge for the deposit of money in Court from time to time seems to be calculated to ensure that the suit filed by the talukriar will be disposed of as speedily as possible.

    14. I agree with the order proposed by my learned brother.

    K.N/R.K

    15. Application dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narsidas Nathubhai Vohra v. Manharsingh Agarsing Thakor Opposite Party.
    (Sep 26, 1930)